Expectations vs reality

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
Y’all act like god quit making basketball coaches when Cal, Roy, K and the like were born. Don’t think so. There’s another Rupp, pitino,, Cal type out there . Question is, do we get him?
OK, I'll play..If Cal left tomorrow, who do you hire?
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
Toppin in year 3 has he gotten better?
Heck Allen in year 2 has been worse
Allen has actually been better in every category but 3 point shooting. It further highlights your point though. Improvement is hard to predict. Measurable, in game improvement in performance isn't solely tied to the development of the individual players skills, but it can also be context dependent. A new coach at Golden State telling Steph Curry to shoot more two's would make Curry seem worse even though his skills haven't changed, for example.
 

KingOfBBN

Heisman
Sep 14, 2013
39,077
38,403
0
I don’t think we’ve been a legit team that could win it all since 2017.
 
Last edited:

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
So Nate Oats?..what has he won ? I think id like to wait a few years and see how he does at Bama

PS..If you want to go back to this board in 09 you'll see I was begging for Cal to get the job..
What had Pitino won before he got here. What had Tubby won? That's your criteria? No coach since Rupp would have been hired then.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
What had Pitino won before he got here. What had Tubby won? That's your criteria? No coach since Rupp would have been hired then.
Everyone knew Pitino was a homerun hire..as I said, I never wanted Tub..was shocked he won a title....Oats might be a good replacement, but I wouldn't trade at this time.....If you're a Cal hater just admit it..
 

Cleisthenes

All-Conference
Nov 21, 2021
829
1,330
0
Are any of those programs UK?

Is UK the gold standard in college basketball or not?

Villanova won 2 titles in 3 years, Baylor won last year and is a threat to get there this year. uNC lost a hall of fame coach, but that guy had 3 titles to his name. He was in the title game 2 years in a row recently.
Since Cal has been at Kentucky, Jay and Villanova exited in the 2nd round in 10 and 11, was 13-19 in 2011-12 and missed the tournament, lost in the 3rd round, 3rd round, and the 2nd round twice sandwiched in between their two National Titles.

Cal at UK in the same time period went Elite 8, FF, NC, NIT, NC Runner up, FF, Round of 32, Elite 8, Sweet 16, and Elite 8. Went 9-16 last year and missed the tournament.

In the same time period Roy went Elite 8, Elite 8, Round of 32, Round of 32, Sweet 16, NC Runner up, NC, Round of 32, Sweet 16, and they were 14-19 when the season was cancelled due to Covid while Cal and Kentucky were 25-6. Last year UNC was 18-11 and lost in the 1st round of the NCAA Tournament. Oh, and their new coach is Hubert Davis...
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
Everyone knew Pitino was a homerun hire..as I said, I never wanted Tub..was shocked he won a title....Oats might be a good replacement, but I wouldn't trade at this time.....If you're a Cal hater just admit it..
I'm not at all. Maybe you're not aware of this, but UK existed before Cal and will exist after him. It survived Rupp retiring, it will definitely survive Cal.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
I'm not at all. Maybe you're not aware of this, but UK existed before Cal and will exist after him. It survived Rupp retiring, it will definitely survive Cal.
I'm not saying UK would have to close shop...but I do know not many out there that would come that's better
 

rick64

Heisman
Jan 25, 2007
24,679
33,926
113
I know we can woulda coulda shoulda things to death but there should be at least two more NCAAT banners hanging in the rafters at Rupp.
 

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,646
11,889
113
I honestly thought we would have two titles under Cal by now. I feel he will end the Final Four drought sometime soon and I do hope he can add another title before he retires. I had hoped we would have gained more on UCLA in all time titles but I've given up on catching them in my lifetime, dang it. I think Cal will do fine in recruiting but feel his time of dominance is behind him, unfortunately.
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
I'm not saying UK would have to close shop...but I do know not many out there that would come that's better
How do we know that? I agree Cal has it in him if he can re-ignite that fire he had when he came.
Eventually though, whether he leaves or retires, UK will have to hire a coach.
 

jjhagan7

Freshman
Jan 18, 2020
90
86
0
Lets do it this way:
If you look at today's college basketball, meaning, this era, do you see UK as the top program?

Again, not historically, I'm talking about this era.

For me, the answer is simple… NO. In fact, I don't even know if UK is top 5. Villanova, duke, uNC, KU, Gonzaga and maybe even Baylor are ahead of us. If they weren't before 9-17, they are now.

It’s not just about titles and final fours, it's about the programs that have been consistently in the top 5 or 10. UK has not been. We’re always too young and we always have a new roster, so we end up taking more losses than a top program should.

As far as people bringing up gaps in titles and final fours, just stop it, nothing is equal. Cal gets paid a lot more, he has a private jet, he has had a thousand times the talent and he gets the benefit of using UK as a brand that those other coaches helped build.

Cal is also in an era where he has Nike and AAU that are huge advantages in recruiting and the quality of player that comes through the door. I'm not sure these facts have come up in the past, did Tubby and RP have AAU ball to go to for recruiting? Nike?

We can argue all day about how many FF's and titles Cal has, but even the biggest Cal fan (MD) has to admit that he should have more titles and final fours. They also have to admit that his in-game coaching has cost us a title or two.
After reading 7 pages of comments, you are the first person to actually mention his in-game coaching. This is Cal’s biggest flaw in my opinion. Last year we were all excited about Sarr and it was said he was the missing piece. Cal refused to use him for his strengths and was a big part of his bad year. We all were yelling for Mintz to be our point guard after Askew was clearly not but he refused until it was too late. Now we have one of the most experienced 3 point shooters in college basketball but we run no plays for him. He is the highest paid coach, has unlimited resources and to his credit brings in so much talent. But the fact that we have no offensive identity with all the experience we have on this years team tells me he will never change and is why I see him as another HOF coach like Bobby Knight that was the best until his ego got in the way when the game changed and he is unwilling too. How many times after a game you can honestly say to yourself, Cal out coached his opponent. Not many. Again, highest paid coach that went 9-16 with a top 2 recruiting class. BTW, Boston is a completely different player this year with a coach that knows how to get the best out of players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UK-Chulo

lexwildcat859

Junior
Dec 16, 2015
327
347
0
After reading 7 pages of comments, you are the first person to actually mention his in-game coaching. This is Cal’s biggest flaw in my opinion. Last year we were all excited about Sarr and it was said he was the missing piece. Cal refused to use him for his strengths and was a big part of his bad year. We all were yelling for Mintz to be our point guard after Askew was clearly not but he refused until it was too late. Now we have one of the most experienced 3 point shooters in college basketball but we run no plays for him. He is the highest paid coach, has unlimited resources and to his credit brings in so much talent. But the fact that we have no offensive identity with all the experience we have on this years team tells me he will never change and is why I see him as another HOF coach like Bobby Knight that was the best until his ego got in the way when the game changed and he is unwilling too. How many times after a game you can honestly say to yourself, Cal out coached his opponent. Not many. Again, highest paid coach that went 9-16 with a top 2 recruiting class. BTW, Boston is a completely different player this year with a coach that knows how to get the best out of players.
Cal coached Murray and Monk to tremendous 3 pt shooting seasons, all of a sudden he doesnt know how to get players open 3s????

Doesnt sound plausible my dude
 

jjhagan7

Freshman
Jan 18, 2020
90
86
0
Cal coached Murray and Monk to tremendous 3 pt shooting seasons, all of a sudden he doesnt know how to get players open 3s????

Doesnt sound plausible my dude
Apparently you haven’t watched one game this year. Again, that was 4/5 years ago. Have you witnessed anything that resembles getting your best shooters open? Didn’t think so
 

lexwildcat859

Junior
Dec 16, 2015
327
347
0
Apparently you haven’t watched one game this year. Again, that was 4/5 years ago. Have you witnessed anything that resembles getting your best shooters open? Didn’t think so
Ive watched every minute of every game this year and ive seen alot of missed wide open shots, is that cal's fault or do you just want him to keep forcing shots to our 3 pt shooters so they can keep missing?
 

jjhagan7

Freshman
Jan 18, 2020
90
86
0
Ive watched every minute of every game this year and ive seen alot of missed wide open shots, is that cal's fault or do you just want him to keep forcing shots to our 3 pt shooters so they can keep missing?
Grady is shooting 42.1% from 3’s this year. You might want to pay more attention to the games
 
  • Like
Reactions: UK-Chulo

lexwildcat859

Junior
Dec 16, 2015
327
347
0
Grady is shooting 42.1% from 3’s this year. You might want to pay more attention to the games
Yup and he was 3-4 for the first half the last game, second half he was 0-3 all wide open; so how many more shots should he have been allowed to miss?
 

jjhagan7

Freshman
Jan 18, 2020
90
86
0
Yup and he was 3-4 for the first half the last game, second half he was 0-3 all wide open; so how many more shots should he have been allowed to miss?
Apparently Jonny you don’t understand basketball very much. Grady’s shooting is on par with Lamb. That percentage is extremely high for any great 3 point shooter. It’s obvious to me you are a Cal fan and statistics won’t change your mind. Yes, Cal is a HOF coach, the best ever and deserves more than a million dollars a win. He can flat out coach. Same offense since he’s been here
 

lexwildcat859

Junior
Dec 16, 2015
327
347
0
Apparently Jonny you don’t understand basketball very much. Grady’s shooting is on par with Lamb. That percentage is extremely high for any great 3 point shooter. It’s obvious to me you are a Cal fan and statistics won’t change your mind. Yes, Cal is a HOF coach, the best ever and deserves more than a million dollars a win. He can flat out coach. Same offense since he’s been here
The same offense youre trashing is responsible for getting Murray and Monk multiple games of 6 or more made threes, Doron Lamb had alot of those games too including in the championship game, so when is the last time a UK player hit 6 or more 3s in a game? If its happened under Cal before does that mean its the fault of the offense or the players not making shots????

Edit: Quickley had 1 or 2 of these games so obviously the offense is conducive to 3 pt shooters but they have to make the shots
 

jjhagan7

Freshman
Jan 18, 2020
90
86
0
The same offense youre trashing is responsible for getting Murray and Monk multiple games of 6 or more made threes, Doron Lamb had alot of those games too including in the championship game, so when is the last time a UK player hit 6 or more 3s in a game? If its happened under Cal before does that mean its the fault of the offense or the players not making shots????

Edit: Quickley had 1 or 2 of these games so obviously the offense is conducive to 3 pt shooters but they have to make the shots
Who’s the best 3 pointer shooter of all time…Steph Curry. He is shooting 41.3% this year and that is the focal point every game and is why they win so many games and have one of the best records this year. Grady is our 5th option on offense. Is that really good coaching? No it’s not
 

lexwildcat859

Junior
Dec 16, 2015
327
347
0
Who’s the best 3 pointer shooter of all time…Steph Curry. He is shooting 41.3% this year and that is the focal point every game and is why they win so many games and have one of the best records this year. Grady is our 5th option on offense. Is that really good coaching? No it’s not
How do you know hes our 5th option, it looks to me like hes our 2nd option but the opposing teams have successfully taken him away, and when they dont hes missing shots lately
 

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
50,617
70,884
113
After reading 7 pages of comments, you are the first person to actually mention his in-game coaching. This is Cal’s biggest flaw in my opinion. Last year we were all excited about Sarr and it was said he was the missing piece. Cal refused to use him for his strengths and was a big part of his bad year. We all were yelling for Mintz to be our point guard after Askew was clearly not but he refused until it was too late. Now we have one of the most experienced 3 point shooters in college basketball but we run no plays for him. He is the highest paid coach, has unlimited resources and to his credit brings in so much talent. But the fact that we have no offensive identity with all the experience we have on this years team tells me he will never change and is why I see him as another HOF coach like Bobby Knight that was the best until his ego got in the way when the game changed and he is unwilling too. How many times after a game you can honestly say to yourself, Cal out coached his opponent. Not many. Again, highest paid coach that went 9-16 with a top 2 recruiting class. BTW, Boston is a completely different player this year with a coach that knows how to get the best out of players.
A perfect example of his offensive coaching inabilities, is this Notre Dame game. My goodness he’s bad.
 

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
50,617
70,884
113
The same offense youre trashing is responsible for getting Murray and Monk multiple games of 6 or more made threes, Doron Lamb had alot of those games too including in the championship game, so when is the last time a UK player hit 6 or more 3s in a game? If its happened under Cal before does that mean its the fault of the offense or the players not making shots????

Edit: Quickley had 1 or 2 of these games so obviously the offense is conducive to 3 pt shooters but they have to make the shots
This isn't the same offense man. How can you say this team plays the same offense as any of his previous teams AFTER saying you've watched every minute of UK ball this season?

This offense is completely different. It’s mostly long two pointers and no rim runs.
 

fisherscat

All-Conference
Feb 9, 2005
11,283
4,714
0
If I left off 2016 then you left off 2015 - (38-1) and 2014 - (Final Game).
No 1 seeds since 2015. 1 2 seed.

Decline
Looking at the last five years, as I did, is an objective take. People generally look at things in five-year increments.

Choosing to start at an odd number like 6 is simply trying to reinforce a biased point of view. Either look at the whole story back to 2010, or if trying (and failing) to make the point that the recent past has been bad, go back five years, as I did.
 

rodserling

All-Conference
Apr 19, 2011
1,580
1,173
0
I really expected us to be on probation by now.

99.9% of the fans on this site thought Cal was a lying, cheating, snake oil salesman who was not a top level game coach when he was at Memphis.

It appears he may have stopped cheating.......hopefully.

One out of 4 ain't bad.
Now, that is funny. It's funny because it's true.
 

jjhagan7

Freshman
Jan 18, 2020
90
86
0
How many years of crap teams will it take to convince the Cal fans that he refuses to modernize his offense
Those Cal fans are just like him…PRIDEFUL. They will continue to make excuses for him while it’s so clear to any college basketball fan how atrocious our offense is with the talent we have. It’s embarrassing and I try so hard to route for Cal but with every bad offensive game plan, I can’t. I love UK basketball, not Cal.
 

rodserling

All-Conference
Apr 19, 2011
1,580
1,173
0
Calipari interjected an immediate dose of energy into the program when he was hired. I thought we'd have multiple titles by now, so that's disappointing that we just have one, especially since we came so close with the 2011, 2014, and 2015 teams.

I still insist, as do many here, that Calipari has never been the same since 38-0 vs. Wisconsin. Sometimes bad beats just stay with coaches/programs for a really long time and that has hung over ours for what seems like an eternity. Just looking at Calipari on the bench these he seems tired and worn out. The same swag just isn't there anymore.
If this is the case, he should have quit coaching after that miserable loss to Kansas in the final game when he was at Memphis. I thought that game was just an aberration but I'm not so sure anymore.
 

jjhagan7

Freshman
Jan 18, 2020
90
86
0
How do you know hes our 5th option, it looks to me like hes our 2nd option but the opposing teams have successfully taken him away, and when they dont hes missing shots lately
Don’t ever
The same offense youre trashing is responsible for getting Murray and Monk multiple games of 6 or more made threes, Doron Lamb had alot of those games too including in the championship game, so when is the last time a UK player hit 6 or more 3s in a game? If its happened under Cal before does that mean its the fault of the offense or the players not making shots????

Edit: Quickley had 1 or 2 of these games so obviously the offense is conducive to 3 pt shooters but they have to make the shots
Don’t ever take up for Cal for his offensive philosophy. He is a terrible in-game coach and he just showed you 40 minutes of proof. We just got beat by a 3-4 team. Please wake up.
 
May 4, 2015
10,514
13,584
86
Cal & the pumpers say: