What an incredible career,!“Cherish the memories," McCourty told me a couple of years earlier. At the risk of forfeiting my "objective media card" that's exactly what I will do for No. 32.”
Thanks for all the great memories, Devin.
Is it 5 years 'till the HOF?
Deron Cherry isn't in there.. KC's yes, NFL's no.Is it 5 years 'till the HOF?
NFL HOF is a stretch. He was 2x Pro Bowls 0x First Team All Pro 2x Second Team All Pro. He had a great career but people don't understand how great it takes to make the HOF.I have to think that he will eventually make it to the NFL HOF.
Maybe - but he played on what is now NFL royalty. There's a reason Jeter was unanimous and it wasn't just his stats.NFL HOF is a stretch. He was 2x Pro Bowls 0x First Team All Pro 2x Second Team All Pro. He had a great career but people don't understand how great it takes to make the HOF.
Here are the most recent DB/S who made it
Champ Bailey 12x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Brian Dawkins 9x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
John Lynch 9x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Troy Polameu 8x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Ed Reed 9x Pro Bowls 5x 1st team All Pro 3x 2nd Team All Pro
Here are some of the top guys who haven't made it and have better resumes.
Leroy Butler 4x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 0x 2nd Team All Pro
Deron Cherry 6x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Eric Allen 6x Pro Bowls 1x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Don Shell 5x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
Steve Atwater 8x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
So did Donnie Shell with the Steelers. He won 4 super bowls one more McCourty. It takes a lot more than that to reach the NFL hall of fame.Maybe - but he played on what is now NFL royalty. There's a reason Jeter was unanimous and it wasn't just his stats.
NFL HOF is a stretch. He was 2x Pro Bowls 0x First Team All Pro 2x Second Team All Pro. He had a great career but people don't understand how great it takes to make the HOF.
Here are the most recent DB/S who made it
Champ Bailey 12x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Brian Dawkins 9x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
John Lynch 9x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Troy Polameu 8x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Ed Reed 9x Pro Bowls 5x 1st team All Pro 3x 2nd Team All Pro
Here are some of the top guys who haven't made it and have better resumes.
Leroy Butler 4x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 0x 2nd Team All Pro
Deron Cherry 6x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Eric Allen 6x Pro Bowls 1x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Don Shell 5x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
Steve Atwater 8x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
The one thing in his favor would be that he was an All-Pro as a CB and as a Safety.NFL HOF is a stretch. He was 2x Pro Bowls 0x First Team All Pro 2x Second Team All Pro. He had a great career but people don't understand how great it takes to make the HOF.
Here are the most recent DB/S who made it
Champ Bailey 12x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Brian Dawkins 9x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
John Lynch 9x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Troy Polameu 8x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Ed Reed 9x Pro Bowls 5x 1st team All Pro 3x 2nd Team All Pro
Here are some of the top guys who haven't made it and have better resumes.
Leroy Butler 4x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 0x 2nd Team All Pro
Deron Cherry 6x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Eric Allen 6x Pro Bowls 1x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Don Shell 5x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
Steve Atwater 8x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
True. I don't think Devin will get in but my point was he has a much better chance due to Patriots/Belichik connection than say if he played for the Cardinals or Browns. These things "shouldnt" matter but they do.So did Donnie Shell with the Steelers. He won 4 super bowls one more McCourty. It takes a lot more than that to reach the NFL hall of fame.
NFL HOF is a stretch. He was 2x Pro Bowls 0x First Team All Pro 2x Second Team All Pro. He had a great career but people don't understand how great it takes to make the HOF.
Here are the most recent DB/S who made it
Champ Bailey 12x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Brian Dawkins 9x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
John Lynch 9x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Troy Polameu 8x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Ed Reed 9x Pro Bowls 5x 1st team All Pro 3x 2nd Team All Pro
Here are some of the top guys who haven't made it and have better resumes.
Leroy Butler 4x Pro Bowls 4x 1st team All Pro 0x 2nd Team All Pro
Deron Cherry 6x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Eric Allen 6x Pro Bowls 1x 1st team All Pro 2x 2nd Team All Pro
Don Shell 5x Pro Bowls 3x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
Steve Atwater 8x Pro Bowls 2x 1st team All Pro 1x 2nd Team All Pro
There are a lot of Steelers from that era in the HOF. Most are deserving. Some are borderline.So did Donnie Shell with the Steelers. He won 4 super bowls one more McCourty. It takes a lot more than that to reach the NFL hall of fame.
I know but Donnie Shell shows that it takes more than just having superbowl rings to get into the HOF.There are a lot of Steelers from that era in the HOF. Most are deserving. Some are borderline.
Why isn't Donnie Shell in then? He has one more super bowl ring, more pro bowls, more all pro seasons. It takes a lot more to get into the hall of fame then just winning super bowls. He had a great career but certainly not a hall of fame career.One difference - all the playoff/Super Bowl achievements.
It depends on the position. I don't think that Joe Namath, Lynn Swann, or Bob Griese would be in the HOF if they didn't have Super Bowl rings. I would argue that it's a big reason why they're in there.I know but Donnie Shell shows that it takes more than just having superbowl rings to get into the HOF.
There are a lot of Steelers from that era in the HOF. Most are deserving. Some are borderline.
The Knight Report
From FCS to the Big Ten, Bradlee Jones is betting his speed opens the door at Rutgers
The Knight Report
Rutgers Football Fall Camp: Get 75% off The Knight Report - Final Day!
The Knight Report
2028 Illinois EDGE Kristian Chadick adds Rutgers Football Offer
The Knight Report
WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
The Knight Report
Chin, Walker named to Comeback Player of the Year Watch List