You do understand that the 100k-200k deaths were in effect preventable? Somewhere along the line people made choices to go on cruises, spring break, or continue their daily routines. People who carried the virus onto cruise ships could be responsible for thousands of deaths...is there any accountability for infecting people because you are care-less? Government exists to protect humans from humans by placing servants in positions of power. Our military protects us, our police protect us, our teachers educate us...enforcement that keeps people alive has absolutely nothing to so with SS, or KGB...
Other than nursing homes, how did the person get sick if they weren't also exercising their freedom?
been hearing it's going to get a lot worse for [checks notes] 7 weeks nowOn another note...was looking at mortality rates on the CDC website...always fascinating. From February 1 to April 4th America has only experience 86% of its expected mortality. The shutdown has saved a lot of lives due to accidents and other illnesses...it is going to get a lot worse and a lot of condensed death but just a weird number.
Umm, which model of expected mortality?On another note...was looking at mortality rates on the CDC website...always fascinating. From February 1 to April 4th America has only experience 86% of its expected mortality. The shutdown has saved a lot of lives due to accidents and other illnesses...it is going to get a lot worse and a lot of condensed death but just a weird number.
Umm, which model of expected mortality?
The doubling every day, the doubling every other day, the doubling every third day, the 24% as seen in Italy in early march?
Or, the 4% we see today?
The whole point of the shutdown, was two things, find tools to fight against the virus, like chloroquine, until a vaccine is made, in 12-18 months, and, to lessen the impact on our medical resources to get to the number youre,now throwing up, but, if you noticed, there's two curves, one which jumps up quickly, the other, doesn't jump up, is slowed, but is prolonged, which, if you never stress those medical resources, still has the same number of deaths,only over a longer period of time.
So no, we haven't lost lives foolishly at a much higher percentage, but things haven't changed as to who's going to die from this with all given best cares.
"Italy: the real number of COVID-19 cases in the country could be 5,000,0000 (compared to the 119,827 confirmed ones) according to a study which polled people with symptoms who have not been tested, and up to 10,000,000 or even 20,0000,000 after taking into account asymptomatic cases, according to Carlo La Vecchia, a Professor of Medical Statistics and Epidemiology at the Statale di Milano University.
This number would still be insufficient to reach herd immunity, which would require 2/3 of the population (about 40,000,000 people in Italy) having contracted the virus [source].
The number of deaths could also be underestimated by 3/4 (in Italy as well as in other countries) [source], meaning that the real number of deaths in Italy could be around 60,000.
If these estimates were true, the mortality rate from COVID-19 would be much lower (around 25 times less) than the case fatality rate based solely on laboratory-confirmed cases and deaths, since it would be underestimating cases (the denominator) by a factor of about 1/100 and deaths by a factor of 1/4."
Source: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/
seems like nearly everyone on this board either has a similar story or knows someone who does regarding sickness during the first couple months of the year.
very few interfacing with COVID today, save a few tragic cases we're all rooting for.
at least worth an eyebrow raise, IMO.
On another note...was looking at mortality rates on the CDC website...always fascinating. From February 1 to April 4th America has only experience 86% of its expected mortality. The shutdown has saved a lot of lives due to accidents and other illnesses...it is going to get a lot worse and a lot of condensed death but just a weird number.
Half are asymptomatic or have such low levels of reaction that they wouldn't have known. A good amount experience mild to moderate flu like symptoms.My question would be if COVID is asymptomatic in the vast majority of the population, why would everyone think the illness they had early in the year is COVID? It makes no sense.
Take you and your wife/girlfriend for example, I take it you are both fairly young and healthy. The complete opposite profile of those impacted by COVID. Yet you were both hit really hard by whatever you had in Jan.
Maybe the bug everyone had was one of the other 1000s of other virus that go around.
There is no data other than anecdotal to suggest that COVID was wide spread early in the year.Half are asymptomatic or have such low levels of reaction that they wouldn't have known. A good amount experience mild to moderate flu like symptoms.
Brazilian Covid death occurred in January, a month before 1st reported case. Was it only early in Brazil or is it safe to say most places had Covid as early at January?There is no data other than anecdotal to suggest that COVID was wide spread early in the year.
Stating that stuff is just as silly as those saying it is going to kill millions in the US.
Everyone wants to be right so it is easy to find things that meet your view.
As always the truth is somewhere in-between the extreme narratives. Confirmation bias is running rampant right now.
Brazilian Covid death occurred in January, a month before 1st reported case. Was it only early in Brazil or is it safe to say most places had Covid as early at January?
https://riotimesonline.com/brazil-n...-finds-coronavirus-reached-brazil-in-january/Not sure where you are getting that. I am not up to speed with Brazil and COVID, but a quick Google shows first positive there was late Feb and first death in March.
Fully admit I didn't look deep into it. And really that would show much unless it was non-travel related.
You’re right. Positive antibody tests are anecdotal.There is no data other than anecdotal to suggest that COVID was wide spread early in the year.
Stating that stuff is just as silly as those saying it is going to kill millions in the US.
Everyone wants to be right so it is easy to find things that meet your view.
As always the truth is somewhere in-between the extreme narratives. Confirmation bias is running rampant right now.
I guess we would have to tally us travel of ones from Wuhan and see where the most travel is. If it got to Brazil early, I'm confident it got many other big nations early as well.Thanks for the share.
But don't necessarily see that a travel related case in late Jan in Brazil validates numerous cases in the US in the same time frame.
It could, but it is anecdotal at best.
You’re right. Positive antibody tests are anecdotal.
Also, it makes perfect sense that a virus would take 5 months to get out of China, even when those months overlap with the busiest travel season of the year.
Mmhm yep, perfect sense.
He's an expert in a small field, he's earned his respect. But,as others have said, Fauci likely won't push the fda to fast track a vaccine, as they need data, he made this statement in January without data.
It's why we have a president.
Italy's death toll from COVID-19 is not nearly as high as they are reporting either. I have extended family stuck there and they say that if you die of anything right now and some other cause is not evident (like a gunshot wound) you are counted as a COVID-19 death. They aren't able to take care of live patients let alone test the dead. The numbers are WAY off from Italy. LIkewise, China's numbers are WAY under reported."Italy: the real number of COVID-19 cases in the country could be 5,000,0000 (compared to the 119,827 confirmed ones) according to a study which polled people with symptoms who have not been tested, and up to 10,000,000 or even 20,0000,000 after taking into account asymptomatic cases, according to Carlo La Vecchia, a Professor of Medical Statistics and Epidemiology at the Statale di Milano University.
This number would still be insufficient to reach herd immunity, which would require 2/3 of the population (about 40,000,000 people in Italy) having contracted the virus [source].
The number of deaths could also be underestimated by 3/4 (in Italy as well as in other countries) [source], meaning that the real number of deaths in Italy could be around 60,000.
If these estimates were true, the mortality rate from COVID-19 would be much lower (around 25 times less) than the case fatality rate based solely on laboratory-confirmed cases and deaths, since it would be underestimating cases (the denominator) by a factor of about 1/100 and deaths by a factor of 1/4."
Source: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/
IF they test for the antibodies to COVID-19 they can tell. We have a poster in this thread who was ill in January and his wife and he both test positive now for the anitibodies. The test is only available at this point my wife says to medical personnel. There will soon be a rapid test kit to check for antibodies available.Testing question... Let's say you feel fine now but had a brief illness in February. If they tested you now could they tell you if had COVID back then?
How dare you question the experts
They didn't start testing until late February. The Washington state cases erupted when a private lab developed their own test for CV and tested samples they had taken for an influenza study a month before. I have zero doubt that we had cases in the U.S. present over the holidays. I've said early on that it was logical that we would have had the virus on U.S. soil in early January. Now I think it was here in December.Not sure where you are getting that. I am not up to speed with Brazil and COVID, but a quick Google shows first positive there was late Feb and first death in March.
Fully admit I didn't look deep into it. And really that would show much unless it was non-travel related.
The people who die from less than obvious other causes are actually counted as COVID-19 fatalities. IF you have a heart attack and die right now, you're a COVID-19 victim in Italy. Their death toll is actually over inflated.In Italy they are saying the the number infected as well as those who have died are much much higher than the official number. Simply because people are/were getting sick and dying so rapidly that it was impossible to test everyone before they died. I have a feeling that is going to be the case in many parts of the world as well as here in the US.
People continued to get on cruises into March...by the time they were two days in the cruises were looking for ports to dump sick and dying passengers...and don't tell me millions of ignorant Americans didn't ignore the signs...people are supposed to have personal responsibility and a virus that has been killing people since January should alert some people to change habits. It is hard...my wife was pushing for a spring break vacation and I had to continually say no because it looked like this was going to be bad. I can't stand how easily some can stand and watch freedoms kill people. Freedom is in the eye of the beholder...the person who will spend their last 4 days with a tube down their throat has certainly lost some freedom because another person wanted to exercise theirs...
Move to my state and you would still be working unless you're a bar tender or waitress.it's time for local leaders to start making some reasonable decisions about getting back to work.
one-size-fits-all won't apply much longer in terms of quarantine and staying at home. those who don't live with nana, who aren't at risk themselves and who can reasonably get back to work should start to be able to, and soon.
resuming the economy when it's 100% safe for everyone is ridiculous and completely pie-in-the-sky. there's just no such thing.
You do realize that 200k is only .06% of the population of the USA and that if you are sacrificing 99% of the population to save .06% of the population that you are already doomed.
Hell I voted for the character and will vote for him again if the other option is Biden but I don't like the guy.I'm starting to think you don't care for Trump.
Thanks for the share.
But don't necessarily see that a travel related case in late Jan in Brazil validates numerous cases in the US in the same time frame.
It could, but it is anecdotal at best.
People who went on cruises after this broke in late January were very foolish IMO. I took a couple of air flights in February and I was more than a little nervous and extremely cautious.People continued to get on cruises into March...by the time they were two days in the cruises were looking for ports to dump sick and dying passengers...and don't tell me millions of ignorant Americans didn't ignore the signs...people are supposed to have personal responsibility and a virus that has been killing people since January should alert some people to change habits. It is hard...my wife was pushing for a spring break vacation and I had to continually say no because it looked like this was going to be bad. I can't stand how easily some can stand and watch freedoms kill people. Freedom is in the eye of the beholder...the person who will spend their last 4 days with a tube down their throat has certainly lost some freedom because another person wanted to exercise theirs...
I think it is becoming more and more evident that the the numbers we are seeing are far from accurate. There are many many more who have or had this that never got tested. Im going to guess the death rate of this is going to be well under 1%."Italy: the real number of COVID-19 cases in the country could be 5,000,0000 (compared to the 119,827 confirmed ones) according to a study which polled people with symptoms who have not been tested, and up to 10,000,000 or even 20,0000,000 after taking into account asymptomatic cases, according to Carlo La Vecchia, a Professor of Medical Statistics and Epidemiology at the Statale di Milano University.
This number would still be insufficient to reach herd immunity, which would require 2/3 of the population (about 40,000,000 people in Italy) having contracted the virus [source].
The number of deaths could also be underestimated by 3/4 (in Italy as well as in other countries) [source], meaning that the real number of deaths in Italy could be around 60,000.
If these estimates were true, the mortality rate from COVID-19 would be much lower (around 25 times less) than the case fatality rate based solely on laboratory-confirmed cases and deaths, since it would be underestimating cases (the denominator) by a factor of about 1/100 and deaths by a factor of 1/4."
Source: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/
Don't put your hand on the stove or you get burned.
"But give me the data," he screams as he burns his hand.
Happy voting.Hell I voted for the character and will vote for him again if the other option is Biden but I don't like the guy.