Johnson seemed like a good coach but they weren't really doing much.. This new guy Oats looks like a real good hire. He can coach but can he recruit?
They had good success with Gottfried and seem to be trying to find that type of guy again and didnt feel Johnson was going to get them there I guess.
Gottfried was OK. Nice 5 year run of tournament appearances, one flukey Elite 8. But he was slipping when he was replaced, and really, they've been treading water for 25 years now, never really as good as they were under CM Newton and Wimp Sanderson. Gottfried always gave off a slick salesman vibe, and I never thought there was much substance there.
Not sure about the Oats hire. He did a superb job at Buffalo, and was a great HS coach, but handling HS players and the type of recruits who end up at Buffalo is very different than handling SEC-caliber recruits. And if you don't get SEC-caliber recruits, you're going to lose no matter how solid the effort and scheme.
It's not easy for power conference schools to significantly change their place in the pecking order. Over the last 25 years, I'd say the only real successes at that have been Calhoun at UConn, Izzo at Michigan St., Dick Bennett/Bo Ryan at Wisconsin, Billy Donovan at Florida, Jay Wright at Villanova, and Tony Bennett at Virginia. There have been a lot of other flash in the pans at other places, but those guys were able to raise the level of their programs and maintain it for an extended period. And it often won't last after the guy responsible for it leaves.