For those call for Ash's head....perspective

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,988
8,967
113
I doubt many are calling for his head, but you have to admit that this team has taken a step backwards. Most would be OK, with taking a step backwards, if RU was playing a lot of Freshmen and Sophs, but when it comes to the D-line, O-line, wideouts and running backs there are many upperclassmen filling those positions. Where is the future? What can we be optimistic about? Hopefully the recruiting class comes through and that is what we are able to hang our hats on.
You can be optimistic that there will be different players in the program. The fact that 2 of the weaker areas on the team ( OL & DL) are full of upperclassmen says volumes about player development under the previous regime. This staff needs to be light years better in that area. If they're not, it won't matter how great the incoming recruiting class is.
 

shields

Heisman
Aug 5, 2002
80,364
18,434
113
Before the season we had two good playmakers and Grant has been hurt since Iowa. Martin has done nothing the last 4 weeks. Again the dope who was the previous head coach destroyed the program.
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Hey.. I hated the Flood choice.. based on his time as "co-OC in charge of the running game".

hhmm.. htis is not going to work out as an example.. we did well enough that first season.. but a share of the Big East title did come with some surprising failures. And as you old fans know.. even during that season Flood had his critics here.

But my main point here is that I agree that it is idiocy to call for Ash's head now.

Schiano would be a better example. Cubit did him no favors as OC... even though he would eventually do better on his own.. for a time. And Schiano did not care about winning immediately. But we ere used to dismal failure and blowouts then having come off of Shea...

Its kind of like politics now... Trump voters were ready for a loss. Even a blow-out. Hillary voters.. not so much.. so they are ready to riot.

We were not prepared for just how bad this season would be. Some of you are ready to riot. But it doesn't help us now. Not unless you have millions and millions of dollars to throw out Ash and buy a Saban/Harbaugh type...... and you do not.... so you might as well piss into the wind.
 
Last edited:

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
Calling for the firing of a head coach in the first year is generally overboard. However so is not allowing him to be questioned either. The most important decisions a head coach makes initially is his coaching staff. He chose someone with a resume shorter than a fortune cookie. Your offensive coordinator before this year has only been paid to coach two years in his life. One in true division one. He was only the co offensive coordinator at James Madison. He didn't even have the full title there. Wide receiver coach at Houston. Who cares if he coached with Herman. He's not Herman. Wait till he gets his players in his offense. You know you have to be a coordinator before you have your offense. Does he even know what his offense is? That's the beauty of actually being a coordinator at a smaller gig for a few years so you can work out the kinks and tweak someone else's offense to your liking. No one copies someone else's offense exactly. But congrats you are paying for him to tweak his offense against the Big ten east and the scores show it. You have not scored against Michigan, Michigan State and Ohio State. That's insane. Not even a garbage TD. Your fanbase has every right to ***** about that. It's holding people accountable to choices they make. Just change the line of wait till Mehringer gets his guys in his offense to Flood always finds the hidden gems and you should be in about the same place. JMO


spot on but unfortunately, we have low iq fanbase that accepts losing as a way of life. Apparently, 2mm is NOT enough a year for Ash around here
 

imbazza2

Junior
Jul 9, 2009
612
276
0
First year HC all have the same problem
1) pick a staff with little or no time i.e. pick close friends/old coaches** he did both
the ramification of this is after the first/second year they must let them go, more time to search for better fit. Ash will make another mistake by not cutting loose any coaches in his first year
2) rallying the whole team under your new staff yes you can always sway the Fr/So. but it is harder to get the seniors Maryland looks like they bought in, while we do not seem that unified.
3) Good/great coaches design play around the talent they have. our First year HC has trashed both the O and D style for what he wants to see in the future. this is a calculated move that will be judged next fall.
all said and done our bowl season is the next two week. Ash has to rally the team to give a fight in both of the final games
Even one win will be a bright spot going into the spring
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
stop...

He had time but spent the first month worrying about a OSU bowl game that meant nothing. Maybe if he invested 100% of his time here from day one, he'd of known the players he had, what system tweaks he'd need, more time to get competent assistants etc etc

stop the excuses, he's made the former (who shall remain nameless) look competent!
 
  • Like
Reactions: drewbagel423

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
I don't read every thread or every post, so I never saw the threads or posts calling for Ash's head in his first year. That is crazy, and those people are nuts. I'm searching around now, but I still can't find them. Can you specifically tell me which threads or which posters were calling for Ash's head, because I sure do not see them.

It should be a lot easier for you to find now that we lost to the 8th ranked team, the experts will come out in droves.
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
It should be a lot easier for you to find now that we lost to the 8th ranked team, the experts will come out in droves.
I most certainly did, I said can him now to save us the heartache because it was evident he couldn't coach then and still can't. My opposition is well known here. When people respond with, 'he's young and learning on the job' you know you've the wrong guy. Any HC at a p5 school shouldn't be learning on the job like he is
 

Pirate64

Redshirt
Jun 3, 2001
31
20
0
You guys just don’t have the players. And those you do have aren't doing the basics of blocking. tackling and catching passes that would give you a chance against equal opponents.
What four/five star kid would go to RU now?
Two possible answers: A miracle finish this year..Or a new VERY BIG name coach at the end of this season. Maybe there’s someone well known in the broadcast booth or perhaps a guy who’s retired from the NFL who the kids know and respect.
That’s the only way out in a hurry. Otherwise you guys might need a lifetime of patience.
Good luck. Except on December 15th at the Rock.
 

soundcrib

All-Conference
Oct 7, 2002
6,774
3,940
113
My point being the best coach in the county got his *** kicked when he didn't have his roster. You can't judge a new coach until year 3 the earliest. You can watch for trends like is recruiting better or worse but not wins and losses.
Year 3: 1-11
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
recruiting is dead and will be worse after our 1-11 season. There is zero reason to think he can succeed based on what we've seen from his coaching, stewardship of the program and already bad player development. The only perspective that matters is can he succeed. We know that answer so the next question is simply, how are we getting rid of him?
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start