Anybody checked out Dutton Ranch?

SenseMaker_Cats

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
1,489
5,048
113
My ranking:

1883
1923
Yellowstone
Marshalls
Dutton’s Ranch

1883 - just speaks for itself. Amazing show about those times.
1923 - showed why the Dutton’s had to be so “ruthless” to protect their land but the never ending “get home nephew” thing watered it down. Until the end of course.
Yellowstone - another great show that got watered down over time.
Marshalls - Cheesy with the hyperbolic “seal team” stuff but at least it’s different.
Dutton’s Ranch - Ep 3 just solidified my opinion that it’s just an extension of the watered down Yellowstone.
 

ala_kat2

Heisman
Jan 4, 2003
11,216
10,602
103
Yessir. RIP is by far my favorite character. I was really disappointed in the show with Kaycie. However it’s spelled.
Yeah, I quit watching “Marshall’s”. Just a lot of shooting and not much character.
Dutton Ranch is really good as it maintains the cowboy ranch theme.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DudahUK

Bigtyrone

All-American
May 21, 2002
10,567
6,245
98
My ranking:

1883
1923
Yellowstone
Marshalls
Dutton’s Ranch

1883 - just speaks for itself. Amazing show about those times.
1923 - showed why the Dutton’s had to be so “ruthless” to protect their land but the never ending “get home nephew” thing watered it down. Until the end of course.
Yellowstone - another great show that got watered down over time.
Marshalls - Cheesy with the hyperbolic “seal team” stuff but at least it’s different.
Dutton’s Ranch - Ep 3 just solidified my opinion that it’s just an extension of the watered down Yellowstone.
I agree with you mostly. I would switch Dutton Ranch and Marshalls.
 

DudahUK

Heisman
Jul 23, 2020
7,158
11,365
113
Yeah, I quit watching “Marshall’s”. Just a lot of shooting and not much character.
Dutton Ranch is really good as it maintains the cowboy ranch theme.
Exactly. Completely agree. I still watch Marshalls but I don’t really pay attention to it. I’m glad they at least killed off Monica, I believe was her name, she was absolutely god awful.
 

DudahUK

Heisman
Jul 23, 2020
7,158
11,365
113
My ranking:

1883
1923
Yellowstone
Marshalls
Dutton’s Ranch

1883 - just speaks for itself. Amazing show about those times.
1923 - showed why the Dutton’s had to be so “ruthless” to protect their land but the never ending “get home nephew” thing watered it down. Until the end of course.
Yellowstone - another great show that got watered down over time.
Marshalls - Cheesy with the hyperbolic “seal team” stuff but at least it’s different.
Dutton’s Ranch - Ep 3 just solidified my opinion that it’s just an extension of the watered down Yellowstone.
Don’t forget that show with the chick and they are like a special operations unit. Name is escaping me at the moment.
 
Jul 20, 2025
384
324
63
You nailed it! You aren’t missing much by not watching Yellowstone. The acting is not good. Hell or High Water is one of the greatest movies in the last 30 years in my opinion. You would like Kingstown. His best tv show in my opinion.
But 1883 and 1923, prequels to Yellowstone are fantastic. Kingstown, Tulsa King, Landman are all excellent.
 
Jul 20, 2025
384
324
63
And predictable. I do like his stuff, but we don't watch all of them (he has too many spinoffs from Yellowstone to be honest). But they are all literally identical to the last with a different plot. Landman is a great series, but I can predict what's going to happen in almost every scene like clockwork.
But 1883 and 1923 prequels to Yellowstone are no where near the same. They are much different, but very, very good 👍
 

BlueBloodKyFan72

All-Conference
Apr 18, 2026
664
1,085
93
I figured it would suck but it’s surprisingly good. Thoughts?
Haven’t yet but the wife just mentioned it. We are going to start watching both liked Yellowstone. I’ve watched landman with hit and miss episodes which is on par with any series and Mayor of Kingston which I really like. We both really liked Wind River
 
  • Like
Reactions: DudahUK

DudahUK

Heisman
Jul 23, 2020
7,158
11,365
113
Haven’t yet but the wife just mentioned it. We are going to start watching both liked Yellowstone. I’ve watched landman with hit and miss episodes which is on par with any series and Mayor of Kingston which I really like. We both really liked Wind River
For sure check it out. I love Landman. You thought it was hit and miss? The girls get annoying but they are at least smoking hot.