Something Todd posted needs to be pointed out about Mullen

Sep 11, 2012
410
0
0
You did not play the same Arkansas team we did

When we played Arkansas they had just come off winning two SEC games. They beat us in LR and they can still salvage the season. They gave up in the 3rd quarter in Starkville. Until then it was a close game.

Besides Auburn who, specifically, "got up" to play MSU this year that didn't for OM.
 

Koldfire

Redshirt
Sep 15, 2012
558
0
0
On one hand you ***** about everything wrong with our team....fire assistants, change QB, wrong players on the field, then you jack off cause we went 3-1 to UM and won three bowl games (two on New Year's Day). If we are having great football by Croom and MSU standards, stop bitching. I want that the damn championship I hear so much about.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
I want that the damn championship I hear so much about.

All coaches talk championships to get the fans fired up...we arent going to win any kind of championship as long as Bama and LSU are top 6-7 in the nation every year. Now throw Texas A&M in the mix who has way more resources and talent base than us. State, OM, and UPig arent going to win the West when those 3 schools are playing at their optimum level. UPig had their best teams in 40 years and finished 3rd in the West in 2010 and 2011.

If you cant be happy being a bowl team every year- you root for the wrong team
 
Last edited:

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,856
1,708
113
3 out of 4, 4 out of 6, dominated the last 20 years, dumb luck a Sunbelt-level skool with a gimmick offense caught us on an off night, followed by a 50th Anniversary celebration of the James Meredith riots after the game.
 

Sutterkane

Redshirt
Jan 23, 2007
5,100
0
0
So A&M had a better season than Bama? In 09 did we have a better season than your Cotton Bowl winning team? Let's talk about most ridiculous things that have ever been posted.
 

cofreb

Redshirt
Oct 6, 2009
159
33
28
It is challenging

to craft a response to this that wouldn't be labelled trolling, but I'll give it a shot:

1) I'm not aware of any post-season rankings (not originating from here or Genespage) that have MSU ahead of Ole Miss. Obviously neither of us were ranked so that slightly complicates things, but Sagarin has Ole Miss 20 spots ahead of MSU, Chris Low ranked Ole Miss ahead of MSU, and I believe Ole Miss was ahead of MSU in the all-important Cream Rankings.

2) The Egg Bowl was not, in any sense, a close game. By the time Ole Miss pulled its starters with 10 minutes to go, we were up 41-17, with MSU's 2 TDs coming on a KO return and a busted play. Total yardage was >500 for Ole Miss and <250 for MSU. For the game, MSU averaged 1 ypc and even stripping out Russell's negative yardage, MSU RBs only averaged ~2.5 yards per carry. MSU won the turnover battle, so it wasn't a case of bad luck. To an impartial observer, these facts would not be consistent with 'the better team losing.'

3) The SEC-only stats for the season further my argument. Despite the fact that MSU's SEC East opponents went 1-15 in conference play, while Ole Miss' went 12-4, Ole Miss finished ahead of MSU in total offense, scoring offense, total defense, and one spot behind in scoring defense. Further, Ole Miss was ahead of MSU in passing offense, rushing offense, rushing defense, and pass efficiency defense.

If you put all of this together, I think it's virtually impossible to say MSU had a better team. Although I'm sure my argument will be viewed as less-than-persuasive by most here.
 

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,856
1,708
113
41>27, 31>23, 31>3, 3 out of 4, 4 out of 6, dominated last 20 years, upset by a Sunbelt skool at their home field on an off-night. Your recruiting class was good, congratulations, you've had "all-time great recruiting classes" ever since Bear fans started buying Recruiting magazine subscriptions and writers realized they could make money off you idiot suckers. In the meantime, The Mississippi State University has had Top 20 recruiting classes the past 3 years and building up depth to compete for Conference and National Championships.

