Disappointed in Rupp/question for architects/ Engineers

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
Plus, codes vary from state to state.

Different states adopt different versions of the building codes. KY follows KBC which is based on the IBC. Every so often there are changes and states move to adopt the updates as they see fit. So KY may be enforcing things that are "new" while another state may not. Its up to the local authority having jurisdiction as to what they push or frankly ignore by waiver. In this case it may be something that changed in the code between the 70's and now. For example ADA was well after Rupp was built. So whenever there is a major renovation you would have to bring the facility up to the new codes.

My guess, and it is just a guess based on the earlier link to the code I found, is that there MUST be a top rail now rather than the cable they previously had. The cable may still be there, just hidden inside the new rail. Can you imagine how much force would be applied to that railing system in case of a terror even. Hundreds pushing against that glass railing without any top support that would meet the code requirement. No one wants to be sued out of existence. So rather than blaming the architect or engineer for VE....I would wait to see if someone in the know gives the actual answer. They didnt change it for the heck of it. JMHO
 
Last edited:

RobynL

Junior
Apr 9, 2007
402
285
0
Any pictures of these issues? I never sat in those areas to know what you are talking about. Don't really understand what the issue is without seeing it.
I have a pic I took in section 215 Row C because I couldn’t believe that metal strip was there. I can’t get the pic to post though
 

RobynL

Junior
Apr 9, 2007
402
285
0
I’ll take pics but no sure I’m tech savvy enough to post them. . Better still why don’t those of you who are interested simply go up before the game and find an open seat in row C(that’s the worst } and you will immediately see what I mean. Last night most of the seats were unoccupied and believe me the ones who were there for the first time were very vocal about it.

I realize this is not a life altering event. I just had A friend diagnosed with cancer . No this us not a big deal in the grand scheme of things.

I can solve my problem . I give UK enough each year that I can simply redirect a few grand or so and Move downstairs for the five or so games I really want to attend. I normally love sitting up high at sporting events and always try and get in the first row or two in the second tier , best seat in the. House . I just think it’s a lousy thing for uncaring or unknowledgeable architects to do to loyal fans .

There has to b a better way to do this architecturally . My guess is this was this architects first job. Or maybe she was doing a sports arena for the first time .

Hopefully, the powers that b will fix this . Several years ago I wrote a post that the biggest problem with Rupp was not selling ice cream upstairs . Next season they had it . Not saying my post did it but just saying if you don’t point out how things can be better they never will b.
Thanks
I have a picture I took section 215 row c. It’s awful. Not my seats but I couldn’t believe it. That darn strip runs right through the center of the court when you are sitting in your seat. It’s unacceptable. I can’t post the picture for some reason.
 

RobynL

Junior
Apr 9, 2007
402
285
0
I remember when the nhl first required netting around behind the goals that wrapped around. At first it sucked but I got used to it. I imagine this is the same. Eventually you’ll get used to it
False. Not even close to being the same as netting. This is a big deal. You have to sit there to know.
 

KyCatFan1

Heisman
May 6, 2002
30,867
31,594
113
I have a picture I took section 215 row c. It’s awful. Not my seats but I couldn’t believe it. That darn strip runs right through the center of the court when you are sitting in your seat. It’s unacceptable. I can’t post the picture for some reason.

If you upload it to a site like Imgur to host it, then copy the link to the photo, and paste it here we can then see it. You click the box next to the emoji and paste it in there. It should show up on here. If you don't want to go through all that then just send it to me at [email protected] and I will do it for you.
 

NothinButNylon

All-Conference
Jan 3, 2003
1,061
1,147
0
 

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
OP is plotting a Marxist uprising at Rupp among the nosebleed section Proletariat.

Look out blue hairs, the revolution is upon you.
 

RobynL

Junior
Apr 9, 2007
402
285
0
If you upload it to a site like Imgur to host it, then copy the link to the photo, and paste it here we can then see it. You click the box next to the emoji and paste it in there. It should show up on here. If you don't want to go through all that then just send it to me at [email protected] and I will do it for you.
Just sent to your email. Thanks!!!
 

RobynL

Junior
Apr 9, 2007
402
285
0
Yes, quality did go down. Sorry about that. The gray bar is much more pronounced in person and really obstructs the view.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
Yes, quality did go down. Sorry about that. The gray bar is much more pronounced in person and really obstructs the view.
Of course it is even worse than shown because you are changing your view of the court as the play goes back and forth. Basically the tickets in rows B tru D are worthless and Rupp should make the architectural firm fix the problem .

As shown above it can be fixed . It’s just a matter of money .

For years I traveled around the country doing crisis management for many major corporations . This is a bad PR screw up . Best thing to do is apologize and fix it. Someone tried to go the cheap route and UK basketball should be first class at everything including how it treats its loyal fans. Not take the cheap route .

The problem is also the priority system . Under the system the most loyal fans (With the most points) ended up with the worst seats . What are u going to do to correct it if u don’t fix the problem?

Tell the most loyal fans to buzz off? Redo the selection of seats next year ? If you do that everybody will b po’d and nobody will select those four rows .
Best thing to do is fess up . Made a mistake . And fix the problem IMHO . Otherwise nobody is going to want those seats for the life of the arena. Give loyal fans what they paid for .
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
Of course it is even worse than shown because you are changing your view of the court as the play goes back and forth. Basically the tickets in rows B tru D are worthless and Rupp should make the architectural firm fix the problem .

As shown above it can be fixed . It’s just a matter of money .

For years I traveled around the country doing crisis management for many major corporations . This is a bad PR screw up . Best thing to do is apologize and fix it. Someone tried to go the cheap route and UK basketball should be first class at everything including how it treats its loyal fans. Not take the cheap route .

The problem is also the priority system . Under the system the most loyal fans (With the most points) ended up with the worst seats . What are u going to do to correct it if u don’t fix the problem?

Tell the most loyal fans to buzz off? Redo the selection of seats next year ? If you do that everybody will b po’d and nobody will select those four rows .
Best thing to do is fess up . Made a mistake . And fix the problem IMHO . Otherwise nobody is going to want those seats for the life of the arena. Give loyal fans what they paid for .

Doesn’t sound to me like there has been a screw up. The PR screwup happens if they circumvent code and people die.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
Yes that sucks. My hope is by this thread someone from UK athletics will quietly go down to Rupp and sit in the seats. They are reasonable people.
If we can just get them to do it my thought is their reaction will b “good lord . We have to fix this”.

I’m all for progress . Even though seven things about progress resulted in my tailgate crew of 14 giving up our football tickets after 40 years . Won’t go into that because of time and UK certainly makes more money because of the progress in football infrastructure . We were just collateral damage .i get that and would have done the same thing if I were them to maximize profit.

However , this is different . UK and Rupp will b better off if they fix this now . A solution is possible . The Greeks and Romans built coliseums with better sight lines over 2000 years ago for God’s sake .
 

The_Godfather_rivals

All-Conference
May 22, 2002
25,432
3,795
113
My parents are forced to deal with this at the moment. The most frustrating part of this was that they called UK 5 times prior to them selecting their seats in order to get some clarity as to whether there'd be some sort of obstruction and nobody could give them an answer.

Now, I don't know what UK can do since they don't own the facility, but it's going to render those seats to being difficult to sell in the future unless they either fix this issue our discount them significantly.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
Doesn’t sound to me like there has been a screw up. The PR screwup happens if they circumvent code and people die.
its a screw up when several hundred of your most loyal fans are screwed and feel let down. What should have been an improvement is a nightmare. as pointed out above it can be fixed. Just a question of money and who pays. May thought is the architect 's E And O c carrier is on the hook. nobody in their right mind would buy these tickets. Rupp/UK did not get what it paid for.
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
its a screw up when several hundred of your most loyal fans are screwed and feel let down. What should have been an improvement is a nightmare. as pointed out above it can be fixed. Just a question of money and who pays. May thought is the architect 's E And O c carrier is on the hook. nobody in their right mind would buy these tickets. Rupp/UK did not get what it paid for.

I never saw a viable solution that offered equivalent safety.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
I never saw a viable solution that offered equivalent safety.


