Not sure the defense can be fixed.....Here's why

LeonThe Camel

Senior
May 3, 2016
1,896
717
0
There are several factors in play, that probably will keep this team from getting a lot better on defense. The primary weapon used by opposing coaches is spread the court (everybody outside the 3 point line), use a middle ball screen involving Bam (usually 25-30 feet from basket), drive downhill and then our opponents either hope for a bucket, a rebound, a whistle or a kick out three. However Cal has several principles that he is unwilling to back down from, so that will probably be an issue all season.

1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.
Need to watch the Houston Rockets then. They ran a match-up zone for most of the night last night. Simply implement mas principles to the zone design.

2) Doesn't believe in drawing charges, more of a mano to mano philosophy as he hates floppers, but the best way to eliminate straight line drives is sliding over and picking up charges.

3) Absolutely doesn't want any corner threes, any man that leaves to help on the drive, will get jerked out of game if corner three is hit by his man. That's why there is little team defense help on drives.
A personal choice that needs to be changed based on the shooter.

I think the best we can hope for is an adjustment yet keeping Cal's principles in play.

1) No Need for Bam to challenge a ball screen 25 feet from basket. Hedge, recover and stay back in the paint as much as possible.

2) No more switching, fight over the screen, using hedge and recover.

3) Allow weakside defenders to get in position to pick up charges, others can rotate to corner to defend threes

4) Become connected as five with a sagging man to man defense, make them play over your instead of around you.
 

Soupbean

All-American
Jan 19, 2007
5,945
8,109
0
They do but that stuff is more consistent game by game. If I have the better talent as we do nearly everytime we take the court, I'm wanting teams to take twos, not threes against me. If I am the weaker team, I may as well slow the tempo down and bomb away from 3 hoping that it's my night and I'm connecting.

Another thing about our 2 pt defense if guys would stay on the court it would be a huge help. I think Bam isn't really a bad defender. The problem is when he goes out and Issac comes in. There's a huge drop off there.

I think if we just stayed out of foul trouble (i know hard to do in this SEC) that we'd see much better numbers.
I agree with a lot of what you say but keep in mind you are going to foul more in man to man especially when guys are getting to the next level and having to help.

We do get a lot of cheap ones too though just because we reach too much and don't move our feet.
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
I agree with a lot of what you say but keep in mind you are going to foul more in man to man especially when guys are getting to the next level and having to help.

We do get a lot of cheap ones too though just because we reach too much and don't move our feet.

This is true too. I could see Cal maybe wanting to zone to avoid foul trouble at times
 

Ky_Bred_Cat

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2014
2,201
4,090
113
An elite rim protector would correct a lot of this and allow us to go from being reactionary to playing even more aggressive man-to-man. We don't have one of these on the roster but still have time to tighten up what we do and compete for a title.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chuckinden

Jazzycat

All-Conference
May 23, 2002
16,116
4,758
113
When your primary interior player only gets 2-4 shots/game, there is a problem. Why not run plays in the 'penetrate and dish' mode and break down that spread offense by positioning Gabriel and Bam close the basket while Briscoe, Monk or Fox drive in and set up the play. Put the other guards on the perimeter for the three ...
 
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
There are several factors in play, that probably will keep this team from getting a lot better on defense. The primary weapon used by opposing coaches is spread the court (everybody outside the 3 point line), use a middle ball screen involving Bam (usually 25-30 feet from basket), drive downhill and then our opponents either hope for a bucket, a rebound, a whistle or a kick out three. However Cal has several principles that he is unwilling to back down from, so that will probably be an issue all season.

1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.

2) Doesn't believe in drawing charges, more of a mano to mano philosophy as he hates floppers, but the best way to eliminate straight line drives is sliding over and picking up charges.

3) Absolutely doesn't want any corner threes, any man that leaves to help on the drive, will get jerked out of game if corner three is hit by his man. That's why there is little team defense help on drives.

I think the best we can hope for is an adjustment yet keeping Cal's principles in play.

1) No Need for Bam to challenge a ball screen 25 feet from basket. Hedge, recover and stay back in the paint as much as possible.

2) No more switching, fight over the screen, using hedge and recover.

3) Allow weakside defenders to get in position to pick up charges, others can rotate to corner to defend threes

4) Become connected as five with a sagging man to man defense, make them play over your instead of around you.
You don't identify, far as I can tell, any shortcomings particular to this team - what you cite as problems all have to do with Cal's philosophy. If his philosophy is the problem, you'll have to explain why he routinely has top rated defenses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mjj_2K
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
Exactly.

I mean this thread is talking about "fixing" a defense that's ranked 14th in adjusted defensive efficiency.

If UCLA can be a contender with a defense ranked 109th, I think 14th will do just fine.
I agree with this sentiment, and in fact this sounds like something I'd say. But.......I don't know whether to trust Kenpom, or my own lying eyes - because when I watch this team play defense, they don't look like a top flight defense to me. As others have said, Cal's teams on the defensive end are usually anchored by a rim protector, if not several, and this team doesn't really have that. It's inverted from his usual form - the strength of this D, in theory, should be suffocating perimeter defense. But I don't see it. IB is good. But the trend-setter should be Fox, he should be a nightmare for opposing guards, and he simply isn't. Least not consistently. He stands up too easily and lets others go around him too easily.

Can this all be "fixed" in the next 8 weeks? Not sure. And as you say, maybe there's nothing to fix - perhaps, if I'm right and they aren't really the 14th best defense, what are they? If they are a top 30, even, defense, given our offense, maybe that's enough?
 
Last edited:

Soupbean

All-American
Jan 19, 2007
5,945
8,109
0
You don't identify, far as I can tell, any shortcomings particular to this team - what you cite as problems all have to do with Cal's philosophy. If his philosophy is the problem, you'll have to explain why he routinely has top rated defenses.
Not necessarily. His philosophy is fine and it has worked for the reasons discussed. But again every team is different and this team doesn't have a lot of the attributes that have made it work with other teams. I believe Cal thinks they will eventually get better as most young teams do at defense and they may. But another sign of a good coach is to adjust when needed and while Cal has certainly been great at that on the offensive side with all the different styles he has had to play with each new team, I think he needs to be the same way on the defensive side in case a certain team just isn't that good at his and might be better at another AT TIMES. Nothing wrong with adjusting, experimenting etc.

And again, if I'm going to try zone it would be a quasi man to man anyway with aggressive match up and trapping utilizing our long athletic guys.
 

bluedog79

All-American
Mar 4, 2008
6,015
5,290
0
Zone is the damn answer. Switching in and out of zone. If we did that the defense would improve.

The zone would throw teams off big time. They expect 100% man from UK.



Another day another wish for a zone strategy. As the world turns...
 

Dablueman

All-American
Feb 5, 2003
16,981
5,703
0
Something else to point out. With this teams margin of victory and in alot of our games we jumped all over teams early. We lost focus and were not zeroed in the whole game. That has skewed our defensive stats some as well.
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
I agree with this sentiment, and in fact this sounds like something I'd say. But.......I don't know whether to trust Kenpom, or my own lying eyes - because when I watch this team play team play defense, they don't look like a top flight defense to me. As others have said, Cal's teams on the defensive end are usually anchored by a rim protector, if not several, and this team doesn't really have that. It's inverted from his usual form - the strength of this D, in theory, should be suffocating perimeter defense. But I don't see it. IB is good. But the trend-setter should be Fox, he should be a nightmare for opposing guards, and he simply isn't. Least not consistently. He stands up too easily and lets others go around him too easily.

Can this all be "fixed" in the next 8 weeks? Not sure. And as you say, maybe there's nothing to fix - perhaps, if I'm right and they aren't really the 14th best defense, what are they? If they are a top 30, even, defense, given our offense, maybe that's enough?

I agree what your saying cause I feel the same way.

In some ways the 14th number is a bit misleading. I think you have to look deeper at the underlying reasons for that 14th number and that's when the numbers align with what everyone is seeing.

Teams are shooting 46.8% against this team on 2s. That's not horrible but it does rank 92nd. Compare that to Cal's normal teams in this stat. Every other year they have been 11th or better. So what people are seeing isn't an illusion. This team is giving up more on 2s than it ever has in the Cal era.

So how does that tie back into the 14th number? Welp teams only shoot 30.7% from 3 vs us. That's 25th best.

The alarming thing is......while 2 pt FG% correlates well game to game, 3pt FG% does not. Defenses have more control in how many 3s a team takes. They have less control over actual 3pt FG%. So going back to what I said about how our defense was always top 10 in 2pt FG% if you look at our 3pt FG defense, it's good but kinda all over the map.

This is why to have a truely elite defense, that 2pt figure is going to have to improve. Either that or our adjusted defensive efficiency won't be anywhere near 14 when it's all said and done.
 

docholiday51

Heisman
Oct 19, 2001
22,011
26,718
0
I agree with this sentiment, and in fact this sounds like something I'd say. But.......I don't know whether to trust Kenpom, or my own lying eyes - because when I watch this team play team play defense, they don't look like a top flight defense to me. As others have said, Cal's teams on the defensive end are usually anchored by a rim protector, if not several, and this team doesn't really have that. It's inverted from his usual form - the strength of this D, in theory, should be suffocating perimeter defense. But I don't see it. IB is good. But the trend-setter should be Fox, he should be a nightmare for opposing guards, and he simply isn't. Least not consistently. He stands up too easily and lets others go around him too easily.

Can this all be "fixed" in the next 8 weeks? Not sure. And as you say, maybe there's nothing to fix - perhaps, if I'm right and they aren't really the 14th best defense, what are they? If they are a top 30, even, defense, given our offense, maybe that's enough?
The straight line drive off a screen from the top of the circle is the thing we can't defend very well.If a team has anyone that can do that they can hang with us. Vandy(of all teams) and Miss St did that and they are average teams at best.Can we "fix" that,I'm not sure we can unless Gabriel can step up in the area of protecting the rim from the off side.We have gotten a lot of mileage out of this team even though they struggle with the straight line drive.I am sure Cal is trying to patch that up as best he can but Fox and Monk both have problems in this area.
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,883
4,413
113
Actually i think OP brings up several good discussion points and I agree with most of his assertions. The one and done model without an elite rim protector(s) makes it really difficult to game plan defensively, be it switching defenses, scouting opponents, etc. it's asking too much for freshmen to comprehend. I think Cal wants his guys to give more space to drivers based on his recent comments, personally I think trapping their guards in pick and roll would screw up a lot of teams as non ball handlers would be forced to make decisions, Good news is if they figure this straight line drive defense out, number 9 is going in the rafters
 

CatsRWild

All-Conference
Feb 27, 2010
4,017
1,482
0
Cal's great, but like many a "man to man" coach and just not going to do a zone...we would be deadly in a trapping 1-3-1 and yes it might help against teams that cant shoot but we cant seem to stop straight line dives...not going to happen....so with that said...

...the real answer is why don't we press/trap all the time after makes?

We have the length/speed and depth to be a very good pressing team. We are too content to let them walk it up, start their offense and play follow the leader.

Pressure causes turnovers by making someone else handle the ball for them, like at the end of the half last game... it also speeds them up even if they break it and score a few times ...now their playing our pace...and even if they don't turn it over they just took 10-12 seconds to get in the half court to start their offense and will have to rush to get a good shot against the clock.
 

Blue Decade

All-American
May 3, 2013
10,266
6,034
0
There is a time and place for a zone and it should never be used as your primary defense. I will always be an advocate of having multiple defenses in your defensive arsenal. IMO it makes absolutely no sense why a coach would want to make their team one dimensional so opposing coaches know exactly what we are going to do and can comprise a game plan around that with little fear that we will vary from it even if being gashed. As great as we are, and we are great, if cal would adopt this philosophy it would make us better and harder for opposing coaches/teams to prepare. This really comes into play more so during March madness....
I think Calipari uses almost exclusively man to man for 2 reasons. He sells his players on getting ready for the NBA. And because he plays so many freshmen, he tries not to make things complicated. So it's dribble drive, pick and roll, man to man. I will say this for Calipari. He is a much shrewder defensive coach than the OP is suggesting. However, I agree that being able to mix defenses to change the look and force opponents to adjust is the best approach. If your team is mature enough to do it well.
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,883
4,413
113
I do agree Cal has to keep it simple and that limits the defensive looks, but a trap, occasional press or zone would be nice change of pace
 

UKCAT5FAN

All-Conference
May 9, 2010
5,285
3,822
113
There is a time and place for a zone and it should never be used as your primary defense. I will always be an advocate of having multiple defenses in your defensive arsenal. IMO it makes absolutely no sense why a coach would want to make their team one dimensional so opposing coaches know exactly what we are going to do and can comprise a game plan around that with little fear that we will vary from it even if being gashed. As great as we are, and we are great, if cal would adopt this philosophy it would make us better and harder for opposing coaches/teams to prepare. This really comes into play more so during March madness....



This! As much as I hate Coach K, he is a master at using the zone. I wish Cal would use it when needed. It can be the difference in winning and losing alot of times. I don't think we would be compromising any philosophy with Cal if he would run a zone every now and then. It would not effect anything with anything. We need to be able to use multiple defenses at times whenever we need it.
 
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
I've seen a few references about Cal supposedly playing only man because he wants to get his kids ready for the NBA. If I'm not mistaken, he has always played man, almost exclusively, even at UMASS when there wasn't an NBA prospect in sight.

Perhaps he's clairvoyant and knew he'd one day have to play man at UK for draft reasons, and was just getting ready....
 
Oct 31, 2016
374
477
0
I don't expect any postseason defensive surprises, it's too risky...to try something without testing it first. If he is going to experiment, do it against some upcoming SEC teams and see how it plays....

I think foul trouble with Bam or Fox could be the biggest obstacle going forward.

I understand the number of possessions factors into UK's defense numbers, but the straight line drives yields not only points, but fouls which keeps UK out of transition.

Will be interesting to see how this plays out.
 

Johnfarrel

All-American
Oct 9, 2001
5,409
5,453
113
Bam does seem to spend more time out of the paint than in it on defense. May be to keep him out of foul trouble.
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,883
4,413
113
Foul trouble is a definite worry the way refs are calling these games, even more than 2pt FG% defense
 

lkc1021

All-Conference
Apr 12, 2007
6,985
1,650
0
There are several factors in play, that probably will keep this team from getting a lot better on defense. The primary weapon used by opposing coaches is spread the court (everybody outside the 3 point line), use a middle ball screen involving Bam (usually 25-30 feet from basket), drive downhill and then our opponents either hope for a bucket, a rebound, a whistle or a kick out three. However Cal has several principles that he is unwilling to back down from, so that will probably be an issue all season.

1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.

2) Doesn't believe in drawing charges, more of a mano to mano philosophy as he hates floppers, but the best way to eliminate straight line drives is sliding over and picking up charges.

3) Absolutely doesn't want any corner threes, any man that leaves to help on the drive, will get jerked out of game if corner three is hit by his man. That's why there is little team defense help on drives.

I think the best we can hope for is an adjustment yet keeping Cal's principles in play.

1) No Need for Bam to challenge a ball screen 25 feet from basket. Hedge, recover and stay back in the paint as much as possible.

2) No more switching, fight over the screen, using hedge and recover.

3) Allow weakside defenders to get in position to pick up charges, others can rotate to corner to defend threes

4) Become connected as five with a sagging man to man defense, make them play over your instead of around you.

You are an expert. Please talk to Cal and get this defense corrected.
 
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
Not sure there is a lot of interest in playing defense for more than a few seconds. The team mentality seems to be focused on running out to the other end ASAP. We get a lot of run outs and easy baskets but I think we're giving up something in return. A half court game on both ends does not play to our strengths. Whether fixable or not, it's clear that this is not, and will not be, one of Cal's best defensive teams as was originally alleged.

You will never have a great defensive team without at least one player who can consistently turn his man. I don't see such a defender on this team. It is what is.
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,883
4,413
113
Amen to this thread and I truly believe the defense can't be fixed ultimately the fatal flaw for this team
 

BourbonBalz

All-American
Mar 5, 2005
11,430
9,235
0
Let me point out that I think our defense is fine as is but it could get better and should over the course of the season, but it's not a weakness. I like and agree with what Aike said above.
So, you've missed most of our games this year, huh?
 

Brooklyn to BBN

Redshirt
Mar 15, 2013
59
23
0
freshmen mistakes and low IQ. There are a bunch of times when guys are in position and then mentally break down. Have to stay solid.
 
Oct 31, 2016
374
477
0
Cats take very little pride keeping the other team from scoring. All their focus and energy is on the offensive end. You can't win playing this way. Cal knows it, but he has little idea how to change it.

If I hear one more time, we have a young team, well, coach, this is the path you have chosen, so save that please.
 

RoyKent

Heisman
Feb 3, 2015
23,111
33,629
66
The defense (or lack of) halfway through the season is quite disturbing. All they do is foul (regardless of the officiating, it's a problem).

It's the exact reason this time is prime for a first weekend upset. No defense + a shooting night like last night = loss to a 8, 9, 10, 11 seed.
 

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
There are several factors in play, that probably will keep this team from getting a lot better on defense. The primary weapon used by opposing coaches is spread the court (everybody outside the 3 point line), use a middle ball screen involving Bam (usually 25-30 feet from basket), drive downhill and then our opponents either hope for a bucket, a rebound, a whistle or a kick out three. However Cal has several principles that he is unwilling to back down from, so that will probably be an issue all season.

1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.

2) Doesn't believe in drawing charges, more of a mano to mano philosophy as he hates floppers, but the best way to eliminate straight line drives is sliding over and picking up charges.

3) Absolutely doesn't want any corner threes, any man that leaves to help on the drive, will get jerked out of game if corner three is hit by his man. That's why there is little team defense help on drives.

I think the best we can hope for is an adjustment yet keeping Cal's principles in play.

1) No Need for Bam to challenge a ball screen 25 feet from basket. Hedge, recover and stay back in the paint as much as possible.

2) No more switching, fight over the screen, using hedge and recover.

3) Allow weakside defenders to get in position to pick up charges, others can rotate to corner to defend threes

4) Become connected as five with a sagging man to man defense, make them play over your instead of around you.


Add # 4 to the first list -- deciding to double team a bunch of undersized turds in the post last night ? Seriously , can anyone describe or even offer theory why in the hell we would ever consider helping , meaning leaving your man , to go double some turd who couldnt score anyway ? Why would that ever .. EVER be in a game plan vs a team with very very little post presence ?
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,883
4,413
113
The worst ball containment I have seen under Cal and watching the defensive film ought to make Him puke

Problem is Fox Monk Briscoe are playing a combined 100 minutes come hell or high water they know Cal won't bench them for lack of defense

Matador D to a T
 

Icecoldbrewdoggy

All-Conference
Nov 14, 2015
3,258
2,952
0
its odd to me that there are soooo many posters here who seem hell bent on convincing everyone really arent very good.

Sad, isn't it? And it's like they want to be right and us play poorly. We have a sad sack group out there that just hates their life and is neurotic. They can't just shut up and find something else to do but ***** and whine about what SHOULD amount to entertainment. Entertainment for pete's sake.
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,883
4,413
113
Isn't This Is a message board to express opinions and maybe share basketball knowledge

Nobody wants the Cats to lose to be proven right cmon now
 

Ukbrassowtipin

Heisman
Aug 12, 2011
82,421
90,537
113
There are several factors in play, that probably will keep this team from getting a lot better on defense. The primary weapon used by opposing coaches is spread the court (everybody outside the 3 point line), use a middle ball screen involving Bam (usually 25-30 feet from basket), drive downhill and then our opponents either hope for a bucket, a rebound, a whistle or a kick out three. However Cal has several principles that he is unwilling to back down from, so that will probably be an issue all season.

1) Zone defense-That would solve a lot of problems, but this wont happen, Cal prepares these guys for NBA, thus 100% man to man is only D he believes in, also he hates to give up threes which even good zones invariably give up.

2) Doesn't believe in drawing charges, more of a mano to mano philosophy as he hates floppers, but the best way to eliminate straight line drives is sliding over and picking up charges.

3) Absolutely doesn't want any corner threes, any man that leaves to help on the drive, will get jerked out of game if corner three is hit by his man. That's why there is little team defense help on drives.

I think the best we can hope for is an adjustment yet keeping Cal's principles in play.

1) No Need for Bam to challenge a ball screen 25 feet from basket. Hedge, recover and stay back in the paint as much as possible.

2) No more switching, fight over the screen, using hedge and recover.

3) Allow weakside defenders to get in position to pick up charges, others can rotate to corner to defend threes

4) Become connected as five with a sagging man to man defense, make them play over your instead of around you.
Zone defense sucks...there's a reason it's not played at the highest level. You play zone when your not athletic enough or tall enough to defend your opponent. Zone also hurts rebounding bc your not always between man and basket. Our help defense is what needs improvement especially at the 4 spot. If zone is so awesome why don't more teams run it all the time...If you rotate correctly, limit second chances, rebound with both hands/put a body on people..it makes a difference...that's usually why Willis and Gabriel get pulled

Also on defense, the man guarding the corner IS NOT supposed to step in and gaurd the drive. It's not fundamental to do so.

I agree with the hedge and recover and no switching.
 
Last edited:
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein Show Recap: Who's Improved the Most for Kentucky?
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kam Williams is showing rust, but Mark Pope is confident he'll 'get his vibe back'
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein knows Missouri is better than its recent losses suggest