Official '26 PSU - Rutgers game thread

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
Easy. If you were a talented player, why would you want to come here? Outplayed. Out coached. Consistently a terrible second-half team. Coach has no answer for it. And I’m a CMC fan. But he’s not it. Let’s just be honest at this point.
I want to play here because I'll have a chance to play early
I also understand that this was a team thrown together late and was without their top 5 offensive weapons by the end of the game
Yes, that's be honest please. Recruits have never cared about the outcome like fans do. Never
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
Yet we kept running the ball between the tackles instead of throwing to our best playmakers (Sowell, Rapp) or even Robinson or Jackson.
Rapp and Sowell also got injured--you know that, right?
At best they weren't 100%
And Brahmer has to make that catch
 

stater02

Senior
Dec 28, 2007
305
528
93
I want to play here because I'll have a chance to play early
I also understand that this was a team thrown together late and was without their top 5 offensive weapons by the end of the game
Yes, that's be honest please. Recruits have never cared about the outcome like fans do. Never
I agree with some of your points. But players want to play for a winner. I think we can both agree that, at best, the jury is out on CMC. I was a defender. No longer.
 
Dec 14, 2021
574
824
93
Easy. If you were a talented player, why would you want to come here? Outplayed. Out coached. Consistently a terrible second-half team. Coach has no answer for it. And I’m a CMC fan. But he’s not it. Let’s just be honest at this point.
Talented players think differently. They think that they're the one who can make a difference, turn it around. Also, NIL may be a bigger factor than an upset loss here and there
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
lol I've never said anyt

other than this team is mediocre--which remains true

lol I've never said anything other than this team is mediocre--which remains true
You were making fun of people who couldn’t see that this team would be 8-4, and predicted less that that in the prediction thread when they were 3-3( I predicted 6-6, which still could happen) I think your words were your 4 year old grandson saw the talent in the team after losing to Michigan. The only thing worse than being an ***, is not owning it!
lol I've never said anything other than this team is mediocre--which remains true
 
  • Like
Reactions: m.knox

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
I agree with some of your points. But players want to play for a winner. I think we can both agree that, at best, the jury is out on CMC. I was a defender. No longer.
And if they believe MC will win they'll come here--that's his job to sell them while we're struggling. Just like every other team.
I have concerns with him as well--he's going to be here through 2027 so we have no choice but to support him and hope for the best.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
The competitive comment was regarding the future--it wasn't excusing the lost but you can't grasp that
No, if we won 24-23 I would have said we survived. I don't believe I've ever said this team knows how to win
I'm very critical of lot of what MC is doing--not sure why you're so confused--actually, you lack common sense and knowledge about the sport so I do know
No , you said it was not a bad loss, and Rocco wasn’t bad against a good team. Haven’t seen much criticism of HCMC until today, when he can’t be defended
 
  • Like
Reactions: m.knox

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
You were making fun of people who couldn’t see that this team would be 8-4, and predicted less that that in the prediction thread when they were 3-3( I predicted 6-6, which still could happen) I think your words were your 4 year old grandson saw the talent in the team after losing to Michigan. The only thing worse than being an ***, is not owning it!
I picked us to go 7-5 so I'm not sure what you're talking about
I even specifically stated without Howard it could we worse
I said my "my 2 year old grandkid knew better than you" Search is your friend
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
No , you said it was not a bad loss, and Rocco wasn’t bad against a good team. Haven’t seen much criticism of HCMC until today, when he can’t be defended
You have to learn to read
Here's the problem--now read read this before you cry--you refuse to take what is written--you alter everything because you lack the emotional intelligence to have a discussion.
I've criticized MC all year for the same things--you just ignore those because it doesn't fit your agenda
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
You mocked me for saying:

Rutgers had all the momentum
They got the ball to start the second half
PSU had a history of poor play in the second half

Perhaps that was my "feeling" but it was based in fact. It seemed pretty obvious to me.

Because there's an obligation to play--it's about developing and becoming better players and coaches
But winning and losing no longer has remotely the same relevance. If we were 9-1 coming into today I'd be livid. We were 6-4. It's a bad loss but in the grand scheme means nothing as you know.
That contradicts that we should be playing a different QB. Why would it matter to the Qb, if he’s benched for the future, and still getting paid, but your pov is no one would ever come in the portal again. Keep trying. Why would they care if no one else does
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
Because there's an obligation to play--it's about developing and becoming better players and coaches
But winning and losing no longer has remotely the same relevance. If we were 9-1 coming into today I'd be livid. We were 6-4. It's a bad loss but in the grand scheme means nothing as you know.
Why? Because it is Rutgers, or we lost a competitive game?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
That contradicts that we should be playing a different QB. Why would it matter to the Qb, if he’s benched for the future, and still getting paid, but your pov is no one would ever come in the portal again. Keep trying. Why would they care if no one else does
I've explained the QB thing to you countless times--let's try one more time
1--you don't play the younger QB because if he has any success it's tougher keep him
2--benching your veteran QB prevents you from getting a starter in the portal next
So, while MC has made a lot of mistakes other than not benching Rocco in the 2nd half of Michigan he's handled the QB situation well
Manske will return next year and we'll add a legit starter
 

lion4ever76

Sophomore
Mar 24, 2023
76
131
33
That's a valid argument but ti would have been a great hire
I'm still not convinced Chesney wanted to come here or that he's this elite coach you all claim--time will tell. I do like him though and hope he's successful.
No argument that the BYU guy could have been good, but I see no reason to chase something you can't have - especially that late in the game. Chesney was not my 1st, 2nd or 3rd choice either, but seemed to be the last viable candidate who was available. Was fine with punting till next year and just keep Terry to pursue a Grade A coach.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
That's a valid argument but ti would have been a great hire
I'm still not convinced Chesney wanted to come here or that he's this elite coach you all claim--time will tell. I do like him though and hope he's successful.
You jumped the shark( if you hadn’t already) with you don’t think Chesney wanted the PSU job
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
I didn't "mock" you. I said 65% wasn't logical. Your emotion dictated that--it "worked out" because of the Wallace injury. We lost too many people--did your "feeling" tell you that was happening
Also, Rutgers getting the ball to start the second half was absolutely meaningless even after we fumbled. We scored first in the second half.
I thought he mocked you !!’
 

WestSideLion

All-American
May 29, 2001
5,164
5,596
113
Maybe it's not all on the coaches?
These players just aren't very good.
Can only play the cards you have and sometimes you get dealt a bad hand.
So these players are good enough to build multi-score leads late in games, but they aren’t good enough to close out games? I don’t buy that. The coaches clam up and choke,
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nittering Nabob

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
No argument that the BYU guy could have been good, but I see no reason to chase something you can't have - especially that late in the game. Chesney was not my 1st, 2nd or 3rd choice either, but seemed to be the last viable candidate who was available. Was fine with punting till next year and just keep Terry to pursue a Grade A coach.
You had me until you wanted to keep Terry--that would have been 10x worse
Considering how early we fired Franklin and still messed it up I don't think another year fixes that
Then with Terry you lose 2 classes instead of one because there's no way he was getting more than a year--might lose 3 classes.
 

psu31trap

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2021
1,358
1,277
113
The defense played very hard, it was the D-coordinator who screwed up in my opinion. He ran the same three blitz packages the entire game. The Rutgers O-coordinator may be a slow learner but late in the 3rd quarter he figured it out. One more thing, you can’t put all the blame on the defense, the QB on his last two drives throws into double and triple coverage with two receivers in single coverage.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
So these players are good enough to build multi-score leads late in games, but they aren’t good enough to close out games? I don’t buy that. The coaches clam up and choke,
I think it's both. Once Wallace, Rapp and Sowell all got hurt did you really think we had many options offensively. Brahmer doesn't drop that ball we win--it's little things like that for a team that lack talent.
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,178
4,633
113
It's not the X's and O's it's the Jimmy and Joe's and PSU talent level is at rock bottom.

Reminder: Sadly, some of the same players are coming back for the 2027 season.

This program is doomed for the next 3 years minimum. It’s the least talented Penn State roster I have ever seen. Th team is slow, non-athletic, and in desperate need of more speed and difference makers.

Kraft will not survive this debacle.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
I've explained the QB thing to you countless times--let's try one more time
1--you don't play the younger QB because if he has any success it's tougher keep him
2--benching your veteran QB prevents you from getting a starter in the portal next
So, while MC has made a lot of mistakes other than not benching Rocco in the 2nd half of Michigan he's handled the QB situation well
Manske will return next year and we'll add a legit starter
Just because you keep saying it, doesn’t make it accurate, especially if the games don’t matter. I don’t think seeing a bad qb getting benched preventing you from getting a portal qb
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
You had me until you wanted to keep Terry--that would have been 10x worse
Considering how early we fired Franklin and still messed it up I don't think another year fixes that
Then with Terry you lose 2 classes instead of one because there's no way he was getting more than a year--might lose 3 classes.
What’s 10 times worse than losing to Rutgers?
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Watch: Matt Campbell recaps Penn State's 25-24 loss to Rutgers
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State-Rutgers takeaways: Lions slop and struggle their way to an inexplicable 25-24 loss they earned
  3. 03 BWI Football Highs & Lows: Penn State collapses late against Rutgers on Senior Day
  4. 04 BWI Football Recap: Penn State blows 16-point lead, loses to Rutgers on final play
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Brock Riker, James Peoples, Brett Eskildsen all exit in the first half against Rutgers