After I have calmed down and reflected.

Bulldog Bruce

All-American
Nov 1, 2007
5,084
6,161
113
How long has the Throat Slash been called a unsportsmanlike penalty, 10 years? It just amazes me that anyone would even consider doing that for a celebration. It just reeks of an uncoachable player and someone who is just out for themselves. It reminds me of those kids we have seen on Last Chance U and it is obvious why they are there even though they have more talent than that. Information just does not seem to penetrate and doing the right things are just foreign to players like that. I can accept some of the other penalties we had, but that should be an immediate removal from the game by the coaches.

Can't complain about the refs. They let the teams play generally but i could not argue with what was called on us.

I am not an offensive genius, but we need to have plays with snaps under center when we are 1 yard from the goal line or first down line, especially if the only play you got is QB run. Also there needs to be some sort of RB screen plays so Kylin Hill can start in some space once in a blue moon.

Not sure if I have ever seen such a one sided game end in a loss. Could have just forfeited and saved us 4 hours.

I am going to chalk it up to a learning year. I just hope Joe shows that he has learned something. It was just a shame to have that defense and not help them offensively in so many games.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
22,047
26,222
113
How long has the Throat Slash been called a unsportsmanlike penalty, 10 years? It just amazes me that anyone would even consider doing that for a celebration. It just reeks of an uncoachable player and someone who is just out for themselves. It reminds me of those kids we have seen on Last Chance U and it is obvious why they are there even though they have more talent than that. Information just does not seem to penetrate and doing the right things are just foreign to players like that. I can accept some of the other penalties we had, but that should be an immediate removal from the game by the coaches.

Can't complain about the refs. They let the teams play generally but i could not argue with what was called on us.

I am not an offensive genius, but we need to have plays with snaps under center when we are 1 yard from the goal line or first down line, especially if the only play you got is QB run. Also there needs to be some sort of RB screen plays so Kylin Hill can start in some space once in a blue moon.

Not sure if I have ever seen such a one sided game end in a loss. Could have just forfeited and saved us 4 hours.

I am going to chalk it up to a learning year. I just hope Joe shows that he has learned something. It was just a shame to have that defense and not help them offensively in so many games.

I never complain about officiating and usually mock those who do because it's just crybaby stuff. I dont have a problem with most of the calls today. My only thing is this....if you're going to call them, then call them. If you're going to call us for holding, then when they tackle a defender in the open field on their last TD, you gotta flag that too. If you're going to make us take a time out because you wouldn't reset the game clock for us, then dont reset the game clock for them. If you're going to call borderline targeting, you gotta call it both ways.

Officiating was not consistent at all.
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
I never complain about officiating and usually mock those who do because it's just crybaby stuff. I dont have a problem with most of the calls today. My only thing is this....if you're going to call them, then call them. If you're going to call us for holding, then when they tackle a defender in the open field on their last TD, you gotta flag that too. If you're going to make us take a time out because you wouldn't reset the game clock for us, then dont reset the game clock for them. If you're going to call borderline targeting, you gotta call it both ways.

Officiating was not consistent at all.

I agree. I just ask for consistentcy. That's all anyone should really expect at a minimum.
 

thatsbaseball

All-American
May 29, 2007
18,179
7,080
113
It appeared our players were doing a good bit of trash talking and theirs weren't during the game. I know swag and confidence are a part of it but I also know human nature will cause a ref to favor a disciplined team that quietly goes about their business and lets their "game" do their talking. In my mind our on the field lack of discipline is causing problems on several levels...pissing off the refs is one of them. This should be more obvious to the HC than anyone BUT if you're as clueless as Moorhead seems to be...................
 

ababyatemydingo

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2008
3,986
2,979
113
Regarding the trash talking on defense. Simmons and abram do a long, drawn-out look at me, me, me celebration on every play they make. Granted, they are the most talented on the defense, and can back it up with their play, but the less talented and younger guys see them doing that crap, and think they need to do it, too. Leaders lead. And Simmons and abram were their leaders. That’s how culture breeds in a team. And how you get a bunch of stupid, undisciplined penalties all year long. The coaches and captains are supposed to get a handle on that kind of stuff. Geri is a super guy, but a vocal captain he isn’t. The coaches let the guys listen to media talk about how good they were, and never clamped down on it all year. So, you end up with players doing stupid **** that cost the team.

