For those call for Ash's head....perspective

160louis_rivals149488

All-Conference
Aug 29, 2014
4,428
3,565
0
that thinking is part of the problem

Thank God we didn't give him more money and clearly my post went over your head

Ash had plenty of money for assistants. He consulted with Urban Meyer on how to put together a staff and chose to go with up and comers opposed to ex head coaches that would undermine him and go for his job. See: Ron Prince.

And obviously my post went way over your head because you're ready to judge and get rid of an entire staff after 10 games when they took over a team that cant even run a good pro style offense. Let alone the power spread.
 

ATIOH

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2004
986
1,078
0
Would you prefer I pick of middle of the pack coach to you need time? How mat time did we beat Bilema
I'm not weighing in on the "Ash sucks" vs "Cupboard was bare" argument.

I just think it's funny you created an Ash compared to Saban thread and wrote "I'm not comparing Ash to Saban." And then followed it up with multiple posts comparing the two.

It's like someone saying, "with all due respect, you're an @sshole." The first part of the sentence doesn't excuse what follows.

As far as Bielema, that one might not be the one you want to pick. You know with Nova/Flood beating Ash's D.
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
Ash had plenty of money for assistants. He consulted with Urban Meyer on how to put together a staff and chose to go with up and comers opposed to ex head coaches that would undermine him and go for his job. See: Ron Prince.

And obviously my post went way over your head because you're ready to judge and get rid of an entire staff after 10 games when they took over a team that cant even run a good pro style offense. Let alone the power spread.
lol ok sport, we'll see in 4yrs when a new guy walks through the door
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
I'm not weighing in on the "Ash sucks" vs "Cupboard was bare" argument.

I just think it's funny you created an Ash compared to Saban thread and wrote "I'm not comparing Ash to Saban." And then followed it up with multiple posts comparing the two.

It's like someone saying, "with all due respect, you're an @sshole." The first part of the sentence doesn't excuse what follows.

As far as Bielema, that one might not be the one you want to pick. You know with Nova/Flood beating Ash's D.
It's not a comparison of ash will be Saban. It's definitely a comparison of the struggles a new coach can and most often encounters early on.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
I get it some people here are big ash people and loved the hire. But to ingbore the facts that he and his staff have looked lost and overmatched. Very questionable coaching and program management. On top of it the team packed it in last week.
So yeah I agree give ash time and hope for the best . But for people to double down on the support of ash right now and ignore the facts is mind boggling.
Since Ash is going to be here for at least three years, what possible harm comes from supporting him while he's here?
 

jmc11201

Heisman
Dec 16, 2005
11,754
16,964
113
GIVE HIM THREE YEARS. THEN HAMMER AWAY IF NECESSARY.

Flood looked pretty competent for a few years before his impact on the program started to really show. Ash may end up being awful, but we won't know anything until the end of the third year. I remain cautiously optimistic, and although there are things from my vantage point they could do better, I'm really in no position to judge whether the foundation of the program is getting stronger or weaker.

Based on his work ethic and prior successes, I'd guess he is strengthening the foundation, but we won't know for three years.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
It is the same players....

Just saying...
Correct. It is the same players. And changing things w/those players wasn't going to be accomplished in one off-season. Also, the team is learning a new offense and defense - and that can take time.

Also, last year we had Grant and Carroo whom I think most people would agree are difference-makers. Look how well we did when Carroo was out last season.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: D1ESEL44

scarletrat

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2003
10,990
1,048
0
it's fine to be disappointed. I am to some extent. but it is laughable to consider canning Ash and OC--I'd like to have an OC still here for more than 1 season, to build continunity

I think what we are seeing is breaking in a very different O, and an O that doesn't move the ball and doesn't take time off the clock, giving it back to the opponent who then wears down our D. I think losing Grant--on this team with very little playmakers on O--was devasating. I was encouraged by what I saw against Minny, Iowa, Indiana to some extent. I predicted we would lose badly against a desperate MSU team. We beat a 6-win UNM team when we were healthier. I think that Ash and staff have had to make up for what idiot Flood did--in a far stronger and deeper division and league--is what we are seeing. Laviano was starting in my view only because the staff felt they had no choice early in the year.

I'd like to be competitive against PSU and at MD, and then recruit, recruit, recruit...not hte last or first time it takes 2-3 down years to turn it around. Plenty of other coaches and schools have been talked about...
 

mdh2003

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2003
4,868
3,795
78
I'm not weighing in on the "Ash sucks" vs "Cupboard was bare" argument.