You Bears need to learn your place, lower your expectations, and accept facts- if you have any chance to ever win a championship of any kind again, you need to drop out of the SEC and renew your rivalry with USM (No, wait, USM whipped your *** 4 out of the last 5 times they played you...maybe you should consider making Delta State your rival).
 

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,783
24,668
113
I agree with you. If 2012 MSU and OM played on a neutral field 10 times, you guys would win 6 or 7. I say that because the issues our defensive staff had against spread type teams all year.
 

dawgs.sixpack

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2010
1,395
0
0
Bowl games don't even count, except for the BCS Championship. The others are nothing but money-makers and you never know when a team will show up. You always go by regular season, that's what tells you what type of team you had. Same in basketball and baseball. Do you think MSU had a better baseball season in 2007 than Vanderbilt? I didn't think so.

the difference between non BCS CG bowls and the basketball and baseball postseasons is that everyone in the baseball and basketball postseasons have a shot to win a title, whereas non BCS CG bowl games are glorified exhibitions.

that's not to say that making a sweet 16 as a 10 seed automatically means you had a better season than a 2 seed that loses in the 2nd round. there's a balance there between the regular season and postseason.
 
Sep 11, 2012
410
0
0
You're right

One could say that a&m had pretty much given up on the season when they played us, and completely quit on the game in the third quarter, but that would be retarded.

TAMU "got up" for us. However, their offense hadn't hit their prime until they played MSU. Their defense wasn't any better though, and MSU couldn't score points until late in the game.

So, MSU got the better end of tamu and. We got the better end of Arkansas. Looks pretty even on the "got up" scale.
 

Koldfire

Redshirt
Sep 15, 2012
558
0
0
All coaches talk championships to get the fans fired up...we arent going to win any kind of championship as long as Bama and LSU are top 6-7 in the nation every year. Now throw Texas A&M in the mix who has way more resources and talent base than us. State, OM, and UPig arent going to win the West when those 3 schools are playing at their optimum level. UPig had their best teams in 40 years and finished 3rd in the West in 2010 and 2011.

If you cant be happy being a bowl team every year- you root for the wrong team


Thats just my point. The championship talk was apparently interpreted by many in our fan base as belief and not bs. And they act like the only reason that Mullen hadn't delivered is because of Wilson, Melvin, Les, and even Tyler and little Perkins. Not to forget that he has the perfect championship scheme, but just don't his type players...or Les messes up this perfect system in game play calling. Do you really believe that Les has screwed up our offense? I would wager that be helps Coach Mullen to tweak his system to fit the personnel. You can't do the same things with the 25th ranked recruiting classes of MSU vs. the 5th ranked class of Florida using the exact same scheme. Les simplified the playbook for Relf and produced one of our best seasons.

The chances of our winning the SEC, you are right again, is no chance. As for as being happy with bowls games, I am not. But I am content. I've lived through some really bad MSU football. I'm thrilled that my 12 year old soon has been to more MSU bowl games in his life than I had in the years prior. Coach Mullen has been good for our program in many ways. I have never witness a more excited fan base. The investment in our program is unparalleled in my lifetime. I credit these things to Coach Mullen and I am most grateful.

But please stop attributing our lack of SEC supremacy to assistant coaches and players failure. Hell, Bo Wallace threw a record-breaking number of INT and UM props him up like he is Drew Brees. Tyler has one really bad game after breaking MSU passing records and our fans dog him.
 

GhostOfJackie

Senior
Apr 20, 2009
3,795
712
113
Do state fans really think they had the better team last year?

Dude, we were better than you and had a better season. You beat us because we played like **** in the second half and yall obviously wanted it more. Even my rebel friends at least admit that we had a better season.
 

GhostOfJackie

Senior
Apr 20, 2009
3,795
712
113
God you are just like my Ole Miss cousins. Comparing apples and oranges.... and grapes and cherries and potatoes and pears and pecans..... just to try and find one little enclave to prove that their rebels are better than our bulldogs. **** you people have an inferiority complex worse than Southern fans.
 

Ace-Leroy

Redshirt
Aug 23, 2012
334
34
28
We definitely upgraded on teaching DL fundamentals and I was encouraged by Collins in the bowl game. I'm ready to see Quay 17 some **** up this Fall. We should have 4 pretty damn good DT's in Quay, Eulls, James, and PJ


I agree on being encouraged by Collins in the bowl game. I thought We showed more attack on defense than We had all year. We do have 4 pretty good DTs and considering the defense front all together , Chris Jones will add a lot and don't forget Preston Smith. I think Preston will make an impact this upcoming year. Of course losing Banks and Slay will hurt , but I think the defensive front could help out the secondary a lot with putting pressure on and not asking them to cover for such a long time.

I think We will be much improved on defense next season.
 

121Josey

Redshirt
Oct 30, 2012
7,503
0
0
Lipstick on the Pig

Nobody is happy with the way the season ended- but we still played in a NYD bowl. As I tell my Rebel trolls on twitter- 8 wins > 6 wins...4-4 in the SEC > 3-5 in the SEC....and Gator Bowl > Ghetto Bowl of Birmingham

Yet we are 1 of only 7 SEC teams to play in bowl games the last 3 years- that doesnt scream "near the bottom". That implies top half of the SEC as a program- which is damn good compared to where we used to be

1. Does more = better? Is it like the teacher who gives extra-credit points for the students to do more C- work? Is playing in and losing handily in a NYD bowl w/ an empty stadium to a team that hasn't won a bowl game in 40 years > than winning a bowl game handily with a packed house? Did we get destroyed the second half in Oxford? Please don't embarrass us anymore with these naive comparisons.

2. 7-6 and 8-5 doesn't scream "near the top" either. We're mid-level at best and if last year's team played next year's schedule, it would scream "near the bottom" (and "Aloha Dan: You've just won a one-way ticket to the Mountain West").
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
1. Does more = better? - yes it does. More wins > less wins...I dont know of any sane human that would want to be 7-6 instead of 8-5.

2. 7-6 and 8-5 doesn't scream "near the top" either. We're mid-level at best- totally agree. Mullen has elevated our program from the the worst in the SEC when took over to a mid-level SEC team. Thats pretty damn good.

and if last year's team played next year's schedule, it would scream "near the bottom" - this isn't fantasy football- it's real football. If the 2010 team team played the 2012 schedule- we would have won 9 or more. See? I can play that game too. Bottom line is the 2012 played the 2012 schedule, won 8 games, and played in a NYD game. OM- in spite of beating us- they played in the shittiest bowl game the SEC is affiliated with. They did not have as good of a season as we did.

The 2013 team will play the 2013 schedule. New players, new coaches, more experience in some positions, less experience in other positions- we'll see how it pan out.


bbdhkdkjfoek
 

BigLeagueChew

Redshirt
Aug 25, 2008
411
0
16
So if more wins are better, Toledo, Utah State, San Diego State, Ball State, UCF, U-La-La, San Jose State, Fresno State, Cincinnati, Ohio, Rutgers, Vanderbilt, Tulsa, N. Illinois, Ark. State, and Kent State are all better than msu because all wins are equal. What a bunch of f#cking morons.

If we trade Texas, UGA, and Vandy for Jackson St., TN, and Ky., we'd 9-4 and msu would be 5-7. So yes we had a better year than you. Also, look at our mutual losses to Alabama, LSU and A&M. We lose by a combined 23 points and msu by 76 points.

I know no one on here will admit for of getting ostracized by other posters
 

diddog

Redshirt
Sep 26, 2012
81
0
0
Mullen inherited mid-level SEC team

Folks, when Mullen took over in 2009, MSU was already a mid-level SEC team. Mullen didn't elevate us to that place. In 2007, we went 4-4 in the SEC, beat two teams (Auburn and Alabama) that were much better than any team we beat in 2013 (check computer rankings). In 2008, we lost 8 of our top underclassman to a totally unpredictable and once in maybe 30 years occurrence - the shooting suspensions and expulsions - and injury (Chaney, etc.). Even with that, we beat a Petrino coached Arkansas, a top 25 Vandy team, and lost two SEC games by one point. Plus, our OOC schedule included WVU (a top 10 team that year) and La. Tech at La. Tech in their best season in program history.
Without those explosions and injuries, we would have easily been to another bowl. We were clearly a mid-level SEC team in 2007 and 2008. And the talent was clearly increasing given how incredibly young our 2007 and 2008 teams were and our vastly increasing recruiting talent.
Even with the injuries and suspensions, in 2008, Croom would have made a bowl game with Mullen's 2013 OOC schedule.

In the next two years after Mullen took over, our recruiting got worse. Our wins got better which clearly they would because Croom's staff had elevated the talent at MSU.

Sorry, but Croom got us to that level. Mullen has not improved it because his recruiting has not been good enough. He has won the games he needed to win against weaker teams -agreed. The spread option offense is a good offense to beat weaker and less talented teams - agreed. (It limits turnovers and guarantees ground yardage therefore helping beat weaker opponents). He has not done a bad job coaching on the field but his recruiting has not been good enough. When Vandy has moved ahead of you in recruiting, it is not good enough.
When Mullen took over, people had big expectations. As I've said, Coach34 said that after five years, if Mullen didn't have a winning SEC record, he should be fired. Well, it's not going to happen, and instead we've moved the goalpost by saying let's schedule a cupcake OOC schedule, get two SEC wins, and get to a bowl, and that is good enough.
We were already there in 2008. That is not progress.
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,384
3,324
113
Vandy was mediocre in 2008, regardless of how grossly overranked they were when we played them. Final rankings are the only ones that matter, unless there's a major injury or something that skews things. Vandy 2008 was only a little better than any other Johnson team and nowhere near as good as any of Franklin's. That Petrino team we beat didn't make a bowl, nor did the Auburn team we lost to. We also lost at home to a very mediocre Kentucky team who had 2 1-point SEC wins over non-bowl teams.

La Tech's best year was 2008? Seriously? Did you just not pay attention the last 2 years?

And YOU are the one who's moving the goalposts...the challenge was Mullen needs to go .500 in the SEC by year 5, and he did it in year 2 and year 4.
Even if Dan Mullen goes 0-8 in the SEC this fall (which isn't going to happen), he'll still have 3 more SEC wins in 5 years than Croom did in his 5.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Folks, when Mullen took over in 2009, MSU was already a mid-level SEC team. Mullen didn't elevate us to that place. In 2007, we went 4-4 in the SEC, beat two teams (Auburn and Alabama) that were much better than any team we beat in 2013 (check computer rankings). In 2008, we lost 8 of our top underclassman to a totally unpredictable and once in maybe 30 years occurrence - the shooting suspensions and expulsions - and injury (Chaney, etc.). Even with that, we beat a Petrino coached Arkansas, a top 25 Vandy team, and lost two SEC games by one point. Plus, our OOC schedule included WVU (a top 10 team that year) and La. Tech at La. Tech in their best season in program history.
Without those explosions and injuries, we would have easily been to another bowl. We were clearly a mid-level SEC team in 2007 and 2008. And the talent was clearly increasing given how incredibly young our 2007 and 2008 teams were and our vastly increasing recruiting talent.
Even with the injuries and suspensions, in 2008, Croom would have made a bowl game with Mullen's 2013 OOC schedule.

In the next two years after Mullen took over, our recruiting got worse. Our wins got better which clearly they would because Croom's staff had elevated the talent at MSU.

