Something Todd posted needs to be pointed out about Mullen

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
and the job he is doing. Critics of Mullen want to point out how "easy" it is to go to a bowl game now. However, only 7 SEC teams have been to a bowl game in each of the last 3 seasons. And we are one of the seven. Just half of the SEC has been to 3 straight bowls- so apparently it's not that damn easy afterall.

Now we are working to go to our fourth straight. Something we have never accomplished and our rival has only done once in the last 40 years (97-2000) when they frequented the Motor City and Independence Bowls. Building a program takes consistency. Consistency helps you get to the next level because it takes only adding a couple more important pieces to what you already have that can make a group special

We have been to 3 straight bowls (1 of only 7 SEC teams to do this)
We have put pretty good back-to-back recruiting classes together which bodes well for the future of the program
We have our entire OL returning
We have lots of talent on the DL

Nobody is happy with the way the season ended- but we still played in a NYD bowl. As I tell my Rebel trolls on twitter- 8 wins > 6 wins...4-4 in the SEC > 3-5 in the SEC....and Gator Bowl > Ghetto Bowl of Birmingham

It's time to let our guys coach and see what they can get done in 2013. Bring on Spring Practice
 
Last edited:

thatsbaseball

All-American
May 29, 2007
18,472
7,590
113
What exactly happened the end of last year and what is being done to correct "it". Whatever "it" was was evident in Mullen`s and the team`s demeanor, affected effort on the field, undermined a lot of people`s faith in Mullen and had to have affected recruiting. If "it" hasn`t been corrected, no amount of random sunshine pumping and cheer leading is going fire up a lot of us til we see "it" is gone and the collective program has a fire in it`s belly again.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
We're not going to have proof of anything until the Fall. I was strictly taking a shot at the "it's easy to go to a bowl now" people. Of which you are a member

So I'll repeat- only half of the SEC has been to 3 straight bowl games
 
Last edited:

Faustdog

All-Conference
Jun 4, 2007
4,204
2,779
113
Good post. I'm like you in believing that our future looks bright.
 

woozman

All-Conference
Nov 13, 2004
3,466
2,697
113
One very important correction is coaching DL at Georgia now...
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
One very important correction is coaching DL at Georgia now...

We definitely upgraded on teaching DL fundamentals and I was encouraged by Collins in the bowl game. I'm ready to see Quay 17 some **** up this Fall. We should have 4 pretty damn good DT's in Quay, Eulls, James, and PJ
 

thatsbaseball

All-American
May 29, 2007
18,472
7,590
113
I know you know more than you can post here but I really am curious as to what the hell happened. Perhaps if we ever meet you can tell me over a beer.
 
Nov 12, 2007
26,210
10,364
113
Until someone can point me at a period in MSU football history that is better

than the Mullen era, that includes competing in a SEC West (or Pre SEC divisions) era that has been as tough as what we have been playing in, any talk of dumping him and the staff based on a 1-6 finish to last season is beyond stupid.

People love to use the phrase "We are M State", then forget what we trying to climb out of and expect a complete happy meal delivered by the time the make it to the drive up window.

It is going to take a long process to get out of the bottom dweller group. It starts with improved recruiting like we have had the past two seasons. It will have ups and downs like we had last season.

It really takes having some perspective as a fan. Some of us are willing to have it and some are not.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
I know you know more than you can post here but I really am curious as to what the hell happened. Perhaps if we ever meet you can tell me over a beer.

There were some opinion differences for sure. Easiest way to say it is that we all werent on the same page defensively. Plus, our young DL guys had problems away from football that kept them off the field. Hopefully that can be attributed to "spirited youth" and being a dumbass freshman.

One question I never had answered is why we played like we did in the 2nd half vs M. Tennessee on defense? We didnt play that way before or after defensively.

Offensively, as I said somewhere in another thread- the latest rumor is we actually ran more of what Koenning wanted to do in 2012. And that offensive plan is now being thrown in the garbage. It's still not out of the question an offensive coaching change could still happen. I'm extremely curious what is going to happen on this side of the ball.
 

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
7,272
781
113
Don Mullins needs an epic win this season

and a strong finish in major bowl. THEN we will see MSU long-term fortunes change and along w/that better recruiting classes.

Mississippi is building their program in a "plastic" way. Cart before the horse.
 
Nov 12, 2007
26,210
10,364
113
I agree. He does need an epic win or two this season.

If that happens and we have another bowl you will see this reflect even more in the quality of recruits we have.

I do agree it is at the point that it will take an exciting win or two to push us forward. Hopefully the increase in overall team depth will help us pull one of these out.
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,511
3,080
113
Why doesn't Mullen simply take over the play calling? I know he is the HC and you have to delegate, but until he finds an OC that is on the same page as him we are going to have problems. As far as where we are at this point in time with our program, I can't argue with your analysis. But we lost the 'play with relentless effort' theme last year and that is what is the most disappointing thing to me. Hopefully the changes on the staff will correct that.
 

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
7,272
781
113
If MSU is gonna be relevant, we must CONTINUE to beat AU and UA like this

If that happens and we have another bowl you will see this reflect even more in the quality of recruits we have.

I do agree it is at the point that it will take an exciting win or two to push us forward. Hopefully the increase in overall team depth will help us pull one of these out.

season. Continue beating the B-leaguers on the schedule. Then take out LSU and TAMU then beat a better Mississippi team. We have nationwide attention
 

DancingRabbit

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
2,209
0
0
Our overall chemistry definitely seemed to suffer down the stretch.

I think the whole staff and maybe the team came to the realization well before the bowl game that a defensive change was probably going to happen. That creates an awkward "elephant in the room" scene that creates a chemistry problem no matter how much you work to avoid it.

On offense we may have had some issues with Les' play-calling or maybe it was just failing to make the correct gameplan adjustments in how we used Tyler and Perk. During the first half of the season talent superiority hid the problems. Although he had a few prominent mistakes (mainly in the bowl game), Tyler's play was not our biggest weakness by any means - he didn't have guys open - partly due to talent level and partly due to play-calling. Hopefully with another year Brew can coach up the receivers some.

I think our confidence on offense took a major hit after the Bama game that we never fully recovered from, although we did have some bright spots in the Arky and LSU games.
 

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
7,272
781
113
Beating Alabama is only a pipe dream now. Moral victories are what we seek vs them
 

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,543
7,006
113
We can't ignore the impact of weak schedules though

If you count A&M and Missouri as conference members over the past 3 years, we finished 14/14, 12/14, and 9/14 in SOS during 2012, 2011, and 2010, respectively. That's according to Sagarin.

Overall, I like what Mullen is doing. Talent is better and deeper and we are beating the teams we should. Fans support the program and our facilities are drastically or are in the process of being drastically improved. That's miles ahead of where Croom got us. We never were going to step ahead of a pn Arkansas or USCe overnight, but we are laying the groundwork to get there.

However, we are also taking advantage of having extremely ****** OOC opponents to get us bowl eligible. If we are going to be fair, I think you have to acknowledge those patsies we've been beating as a big part of us having been a routine bowl participant. Hell, playing OSU next year instead of a crap team already has many of our fans preparing for the possibility of not bowling next year.
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
That needs to be put into perspective as well

If you count A&M and Missouri as conference members over the past 3 years, we finished 14/14, 12/14, and 9/14 in SOS during 2012, 2011, and 2010, respectively. That's according to Sagarin.

Overall, I like what Mullen is doing. Talent is better and deeper and we are beating the teams we should. Fans support the program and our facilities are drastically or are in the process of being drastically improved. That's miles ahead of where Croom got us. We never were going to step ahead of a pn Arkansas or USCe overnight, but we are laying the groundwork to get there.

However, we are also taking advantage of having extremely ****** OOC opponents to get us bowl eligible. If we are going to be fair, I think you have to acknowledge those patsies we've been beating as a big part of us having been a routine bowl participant. Hell, playing OSU next year instead of a crap team already has many of our fans preparing for the possibility of not bowling next year.

