Not sure the defense can be fixed.....Here's why

Burly

All-American
Sep 3, 2002
17,239
8,843
113
There are several factors in play, that probably will keep this team from getting a lot better on defense. The primary weapon used by opposing coaches is spread the court (everybody outside the 3 point line), use a middle ball screen involving Bam (usually 25-30 feet from basket), drive downhill and then our opponents either hope for a bucket, a rebound, a whistle or a kick out three. However Cal has several principles that he is unwilling to back down from, so that will probably be an issue all season.

1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.

2) Doesn't believe in drawing charges, more of a mano to mano philosophy as he hates floppers, but the best way to eliminate straight line drives is sliding over and picking up charges.

3) Absolutely doesn't want any corner threes, any man that leaves to help on the drive, will get jerked out of game if corner three is hit by his man. That's why there is little team defense help on drives.

I think the best we can hope for is an adjustment yet keeping Cal's principles in play.

1) No Need for Bam to challenge a ball screen 25 feet from basket. Hedge, recover and stay back in the paint as much as possible.

2) No more switching, fight over the screen, using hedge and recover.

3) Allow weakside defenders to get in position to pick up charges, others can rotate to corner to defend threes

4) Become connected as five with a sagging man to man defense, make them play over your instead of around you.
Great post... Obviously like myself you have actually played and or Coached the game most likely at College level.
BTW the greatest offensive team in College hoops (UCLA)struggled against a zone last night. USC just stayed in it. Looking at the make up of our roster we should be 30% zone.
 
Oct 31, 2016
374
477
0
Great post... Obviously like myself you have actually played and or Coached the game most likely at College level.
BTW the greatest offensive team in College hoops (UCLA)struggled against a zone last night. USC just stayed in it. Looking at the make up of our roster we should be 30% zone.

Correct assumption Rolaid, there is a time and place for a zone as Self demonstrated. In order to play it effectively, you have to scout your opponents and know what shooters to shade as Self did, this defense prevented Monk from getting off a shot for about 18 game minutes. So all you zone haters, if you thoroughly scout opponents (which Cal doesnt do), it can actually work and change the flow and outcome of a game.
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,883
4,413
113
Follow up to zone haters, how about a sagging man to man i.e. Sag off non shooters and keep bigs in paint for most part don't allow yourself to get so spread out chasing ball Screens 30 feet from basket also would eliminate switching
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
Any defense is only as good as the execution of it, right? So, for example if a team is committed to a zone or full court pressing defense and plays it well, then I expect their defense will generally be good enough against most similarly situated teams to give them a chance to win. And if you have an inferior team, then more gambling (gimmicky?) defenses (e.g., press, zone, etc.) might give you your best chance.

But, if you have the talent and work ethic, I think most coaches would agree that man-to-man defense is the best and least exploitable defense. Although I have heard it said that man-to-man is the easiest to teach but hardest to master.

Of course, I understand the argument for wanting to have other options in your bag too. But you have to think that UK's teams being so perpetually young makes it difficult to get them to learn and execute one defense well as it is.
 

jabney51

Redshirt
Dec 16, 2003
27
5
0
There are several factors in play, that probably will keep this team from getting a lot better on defense. The primary weapon used by opposing coaches is spread the court (everybody outside the 3 point line), use a middle ball screen involving Bam (usually 25-30 feet from basket), drive downhill and then our opponents either hope for a bucket, a rebound, a whistle or a kick out three. However Cal has several principles that he is unwilling to back down from, so that will probably be an issue all season.

1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.

2) Doesn't believe in drawing charges, more of a mano to mano philosophy as he hates floppers, but the best way to eliminate straight line drives is sliding over and picking up charges.

3) Absolutely doesn't want any corner threes, any man that leaves to help on the drive, will get jerked out of game if corner three is hit by his man. That's why there is little team defense help on drives.

I think the best we can hope for is an adjustment yet keeping Cal's principles in play.

1) No Need for Bam to challenge a ball screen 25 feet from basket. Hedge, recover and stay back in the paint as much as possible.

2) No more switching, fight over the screen, using hedge and recover.

3) Allow weakside defenders to get in position to pick up charges, others can rotate to corner to defend threes

4) Become connected as five with a sagging man to man defense, make them play over your instead of around you.
Defense is all about focus and hustle and until we get everyone doing both we will not be a good defensive team.
 

jc2010

All-Conference
May 13, 2008
4,593
4,369
62
Zone defense sucks...there's a reason it's not played at the highest level. You play zone when your not athletic enough or tall enough to defend your opponent. Zone also hurts rebounding bc your not always between man and basket. Our help defense is what needs improvement especially at the 4 spot. If zone is so awesome why don't more teams run it all the time...If you rotate correctly, limit second chances, rebound with both hands/put a body on people..it makes a difference...that's usually why Willis and Gabriel get pulled

Also on defense, the man guarding the corner IS NOT supposed to step in and gaurd the drive. It's not fundamental to do so.

I agree with the hedge and recover and no switching.
That is just too funny, what in the world is gained defensively if you switch Willis for Gabriel or Gabriel for Willis, like switching identical twins
 
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.

I've not waded through this thread, probably won't. I'm sure others have pointed out to you the shortcomings of the zone as a staple. I won't do that. Instead what I'm going to point out is another obvious thing: the kind of zone we would likely play is not what you have in your head. You're probably envisioning some well practiced, cohesive effort. That's not likely what you'd see if Cal gave in to the mindless calls from fans for zone. First, we've not practiced it to any real extent. Second, defense is defense - all defenses are predicated on some basics, such as communication, team-work, taking on and meeting individual responsibility. We aren't good at any of that, which is why the man to man isn't great.

This is like taking someone who is a poor employee and moving him to a different role with hopes he will miraculously be a good employee. Hardly ever works. Whatever made him a bad employee before will make him a bad employee in the new role. Same thing with playing zone because you're not good enough at man.
 
Nov 3, 2007
30,776
6,855
0
Zone defense sucks...there's a reason it's not played at the highest level. You play zone when your not athletic enough or tall enough to defend your opponent. Zone also hurts rebounding bc your not always between man and basket. Our help defense is what needs improvement especially at the 4 spot. If zone is so awesome why don't more teams run it all the time...If you rotate correctly, limit second chances, rebound with both hands/put a body on people..it makes a difference...that's usually why Willis and Gabriel get pulled

Also on defense, the man guarding the corner IS NOT supposed to step in and gaurd the drive. It's not fundamental to do so.

I agree with the hedge and recover and no switching.

Been listening to Coach Cal too much.
Zone does not hurt rebounding. You're actually in position already.
You don't run it all the time. You switch defenses at times to throw teams off a bit.
Switching vs. hedging and recovering is difficult for freshmen to master in a couple months vs. experienced teams that exploit your youth.
 

AllBall

All-American
May 5, 2015
4,985
6,610
93
We ca
The worst ball containment I have seen under Cal and watching the defensive film ought to make Him puke

Problem is Fox Monk Briscoe are playing a combined 100 minutes come hell or high water they know Cal won't bench them for lack of defense

Matador D to a T
That's funny. We call it Ole' or bull fighting defense.
 

jc2010

All-Conference
May 13, 2008
4,593
4,369
62
HS stars do not play defense, AAU stars do not play defense, Cal brings in five stars so it is unlikely they know how to play defense. The coaches in our conference take advantage of this. If we don't have a rim defender, we're screwed....we don't have a rim protector.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
HS stars do not play defense, AAU stars do not play defense, Cal brings in five stars so it is unlikely they know how to play defense. The coaches in our conference take advantage of this. If we don't have a rim defender, we're screwed....we don't have a rim protector.

Cal has brought in HS star after HS star and they have played some pretty good defenses since he's been here.
 

Untouchables22

All-Conference
Mar 5, 2013
2,359
3,129
0
Dang this thread seems clairvoyant at this point. We've got some serious defensive issues that hopefully can be fixed but I'm not hopeful without some strategic adjustments and the coaching staff always says more effort is going to work color me skeptical.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

jc2010

All-Conference
May 13, 2008
4,593
4,369
62
Cal has brought in HS star after HS star and they have played some pretty good defenses since he's been here.
Some have, some haven't, the point is they don't come here knowing how to play good defense. To have a "brow" or Noel makes the job easier but this team is a whole lot like last year. We don't have that eraser to cover mistakes
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
Some have, some haven't, the point is they don't come here knowing how to play good defense. To have a "brow" or Noel makes the job easier but this team is a whole lot like last year. We don't have that eraser to cover mistakes

To say we don't have a rim protector is fine. I agree with you there.

But we have had a ton of freshman come in that are highly rated and have played good to great defense.

If they didn't play d they certainly learned pretty quickly lol
 
Oct 31, 2016
374
477
0
The post is about 2 weeks old and will be pertinent 2 weeks from now, or 2 months from now, this defense wont be better unless Cal is willing to try something new. But he is stubborn about his defensive principles, to a fault sometimes, I might add. I have never seen better athletes get beat off the dribble as much as this team, simply, there is no defensive pride from several of the so-called lotto picks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jc2010
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein Show Recap: Who's Improved the Most for Kentucky?
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kam Williams is showing rust, but Mark Pope is confident he'll 'get his vibe back'
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein knows Missouri is better than its recent losses suggest