Do we take Cal for granted?

oakhillcatman

All-Conference
Oct 23, 2010
1,315
2,050
113
When we lost Antigua our recruiting went down now with him and Chin back we are once again on top this will help plus we need to invest more in the transfer market
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,407
46,214
90
We take Cal's off the court strengths for granted.

The next coach here likely won't have as robust of a network of connections into the most important parties involved in player acquisition or as successfully manage off court player mishaps and shenanigans.
The first part I’d say is a question mark. The Nike machine doesn’t necessarily disappear without Cal. No doubt he has been good at keeping off court issues tamped down. But he draws attention to issues much more than he did in the past.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jrm693 and fatguy87

ukcatz12

Heisman
Mar 27, 2009
5,199
12,325
0
But things have definitely been different since 2019.
The only thing that's been different since 2019 is the 9-16 season, which is obviously such an outlier I'm not sure why people really care much at this point. It's over and done with and the very next year we were a 2 seed. And as people are hopefully slowly realizing, losing in the first round last year is just something that was bound to happen at some point, especially in this current era of college ball.
 

Sportspm

All-Conference
Jul 26, 2009
875
1,720
57
We don’t forget. That was 6 years ago and we still lost. Counting 2020 is for losers, no offense. It’s like counting Helms titles but worse.
Counting 2020 is for losers? What are you talking about. I’m not defending Cal, I’ve been as upset as anyone last few years. All I was saying is that team had a chance and we was cheated in 2017. No need to resort to name calling
 

jbne222

Heisman
Dec 14, 2019
5,561
10,515
113
The only thing that's been different since 2019 is the 9-16 season, which is obviously such an outlier I'm not sure why people really care much at this point. It's over and done with and the very next year we were a 2 seed. And as people are hopefully slowly realizing, losing in the first round last year is just something that was bound to happen at some point, especially in this current era of college ball.
I don’t disagree about the loss last year being something that happens to everyone, and it was actually impressive we had avoided that for so long. But I think it’s just been tough because it was right after the 9-16 year, and obviously the year before that the tournament getting cancelled sucked (not that it was anyone’s fault). We’ve just been thirsty for tournament success as a fanbase
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,407
46,214
90
Since losing to Wisconsin he's been literally two shots away from two more Final Fours. The 9-16 season is really the only horrible part about the last seven years.
Tell that to Tubby, Bobby Perry, and Sheray Thomas. Tell that to Keith Bogans ankle.

Just win baby. This is the pinnacle. Close doesn’t cut it for long. Time to move along and give someone younger and hungrier a shot at the chair.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jrm693 and LmdCat

ukfan2410

All-American
Feb 15, 2003
7,914
8,147
113
The problem is most of those were from 2009-15 and I loved having Cal during that time. He was hungry.

Since losing to Wisconsin, he hasn’t been the same. To use Cal’s words against him, they broke his spirit.
I really do not understand this line of thinking. Fox,Monk,Bama was a jumpsuit away from Final 4 and possibly a Title. PJ,Herro,Keldon team was an OT away from Final 4 and another possible Title. Last year's team was maybe the best team in the country until injuries hit, they mopped the National Champion on their home floor in late Jan. This doesn't even mention the Quickley,Maxey team that was primed for a run or the Ulis,Murray team who got beat by a good IU team on an off night, it happens
 
  • Like
Reactions: jbne222

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,407
46,214
90
Counting 2020 is for losers? What are you talking about. I’m not defending Cal, I’ve been as upset as anyone last few years. All I was saying is that team had a chance and we was cheated in 2017. No need to resort to name calling
Acting like we might have won it in 2020 is a loser ploy. Sorry. Every team could do that, and we would be fairly far down the list of teams with a legitimate claim. Kansas would be at the top.
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
The first part I’d say is a question mark. The Nike machine doesn’t necessarily disappear without Cal. No doubt he has been good at keeping off court issues tamped down. But he draws attention to issues much more than he did in the past.
The soft power of his verbal persuasion tools diminishes as examples of hypocrisy, lying, and duplicity accrue over time.

Mediocre results accelerates the atrophy of his grip on the wheels of the program.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jrm693 and Aike

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,407
46,214
90
The soft power of his verbal persuasion tools diminishes as examples of hypocrisy, lying, and duplicity accrue of time.

Mediocre results accelerates the atrophy of his grip on the wheels of the program.
Well stated.
 

ukcatz12

Heisman
Mar 27, 2009
5,199
12,325
0
I don’t disagree about the loss last year being something that happens to everyone, and it was actually impressive we had avoided that for so long. But I think it’s just been tough because it was right after the 9-16 year, and obviously the year before that the tournament getting cancelled sucked (not that it was anyone’s fault). We’ve just been thirsty for tournament success as a fanbase
Yeah I get the feeling, I just try to be objective about things if possible. And the whole narrative around Cal recently is completely different if we change the results of a handful of shots over the last ten years. The '11 and '14 Final Fours were as lucky as the '17 and '19 Elite Eight losses were unlucky. And that's not enough for me to want a change just yet.
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
Acting like we might have won it in 2020 is a loser ploy. Sorry. Every team could do that, and we would be fairly far down the list of teams with a legitimate claim. Kansas would be at the top.
Ha yeah. We were barely top 30 in Kenpom and had the 52nd ranked team in adjusted defensive rating.

That was with 2 NBA guards and Nick Richards on the roster, no less.
 

LmdCat

Heisman
Jan 8, 2006
23,627
18,894
0
I really do not understand this line of thinking. Fox,Monk,Bama was a jumpsuit away from Final 4 and possibly a Title. PJ,Herro,Keldon team was an OT away from Final 4 and another possible Title. Last year's team was maybe the best team in the country until injuries hit, they mopped the National Champion on their home floor in late Jan. This doesn't even mention the Quickley,Maxey team that was primed for a run or the Ulis,Murray team who got beat by a good IU team on an off night, it happens
Why doesn't he suggest the hanging of almost final 4 banners. Maybe you can convince the NCAA to give out some almost trophies and rings. Almost conversations are for those who only have "almosts" to talk about. You must be from the participation-trophy generation,
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jrm693

jbne222

Heisman
Dec 14, 2019
5,561
10,515
113
You're wrong. We always have one of the top classes. It's basically meaningless at this point.
I think what he means is that next year’s class is at a level it hasn’t been at since the Fox/Monk team. In the 4 years we’ve had 3 top 10 recruits we have one championship, a final four, and two elite 8s
 

jbne222

Heisman
Dec 14, 2019
5,561
10,515
113
Yeah I get the feeling, I just try to be objective about things if possible. And the whole narrative around Cal recently is completely different if we change the results of a handful of shots over the last ten years. The '11 and '14 Final Fours were as lucky as the '17 and '19 Elite Eight losses were unlucky. And that's not enough for me to want a change just yet.
Yeah that’s exactly what I pointed out in my original post. We had a couple shots go our way in ‘11 and ‘14 and those same plays just went the other way in ‘17 and ‘19.

And that’s not even including PJ missing 10 free throws in 2018
 

Sportspm

All-Conference
Jul 26, 2009
875
1,720
57
Acting like we might have won it in 2020 is a loser ploy. Sorry. Every team could do that, and we would be fairly far down the list of teams with a legitimate claim. Kansas would be at the top.
Every team? Use common sense man. We were playing great at end of that year. Quickly was SEC player of the year. Lighting it up from 3. We had a better shot than most. I wasn’t claiming it. Just saying we had a good chance that year. That said the 9-16 year is worst in our history
 

jrm693

All-Conference
Jan 14, 2007
12,363
4,206
68
People can’t understand ebb and flow
The money doesn't ebb and flow, he is rich and is family is set for life, he has a contract that is difficult to buy out, and he loves to be right and will not change...because he doesn't have too and their is nothing short of making him richer that can be done about it. He doesn't get the best of the best anymore which is what he set the tournament wins with. I dont dislike him and hope he turns it around and sails off into the sunset on top of the College basketball world, but he has become complacent and it is something most humans would do under similar circumstances but it has adversely affected the Kentucky basketball program. When he came I hoped he would coach here until they had to roll him out in a wheelchair and I did not put stock in the "its a 10 year job" talk but I am believing now there may be something to that.
 
