Clear cut: LANGAN should be starting QB

Status
Not open for further replies.

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,170
8,516
113
Lol. This guy again. Coaches make bad QB decisions all the time. I can name a bunch of teams in the Top 50 of college football who are playing with guys who were once backup QB's who weren't chosen by coaches and now are better. It's always worth questioning.
Dunning Kruger effect
 

RUInsanityToo

All-American
May 5, 2006
9,619
9,996
113
Part of your job as QB (especially a veteran grad transfer) is to recognize and react to defenses pre-snap and during the play. He did a terrible job of this yesterday. Holding the ball, bad reads, had plenty time to throw most plays! Go back and watch the game. Also, Millen pointed this out multiple times on the broadcast, so argue with him if you don't want to hear me say it.

You're point on good QB's being able to read/react pre-snap is not wrong. However this is not the Pro's and mostly proficient QB's at a high level in the NCAA do this well. Also, your point has to also include how RU's other QB options might be able to read/react in the same situations. Who would you suggest is better at read & react of the current RU rostered QB's? Of the options......
  • Langdon is mostly a physical/runner and I'm going to guess that Gleeson will continue to install him in 2QB sets or for Wildcat or Option plays designed as run first with a sprinkling of pass options to keep defenses honest. 2 QB sets is something that Gleeson has done before in both Princeton and OK State. Langdon has not shown a proclivity to being a proficient read/react passer (at least not at this point in his development) and this is likely the reason that the coaches have not put him in as starter.
  • Sitkowski to this point has shown to be more of a traditional pocket passing QB with a better arm than Vedral but also who with a lesser ability to move in the pocket and as a running threat in the abundant read option packages in Gleeson's offense. Last year as starter, Sit also turned the ball over frequently, did not show enough accuracy nor quick decision making to make anyone realistically think he would be a better option than Noah at this point. This is not to say that Sit has not / or will not further develop (he can). If he develops to a level in the mold of to say Nova or Teel - RU have a quality QB on its roster.
  • The other options - Snyder and Simon, who really knows for sure, but it would probably most fan's guess that in the judgement of the Coaching Staff, they have shown some gaps or have needed development behind where Vedral is right now.
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,170
8,516
113
You're a poster who once argued with people for years that Ash was building something good. Talk about effect.
Lol what? Wtf are you talking about?

You think Langan is a starting Big Ten QB. Love the kid, but there's a reason we have a special package for him. You're the only one who thinks he should be our starter besides his mom probably.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
Lol what? Wtf are you talking about?

You think Langan is a starting Big Ten QB. Love the kid, but there's a reason we have a special package for him. You're the only one who thinks he should be our starter besides his mom probably.
You think Vedral is? Lol.
 
Oct 21, 2010
15,576
15,087
113
This whole thread is silly. HCGS and OCSG have watched and evaluated all our current QB's. I as a keyboard jockey fan have to trust in their judgement that right now Vedral is our starting QB based on their assessment over many practices and game experience. The fact that some numb Nut on an internet forum knows more than them is preposterous on its face.
Yes, against Indiana Vedral did not have a great game but I can tell you I have seen QB's who have had terrible games only to return the next week to have great games. Maybe Coach Gleeson wants to instill some confidence into Vedral and that will make him a better QB. Lets Trust in our coaching staff to make the best decisions to win games.
Regardless, We are making progress beyond expectations so far. We have a really tough game coming up this weekend. Our program is in a much different place than where we were this time last year. I have a suggestion for our fanbase, enjoy the rebuild process and support our team!
 
Oct 21, 2010
15,576
15,087
113
Lol what? Wtf are you talking about?

You think Langan is a starting Big Ten QB. Love the kid, but there's a reason we have a special package for him. You're the only one who thinks he should be our starter besides his mom probably.
This could be Johnnys mom! LOL!
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
This whole thread is silly. HCGS and OCSG have watched and evaluated all our current QB's. I as a keyboard jockey fan have to trust in their judgement that right now Vedral is our starting QB based on their assessment over many practices and game experience. The fact that some numb Nut on an internet forum knows more than them is preposterous on its face.
Yes, against Indiana Vedral did not have a great game but I can tell you I have seen QB's who have had terrible games only to return the next week to have great games. Maybe Coach Gleeson wants to instill some confidence into Vedral and that will make him a better QB. Lets Trust in our coaching staff to make the best decisions to win games.
Regardless, We are making progress beyond expectations so far. We have a really tough game coming up this weekend. Our program is in a much different place than where we were this time last year. I have a suggestion for our fanbase, enjoy the rebuild process and support our team!
Coaches make bad decisions all the time - including picking QB's (for various reasons). Bad Decision Example: Remember when James Franklin forgot to take three knees to win a game two weeks ago vs. Indiana?! That's something num nuts on fan boards know. You want a million other examples?
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
This could be Johnnys mom! LOL!
He was one series away from beating Ped St last year, ya know, a team we've never beat in the Big Ten. The audacity of me to question a QB decision. Vedral will get yanked soon! Whether it's for Sit or Langan. Not up to me!
 
Oct 21, 2010
15,576
15,087
113
Coaches make bad decisions all the time - including picking QB's (for various reasons). Bad Decision Example: Remember when James Franklin forgot to take three knees to win a game two weeks ago vs. Indiana?! That's something num nuts on fan boards know.
Well if Schiano fails at Rutgers then we will take a vote on the TKR board and make you one of the candidates to coach the team. Until then I will trust HCGS and OCSG to make our QB decisions.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,146
90,310
113
He was one series away from beating Ped St last year, ya know, a team we've never beat in the Big Ten. The audacity of me to question a QB decision. Vedral will get yanked soon! Whether it's for Sit or Langan. Not up to me!
I give you a lot of credit for standing firm in your conviction on this point. I don't necessarily agree with you, but I give you credit for not backing down or changing your tune. Just please don't be like the guy who said he smelled the stink on Ash at the beginning and proclaim yourself some sort of amazing QB evaluator should there be a change at QB. And to be fair, it should not surprise fans if Greg and Sean empty the QB cupboard against Ohio State this weekend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUHouston

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
Well if Schiano fails at Rutgers then we will take a vote on the TKR board and make you one of the candidates to coach the team. Until then I will trust HCGS and OCSG to make our QB decisions.
Only a moron would think that's what I'm saying. Love Schiano and this staff. Get outta here, clown.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,146
90,310
113
At Princeton Gleeson sometimes utilized sets with 3 QBs in. Do not be surprised to see more and more 2 qb, and maybe 3 qb sets.
Would love to see 4 or 5 QB in an "I" formation. Vedral, Langan, Sit, Snyder and Simon. What the hell, let's count Pacheco (played QB in high school) and Jonathan Lewis, and if eligible, Powell. An 8 QB set, with a center and 2 OL. They can lateral the ball until someone gets open downfield. What could go wrong?
 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
51,247
63,330
113
Lol what? Wtf are you talking about?

You think Langan is a starting Big Ten QB. Love the kid, but there's a reason we have a special package for him. You're the only one who thinks he should be our starter besides his mom probably.
Ah, geeze, now he's got you talking about Langan's package!
 
Oct 21, 2010
15,576
15,087
113
Only a moron would think that's what I'm saying. Love Schiano and this staff. Get outta here, clown.
You are second guessing HCGS and OCSG which is your right to do as a fan. I don't agree with you but you keep wanting people to agree with you and when they don't you go to insults. I will stick to my contention that Coach Schiano and Coach Gleeson are in a better position to decide who are starting QB should be, Not you! Vedral is our Starting QB and until their is a change made by those who know something that is who our guy is.
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,406
56,428
113
And we just saw exactly why Langan can't be a real P5 QB, he doesn't see the defender and throws dangerous passes as a result.
 

RUHouston

All-American
Jul 24, 2009
5,183
5,134
58
Yesterday, against the #3 School in the Land Vedral was 21/32, no TDs but NO picks!

Tell me you wouldn’t take that given the “usual” results to the Buckeyes.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,316
9,515
113
This is a silly conversation. It’s obvious all the qbs are going to play a lot this season.
I don't think it is obvious that either Langan or Sit will play a lot this season. Langan will get consistently limited playing time. Not sure if Sits will get anything more then a few garbage time series.
 

RUBOB72

All-American
Aug 5, 2004
23,385
7,924
0
You're high. Johnny's the weakest passer of the bunch.
Lagan is a tough kid who given a little coaching might become an adequate emergency QB... if Sitkowski is still # 2 on Monday and it’s game 4 now coming up...guess what ? Schiano and Gleeson must think Sitkowski gives them a better chance...There are still idiots on this board who will and have rooted against this player since his terrible first 1 1/2 years under Ash.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,213
17,017
113
Langan's good the way he's being used, but shouldn't be considered even a back-up unless Sit shows he's still not ready for prime time.
Noah is the one whose play gives RU the best chance to win and though a slim one against good teams, it is still the best chance .
Cole Snyder might not be ready to take a shot and Schiano might not want to make Evan Simon a sacrificial lamb , just yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: -RUFAN4LIFE-
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  2. 02 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / Notre Dame; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Houston Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener