Dicky V being Dicky!!

KyCat

All-American
Sep 29, 2006
5,688
9,416
113
Great question... anyone want to answer it?
Pure speculation on my part but I imagine from a university president perspective who comes from the scholarly world of academia that the NCAA should not be weighing in on what constitutes acceptable academic standards for a college or university. As a university president I am sure he has to believe his colleagues will act professionally and with integrity, even though some will not. I do not see his position as tolerance of UNC's behavior rather as protecting their turf from non-academia types. To scholars the world of academia is their arena and not an area they would give a sports based entity the power to make determinations with regards to whether academic standards were being met.

However, I would like to have seen some weight given to outside accreditation associations to have the authority to determine whether some classes, courses or even fields of study met adequate acadmic standards necessary to be counted toward achieving progress for a degree. Just not the NCAA.
 

kl40504_rivals

Heisman
Oct 5, 2018
15,258
11,184
0
Pure speculation on my part but I imagine from a university president perspective who comes from the scholarly world of academia that the NCAA should not be weighing in on what constitutes acceptable academic standards for a college or university. As a university president I am sure he has to believe his colleagues will act professionally and with integrity, even though some will not. I do not see his position as tolerance of UNC's behavior rather as protecting their turf from non-academia types. To scholars the world of academia is their arena and not an area they would give a sports based entity the power to make determinations with regards to whether academic standards were being met.

However, I would like to have seen some weight given to outside accreditation associations to have the authority to determine whether some classes, courses or even fields of study met adequate acadmic standards necessary to be counted toward achieving progress for a degree. Just not the NCAA.
UNC agrees. They believe the school should be able to have all the fake classes they want and the NCAA should have nothing to do with it.
 

thack_kat

Junior
Mar 2, 2007
219
334
0
I seem to remember that among all of the other nonsense going on at UNC that there was an issue with players exceeding the number of independent studies courses that the university allows. If that is true, then any courses over the max should not have counted. There is no need for an academic judgement on that, it is just simply math (although that might be difficult for an unc graduate).
 
Last edited:

Ty1erT

Redshirt
May 30, 2020
25
2
0
Or maybe your president doesn't want the NCAA looking into classes that so many OAD players are taking during the few months they are on campus. And before anyone here bashes me, I remember what Zion's class schedule looked like. A lot of these players aren't in college for the academics.
 

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,674
2,360
113
Or maybe your president doesn't want the NCAA looking into classes that so many OAD players are taking during the few months they are on campus. And before anyone here bashes me, I remember what Zion's class schedule looked like. A lot of these players aren't in college for the academics.
Duke has fake classes? Interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kl40504_rivals

Ty1erT

Redshirt
May 30, 2020
25
2
0
Classes at UNC were fake. That is a whole different level than taking simple courses.
Not disagreeing with you there, but if you think most of these OAD athletes are in college to get an education, then that's delusional thinking on your part. They should be allowed to play in the NBA, not wasting their time in college.
 

GaryAlbright

Sophomore
Nov 24, 2019
174
105
0
Classes at UNC were fake. That is a whole different level than taking simple courses.
Not so fast Marty. Remember when Duke was caught in their own academic scandal? Shockingly, another Duke internal investigation discovered these alleagations were completely false.

Duke is a strong academic school that’s perennially celebrated for graduating its players, even when it doesn’t. But OTL shows Duke players, many of whom enter academically deficient, being steered toward cake and/or no-show courses of dubious value.

OTL reports that since 1995, 40 percent of Duke’s basketball players have majored in sociology – “the basketball major” – compared to two percent among other Duke students.

https://nypost.com/2002/03/01/whistle-toots-on-academic-fraud-div-1-hoop-grad-rates-a-scam/
 
  • Like
Reactions: kl40504_rivals

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,674
2,360
113
Not so fast Marty. Remember when Duke was caught in their own academic scandal? Shockingly, another Duke internal investigation discovered these alleagations were completely false.

Duke is a strong academic school that’s perennially celebrated for graduating its players, even when it doesn’t. But OTL shows Duke players, many of whom enter academically deficient, being steered toward cake and/or no-show courses of dubious value.

OTL reports that since 1995, 40 percent of Duke’s basketball players have majored in sociology – “the basketball major” – compared to two percent among other Duke students.

https://nypost.com/2002/03/01/whistle-toots-on-academic-fraud-div-1-hoop-grad-rates-a-scam/
Well, "Gary", I don't care about Duke running a diploma mill. UNC was running one too. You tobacco road guys are all the same. Pretend like your schools are paragons of academia but when we get a glimpse under the hood your schools sell their academic integrity for athletic success. The hypocrisy amongst your bunch is amazing. You seem familiar, uncfanin...
 
  • Like
Reactions: kl40504_rivals

GaryAlbright

Sophomore
Nov 24, 2019
174
105
0
Calm down Marty, i'm not a tobacco road fan, and it's weak too call people that if they don't fall in line and agree with everything you preach. I'm also not living in a fantasy world where I believe these star athletes are getting a proper education while in college.
 

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,674
2,360
113
Calm down Marty, i'm not a tobacco road fan, and it's weak too call people that if they don't fall in line and agree with everything you preach. I'm also not living in a fantasy world where I believe these star athletes are getting a proper education while in college.
Congrats on the dupe account Runt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kl40504_rivals

kl40504_rivals

Heisman
Oct 5, 2018
15,258
11,184
0
Calm down Marty, i'm not a tobacco road fan, and it's weak too call people that if they don't fall in line and agree with everything you preach. I'm also not living in a fantasy world where I believe these star athletes are getting a proper education while in college.
Troll
 

fla.cat

Junior
May 23, 2002
3,981
351
0
Long thread...self examination is good, but it is not the proper responder and reporter vehicle if you are under suspect for your actions.

Re Vitale....he long ago lost credibility in my eyes, when he vilified UK and our fans for RUNNING OFF TUBBY, and alluded to a racist cause. We know Tubby was shopping for jobs apparently for a while, and essentially left under the cover of darkness, on very short notice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kl40504_rivals