Regarding the offensive play calling and execution, and dumb coaching mistakes that should never still be present by the end of the year, I have two words.

Peter Principle.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
59,432
30,082
113
What pisses me off even more about the throat slash is that's the second game in a row Kobe Jones has gotten an automatic 15-yard penalty. The referees in both games had no choice but to throw the flag. If he can't control himself any more than that, he needs to sit.
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,271
2,762
113
It appeared our players were doing a good bit of trash talking and theirs weren't during the game. I know swag and confidence are a part of it but I also know human nature will cause a ref to favor a disciplined team that quietly goes about their business and lets their "game" do their talking. In my mind our on the field lack of discipline is causing problems on several levels...pissing off the refs is one of them. This should be more obvious to the HC than anyone BUT if you're as clueless as Moorhead seems to be...................

Agree 100%. All the trash talking and look at me gestures after a tackle has to influence the way the refs view a game. We need more discipline.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
59,432
30,082
113
Spun the ball on the ground after the turnover. Wouldn't have been that big a deal, but it's specifically written in the rule that's a 15-yard penalty.
 

Trojanbulldog19

All-American
Aug 25, 2014
10,068
5,848
113
Even though that’s two separate guys. I agree they both need to go to the sidelines a while. We want them to be aggressive but at times shoop and Moorhead never had any control of the guys on the team and their attitude. They let them do whatever they want.
 

drt7891

Redshirt
Dec 6, 2010
6,727
0
0
Unfortunately,

I never complain about officiating and usually mock those who do because it's just crybaby stuff. I dont have a problem with most of the calls today. My only thing is this....if you're going to call them, then call them. If you're going to call us for holding, then when they tackle a defender in the open field on their last TD, you gotta flag that too. If you're going to make us take a time out because you wouldn't reset the game clock for us, then dont reset the game clock for them. If you're going to call borderline targeting, you gotta call it both ways.

Officiating was not consistent at all.

That “tackle” was a pancake block. Those won’t get called. Nothing about that setup block was illegal. I thought it was a lot worse when I saw it live, but on replay, it was just a good block.
 

Shmuley

Heisman
Mar 6, 2008
24,148
11,702
113
Somebody make a compilation of 15 yarders caused by sheer stupidity (yes, the MFer will be 17n feature length) and send it to crxxmshead. Mandatory watching for next year on “how not to act.”
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
22,047
26,222
113
That “tackle” was a pancake block. Those won’t get called. Nothing about that setup block was illegal. I thought it was a lot worse when I saw it live, but on replay, it was just a good block.

It looked pretty blatant to the naked eye in real time. I mean, really bad. I might change my tune when I see the replay.
 

drt7891

Redshirt
Dec 6, 2010
6,727
0
0
We didn’t help ourselves at all. The only call I kinda disagreed with was the Defensive Pass Interference they called on McLaurin. I thought he got his head around in time to play the ball. Other than that, everything else was stupid, preventable ******** we brought on ourselves.
 

drt7891

Redshirt
Dec 6, 2010
6,727
0
0
The blocker was in position, engaged with open hands, and drove him to the ground by driving his feet. Textbook open field pancake. Defender didn’t even attempt to engage.

Go to the 3:24 mark.

https://youtu.be/i2xsZCmjT6k
 

dudehead

Senior
Jul 9, 2006
1,591
684
113
Somebody make a compilation of 15 yarders caused by sheer stupidity (yes, the MFer will be 17n feature length) and send it to crxxmshead. Mandatory watching for next year on “how not to act.”

That would be time well spent.
 

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
7,096
2,459
113
But didn’t we have someone do the throat slash earlier this year & get flagged for it? Maybe that was another game I was watching - just remember seeing it called recently and thinking how dumb that was.
 

