Disappointed in Rupp/question for architects/ Engineers

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
  1. First those who are familiar with my posts know I am not a complainer . I think MB has done a fantastic job with all the conflicting priorities of our various programs . He gets an A plus in my book ..
However my observation is that in the name of safety the improvements to the upper tier of Rupp were perhaps performed by architects not familiar with sporting events. Basically , rows B tru F have gone from some of the best seats in the house to some of the worst .

Question. With all of the technology available is it really necessary to have a two inch metal strip obstructing the view to hold the plastic panels in place . Before u had simply a wire which worked fine and after a while your eyes got use to it. No way to see though two inches of metal . Has to b a better solution.

Second question . Is it really necessary to have a half inch gap between plastic panels ? The gap creates a further visual barrier which when combined with the Two inch metal strip Is really annoying .
Also ,
When the person below u leans forward u either have to also lean forward or see the back of their head for half of the court area. I don’t remember this ever being a problem in any other coliseum or stadium where I have watched games . Something the matter with the pitch?

I also note that for some reason they raised the second tier by about seven or eight feet .
which makes you that much further from the court .

Any architects or engineers have any solution to the two inch bar at the top of the plastic panels obstructing the view or of the half inch gap between the panels. Are both really necessary?
why not go back to the metal cord which worked fine previously ?any other modern solution.

I find myself watching the game on the big screen most of the time . Kind of crazy to go to the fame to see it on TV.

Again not trying to b a complainer. I’m not a season ticket holder . But many if those around me in row C tonight were and to say the least were disappointed . Any constructive solutions any if you have seen elsewhere or is that simply the limit of today’s technology that it delivers worst sight lines than the architects of forty and fifty years ago.
Thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: catmankev and -BBH-

Catapult_rivals218351

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2002
3,472
1,705
0
I am now in row C (was in row A since Rupp opened but as we all know money talks). It may be the worst. Contacted UK and the stated reason for the strip is building codes. I suppose if enough people complain, they may try harder to find a better solution or possible get an exemption.
 
Sep 6, 2005
1,297
400
0
Row H in section 211 (across from the UK bench) here. I hesitate to complain because I'm thrilled to not be on the bleachers with somebody's knees in my back and someone else taking up half my seat anymore, but I'm bothered by the same thing when the play moves to the sideline nearest me. Worse than that are the people filing up and down the aisle during play - I completely lose sight of the far end of the court. They should do as they do in pro arenas where the ushers hold you until there is a dead ball.
 
Jun 26, 2011
216
426
0
  1. First those who are familiar with my posts know I am not a complainer . I think MB has done a fantastic job with all the conflicting priorities of our various programs . He gets an A plus in my book ..
However my observation is that in the name of safety the improvements to the upper tier of Rupp were perhaps performed by architects not familiar with sporting events. Basically , rows B tru F have gone from some of the best seats in the house to some of the worst .

Question. With all of the technology available is it really necessary to have a two inch metal strip obstructing the view to hold the plastic panels in place . Before u had simply a wire which worked fine and after a while your eyes got use to it. No way to see though two inches of metal . Has to b a better solution.

Second question . Is it really necessary to have a half inch gap between plastic panels ? The gap creates a further visual barrier which when combined with the Two inch metal strip Is really annoying .
Also ,
When the person below u leans forward u either have to also lean forward or see the back of their head for half of the court area. I don’t remember this ever being a problem in any other coliseum or stadium where I have watched games . Something the matter with the pitch?

I also note that for some reason they raised the second tier by about seven or eight feet .
which makes you that much further from the court .

Any architects or engineers have any solution to the two inch bar at the top of the plastic panels obstructing the view or of the half inch gap between the panels. Are both really necessary?
why not go back to the metal cord which worked fine previously ?any other modern solution.

I find myself watching the game on the big screen most of the time . Kind of crazy to go to the fame to see it on TV.

Again not trying to b a complainer. I’m not a season ticket holder . But many if those around me in row C tonight were and to say the least were disappointed . Any constructive solutions any if you have seen elsewhere or is that simply the limit of today’s technology that it delivers worst sight lines than the architects of forty and fifty years ago.
Thanks
Some fans will never be happy. They’ll pray for rain then complain about the mud.
 

RickUK-Club74

Redshirt
Mar 26, 2015
53
43
0
Don't fall for the response "it was required by building codes." That term is an architect's fall back version of rope a dope. There is always a more innovative and sometimes more costly solution. A good architect would have modeled every view line in game like conditions to see the impact of their design. And responsible architects would have looked at the vews in virtual reality and augmented reality to spot problems and to develop solutions. Maybe they did and elected not to do anything. You got seat backs right? Now you want unobstructed vews!
 
Last edited:

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
My belief that it is per building code. I do not think you can use a cable as the top rail. ADA and many other changes to building codes have been adopted since Rupp was built in the 70. Many safety issues drive railing design and those are to protect from lawsuits.
 

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
There are many examples of structural glass walls that replace solid railings in arenas that do not have a 2 inch top rail.

No doubt. But did he say they replaced the existing glass panels too or just the cable? That may be the reason. Entire new system maybe being too costly?
 

Davae9

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2007
1,620
3,555
113
Row H in section 211 (across from the UK bench) here. I hesitate to complain because I'm thrilled to not be on the bleachers with somebody's knees in my back and someone else taking up half my seat anymore, but I'm bothered by the same thing when the play moves to the sideline nearest me. Worse than that are the people filing up and down the aisle during play - I completely lose sight of the far end of the court. They should do as they do in pro arenas where the ushers hold you until there is a dead ball.
I was at the game last night. All game long people were walking up and down the aisle obstructing my view. it was so frustrating and really took away from the enjoyment of watching the game. I agree that ushers should hold people back until there is a dead ball.
 

KyCatFan1

Heisman
May 6, 2002
30,867
31,594
113
I am guessing the other poster is talking about what I have the arrows pointing to.



Doesn't look like much if it is that strip along the top of the glass they are talking about. I couldn't find a better picture from the seat view. So if someone has one feel free to post it. From this picture though there doesn't seem to be that big of an issue.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
Some fans will never be happy. They’ll pray for rain then complain about the mud.
I’ll post pictures after next game I get to attend and then accept your apology.

It is so bad Rupp arena should not sell tickets in rows B tru E until it is fixed.
No I’m not a habitual complainer and can’t stand people who are .

This my friend is a real and legitimate grip for fans who thought their situation was being improved with seat backs only to find their view which was fantastic is now obstructed .
After all to see the game in person rather than a TV screen is why you pay to attend games . Right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1717038352

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
I am guessing the other poster is talking about what I have the arrows pointing to.



Doesn't look like much if it is that strip along the top of the glass they are talking about. I couldn't find a better picture from the seat view. So if someone has one feel free to post it. From this picture though there doesn't seem to be that big of an issue.
No. If that was the case I would not b complaining about it. They have installed a two inch metal strip where you have the arrows . Where did you get this picture ? It must have been taken before installation of the strip . Thanks for posting it but it’s not how it is now.
 

Ben101er

Heisman
Apr 21, 2004
25,982
61,134
103
I am now in row C (was in row A since Rupp opened but as we all know money talks). It may be the worst. Contacted UK and the stated reason for the strip is building codes. I suppose if enough people complain, they may try harder to find a better solution or possible get an exemption.

This is the problem with any renovation. The arena was ok the way it was initially constructed, but once you start renovating, it now must conform to current codes. Sometimes the original configuration makes it tough to change it and keep it as good as it was. Should have had the chair backs in it from the get-go.
 

KyCatFan1

Heisman
May 6, 2002
30,867
31,594
113
No. If that was the case I would not b complaining about it. They have installed a two inch metal strip where you have the arrows . Where did you get this picture ? It must have been taken before installation of the strip . Thanks for posting it but it’s not how it is now.

That was from off of WDRB news site. Only picture I could find that shows anything that might be in the view. I'm surprised no one else has mentioned what you are talking about on here the previous game and at BBM if it causes that many people issues. Hopefully something can be done about it if it is a big problem. Definitely post pictures the next time you go so then it can be spread online and see if it can be fixed. Unfortunately, they probably won't do anything about it until after the season if they do anything at all.
 

Catapult_rivals218351

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2002
3,472
1,705
0
Any pictures of these issues? I never sat in those areas to know what you are talking about. Don't really understand what the issue is without seeing it.
From my seat in row C, the metal strip is right in my line of sight (if I sit back comfortably, the strip is in line with center of court end line to end line). For instance, I can see a player's head but not the ball or vice versa or I can't see his feet. It just makes watching the flow of the game difficult. Picture a 2 inch line running across the middle of your TV screen (assuming big screen TV).
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
That was from off of WDRB news site. Only picture I could find that shows anything that might be in the view. I'm surprised no one else has mentioned what you are talking about on here the previous game and at BBM if it causes that many people issues. Hopefully something can be done about it if it is a big problem. Definitely post pictures the next time you go so then it can be spread online and see if it can be fixed. Unfortunately, they probably won't do anything about it until after the season if they do anything at all.
I’ll take pics but no sure I’m tech savvy enough to post them. . Better still why don’t those of you who are interested simply go up before the game and find an open seat in row C(that’s the worst } and you will immediately see what I mean. Last night most of the seats were unoccupied and believe me the ones who were there for the first time were very vocal about it.

I realize this is not a life altering event. I just had A friend diagnosed with cancer . No this us not a big deal in the grand scheme of things.

I normally love sitting up high at sporting events and always try and get in the first row or two in the second tier , best seat in the. House . While in the grand scheme of things it is not a life altering event I just think it’s a lousy thing for uncaring or unknowledgeable architects to do to loyal fans .

There has to b a better way to do this architecturally . My guess is this was this architects first job. Or maybe she was doing a sports arena for the first time .

Hopefully, the powers that b will fix this . Several years ago I wrote a post that the biggest problem with Rupp was not selling ice cream upstairs . Next season they had it . Not saying my post did it but just saying if you don’t point out how things can be better they never will b.
Thanks
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Wall Knight Teague
Sep 13, 2003
23,905
33,655
113
I haven't been in those seats since the renovation, but I know exactly what you are talking about. I attend several High School games during the season and if you sit in the first 4-5 rows of the upper section of some of the older gyms, you are obstructed by the railing. I would imagine it's the same problem.

If I paid what our fans have to pay to get season tickets, I would be HIGHLY pissed!!:mad::mad:
 

NothinButNylon

All-Conference
Jan 3, 2003
1,061
1,147
0
This is not meant to be a smart aleck reply so please don't take it like that.. but until they get the issue resolved (I would think at least next season at the earliest) have you thought about offering to trade your tickets with someone about 10-15 rows higher? They may like being closer and would be more than willing to put up with the annoyance of the obstruction of the railing.
 
May 27, 2007
32,279
25,677
113
What I don't understand is why install seat backs everywhere but the endzone sections? Tne new seats look really good until u see the 6 sections or so without lol

As far as the obstructed view on the lower rows of the upper section........I see that quite a bit in stadiums I've gone to. So it wouldn't surprise me if they were telling the truth about keeping the building up to code.

UK should prob charge less for those seats..........that's not going to happen but they should at least let people know when purchasing those tickets there will be an obstructed view.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jazzycat

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
I went to a baseball game and sat behind home plate......they put up this dadgum netting for some reason and I had to look between all the holes in the net. They should take it down because it interfered with my viewing pleasure....
 
  • Like
Reactions: NothinButNylon

Catapult_rivals218351

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2002
3,472
1,705
0
I went to a baseball game and sat behind home plate......they put up this dadgum netting for some reason and I had to look between all the holes in the net. They should take it down because it interfered with my viewing pleasure....
None of us are complaining about safety issue. We all understand the need for railing. Just don't understand the need for metal cap. I'm quite sure there are clear materials that could be used that are even stronger than metal.
 

catfanlou

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2005
3,665
1,363
41
I went to a baseball game and sat behind home plate......they put up this dadgum netting for some reason and I had to look between all the holes in the net. They should take it down because it interfered with my viewing pleasure....
I go to baseball games all of the time and this is much different . I have a partial solution . Rows B tru E are effected . My wife who is short has no problem with being on row b . Since I’m taller I do .
So why not only sell row B to short people (less than 5 feet four inches ) . And row e only to tall people So they can see over it .

nor sure yet what to do about rows C and D .
Maybe fill them up with city of Lexington engineers and politicians and maybe the problem will b solved .

Yes , I have learned when u get screwed it’s best to laugh it off and concentrate on positive ways to solve it .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. H Lecter

Ben101er

Heisman
Apr 21, 2004
25,982
61,134
103
I’ll take pics but no sure I’m tech savvy enough to post them. . Better still why don’t those of you who are interested simply go up before the game and find an open seat in row C(that’s the worst } and you will immediately see what I mean. Last night most of the seats were unoccupied and believe me the ones who were there for the first time were very vocal about it.

I realize this is not a life altering event. I just had A friend diagnosed with cancer . No this us not a big deal in the grand scheme of things.

I can solve my problem . I give UK enough each year that I can simply redirect a few grand or so and Move downstairs for the five or so games I really want to attend. I normally love sitting up high at sporting events and always try and get in the first row or two in the second tier , best seat in the. House . I just think it’s a lousy thing for uncaring or unknowledgeable architects to do to loyal fans .

There has to b a better way to do this architecturally . My guess is this was this architects first job. Or maybe she was doing a sports arena for the first time .

Hopefully, the powers that b will fix this . Several years ago I wrote a post that the biggest problem with Rupp was not selling ice cream upstairs . Next season they had it . Not saying my post did it but just saying if you don’t point out how things can be better they never will b.
Thanks

If most seats were empty, I would have just moved up a couple of rows. Know that is not a long term solution, but for last night, it would have worked. Long term, I would check with the ticket office and see about changing seats before the season gets too far along.
 

Catapult_rivals218351

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2002
3,472
1,705
0
If most seats were empty, I would have just moved up a couple of rows. Know that is not a long term solution, but for last night, it would have worked. Long term, I would check with the ticket office and see about changing seats before the season gets too far along.
They offered that option to me, but the ones were not signifcantly better (row B in another section) or move up several rows (again in another section). As we still have some friends in our section, we decided to stay put and just live with it. Still selfishly hoping that enough of you will complain so maybe they'll really pursue other options.
 

RickUK-Club74

Redshirt
Mar 26, 2015
53
43
0
Structural glass walls do not require metal caps. The mounting, bracing, and braketing are more expensive. But the code can be met without a 2 inch metal cap.

Proof is the railings in the newly renovated Apple store on 5th Ave. in NYC.

Front row Rupp fans either got valued engineered or were the victims of short sighted architects.
 

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
Structural glass walls do not require metal caps. The mounting, bracing, and braketing are more expensive. But the code can be met without a 2 inch metal cap.

Proof is the railings in the newly renovated Apple store on 5th Ave. in NYC.

Front row Rupp fans either got valued engineered or were the victims of short sighted architects.

http://www.glassmagazine.com/files/gmfiles_2010/Codes_GM511.pdf

I would assume that the load requirements would not be met without the rail. You have potential for lots of people pressing against that section and I'm guessing because of the IBC and other code requirements...they had little or no choice. Safety first.
 

CB3UK

Hall of Famer
Apr 15, 2012
65,397
110,324
78
Im familiar with the glass panels. If those are essentially the same as they have been, and theyve added a metal strip on top of it running horizontally the length of the uppers, then yeah, I think OP has made a legitimate point. Who the hell wants a strip running in the middle of their view. When you're up there that can block a decent percent of the court from where you're sitting.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
I haven't been in those seats since the renovation, but I know exactly what you are talking about. I attend several High School games during the season and if you sit in the first 4-5 rows of the upper section of some of the older gyms, you are obstructed by the railing. I would imagine it's the same problem.

If I paid what our fans have to pay to get season tickets, I would be HIGHLY pissed!!:mad:
Structural glass walls do not require metal caps. The mounting, bracing, and braketing are more expensive. But the code can be met without a 2 inch metal cap.

Proof is the railings in the newly renovated Apple store on 5th Ave. in NYC.

Front row Rupp fans either got valued engineered or were the victims of short sighted architects.

thanks. That’s what I guessed . Basically Rupp went on the cheap and now has four rows of what should have been prime seats which they have to sell to their best customers with an obstructed view. That’s true for events as well .
question is will they fess up and either correct it or for the rest of the time it is like that sell the seats with “ “OBSTRUCTED VIEW “ to be honest with their customers.

What should happen is that Rupp/ and or UK should sue the architects for the public relations mess they have created. IMHO
 

Wildcats1st

Heisman
Sep 16, 2017
18,949
28,911
0
I remember when the nhl first required netting around behind the goals that wrapped around. At first it sucked but I got used to it. I imagine this is the same. Eventually you’ll get used to it
 

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
thanks. That’s what I guessed . Basically Rupp went on the cheap and now has four rows of what should have been prime seats which they have to sell to their best customers with an obstructed view. That’s true for events as well .
question is will they fess up and either correct it or for the rest of the time it is like that sell the seats with “ “OBSTRUCTED VIEW “ to be honest with their customers.

What should happen is that Rupp/ and or UK should sue the architects for the public relations mess they have created. IMHO

I would simply point to the IBC section of the code and say....argue with the AHJ.
 

ck-2

Heisman
Apr 7, 2007
11,306
19,154
113
I like how people who have never sat where the OP seats are look at a pic taken from 150 feet away on the internet and tell him It’s no big deal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Notelvis2
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Cats in the NBA BBNBA: Tyler Herro's 50-piece bucket almost came with a side of buzzer-beater
  2. 02 KSR Football Where Kentucky sits in updated AP, Coaches Polls following loss at Mizzou
  3. 03 KSR Football SEC Officials Made an Egregious Error in Kentucky vs. Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Dethroned: Kentucky VB’s SEC title streak snapped, but chance for redemption is alive
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky will host Louisville as an underdog at Kroger Field