Sorry, but Croom got us to that level. Mullen has not improved it because his recruiting has not been good enough. He has won the games he needed to win against weaker teams -agreed. The spread option offense is a good offense to beat weaker and less talented teams - agreed. (It limits turnovers and guarantees ground yardage therefore helping beat weaker opponents). He has not done a bad job coaching on the field but his recruiting has not been good enough. When Vandy has moved ahead of you in recruiting, it is not good enough.
When Mullen took over, people had big expectations. As I've said, Coach34 said that after five years, if Mullen didn't have a winning SEC record, he should be fired. Well, it's not going to happen, and instead we've moved the goalpost by saying let's schedule a cupcake OOC schedule, get two SEC wins, and get to a bowl, and that is good enough.
We were already there in 2008. That is not progress.


I would go through and pick this apart point by point like I've done every other time you've posted this foolishness, but it's not even worth repeating at this point.

"Best la tech team in program history" @ 8-5... YEAAAAA, you should just shut up while you are behind JShort.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,164
113
Good points but a W is still better than a moral victory

The Bears certainly played some common opponents closer than we did, but still did not win the games. Had you hung on to beat A&M, Vandy, and LSU you would have a better record. But I don't think you won a single "big" game this year, unless you count us. I don't like the easy schedule any better than you, and especially when it was front loaded with easy teams and gave a false sense of accomplishment. The front-loading was somewhat fortuitous for us though, since Auburn and Tennessee should have been more of a challenge. But the 7 wins only lead to falling off the cliff because it gave us the impression that we were really good. Alabama changed that in a hurry. I think they probably played us with a bit more enthusiasm than they did you. OM spread their easy ones out a bit better so it seemed better.

Your finish was without a doubt better than ours, and winning the bowl game against a traditionally pretty good team helped. And the Egg Bowl shellacking certainly was a major factor, and might have given a fairly true measure of the relative "goodness" of the two teams at the end of the year. There's no doubt that we sucked at the end of the season.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,164
113
I think it was because we got beat so badly by Alabama, a game we went into thinking we had a real chance to win. And all they pre-game hype got the players to thinking they were Alabama's equal, and then we got schooled. That was a big psychological letdown that was only made worse the next week by Johnny Football. We actually played LSU a pretty good game ... had a chance to win up til the end. And we beat Arkansas by a bunch, then folded against the Bears. But they had a vendetta. We didn't.
 

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,783
24,668
113
It is, but all of our Ws the last two years have come against the worst teams in the SEC. In fact, I don't think we've beat a bowl eligible SEC team since the 2010 Egg Bowl.

It's the largest area of improvement for Mullen and staff.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
Best 6-6 season EVAHHHHH

I've never seen a group of people trumpet a 6-6 season so highly in my life and constantly try to explain to everyone how their 3-5 in the SEC was better than our 4-4...and then how our loss in a NYD bowl was so much below their win in a **** bowl over another **** 6-6 team

8-5 > 7-6...that cant be disputed
 
Nov 12, 2007
26,210
10,364
113
I can't decide which is more irritating.

Our own fans that find a way to down grade going to three bowls, three winning seasons and national coverage or the Rebs arguing that they had the better team last year.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,164
113
True, but the point of the discussion was the Bears compared to us. They didn't have any big wins this past year either, and almost lost to Arkansas, a team we wound up pounding. So comparisons of common opponents is not an exact science.

Yes, we need to get busy and get the big wins ... Alabama, SC next year would be good, LSU ... but it's tough given that the SEC West is basically the top 5 nationally every year, and the East isn't far behind.
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,384
3,324
113
It works both ways, bud. If the Gator Bowl had taken yall and we'd gone to Birmingham (which every single one of you swore would happen), we'd have been 9-4 and yall would have been 6-7.
And nice job swapping the hardest OOC game on your schedule for our easiest. I know Ole Miss likes to pad their win total with 2 FCS teams, but at least swap Texas for Troy (who might have beaten yall).
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
Maybe it was because Dan lost faith in his coordinators

I don't disagree that we are building for the future. You are right on there. Where I do disagree is with the excuses that it was only disagreements of opinion on D and Les on O for the "it". Anyone who has watched Dan over his tenure here could see his change in demeanor. He lost confidence and the team followed. Also, I think seven easy games in a row followed by an *** raping at Bama where we looked totally confused on the field and on the sideline was difficult to recover from. The way we were losing was crazy. Last, somewhere along the way it appeared Dan's statements about relentless effort were hollow. He sure as hell was no longer demanding it.