  • Love
Reactions: LmdCat

jbne222

Heisman
Dec 14, 2019
5,561
10,515
113
Why don't suggest the hanging of almost final 4 banners. Maybe you can convince the NCAA to give out some almost trophies and rings. Almost conversations are for those who only have "almosts" to talk about. You must be from the participation-trophy generation,
That’s not his point. He’s just pointing out that we haven’t been as far off as many people like to think. No one thinks the last few years have lived up to expectations, but if a couple plays go our way this is a much different conversation.
 

LmdCat

Heisman
Jan 8, 2006
23,627
18,894
0
I think what he means is that next year’s class is at a level it hasn’t been at since the Fox/Monk team. In the 4 years we’ve had 3 top 10 recruits we have one championship, a final four, and two elite 8s
If other coaches can win without have overwhelming talent, why do you think a coach who needs that deserves praise? If the level of talent is so great that a coach isn't required, why have one. Just hire a full-time recruiter and allow the best players to be player coaches.
 
Last edited:

LmdCat

Heisman
Jan 8, 2006
23,627
18,894
0
That’s not his point. He’s just pointing out that we haven’t been as far off as many people like to think. No one thinks the last few years have lived up to expectations, but if a couple plays go our way this is a much different conversation.
His point is that he is searching hard for some feel-good story or reason to praise Cal. When the coach's salary syncs up with almost winning, bring your discussion back. Winners are about result and not feel-good cliche's.
 

Jont0805

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2019
1,010
1,615
0
If other coaches can win without have overwhelming talent, why do you think a coach who needs that deserves praise? If the level of talent is so great that coach isn't required, why have one. Just hire a full-time recruiter and allow the best players to be player coaches.
I think that’s essentially what Cal wanted to do and our wonderful athletic director turned him down.

But that is according to Tucker so who knows.

This Program with Cal as “GM” is next level good and innovative again.
 

jbne222

Heisman
Dec 14, 2019
5,561
10,515
113
If other coaches can win without have overwhelming talent, why do you think a coach who needs that deserves praise? If the level of talent is so great that coach isn't required, why have one. Just hire a full-time recruiter and allow the best players to be player coaches.
I’m not praising him I’m just pointing it out.

I don’t think that argument holds true. Clearly we’ve learned that it isn’t all about talent in college basketball, you can have all the talent/potential in the world but it doesn’t mean you can win 6 games in a row in March. Duke had 3 top 10 recruits this year and lost in the 2nd round. They also didn’t make a final four with 3 top 5 recruits the Zion year. That’s just two of countless examples.
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,407
46,214
90
Cal’s first 5 years here we won 18 tournament games.

His next 5 we won 13. 4 of those in year 6 (last FF appearance).

Next 4 seasons - 1 so far. I know I know. Covid, etc. Let’s see what we can do with the rest of this season.
 

jbne222

Heisman
Dec 14, 2019
5,561
10,515
113
His point is that he is searching hard for some feel-good story or reason to praise Cal. When the coach's salary syncs up with almost winning, bring your discussion back. Winners are about result and not feel-good cliche's.
I don’t think a lot of us are praising Cal. I’m certainly not. I’m just trying to be objective and say that it hasn’t been the absolute hopeless disaster that people think
 

STL_Cat

Heisman
Dec 4, 2011
64,890
57,651
98
The only thing that's been different since 2019 is the 9-16 season, which is obviously such an outlier I'm not sure why people really care much at this point. It's over and done with and the very next year we were a 2 seed. And as people are hopefully slowly realizing, losing in the first round last year is just something that was bound to happen at some point, especially in this current era of college ball.
We got a 6 seed this season.
 
Jan 9, 2007
15,353
13,412
0
Right. Great team ‘17, ‘19, ‘20, ‘22 and a decent team still alive in ‘23.

That’s the “trend”. And trending up for next year.
None of those teams were 1 seeds. None of them made the Final 4. One of them had the worst tournament loss in program history.

You’re also conveniently omitting he worst season in program history.

We have a different definition of “great” I guess
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKNothinButNet

mc140

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
8,807
2,879
113
No. He won the game he was supposed to Friday. Now win today and you can at least argue it wasn't a disappointing season.
 

LmdCat

Heisman
Jan 8, 2006
23,627
18,894
0
I don’t think a lot of us are praising Cal. I’m certainly not. I’m just trying to be objective and say that it hasn’t been the absolute hopeless disaster that people think
If you want the basketball world to recognize us as the best, stop acting like we are in need of undeserving praise.