Clear cut: LANGAN should be starting QB

Status
Not open for further replies.

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
I trust Schiano and gleeson to pick the best they h@ve at each position instead of a poster On a football forum.
Love Schiano and Gleeson. But coaches don't always make the right decisions for various reasons. You may recall last week James Franklin decided not to take 3 knees and end the game vs. Indiana to win a game.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
And on the third one, it was effectively a surrender punt. It was actually a smarter play then taking the sack or throwing it out of bounds. Vedral gained 2 yards on that play. Yes, that is a strange way to look at it, but if some fan with an axe to gring is going to crucify him for three interceptions, agree that the first two were not errant throws, and while the third one was all on him, it was actually a smart play, regardless of whether he was thinking about it or not.

  • 4th & 8 at IU 34

    (12:33 - 3rd) Noah Vedral pass intercepted Micah McFadden return for no gain to the Ind 32
Huh? So on the third one you want to ignore the fact that the point of the play was to get a first down? Whether you gain a yard or not an int is always a turnover and momentum killer!
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,404
56,426
113
You think Vedral is clearly best QB on the roster? Lol.

Ah Langan showed nothing last year that says he can effectively lead a P5 offense.

- He can run with the ball and take a hit...check
- He can pass the ball effectively....nope
- He can place the ball where only his receiver has a chance at it...nope
- He can recognize when to throw it away...nope
- He can sit in the pocket waiting for the receiver to come up....nope

As we saw yesterday on the one play, he's best as an H-back. They can still keep the run package for him but he'd be more valuable being on the field more often fulfilling different roles instead of just gimmicks.
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,445
25,403
113
But we can call plays where he has to pass the ball BEFORE he can feel pressure.. where he doesn't have to see if the target is open.. because he is throwing the spot.. a vacant spot.. that the target has to get to. Drop back 4-5 steps.. immediately step up and turn to the target area and launch.. no questions asked.. requires a lot of practice and timing .. and presnap reads and signals as to where/who is the target.. but that is how you pass when you cannot give the QB time and a clean pocket. Or you play Flutie-ball and roll him out and let him run and get the receivers to keep running and pointing until he can throw the ball.
We did not do this at all for Langan last year. Now you want to start this now? We have no bye weeks. No is not the time to abandon Vedral.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,125
90,286
113
Huh? So on the third one you want to ignore the fact that the point of the play was to get a first down? Whether you gain a yard or not an int is always a turnover and momentum killer!
You either missed the point, or you are being obstinate. I don't want to fight. If there was nowhere else to go with the ball and you know you are getting sacked, the smart play is to throw the INT to a player who is going to have to dive for the ball and/or get tackled. That is all. No, that is not the way the play was supposed to go, but as it developed, the smart thing to do is to do what Vedral did--take the chance to force it into a tight window. Low risk, low reward type of play.
 

RUInsanityToo

All-American
May 5, 2006
9,619
9,996
113
Huh? So on the third one you want to ignore the fact that the point of the play was to get a first down? Whether you gain a yard or not an int is always a turnover and momentum killer!

The interception on the 4th down play was a playcall controlled roll right by the QB. If you were paying any attention at all, there was no one open on neither the first and second level.

The other 2 interceptions were on QB hits..
..one of which was in 2 seconds.

Vedral is not Johnny Unitas. He is servicable and likely the best QB option on the roster at this point with a much better output than QB's over the past 20 plus games for RU.

Not sure what game you were watching but Indiana's defense took advantage of RU's relative innefectiveness at a conventional running attack for most of the game. They used several effective blitz packages in obvious passing situations, of which RU found itself in often. In spite of this RU managed 21 points against a team that shut us out 35 to zip last time we played.
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
Seeing more Langan is different then what you originally proposed though no?

Yes it is. Feels like he's slowly backing off his original assertion for a more likely one.

I love the Langan packages, and if they're working, happy to see more of them mixed in. Which is entirely not the same as expecting Langan to replace NV.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU05

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
Yes it is. Feels like he's slowly backing off his original assertion for a more likely one.

I love the Langan packages, and if they're working, happy to see more of them mixed in. Which is entirely not the same as expecting Langan to replace NV.
Huh? Slowly backing off of what? I said "should." Not in my power to make the decision. It wasn't a prediction. Was an opinion of what I believe should be done.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
I'm going to trust Schiano and Gleeson. They are 1000x more qualified than you. Vedral is at best an average p5 qb. Which also happens to be so much better than anything we've had the past 5 years.
You sure? Will you repost this when he gets pulled within a few weeks?
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
Huh? Slowly backing off of what? I said "should." Not in my power to make the decision. It wasn't a prediction. Was an opinion of what I believe should be done.

You just said you're going to remind "the clowns" about this thread when they start using Langan in games more. No one was arguing against using Langan more. We're arguing against the idea that Langan is better than Vedral and *should* replace him.

Long story short, unless Langan outright replaces Vedral, you have nothing to crow about.
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
And you literally keep predicting they're going to pull him. You just did it again, two seconds after saying you weren't making predictions.

You *should* figure out what it is you're actually saying before you dredge this thread up as a gotcha.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
And you literally keep predicting they're going to pull him. You just did it again, two seconds after saying you weren't making predictions.

You *should* figure out what it is you're actually saying before you dredge this thread up as a gotcha.
Uh yeah he will be pulled absolutely if this keeps up. That's a different issue from my initial post wise guy. Schiano doesn't mess around with sloppy play if you're not aware. Whether it's Langan who would replace him that up to the staff...
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
You just said you're going to remind "the clowns" about this thread when they start using Langan in games more. No one was arguing against using Langan more. We're arguing against the idea that Langan is better than Vedral and *should* replace him.

Long story short, unless Langan outright replaces Vedral, you have nothing to crow about.
You have your opinion, I have mine. You can ride or die with Vedral. More power to you.
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,404
56,426
113
The interception on the 4th down play was a playcall controlled roll right by the QB. If you were paying any attention at all, there was no one open on neither the first and second level.

The other 2 interceptions were on QB hits..
..one of which was in 2 seconds.

Vedral is not Johnny Unitas. He is servicable and likely the best QB option on the roster at this point with a much better output than QB's over the past 20 plus games for RU.

Not sure what game you were watching but Indiana's defense took advantage of RU's relative innefectiveness at a conventional running attack for most of the game. They used several effective blitz packages in obvious passing situations, of which RU found itself in often. In spite of this RU managed 21 points against a team that shut us out 35 to zip last time we played.

Nice analysis!! He probably won't reply because he's overmatched...lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

jsol_05

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2005
5,546
3,211
113
While I "get" the idea of not shaking the confidence of the starter you chose.. I think there is more upside overall to pulling him on days like today and sending in AS or someone else. THEN.. 2 things can happen.. AS looks great.. and then Vedral would understand if AS got the next start.. or AS looks so-so or bad.. which gives Vedral back the ball. Either way is better for Rutgers. And for AS.. for all players.. this year is a freebie as far as the NCAA goes.. it's not like playing him will spoil a year if he plans to Xfer.

(of course, Vedral actually did better late than earlier.. vs the "prevent".. and as soon as the blitzes came back..)

In any case.. let's have some plays that show the QB not dropping back and looking around.. or rolling out for his life.. let us USE THE TIGHT ENDS for pete's sake.
Don’t worry everyone will get to play against O- State.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
Nice analysis!! He probably won't reply because he's overmatched...lol.
Part of your job as QB (especially a veteran grad transfer) is to recognize and react to defenses pre-snap and during the play. He did a terrible job of this yesterday. Holding the ball, bad reads, had plenty time to throw most plays! Go back and watch the game. Also, Millen pointed this out multiple times on the broadcast, so argue with him if you don't want to hear me say it.
 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
51,240
63,324
113
 

-RUFAN4LIFE-

Heisman
Feb 28, 2015
36,404
56,426
113
Part of your job as QB (especially a veteran grad transfer) is to recognize and react to defenses pre-snap and during the play. He did a terrible job of this yesterday. Holding the ball, bad reads, had plenty time to throw most plays! Go back and watch the game. Also, Millen pointed this out multiple times on the broadcast, so argue with him if you don't want to hear me say it.

A good defense makes a QB do those types of things.

Sitkowski, Langan and the others would not have done better no matter how much you want to argue. Langan for christ sakes would been worse based on what we saw last year.

BTW you still haven't responded to the post that I said you wouldn't respond directly to...lol.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
A good defense makes a QB do those types of things.

Sitkowski, Langan and the others would not have done better no matter how much you want to argue. Langan for christ sakes would been worse based on what we saw last year.

BTW you still haven't responded to the post that I said you wouldn't respond directly to...lol.
Not gonna deal with Shifty. He was wrong on 99% of his posts last year. Not worth my time...
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,125
90,286
113
Not gonna deal with Shifty. He was wrong on 99% of his posts last year. Not worth my time...
That hurts. No holiday card for you this year.

Beside, @RUFAN4LIFE was referring to this post

The interception on the 4th down play was a playcall controlled roll right by the QB. If you were paying any attention at all, there was no one open on neither the first and second level.

The other 2 interceptions were on QB hits..
..one of which was in 2 seconds.

Vedral is not Johnny Unitas. He is servicable and likely the best QB option on the roster at this point with a much better output than QB's over the past 20 plus games for RU.

Not sure what game you were watching but Indiana's defense took advantage of RU's relative innefectiveness at a conventional running attack for most of the game. They used several effective blitz packages in obvious passing situations, of which RU found itself in often. In spite of this RU managed 21 points against a team that shut us out 35 to zip last time we played.
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,170
8,516
113
You sure? Will you repost this when he gets pulled within a few weeks?
Pulled for who? Langan? Sitkowski? One couldn't even make the 2 deep at BC and the other had the lowest passer rating in all of D1 two years ago. No doubt Sitkowski has improved but I'm sorry with this OLine and the type of offense Gleeson is running, a mobile QB is much preferred.

Do I think Sitkowski will get an opportunity this year? Of course. Probably will happen next week against OSU if/when we're getting blown out. Doesn't mean he's the best option.
 

Hondo77

Senior
Nov 18, 2001
2,804
957
0
The interception on the 4th down play was a playcall controlled roll right by the QB. If you were paying any attention at all, there was no one open on neither the first and second level.

The other 2 interceptions were on QB hits..
..one of which was in 2 seconds.

Vedral is not Johnny Unitas. He is servicable and likely the best QB option on the roster at this point with a much better output than QB's over the past 20 plus games for RU.

Not sure what game you were watching but Indiana's defense took advantage of RU's relative innefectiveness at a conventional running attack for most of the game. They used several effective blitz packages in obvious passing situations, of which RU found itself in often. In spite of this RU managed 21 points against a team that shut us out 35 to zip last time we played.
Johnny Unitas wouldn't be Johnny Unitas with this OL.
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
The coaching staff knows which QB gives the team the best chance to win, the fans don't, period.
So you are saying the coaches lied about the QB competition? They haven't seen all the QBs play in real game conditions.

Also.. is this why backups.. when given the chance to replace an injured QB.. sometimes steal the starting job.. because the coaches NKEW they were better but just sat them.. 'cos?
 
  • Like
Reactions: SCILS02

RUforlife

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2002
3,444
4,218
0
So you are saying the coaches lied about the QB competition? They haven't seen all the QBs play in real game conditions.

Also.. is this why backups.. when given the chance to replace an injured QB.. sometimes steal the starting job.. because the coaches NKEW they were better but just sat them.. 'cos?
The coaches see these kids practice everyday and they are paid good money to evaluate player talent. They are professionals, fans are amateurs that have no clue how a kid practices or what is in his head on a daily basis. Let the coaches do their job without all the chirping from the peanut gallery, that is what I am saying, capisce.
 

SCILS02

Senior
Jul 18, 2012
904
863
0
Lol. This guy again. Coaches make bad QB decisions all the time. I can name a bunch of teams in the Top 50 of college football who are playing with guys who were once backup QB's who weren't chosen by coaches and now are better. It's always worth questioning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano talks Penn State game week
  3. 03 The Knight Report Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half