During Dan's tenure so far, the only season that I can see where having an easy OOC schedule really helped us get into a bowl was 2011, when we went 2-6 in the SEC. Dan went gone 4-4 in the SEC in 2010 and 2012, and then 3-5 his first year where we didn't go to a bowl because our OOC was ridiculous.

So, really having an easy schedule has actually helped us more with going to a NYD bowl vs. just going to a bowl, which again is part of growing our program. There's a difference between just beating Kentucky and Ole Miss and then beating four cupcakes and beating some other conference opponents and going to a bowl.

The fact that we are even invited to a pre-season bowl is because of what we have done in recent years. If we kept playing people like West Virginia OOC, I highly doubt we have the recruiting classes we are having and I know we wouldn't be going to the Texas Kickoff Classic or whatever it's called.

If you are going to build a program in the SEC, it's a lot better and more logical to do it with a manageable schedule rather than hope you score three upsets or win two or three toss ups and then hope for the best.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
If you count A&M and Missouri as conference members over the past 3 years, we finished 14/14, 12/14, and 9/14 in SOS during 2012, 2011, and 2010, respectively. That's according to Sagarin.

Overall, I like what Mullen is doing. Talent is better and deeper and we are beating the teams we should. Fans support the program and our facilities are drastically or are in the process of being drastically improved. That's miles ahead of where Croom got us. We never were going to step ahead of a pn Arkansas or USCe overnight, but we are laying the groundwork to get there.

However, we are also taking advantage of having extremely ****** OOC opponents to get us bowl eligible. If we are going to be fair, I think you have to acknowledge those patsies we've been beating as a big part of us having been a routine bowl participant. Hell, playing OSU next year instead of a crap team already has many of our fans preparing for the possibility of not bowling next year.

I agree that the schedule has been weak, but that is the only way MSU can begin laying that foundation to take the next step. Now we have OSU and a tougher SEC slate this year...win with that schedule and we can begin scheduling tougher. If we go 5-7 this year, I guarantee you this board will be littered with posts about how stupid it was to schedule OSU. We can't forget that 8 wins with a ****** schedule does way more for our program than 5 wins with a tough schedule. For whatever reasons our fans always want to apologize for success, instead of embracing it like most schools do. We don't have the history of success to be complaining about 8 wins due to "a weak schedule". It's just a mindset we as fans need to get rid of in my opinion.
 

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,543
7,006
113
I like bowling. I fully support a weak OOC.

Until we are actually worse off by having a weak schedule, there's no reason to change. I'm pretty confident the streak would be at 4 if we replaced Ga Tech with a garbage team in '09.
 
Sep 11, 2012
410
0
0
And 41 > 24

To even intimate that MSU had a better team or better overall season than OM this past year is one of the most ridiculous things you've ever posted, and I've been keeping up with most of the ridiculous **** you've posted.
 

Hump4Hoops

Redshirt
May 1, 2010
6,611
13
38
You must be a simpleton

Final score of one game rarely tells the tale of a season. ole miss was better in '09, we were better in '12.
 

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
16,209
3,714
113
I don't disagree that we are building for the future. You are right on there. Where I do disagree is with the excuses that it was only disagreements of opinion on D and Les on O for the "it". Anyone who has watched Dan over his tenure here could see his change in demeanor. He lost confidence and the team followed. Also, I think seven easy games in a row followed by an *** raping at Bama where we looked totally confused on the field and on the sideline was difficult to recover from. The way we were losing was crazy. Last, somewhere along the way it appeared Dan's statements about relentless effort were hollow. He sure as hell was no longer demanding it.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
If you count A&M and Missouri as conference members over the past 3 years, we finished 14/14, 12/14, and 9/14 in SOS during 2012, 2011, and 2010, respectively. That's according to Sagarin.

However, we are also taking advantage of having extremely ****** OOC opponents to get us bowl eligible. If we are going to be fair, I think you have to acknowledge those patsies we've been beating as a big part of us having been a routine bowl participant. Hell, playing OSU next year instead of a crap team already has many of our fans preparing for the possibility of not bowling next year.

a historically doormat program using a weaker OOC to help ensure bowl trips to build it's program? Oh the horror. Not to mention we used to lose to those very teams that we have had in the OOC- UAB, La Tech, and Houston. Now our fans are gonna complain because Mullen beats them?

Now that we are on stable ground- we have added a good BCS program to the schedule for notoriety and a payday. There is a method to the madness. It's not an accident that recruiting has gotten better since we have been a consistent bowl team. I just dont understand how we go from being a loser program wishing we could be a bowl team to a program where just going to bowl games isnt good enough.
 

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,543
7,006
113
I'm not complaining.

Where did it even remotely come across that I was bitching about it? I just don't think the one of 7 SEC teams to bowl in 3 straight years is something we should get fired up about. We probably had the easiest path of those seven (or maybe even the 14) in accomplishing that.

Mullen deserves a lot of praise. I just think we have to be honest and acknowledge that a lot of our recent success must be attributed to patsie scheduling. That doesn't mean I'm bitching at it doesn't mean I have to think Mullen isn't the man for the job either.
 
Last edited:

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
To even intimate that MSU had a better team or better overall season than OM this past year is one of the most ridiculous things you've ever posted, and I've been keeping up with most of the ridiculous **** you've posted.

You guys won the Egg Bowl- congrats...but 8-4 is now and always be the better SEASON.

By your logic, we had a better season in 2009 because of 41-27 right? Doesnt matter that we went 5-7 and you went to the Cotton Bowl.

Moron...tell us aGAIN about how you played Alabama close when you were down 27-7 at half and barely had 200 yards of offense for the game...get out of here with that ********
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
I wasn't trying to call you out

specifically or anything- but I have seen a lot of people (some from other schools) kind of insinuate that we wouldn't go bowling with a difficult schedule. And that's not really the case.

Actually, Croom's first season may have been as easy as a schedule as we had in years- Tulane, Maine, UAB, at Vandy, Kentucky, and not to mention average Alabama and Ole Miss teams. So, Dan taking care of business is improvement for us.
 
Sep 11, 2012
410
0
0
You were 8-5, not 8-4.

We were 7-6. You won 1 more game than we did. You'd say we had similar schedules this year?

Did you guys beat a top 25 team this past year? Finish in the top 25? Win 3 more games in the regular season than OM? I'm just trying to think of the many different ways in which the 2012 MSU team is completely different than the 2009 OM team. I'm sure there are others. I'm just going off the top of my head.
 

Coach 57

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
374
0
0
I mentioned this scenario about our young DTs getting into trouble and get blasted. C34 says the same thing and gets pats on the back? Lol, I guess I don't have the street cred yet. Lol. And that was why Wilson played Cherrington BTW. You people were wondering why? Reduced snaps from big time players that prove their worth in practice because they did something off the field and not playing them when other players who are seniors are pissed at the positional coach, HC for not playing them and messing up their senior yr and possibilities to win trophies is a bad deal and a tough pill to swallow. Coaching is more than letting a kid who continues to screw up play just because a year ago you promised him X amount of snaps and being a beast on the practice field. Team means more. Might cost you a few games because a few kids bow out and take the high road but in the end it's worth not poisoning the program.
 

Koldfire

Redshirt
Sep 15, 2012
558
0
0
Y'all can keep believing the "we will never lose to this team" bs all you want. But the truth is we have not beaten any team except for Michigan in 10' that was worth a ****. We play in the SEC. Until we beat an SEC team that not about to fire their coach, we are still near the bottom. If things don't get better, we will have to move to the Sunbelt to win "championships."
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
Until we are actually worse off by having a weak schedule, there's no reason to change. I'm pretty confident the streak would be at 4 if we replaced Ga Tech with a garbage team in '09.