ShrubDog

Redshirt
Apr 13, 2008
5,307
3
38
Can someone please set the scene of the throat slash for the ones who didn’t or don’t plan on watching the game?
 

tcdog70

Junior
Sep 24, 2012
1,397
263
83
The only way to block Simmons is to hold Him--but they never call it. it looks like He could get the mandatory one hold a game call. The Pass Interference call was incorrect. The stupid penalties are mind blowing but the dagger in our heart is we have no SEC caliber WRs. Not 1 frigging one. Dak had Lewis-Brown -Ross and the Bear. **** --Fitz has Osiris and then zero. is it Illegal for us to throw a slant to one of our 6'4 wrs? Good teams stack the box and JOMO has no answer. One good wr would break that **** up. Seems like every play they had one man completely unblocked. Losing Jenkins was a death blow.
 

drt7891

Redshirt
Dec 6, 2010
6,727
0
0
I don’t think so, but I don’t specifically recall. But it at least flipped the field.

If it did, it was the very first touchdown they got.
 

Hump4Hoops

Redshirt
May 1, 2010
6,611
13
38
They hustle. High football IQ. First ones in, last ones out.

Gotta respect the low pad level and sticktoitiveness.
 

JoMo MoJo

Redshirt
Dec 24, 2017
1,895
0
0
The throat slash turned the refs against this team. They were not impartial to us anymore after that.
 
Feb 19, 2013
1,266
393
83
The blocker was in position, engaged with open hands, and drove him to the ground by driving his feet. Textbook open field pancake. Defender didn’t even attempt to engage.

Go to the 3:24 mark.

https://youtu.be/i2xsZCmjT6k

14 from Iowa reached out with his left hand and grabbed Abram when he went to run by him, then yanked him back in front of him and drove him to the ground. I wouldn't call that a textbook block....I'd call that a hold.
 

DancingRabbit

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
2,209
0
0
The blocker was in position, engaged with open hands, and drove him to the ground by driving his feet. Textbook open field pancake. Defender didn’t even attempt to engage.

Go to the 3:24 mark.

https://youtu.be/i2xsZCmjT6k

Weird how 2 people can watch something and see 2 different things. It was more like a textbook open field tackle. He grabbed him, spun him and drove him to the ground.
 

DawgatAuburn

All-Conference
Apr 25, 2006
11,096
2,049
113
Following the throat slash we got hit with targeting which then led to a field goal.
 

msstate7

Redshirt
Nov 27, 2008
10,388
10
38
Weird how 2 people can watch something and see 2 different things. It was more like a textbook open field tackle. He grabbed him, spun him and drove him to the ground.

1 watches the play for what it was. 1 watches the play as an excuse as to why we lost
 

MSUDawgFan86

Redshirt
Aug 14, 2017
1,331
1
0
If you think a bunch of 2 star white bums from Iowa can block this defense all day and not commit at least 1 penalty then I don’t know what to tell you... Officiating was pretty terrible.
 

grimedawg1

Freshman
Aug 25, 2012
339
77
28
What are the rules on blocking downfield?

I've tried to attach a still shot of the ball in the air. The Iowa guys started blocking as soon as they contacted our players down field. It was mentioned that the slot blocking Abram reached out and grabbed him. He is doing that in this pic. The blocker's left arm is hidden but he was clearly reaching out to grab Abram with his left arm when watching the video. As Abram tried to turn to chase the receiver down the sideline, the blocker was able to get him to the ground when Abram turned. It's not so much the completion of blocking him to the ground that looks like a penalty but the reaching way outside his body to engage him by grabbing Abram with the left hand.

With regard to blocking down field, what is the rule when the ball is in the air. Can the blockers block before the ball is caught? I think in the still it looked like the receiver was a couple of yards downfield, but he came back a little toward the line when he caught the ball.
 
Last edited:
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Scouting Ahead: Alabama QB Battle
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby answers question on adding Class of 2022 seniors
  3. 03 Maroon and White Mississippi State Football Preseason: Day 1 Takeaways
  4. 04 Maroon and White Scouting Ahead: Alabama at Mississippi State Q&A
  5. 05 On3 Salary cap wishes, college football intel from the Personnel and Recruiting Symposium