Clear cut: LANGAN should be starting QB

Status
Not open for further replies.

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,125
90,286
113
He was 100% a huge reason why we lost today with two horrendous int's which turned the game on its head. Also defense was on the field the whole game because he could lead them on any drives.
Time of possession was 32/28 IU/RU. That's a fairly even split not the "whole game."
 

JerseyShoreKnight

All-Conference
Jan 2, 2014
3,081
2,954
0
Let me help you. Vedral just another guy. Played very poorly today and was very average vs. MSU. Not that difficult.
So play the QB that is clearly worse because the starter is “just another guy” to you? Are you high?

Also, have you forgotten that the backup QB is Art? Gleeson’s
put in a few packages for Langan because of his ability to run, but he clearly sees him behind Vedral and Art in running his offense. No chance he starts over either of them. Quit dreaming.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
This feels like a new low, tho. Vedral has been the most productive QB we've had in years and we get people calling to bench him for a guy whose entire resume on our team is losses and 0-fers. After one sub-par game.
Will you be posting when he's benched in the next week or two?
 

RUDieHard

Senior
Dec 20, 2004
375
550
0
This thread is hilarious! The OP is a joke!

We just beat MSU by 11 and lost a competitive game to #17 Indiana.

What did you expect ? 2-0 and perfection from the QB? That's ridiculous!

We've been saying this for years on BBall board, relax and enjoy the ride!
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
This thread is hilarious! The OP is a joke!

We just beat MSU by 11 and lost a competitive game to #17 Indiana.

What did you expect ? 2-0 and perfection from the QB? That's ridiculous!

We've been saying this for years on BBall board, relax and enjoy the ride!
You would 100% correct. I do expect a starting qb not to throw three terrible game-changing int's.
 

mikefla

All-Conference
Nov 19, 2012
6,450
1,552
0
I like most of what Vedral does...alot.

We lost one of our best players to targeting
Indys line pretty much handled us
As did their D-bcks.....
Indy was good

I just hope "V" doesnt have any more 3 INT days...
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdk02

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
I don't see this as a black and white issue. I was not particularly impressed with how NV threw the ball last week and was less so yesterday. He managed the game well last week, threw a couple of nice balls. Being plus 4 on turnovers can mask a lot of issues. He does hold on to the ball too long at times and either does not feel the pressure or believes he can get out of it when too many times that was not the case. Several sacks were not of the blind side variety.

What is difficult to see on TV is whether there are guys open that he is not picking up or if we continue to have WR's and TE's that cannot get separation. Our ability to throw 10 yards down the field was nearly non existent when it mattered. Yes our offensive line got exposed today and next week will likely be worse. I would not view NV as having a lock on the position and would expect to see Sit, Snyder and Simon all get regular reps before Langan.
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
No way there should be a QB change. We’re a week removed from a road win over a team that just beat a ranked Michigan team. Come on.
 

madchuck

Heisman
Oct 22, 2016
21,854
46,628
62
He was 100% a huge reason why we lost today with two horrendous int's which turned the game on its head. Also defense was on the field the whole game because he could lead them on any drives.

His arm was hit on two of the interceptions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: -RUFAN4LIFE-
Oct 21, 2010
15,576
15,087
113
After two games Vedral has been very underwhelming. Can only make basic throws, holds the ball, extremely slow with reads. If that's the case then put Langan in because he can make the same throws plus he's a big time athlete. We need him as the starter not some 5 play per game Taysom Hill gimmick.

No, I'm not a relative but this is completely obvious to anyone watching. What the heck is the coaching staff seeing in Vedral?
Hmmm, I think I will leave the coaching decisions to coach Schiano and coach Gleeson who have had time to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of all our QB’s.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
I think OP is onto something, but came to the wrong conclusion.

Personally I'd continue to roll with Vedral as the starter, but I'd use a lot more Langan packages. I don't think this offense is capable of consistently sustaining drives via traditional, or even more modern play calling. We need to look more like Boise in their hey day, we need to come at teams with tons of creativity. I think the presence of Langan does help make this possible, but more important is the presence of Gleeson.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nikoru09

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
His arm was hit on two of the interceptions.
True but on one of those he did step into the pressure. I thought a couple times yesterday the pass protection was good enough, but Vedral created a negative play by not finding space. Not saying it is easy to do that, and I'm not down on Vedral, I think he's doing a pretty decent job thus far, but sometimes the QB getting hit is on the QB.
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,404
56,426
113
This thread is hilarious! The OP is a joke!

We just beat MSU by 11 and lost a competitive game to #17 Indiana.

What did you expect ? 2-0 and perfection from the QB? That's ridiculous!

We've been saying this for years on BBall board, relax and enjoy the ride!

Some people drank the kool aid after MSU and started to believe teams like Indiana were easy wins. Now they are lashing out with nonsensical change QB posts.
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,404
56,426
113
I think OP is onto something, but came to the wrong conclusion.

Personally I'd continue to roll with Vedral as the starter, but I'd use a lot more Langan packages. I don't think this offense is capable of consistently sustaining drives via traditional, or even more modern play calling. We need to look more like Boise in their hey day, we need to come at teams with tons of creativity. I think the presence of Langan does help make this possible, but more important is the presence of Gleeson.

The offense has the capability to move the ball but Gleeson needs to keep mixing it up with using the QBs as runners. Once he got away from that after the 1st TD they made it easy for Indiana to keep bringing players into the box because they didn't have to account for the QB. The offense got going again in the 2nd half once he started mixing those elements back into the play calling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SCILS02

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
For those posters using our sub-par o-line as an excuse, let me fill you in on somthing. MOST o-lines aren't that good in both college and pro football. In college, there are maybe 10 truly great o-lines, the rest are all good or bad in any given day. Your job as a QB is to execute your plays regardless and not turn the ball over. I know this is a hard concept for you to grasp. Vedral had plenty of time on most throws yesterday.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
I think OP is onto something, but came to the wrong conclusion.

Personally I'd continue to roll with Vedral as the starter, but I'd use a lot more Langan packages. I don't think this offense is capable of consistently sustaining drives via traditional, or even more modern play calling. We need to look more like Boise in their hey day, we need to come at teams with tons of creativity. I think the presence of Langan does help make this possible, but more important is the presence of Gleeson.
Yep. Guarantee you will be seeing a lot more of Mr. Langan in the coming weeks and when it happens I'll be reminding these clown posters about their posts. The film don't lie and these are smart coaches that will see that.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
The offense has the capability to move the ball but Gleeson needs to keep mixing it up with using the QBs as runners. Once he got away from that after the 1st TD they made it easy for Indiana to keep bringing players into the box because they didn't have to account for the QB. The offense got going again in the 2nd half once he started mixing those elements back into the play calling.
Well maybe he's coming to that conclusion? He, like us, is learning what this team is capable of, and I'm sure Schiano is in his ear a bit about trying to establish control of the line of scrimmage. So they try some conventional play calling, and unfortunately the results were not there. And it's not like they are going to go trickery on every play, but they probably do need to mix it up more and they did in the 2nd half yesterday.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
For those posters using our sub-par o-line as an excuse, let me fill you in on somthing. MOST o-lines aren't that good in both college and pro football. In college, there are maybe 10 truly great o-lines, the rest are all good or bad in any given day. Your job as a QB is to execute your plays regardless and not turn the ball over. I know this is a hard concept for you to grasp. Vedral had plenty of time on most throws yesterday.
Ours is not good, see the ypc, well below average and that is with, imo some good rb's.

I think they are better at pass pro, then run blocking, but not having a consistent running game puts added pressure on the passing game.
 

RUTGERS95

Heisman
Sep 28, 2005
37,226
54,670
113
our O line is fine to play with top 25 teams but play calling was incredibly suspect yesterday. I think even Lucas was harping on this
 
  • Like
Reactions: SCILS02

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
Yep. Guarantee you will be seeing a lot more of Mr. Langan in the coming weeks and when it happens I'll be reminding these clown posters about their posts. The film don't lie and these are smart coaches that will see that.
Seeing more Langan is different then what you originally proposed though no?
 
  • Like
Reactions: cshelley

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,523
12,641
82
I think Vedral was playing too tight. Too many over throws and a little too slow on reads. Just need to relax and play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SCILS02

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
our O line is fine to play with top 25 teams but play calling was incredibly suspect yesterday. I think even Lucas was harping on this
I have the exact opposite view. The conventional run game has been a disappointment thus far. The creativity of the play calling has brought success.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jreinsdorf

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
Seeing more Langan is different then what you originally proposed though no?
Just said he "should" be, but I recognize college sports are highly political and likely he won't be the starter. But is very likely he will be on the field a lot more, and it is likely Vedral will be yanked within the next game or two if he plays like yesterday.
 

LETSGORU91

All-American
Jan 29, 2017
7,203
7,952
113
Is he making any throws Langan can't make? If this is the extent of the passing game then he should be the QB.

I dont know. Does Langan throw a football?

Langan looks to run the minute he feels pressure. With our OL he will never attempt a pass.

Exactly

Some people drank the kool aid after MSU and started to believe teams like Indiana were easy wins. Now they are lashing out with nonsensical change QB posts.

I'm not sure which Kool Aid they are sipping. Going into this game, Rutgers had not beaten Indiana in its last four tries. Plus they came in as a ranked team fresh off a Nitty Kitty victory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: madchuck

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
Just said he "should" be, but I recognize college sports are highly political and likely he won't be the starter. But is very likely he will be on the field a lot more, and it is likely Vedral will be yanked within the next game or two if he plays like yesterday.
Political? Don't see how that's in play here.

And could Vedral be pulled if we are getting crushed by OSU? Sure, but at that point I'd expect Sit(or whoever) in the game and Langan in a similar role as we have seen thus far. Then I'd expect Vedral back in as starter the following week.

Vedral has been OK. The team is 1-1. Definitely don't see this as the time to talk about switching the starting QB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: -RUFAN4LIFE-

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
I'm not sure which Kool Aid they are sipping. Going into this game, Rutgers had not beaten Indiana in its last four tries. Plus they came in as a ranked team fresh off a Nitty Kitty victory.
Rutgers eats ranked teams for breakfast. That's why yesterdays loss was so dissapointing.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
I will say though that Langan in the game with another QB, which we saw a bit of yesterday, and I like as it poses more options, makes more sense with Vedral then it does with Sit's. I also think the complexity of the offense, and I think it is fair to say it's pretty complex thus far, makes it more difficult for a QB further down the depth chart to just slide in without scaling things back.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,460
13,076
113
our O line is fine to play with top 25 teams but play calling was incredibly suspect yesterday. I think even Lucas was harping on this

Exactly.
Did we ever throw to the TE yesterday?
How many Screen passes were called ?
Atrocious play calling.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
27,140
19,425
113
At least he had an excuse on two of them, as he was hit while throwing. Art used to just throw it to the wrong guy without any pressure on him. You really have no idea what you're talking about.

Don't feed the troll.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,125
90,286
113
At least he had an excuse on two of them, as he was hit while throwing. Art used to just throw it to the wrong guy without any pressure on him. You really have no idea what you're talking about.
And on the third one, it was effectively a surrender punt. It was actually a smarter play then taking the sack or throwing it out of bounds. Vedral gained 2 yards on that play. Yes, that is a strange way to look at it, but if some fan with an axe to gring is going to crucify him for three interceptions, agree that the first two were not errant throws, and while the third one was all on him, it was actually a smart play, regardless of whether he was thinking about it or not.

  • 4th & 8 at IU 34

    (12:33 - 3rd) Noah Vedral pass intercepted Micah McFadden return for no gain to the Ind 32
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU848789

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,311
9,515
113
Exactly.
Did we ever throw to the TE yesterday?
How many Screen passes were called ?
Atrocious play calling.
As a Giants fan I have no affinity for the screen pass. But Pacheco did have 4 receptions, not sure if any were screen passes.

As a Rutgers fan I'm not sure if we have a quality pass catching TE. We certainly don't have a highly touted one on the roster. Edit: Langan might actually be our best TE and he had one catch.
 

RUbacker

Heisman
Dec 5, 2014
16,232
23,249
108
After two games Vedral has been very underwhelming. Can only make basic throws, holds the ball, extremely slow with reads. If that's the case then put Langan in because he can make the same throws plus he's a big time athlete. We need him as the starter not some 5 play per game Taysom Hill gimmick.

No, I'm not a relative but this is completely obvious to anyone watching. What the heck is the coaching staff seeing in Vedral?
I trust Schiano and gleeson to pick the best they h@ve at each position instead of a poster On a football forum.
 

RutgersChow

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2008
2,945
2,459
113
Totally agree. No knock on Verdal but there is a reason he left Nebraska.
He is not the solution to our Offense . Not a Passing threat. Need to look at Johnny or Art ...Or Cole.
Don't agree at all. I'll give you Langan is a better runner, but he isn't in the same world as a passer, and Vedrel left Nebraska because Martinez is their QB. We don't have anyone who is as good as him. I really want to be fair, but I can't remember a poorer RU passing QB than Langan. There is a reason BC wanted him to change positions.

Langan was 5-13 for 1 yard last year vs. Indiana, and with probably a better OL and basically the same receivers.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: BLewis1968

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Langan looks to run the minute he feels pressure. With our OL he will never attempt a pass.
But we can call plays where he has to pass the ball BEFORE he can feel pressure.. where he doesn't have to see if the target is open.. because he is throwing the spot.. a vacant spot.. that the target has to get to. Drop back 4-5 steps.. immediately step up and turn to the target area and launch.. no questions asked.. requires a lot of practice and timing .. and presnap reads and signals as to where/who is the target.. but that is how you pass when you cannot give the QB time and a clean pocket. Or you play Flutie-ball and roll him out and let him run and get the receivers to keep running and pointing until he can throw the ball.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano talks Penn State game week
  3. 03 The Knight Report Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half