I just think it's funny you created an Ash compared to Saban thread and wrote "I'm not comparing Ash to Saban." And then followed it up with multiple posts comparing the two.

It's like someone saying, "with all due respect, you're an @sshole." The first part of the sentence doesn't excuse what follows.

As far as Bielema, that one might not be the one you want to pick. You know with Nova/Flood beating Ash's D.
Ha. Good points.

Plus, example of one coach out of thousands is not much perspective at all. It proves it can happen. Well....no duh.

Here's to hoping Ash will be added to the list.
 

Kbee3

Heisman
Aug 23, 2002
43,724
35,255
0
Look, I'm no fan of the new offense or the new defense. I prefer a pro set, with a fullback and all. I don't like those dinky passes to the flat. Or an offense predicated on the quarterback carrying the ball a significant amount of time....you know, that whole injury thing. And I loathe a defense where the front four can't get any pressure on the quarterback and still doesn't blitz.
And I seriously doubt the sanity of anyone who thinks a coach is coming to this program and making it competitive on a week-to-week basis with the top teams in the country.
All that being said, there is not enough of a body of work to make a judgment about Ash and co. It's all about recruiting...and his first class looks pretty good...even with the departure of those two south Jersey rbs. Given several classes of that quality and maturation/coaching Rutgers should be able to put a far superior product out there than it is doing this season.
IMO it really sucks....but this is gonna take some time. And you should all know that already.
 

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
Correct. It is the same players. And changing things w/those players wasn't going to be accomplished in one off-season. Also, the team is learning a new offense and defense - and that can take time.

Also, last year we had Grant and Carroo whom I think most people would agree are difference-makers. Look how well we did when Carroo was out last season.

Bingo! That is why recruiting is so important, that is the only way to build depth, without that the whole season is lost as soon as we lose some key guys. With Flood we had zero depth, when Carroo was outt, our offense went straight in the toilet even with Grant! This year, Ash and his staff was able to coach up Grant to make him more than just a return man but sadly, there wasn't another other player as good as him. So as soon as he got hurt our season was over. Many people even said so, they were praying that Grant wouldn't get hurt or we had no way to score. They were 100% correct.

Ash is a defensive guru, he was brought in by OSU to fix their tacking problem and he did and that was one of the main reasons why they won a National Championship.

Last year with Flood, tacking was the worse that I had ever seen in D1 football. Ash taught them the same techniques that help win a national championship, and they still can't tackle worth a damn. At some point no amount of coaching will make up for lack of skill and talent, at least not after a few months anyway, maybe in a few years.

But the point is if freaking Ash can't help you tackle better then... you should not be playing D1 football... sorry.

As far as Offense goes... The spread can help hide two main things that the pro-set can't 1: a QB who isn't very good 2: a OL that isn't very good.

The idea is that you get the ball out so fast that it wouldn't matter if the OL sucked or not. Also since most passes are just quick short passes, they are easy to make.

In other words, you really have to be a whole new level of terrible to not improve with the spread. That is how bad CL was.

Since Flood didn't spend any time delevoping the other QBs on the roster, it took forever to get them up to speed.

The young guys on the team will get better every year since they finally have proper coaching. The new guys coming in will be tailored made for the new system.

Things will get better! But we as fans will just have to gut it out for at least two seasons before we see any real improvement as far as wins goes. Season 1 is almost over at least.

Spoiler alert, next year is going to be rough as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: D1ESEL44

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,378
113
Nebraska lost 62-3 to OSU this season. Fire their coach, right?
Your Nebraska example is a straw man.
Nebraska is 8-2. They will likely wind up 10-2 or 9-3.
They beat Northwestern, Indiana, and Minnesota. Lost only 23-17 to Wisconsin.

Maybe if we eeked out wins in the games that were close (Iowa, Minnesota, and Indiana) and were 5-5, or even 4-6, people would not be so down. But we also got blown out by Ohio State and a bad MSU team. I can see people being upset by three major blowouts, which were worse than the blowouts last year. That's the fact, Jack.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,378
113
Ha. Good points.

Plus, example of one coach out of thousands is not much perspective at all. It proves it can happen. Well....no duh.

Here's to hoping Ash will be added to the list.
I did a thread that I can't find right now, but go look at the records of Sonny Dykes at Cal and Mike MacIntyre at Colorado. If Ash follows that trend, we may see some progress in a couple of more wins and less worse blowouts in year 3. Year 4 may be 6-6 or better. We play in a tough conference, and for the foreseeable feature, everything has to go right to beat Michigan, Ohio State and Penn State. Looking at it as a negatoid, those may be three guaranteed losses before the year starts. Throw in UW next year, and that is four guaranteed losses next year. But nothing is guaranteed. But that is the reality. That said, I will predict wins for all of those games in the prediction threads next year.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
Your Nebraska example is a straw man.
Nebraska is 8-2. They will likely wind up 10-2 or 9-3.
They beat Northwestern, Indiana, and Minnesota. Lost only 23-17 to Wisconsin.

Maybe if we eeked out wins in the games that were close (Iowa, Minnesota, and Indiana) and were 5-5, or even 4-6, people would not be so down. But we also got blown out by Ohio State and a bad MSU team. I can see people being upset by three major blowouts, which were worse than the blowouts last year. That's the fact, Jack.
Incorrect. It's not a straw man in the context in which it was used.

Speaking of a straw man, I never said people shouldn't be upset. I'm not about to tell people how they should feel about anything.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,378
113
Incorrect. It's not a straw man in the context in which it was used.

Speaking of a straw man, I never said people shouldn't be upset. I'm not about to tell people how they should feel about anything.
But it's a sports message board. Do you expect fans to remain silent when we were blown out 3 times? Not complain at all, or question decisions made during the game? What else would we talk about here?
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
But it's a sports message board. Do you expect fans to remain silent when we were blown out 3 times? Not complain at all, or question decisions made during the game? What else would we talk about here?
I never said that people shouldn't complain. But saying "That didn't seem like a well-coached game to me" is one thing. People are saying that coaches should be fired. Big difference.

And if people can't think of anything nice to say, they could always post about hookers and blow. Everybody loves hookers and blow. If we offered the recruits free hookers and blow, people could be as negative as they want online and it wouldn't matter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

JQRU91

All-Conference
Apr 6, 2013
1,855
1,386
0
^And this is a good reason to not let a program fall so low. It just takes too long to rebuild, and even that's no guarantee. Look at how long Michigan, who is one of the Bluebloods, sucked under Rich Rod and Brady Hoke, and even their previous coach, Lloyd Carr, had modest success given their resources (3-loss seasons were common under Carr). Harbaugh inherited a talent-rich roster and brought in an experienced staff thanks to an unlimited budget, but he is the exception. Programs that fall have years of rebuilding to do. Will be interesting to see how Oregon and MSU, for example, rebuild.
I don't really see that as a rebuilding issue. I see that as an issue of having hired the wrong head coaches.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
Don't agree.
The Playcalling has been horrendous this year despite the QB issues.
The OC is not ready and should be a position coach somewhere next year.
When you can't run 30% of your offense and when the QB refuses to keep the ball on read option....yes you can blame it on the QB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: D1ESEL44

ElmiraExpress

Senior
Oct 3, 2004
2,439
767
0
i am not comparing Ash to Saban but for the sake of some perspective, I figured I'd post some of Saban's early losses along his coaching career:
55-14 Nebraska
51-23 Washington
52-28 Purdue
51-28 PSU
41-9 Florida
31-0 Bama
50-10 Nebraska
38-0 Stanford
Also lost to a sunbelt team

I don't read every thread or every post, so I never saw the threads or posts calling for Ash's head in his first year. That is crazy, and those people are nuts. I'm searching around now, but I still can't find them. Can you specifically tell me which threads or which posters were calling for Ash's head, because I sure do not see them.
 

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,468
44,531
113
Anyone calling for his head is just a complete idiot, I'm sorry.

This. I'm not happy right now (who is?), but any new coach with this depleted roster, implementing new systems and trying to change the culture that had grown lax under Flood, was bound to struggle. I thought we could win 4 games and we might've with some breaks, but we all knew 2-3 wins was quite possible (not giving up on MD yet and won't give up on PSU until the game's over). Calling for his head now is idiotic.
 

RutgersRaRa

Heisman
Mar 21, 2011
19,092
31,448
113
I don't really see that as a rebuilding issue. I see that as an issue of having hired the wrong head coaches.
Well we are talking about head coaches, and you don't know if a coach is right or not until he's had some time. Your point is well taken about UM's head-coaching problems being different than our rebuild, but it speaks to the importance of head coach having some time.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,220
17,040
113
i am not comparing Ash to Saban but for the sake of some perspective, I figured I'd post some of Saban's early losses along his coaching career:
55-14 Nebraska
51-23 Washington
52-28 Purdue
51-28 PSU
41-9 Florida
31-0 Bama
50-10 Nebraska
38-0 Stanford
Also lost to a sunbelt team
Yes he had some bad losses, most coaches do .
Nick's first year and first game as the Spartan's HC in 1995 Nebraska beat MSU
50-10.
But he did make a bowl game that season finishing up with a 6-5-1 record. 6-4-1 in regular season
Tied Purdue 35-35 and in his first season as HC Michigan St wound up 5th place in the final conference standings with a 4-3-1 record
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
Yes he had some bad losses, most coaches do .
Nick's first year and first game as the Spartan's HC in 1995 Nebraska beat MSU
50-10.
But he did make a bowl game that season finishing up with a 6-5-1 record. 6-4-1 in regular season
Tied Purdue 35-35 and in his first season as HC Michigan St wound up 5th place in the final conference standings with a 4-3-1 record

  • 1995–1997 – Beginning in 1995, Saban moderately improved MSU's fortunes, taking the Spartans to minor bowl games (all of which they lost by double-digit margins) in each of his first three seasons. From 1995 to 1997, Michigan State finished 6-5-1, 6-6, and 7-5. In comparison, MSU had finished 5–6, 6–6 and 5–6 (prior to NCAA forfeits) in 1992–1994.
 

RS17

Heisman
Jun 3, 2011
3,673
13,700
113
Calling for the firing of a head coach in the first year is generally overboard. However so is not allowing him to be questioned either. The most important decisions a head coach makes initially is his coaching staff. He chose someone with a resume shorter than a fortune cookie. Your offensive coordinator before this year has only been paid to coach two years in his life. One in true division one. He was only the co offensive coordinator at James Madison. He didn't even have the full title there. Wide receiver coach at Houston. Who cares if he coached with Herman. He's not Herman. Wait till he gets his players in his offense. You know you have to be a coordinator before you have your offense. Does he even know what his offense is? That's the beauty of actually being a coordinator at a smaller gig for a few years so you can work out the kinks and tweak someone else's offense to your liking. No one copies someone else's offense exactly. But congrats you are paying for him to tweak his offense against the Big ten east and the scores show it. You have not scored against Michigan, Michigan State and Ohio State. That's insane. Not even a garbage TD. Your fanbase has every right to ***** about that. It's holding people accountable to choices they make. Just change the line of wait till Mehringer gets his guys in his offense to Flood always finds the hidden gems and you should be in about the same place. JMO
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
Calling for the firing of a head coach in the first year is generally overboard. However so is not allowing him to be questioned either.
Again, you are overstating things. Nobody is saying people shouldn't post reasonable critique or questions or whatever. Doing that is fine, normal fan behavior. But when our own fans start posting that we should fire this or that coach; well that **** is pointless at best and potentially counter-productive, especially in the first season.

The AD isn't firing anybody. The HC will do what he thinks is right regarding the coaching staff and isn't going to read this forum to help him decide what to do.
 

NickKnight 1

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2003
8,778
2,052
0
I trust Ash with the defense,but Merringher has to NOT be the offense Cord next season.Get someone in here that has run an offense in power five prior,not Co cord at JMU.
also someone that enough sense to use someone that can throw a pass, like a 4 star he ignored.
Merringher is not ready, not ready, not ready. Problem is the same head coach will be doing the
hiring.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,220
17,040
113
  • 1995–1997 – Beginning in 1995, Saban moderately improved MSU's fortunes, taking the Spartans to minor bowl games (all of which they lost by double-digit margins) in each of his first three seasons. From 1995 to 1997, Michigan State finished 6-5-1, 6-6, and 7-5. In comparison, MSU had finished 5–6, 6–6 and 5–6 (prior to NCAA forfeits) in 1992–1994.

Saban had growing pains, but his MSU teams did make bowl games.
Ash might be better compared with Schiano's first season in which his first season ended 2-9 than compared with Saban, because Saban went to MSU after being the Toledo HC for a year with a 9-2 record there.
Schiano came without HCing experience like Ash, and took over a bad RU FB program.
Hopefully Ash will bring back the respect Rutgers FB had before Schiano left, but Chris will make the program better than Greg was able to.
 

madchuck

Heisman
Oct 22, 2016
21,856
46,631
62
I'm not calling for his head but I wouldn't be surprised if he was terrible. I haven't really seen glimpses of good coaching. I would've at least liked to have won one of those close games. I actually think Flood would've done better this season.
 

ATIOH

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2004
986
1,078
0
  • 1995–1997 – Beginning in 1995, Saban moderately improved MSU's fortunes, taking the Spartans to minor bowl games (all of which they lost by double-digit margins) in each of his first three seasons. From 1995 to 1997, Michigan State finished 6-5-1, 6-6, and 7-5. In comparison, MSU had finished 5–6, 6–6 and 5–6 (prior to NCAA forfeits) in 1992–1994.
Dude, c'mon. This is the worst example. Let me add some info that your Wikipedia cut and paste skipped.

It's true Saban got blown out in his first game at MSU against Nebraska. Yes, that's right... the 1995 Cornhuskers which are widely considered one of, if not the best team ever in college football history. Quote: "You've got a second straight national championship, topped by a 62-24 humiliation of second-ranked Florida in the Fiesta Bowl, and one of the best teams ever, in any sport."

You think our schedule is tough? Every team he played that year is in a power 5 conference now. You think our cupboard is bare? Saban had to deal with sanctions from the previous coach. The Spartans didnt have a winning record for years before he came and he immediately took them bowling. And that was back when there were only eighteen bowls.

He kept that team competitive in almost every game and even beat #7 Michigan, as well as Indiana, Illinois, and Minnesota. Stop dragging Sagan into this. You're bordering on RutgersAl levels now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JQRU91

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,220
17,040
113
I'm not calling for his head but I wouldn't be surprised if he was terrible. I haven't really seen glimpses of good coaching. I would've at least liked to have won one of those close games. I actually think Flood would've done better this season.
Flood might have done better because the players fit his system better, but in the long run Flood wouldn't have been good for RU FB.
Ash might not prove to be a good HC, but with some experience he might just prove to be a good choice .
This season should not be taken as an example of his overall ability as a HC, but
as an example that he needs to learn how to be a good HC and this season should be considered on the job training teaching him what he needs to do in order to be a good HC and in the future make RU FB a contender for major bowls every year
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
Dude, c'mon. This is the worst example. Let me add some info that your Wikipedia cut and paste skipped.

It's true Saban got blown out in his first game at MSU against Nebraska. Yes, that's right... the 1995 Cornhuskers which are widely considered one of, if not the best team ever in college football history. Quote: "You've got a second straight national championship, topped by a 62-24 humiliation of second-ranked Florida in the Fiesta Bowl, and one of the best teams ever, in any sport."

You think our schedule is tough? Every team he played that year is in a power 5 conference now. You think our cupboard is bare? Saban had to deal with sanctions from the previous coach. The Spartans didnt have a winning record for years before he came and he immediately took them bowling. And that was back when there were only eighteen bowls.

He kept that team competitive in almost every game and even beat #7 Michigan, as well as Indiana, Illinois, and Minnesota. Stop dragging Sagan into this. You're bordering on RutgersAl levels now.
Saban was good for about one win extra a year inthosenhtree years. Maybe you should read what you post.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,489
13,099
113
[QUOTE="goethe14, post: 2468054, member: 14811 The most important decisions a head coach makes initially is his coaching staff. He chose someone with a resume shorter than a fortune cookie. Your offensive coordinator before this year has only been paid to coach two years in his life. One in true division one. He was only the co offensive coordinator at James Madison. He didn't even have the full title there. Wide receiver coach at Houston. Who cares if he coached with Herman. He's not Herman. That's the beauty of actually being a coordinator at a smaller gig for a few years so you can work out the kinks and tweak someone else's offense to your liking. But congrats you are paying for him to tweak his offense against the Big ten east and the scores show it. You have not scored against Michigan, Michigan State and Ohio State. That's insane. Not even a garbage TD. Your fanbase has every right to ***** about that. It's holding people accountable to choices they make. Just change the line of wait till Mehringer gets his guys in his offense to Flood always finds the hidden gems and you should be in about the same place. JMO[/QUOTE]

This. We have people on this board who live is some fantasy world and say there is no problem with our OC and blame it on the QB.
LMAO
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start