I'm with you, and yes I will complain my *** off if we miss a bowl this coming season because we are playing a ridiculous schedule made harder by adding an OOC team like OSU. Does ANYBODY but us care we missed a bowl because we had the toughest schedule in the nation in 2009? Hell no, we were 5-7 and that's all anyone remembers now. Playing in the SEC is RIDICULOUSLY difficult for us and to make it worse by scheduling a team that 2 years ago was a whisker from playing for a NC is just stupid. I mean the SEC is a beast to play in right now and that's enough. Heck, we just signed the 24th rated recruiting class in the country which was good enough for LAST in our own division and 10th out of 14 SEC schools. We just need, right now, to keep the ball rolling with non-losing seasons UNTIL we truly show we can compete with the upper crust teams in the SEC and Mullen has not shown us that he has teams ready to do that yet. Our best win in the SEC under Mullen is still probably OM in 2009 (when we were just trying to get our program started under Mullen) or FL in 2010 which was a team on the way down under Meyer. And we certainly didn't show an ability to compete with top level teams this past season.
 
Last edited:

MidTNDawg

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
127
0
0
I mentioned this scenario about our young DTs getting into trouble and get blasted. C34 says the same thing and gets pats on the back? Lol, I guess I don't have the street cred yet. Lol. And that was why Wilson played Cherrington BTW. You people were wondering why? Reduced snaps from big time players that prove their worth in practice because they did something off the field and not playing them when other players who are seniors are pissed at the positional coach, HC for not playing them and messing up their senior yr and possibilities to win trophies is a bad deal and a tough pill to swallow. Coaching is more than letting a kid who continues to screw up play just because a year ago you promised him X amount of snaps and being a beast on the practice field. Team means more. Might cost you a few games because a few kids bow out and take the high road but in the end it's worth not poisoning the program.

The 1st season after Diaz left I criticized Wilson for not being aggressive. Instantly I was told I did not know what I was talking about. I have pretty much left all this behind.
 
Last edited:

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
We are at the point now that missing a bowl game will be unacceptable- schedule be damned this year.

But if you look at things objectionally- Mullen has was at least 3 SEC games in every season except the one in which we had a **** ton of injuries- 2011. There is no reason to think we wont make one again in 2013 and win at least 3 conference games. Hell, since the Egg Bowl returned to the campuses in 1991- OM has only beaten us at home 1 time when we had a winning record- 1997. I dont see us losing that game this year with a very motivated Dan Mullen
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
Do state fans really think they had the better team last year?

Yes, because in the end, the only thing that counts is overall record and conference record and we had you trumped on both this past season. And we've been on both sides of the argument, nobody cared about our No. 1 schedule strength in 09 or the fact that we kicked the crap out of your Rebels. We were 5-7 and that's all that mattered in the end.
 

Railin Jemmye

Redshirt
Oct 29, 2012
1,937
0
0
Bowl games don't even count, except for the BCS Championship. The others are nothing but money-makers and you never know when a team will show up. You always go by regular season, that's what tells you what type of team you had. Same in basketball and baseball. Do you think MSU had a better baseball season in 2007 than Vanderbilt? I didn't think so.

Nobody was 'up' to play Ole Miss this season. Most teams were 'up' to play us, including Ole Miss (storm the field, remember). It's just how the **** works. We were the better team last year, period. But you won the Egg Bowl, and own the **** talking that comes with it.
 

Railin Jemmye

Redshirt
Oct 29, 2012
1,937
0
0
Do you prefer going a Croomtastic 3-9 every year? What is it that impatient pricks like you want? And who exactly do you think we should hire to do whatever it is you want?

I highly doubt you have answers to these questions. Odds are you just have an estrogen surplus.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
But the truth is we have not beaten any team except for Michigan in 10' that was worth a ****. we are still near the bottom. If things don't get better, we will have to move to the Sunbelt to win "championships."

Yet we are 1 of only 7 SEC teams to play in bowl games the last 3 years- that doesnt scream "near the bottom". That implies top half of the SEC as a program- which is damn good compared to where we used to be
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State