While Cleveland's front office has been a joke, they got the better end of this deal. not that Boston got hosed, but Cleveland did better. Irving hasn't even made the playoffs without LBJ, but he also didn't have the talent around him that he will have in Boston. Irving is a ball dominate guard who plays little defense and is a little self-absorbed. He likely would be better outside of the LBJ shadow, so this is likely a good deal for Boston. However, with LBJ on the team, there won't be much drop off in switching Irving for Thomas, plus Cleveland picks up some extra pieces, and a likely top 3 pick which they will either use in a trade to make a run now, or hold onto to potentially snag Bagley/Porter/Ayton. LBJ won't be in Cleveland a lot longer, regardless of what happens next offseason, as he only has a few years left in the tank anyway. The draft pick, if not used in a trade, jumpstarts their rebuilding efforts with a top pick in one of the most talent rich drafts at the top in some time. The IT contract also allows them to totally shed salaries next year should LBJ leave. They have an opportunity to make cap space, snag Bagley, and then turn around and get Barrett the year after due to not being any good whatsoever. Then having shed all those salaries, could draw in a superstar free agent the year after, and reduce the rebuild to 3-4 years.
As for the Boston homer in this thread,
@Mashburned this is no where near the great trade deal you are making it out to be for Boston. Irving is really good, and will likely be better than IT for Boston, he isn't the difference maker, and it's possible that Boston just gave Cleveland Bagley along with the other pieces to a conference rival. Now Boston is a couple of years away anyway, as they wait on Tatum and Brown to develop, and hope that they can hold onto Irving during that time. But if they can do that, they would have a really good core, but not sure it will be enough to win a championship. It generally takes one megastar, with two superstars, and some really good role players to win one, and I'm not sure who the mega star would be. In 2-3 years we can look back at this trade and determine who really got the better end of the deal, but for right now, at least on the surface, Cleveland got the better end of the deal.