Would you buy tickets to any event in Rupp in rows B,C D or E?

If you had been a loyal season ticket holder for 40 years and had built up points to give you priority would you feel you had been treated fairly?

How would you correct the problem for them?redo the selection of seats next year?

Don't tell me every new stadium in the country has four unusable rows.

I'm not on this crusade for myself. I'm not even a season ticket holder.

I have seen hundreds of games in Rupp and will see many more from other seats than these.
I'm a very lucky and fortunate person. I realize that.

I just think my friends have been treated very shabbily and it can and should be fixed.
 
Last edited:

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
Pointed out where that says there is a better but more costly solution?

You were nice enough to post above IBC standards . On the right hand side of the attachment it shows panels without the metal bar at the top. and states:

GUARD WITHOUT TOP RAIL.PERMITTED ONLY WHEN USED WITH LAMINATED,TEMPERED GLASS OR IF THE GLASS BALUSTRADE MEETS THE STRUCTURAL LOAD REQUIREMENTS SET OUT IN 1BC16077.

So they had two ways to do it . And since they were rebuilding the entire structure they could have done it either way without the top rail. I am assuming it would have been more costly . Why else would any architect have this design flaw but to save money.

I know they are supposedly an elite sports architectural firm. Maybe they felt they could put anything over on a bunch of dumb Kentuckians.
It is second rate. and our fans and our program are not second rate and it should be changed to give Rupp arena what it paid for.
They didn't pay for a continual problem.
 

Blue Decade

All-American
May 3, 2013
10,266
6,034
0
  1. First those who are familiar with my posts know I am not a complainer . I think MB has done a fantastic job with all the conflicting priorities of our various programs . He gets an A plus in my book ..
However my observation is that in the name of safety the improvements to the upper tier of Rupp were perhaps performed by architects not familiar with sporting events. Basically , rows B tru F have gone from some of the best seats in the house to some of the worst .

Question. With all of the technology available is it really necessary to have a two inch metal strip obstructing the view to hold the plastic panels in place . Before u had simply a wire which worked fine and after a while your eyes got use to it. No way to see though two inches of metal . Has to b a better solution.

Second question . Is it really necessary to have a half inch gap between plastic panels ? The gap creates a further visual barrier which when combined with the Two inch metal strip Is really annoying .
Also ,
When the person below u leans forward u either have to also lean forward or see the back of their head for half of the court area. I don’t remember this ever being a problem in any other coliseum or stadium where I have watched games . Something the matter with the pitch?

I also note that for some reason they raised the second tier by about seven or eight feet .
which makes you that much further from the court .

Any architects or engineers have any solution to the two inch bar at the top of the plastic panels obstructing the view or of the half inch gap between the panels. Are both really necessary?
why not go back to the metal cord which worked fine previously ?any other modern solution.

I find myself watching the game on the big screen most of the time . Kind of crazy to go to the fame to see it on TV.

Again not trying to b a complainer. I’m not a season ticket holder . But many if those around me in row C tonight were and to say the least were disappointed . Any constructive solutions any if you have seen elsewhere or is that simply the limit of today’s technology that it delivers worst sight lines than the architects of forty and fifty years ago.
Thanks
As I have explained in the past, I work for a company that has consultant contracts with UK and some other large entities. We recommend security protocols and analyze risk/reward for all kinds of capital investment and hiring scenarios. Several years ago, UK’s facility contract with Rupp Arena was nearing its expiration. The University was engaged in analyzing whether they would choose to negotiate a contract renewal with the city or build an on-campus basketball arena on the south side of campus. The on-campus arena was doable as long as verbal agreements for financial support scenarios could be finalized. But pulling UK basketball out of Rupp Arena would have devastated the fragile downtown economy and crossed some red lines in understandings that existed with a group of franchising companies operating in that part of downtown Lexington. So the Lexington government appointed a task force, consisting of city officials, prominent business leaders, and Mitch Barnhart. The upshot is that UK felt obligated to support the city by renewing the contract and keeping the basketball program in Rupp Arena. Mr. Barnhart invoked UK’s leverage by submitting a list of renovation requirements and other stipulations necessary from UK’s point of view in order for UK to agree to a contract renewal. Under the terms, the city oversaw the renovations, which were funded with funds raised by the city through various resource channels including a contribution made by UK. In the big picture, UK was very civic-minded. UK helped to fund the improvements while leaving the largest portion of proceeds from parking and concessions revenues to the city. But the city oversaw the renovations, and budgets were strained at the time. The bottom line is that the city did what was necessary, and no more. But the relationship was preserved, and the downtown Lexington economy dodged a big bullet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lz

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
Would you buy tickets to any event in Rupp in rows B,C D or E?

If you had been a loyal season ticket holder for 40 years and had built up points to give you priority would you feel you had been treated fairly?

How would you correct the problem for them?redo the selection of seats next year?

Don't tell me every new stadium in the country has four unusable rows.

I'm not on this crusade for myself. I'm not even a season ticket holder.

I have seen hundreds of games in Rupp and will see many more from other seats than these.
I'm a very lucky and fortunate person. I realize that.

I just think my friends have been treated very shabbily and it can and should be fixed.

And so your PR solution is to undermine the code and deal with the accidents as they happen along with the liability? Somebody will take those seats.
 

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
You were nice enough to post above IBC standards . On the right hand side of the attachment it shows panels without the metal bar at the top. and states:

GUARD WITHOUT TOP RAIL.PERMITTED ONLY WHEN USED WITH LAMINATED,TEMPERED GLASS OR IF THE GLASS BALUSTRADE MEETS THE STRUCTURAL LOAD REQUIREMENTS SET OUT IN 1BC16077.

So they had two ways to do it . And since they were rebuilding the entire structure they could have done it either way without the top rail. I am assuming it would have been more costly . Why else would any architect have this design flaw but to save money.

I know they are supposedly an elite sports architectural firm. Maybe they felt they could put anything over on a bunch of dumb Kentuckians.
It is second rate. and our fans and our program are not second rate and it should be changed to give Rupp arena what it paid for.
They didn't pay for a continual problem.

I think the most important part of that section is IF THE GLASS BALUSTRADE MEETS THE STRUCTURAL LOAD REQUIREMENTS SET OUT IN 1BC16077.
My assumption is that there was/is no way to meet the load requirements without the top rail. The engineers no doubt had to factor in what is POSSIBLE as to the amount of crowd crushing against that railing in case of a panic situation.

I think they were forced to decide between uprights to share the load and having those spaced out at every point where the glass panels meet like fence posts. I've looked at other facilities such as KFC YUM and they have metal railing systems of steel tube mounted on top of knee walls. You should check out some of those views. Anyway, I personally believe that the system you are stuck with was the best of two evils. I also believe that this was about as expensive a solution as there was available. JMHO It is something that hopefully people will get use to but I feel your pain.

You mentioned that before there was a steel cable across the top of the glass. Did that not obstruct the view as well? Obviously not to the same degree it was something there but you got use to?
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
And so your PR solution is to undermine the code and deal with the accidents as they happen along with the liability? Somebody will take those seats.
as i said I'm sure they felt they could do it on the cheap and a bunch of dumb Kentuckians wouldn't know enough to object to it. Code says it can be done two other ways.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
I think the most important part of that section is IF THE GLASS BALUSTRADE MEETS THE STRUCTURAL LOAD REQUIREMENTS SET OUT IN 1BC16077.
My assumption is that there was/is no way to meet the load requirements without the top rail. The engineers no doubt had to factor in what is POSSIBLE as to the amount of crowd crushing against that railing in case of a panic situation.

I think they were forced to decide between uprights to share the load and having those spaced out at every point where the glass panels meet like fence posts. I've looked at other facilities such as KFC YUM and they have metal railing systems of steel tube mounted on top of knee walls. You should check out some of those views. Anyway, I personally believe that the system you are stuck with was the best of two evils. I also believe that this was about as expensive a solution as there was available. JMHO It is something that hopefully people will get use to but I feel your pain.

You mentioned that before there was a steel cable across the top of the glass. Did that not obstruct the view as well? Obviously not to the same degree it was something there but you got use to?
I respectfully disagree with your assumption. The code clearly shows two options without the metal cap. The code would not allow those two options if they were dangerous.
No the steel cable was no problem at all. pitch was different and height of cable different. that's why I am certain it could have been designed better. It was better before.

furthermore , they didn'tg have the constraints of working with the existing structure. they tore the whole structure out and rebuilt it six feet higher .They easily could have rebuilt it to comply with whatever structural load they wanted to.
I repeat Rupp and UK have been shortchanged here . they should be furious that something they paid lots of money for has turned out so poorly for some of their most loyal fans.
I don't know why anybody on this board would take up for the architects . its clear the design was shoddy and should be corrected.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RobynL

Ben101er

Heisman
Apr 21, 2004
25,982
61,134
103
Well, it's not ideal, but I guess it's better than if they had railings there. They have to have something as a barrier.
 

RobynL

Junior
Apr 9, 2007
402
285
0
I respectfully disagree with your assumption. The code clearly shows two options without the metal cap. The code would not allow those two options if they were dangerous.
No the steel cable was no problem at all. pitch was different and height of cable different. that's why I am certain it could have been designed better. It was better before.

furthermore , they didn'tg have the constraints of working with the existing structure. they tore the whole structure out and rebuilt it six feet higher .They easily could have rebuilt it to comply with whatever structural load they wanted to.
I repeat Rupp and UK have been shortchanged here . they should be furious that something they paid lots of money for has turned out so poorly for some of their most loyal fans.
I don't know why anybody on this board would take up for the architects . its clear the design was shoddy and should be corrected.
This is spot on regarding pitch, etc. It's so much worse in person. I'm no engineer or architect but surely there was a better solution.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
As I have explained in the past, I work for a company that has consultant contracts with UK and some other large entities. We recommend security protocols and analyze risk/reward for all kinds of capital investment and hiring scenarios. Several years ago, UK’s facility contract with Rupp Arena was nearing its expiration. The University was engaged in analyzing whether they would choose to negotiate a contract renewal with the city or build an on-campus basketball arena on the south side of campus. The on-campus arena was doable as long as verbal agreements for financial support scenarios could be finalized. But pulling UK basketball out of Rupp Arena would have devastated the fragile downtown economy and crossed some red lines in understandings that existed with a group of franchising companies operating in that part of downtown Lexington. So the Lexington government appointed a task force, consisting of city officials, prominent business leaders, and Mitch Barnhart. The upshot is that UK felt obligated to support the city by renewing the contract and keeping the basketball program in Rupp Arena. Mr. Barnhart invoked UK’s leverage by submitting a list of renovation requirements and other stipulations necessary from UK’s point of view in order for UK to agree to a contract renewal. Under the terms, the city oversaw the renovations, which were funded with funds raised by the city through various resource channels including a contribution made by UK. In the big picture, UK was very civic-minded. UK helped to fund the improvements while leaving the largest portion of proceeds from parking and concessions revenues to the city. But the city oversaw the renovations, and budgets were strained at the time. The bottom line is that the city did what was necessary, and no more. But the relationship was preserved, and the downtown Lexington economy dodged a big bullet.
Thanks for the explanation . Now the City needs to make the architects fix the problem or sue them to do so.. They didn't pay to have a second rate facility. Nobody with half brain would either design or accept this design if the knew four rows of what should have been prime seats are now the worst in the house.
There is a doctrine in consumer law that a product has to b "fit for a particular purpose" . These seats fail that test. The seats exist to view basketball. You can't do it comfortably from these seats.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Cats in the NBA BBNBA: Tyler Herro's 50-piece bucket almost came with a side of buzzer-beater
  2. 02 KSR Football Where Kentucky sits in updated AP, Coaches Polls following loss at Mizzou
  3. 03 KSR Football SEC Officials Made an Egregious Error in Kentucky vs. Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Dethroned: Kentucky VB’s SEC title streak snapped, but chance for redemption is alive
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky will host Louisville as an underdog at Kroger Field