When you are a football coach and your OC and DC are going full retard with their play calling and you know you can't replace them until the season is over- I could see how that would change a head coach's demeanor. This year will tell the tale about that now that he has replaced Wilson and we will see what happens with Les.

But that's just a hopeless situation- firing coordinators mid season wouldn't have done us any good. We were stuck with what we had until Dan demoted Chris for the Gator Bowl- that move right there tells me that Dan has the fire.
 

mount lefroy

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
2,501
0
36
I'll pick it apart. You are an idiot.

Croom did some good things at state even if some here dont want to admit it. At the very least he managed the daycare of the shitholes we had and threw the ones who couldnt be managed out. That is what he did. He also got some wins over auburn, bama, and 2 over OM. That salvaged his career here.

But to imply that he had one damn thing to do with victories in 2013 is a farce. He coaches a team that literally gave up. Do you think for a second we sign ANYONE of significance with him as our coach in feb of 2009?

If you are selling that, you've lost your mind. Mullen had to change a perception and at the same time, give prospective players a reason to believe that the old perception wasnt real. That happened by him making useful, and successful, Chris Relf. You think that Croom's offense would have ever accomplished that?

How did he beat Florida down there with bad coaching? No other msu coach had done it since the 1960's.How did he pull the 3 peat on OM with one of those wins against their most talented team in decades? What of our 2008 defense led you to believe that 2 years later we could stop Michigan's offense dead in it's tracks?

Croom was good man. I get your loyalty. But he wasnt a good coach. He was the bandaid we needed for a shorter period of time than he was here.
 
Sep 11, 2012
410
0
0
4 more wins is different than 1 more win

A top 25 ranking is different than getting your *** kicked by a big 10 team. It's apples and oranges

You had a substantially easier schedule, and got your *** kicked by OM. I can see how the argument you had a better season than OM because you had more wins. I don't agree with it, but I can understand it. I can't see how you can say you had a better team. Literally had your *** handed to you after OM spotted you 2 touchdowns.

Bama got beat by TAMU one week after playing a one of the most intense games of the season against LSU. Bama won a national championship. MSU got their *** handed to them by a big 10 team.

someone else in this thread said that bowl games don't count. By that logic ND had a better season than Bama.
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,384
3,324
113
I concede Ole Miss was probably the better team on the basis of the Egg Bowl and common opponents, but there's no need to bring the bowls into the discussion. Yall would have lost to Northwestern, and we would have beaten Pittsburgh.
 

RebelBruiser

Redshirt
Aug 21, 2007
7,349
0
0
Goat, will you admit that if you had played our schedule you would've been 5-7 this year, or at least no better than 6-6?

That's why so many of your fans are worried about adding Oklahoma State and South Carolina this year along with having to play Arkansas and Auburn on the road. You know very well that with a tough schedule, 5-7 is a real possibility, and 8-4 is a long shot.
 

Ace-Leroy

Redshirt
Aug 23, 2012
334
34
28
To even intimate that MSU had a better team or better overall season than OM this past year is one of the most ridiculous things you've ever posted, and I've been keeping up with most of the ridiculous **** you've posted.

That's not the tune You Rebs were whistling after Mullen's first year when We had the nations hardest schedule and He beat the hell out of You. Congrats on being 1-3 vs. Mullen and winning 13 games in 3 years. Hell , We only have 24 wins in that time frame.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  2. 02 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Sunday Notebook: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State
  4. 04 Rivals Football Recruiting Biggest rankings risers in the updated 2027 Rivals300 rankings
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss