Official '26 PSU - Rutgers game thread

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
How is this guy Campbell our coach? He has no idea what he is doing out there. Loses to Rutgers!!
I'll tell you once again why Campbell is here - because we have a moron for an AD. Kraft whiffed on every good coach and then he panics and settles on this clown. As I said all year, he should have kept Smith on a short-term contract until he was able to get a real elite coach. Now we're saddled with a B grade guy on an 8-year contract being paid twice his market value. He passed on Bob Cheney because he wanted to hire away a Mormon from BYU? Can someone actually be that stupid and incompetent?
Hiring the Mormon from BYU probably would have been the best hire if it worked
Cheaney with a real bad loss today--they'll be free falling in the rankings tomorrow
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
883
944
93
Once you're eliminated from the playoff losses don't matter
We played poorly and it's a bad loss but what difference does it make if we win or lose? Answer the question with something that isn't pride
Your right, it doesn’t matter, but we have sucked all year and RB threw away the Wisconsin and Michigan games and said it was ok because we were competitive against bad teams. This team sucked them when they had something to play for, and they suck now. And I’f PSU won 24-23, you’d still be saying this team knows how to win.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,469
6,206
113
Once you're eliminated from the playoff losses don't matter
We played poorly and it's a bad loss but what difference does it make if we win or lose? Answer the question with something that isn't pride
Then why even play? Just sit out the rest of the season after loss number 3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GSPVik and m.knox
Dec 14, 2021
574
824
93
Random Stream of Consciousness Thoughts
Officiating was awful, but it shouldn't have come down to that. Continually trying to run into an 8-man box. Not taking advantage of Sowell and Robinson. Brahmer not dependable on 3rd down. 3 tight end offense makes no sense. Certainly hasn't made the run game better. No play action. No misdirection. Disappearance of the mid-range passing game.

Defensively, fell back into allowing too many 3rd and 4th down and long conversions. 4th & 11 and taking 15-yard drops? Did Zion Tracy play? Did Cam Smith? Some ugly missed tackles. Zayas can be great, but shows too much immaturity. Gave up on the last play. How does McPherson get matched up with the running back on the 2-point conversion? So many times, one play from sealing the victory. Didn't make any of them. Easy to see how important Carson Hanson is to the offense.

Every year there seems to be that unexplainable Saturday, looks like today is that day for 2026.
 

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
10,519
18,110
113
The pattern this year when teams lose games they should not lose...either the OC gets relieved of duties or the DC does.

Who does Matty terminate?
 

lion4ever76

Sophomore
Mar 24, 2023
76
131
33
Hiring the Mormon from BYU probably would have been the best hire if it worked
Cheaney with a real bad loss today--they'll be free falling in the rankings tomorrow
It was never going to happen. No Mormon is leaving BYU to come here. Clown Kraft got played so the guy could get a better deal at BYU. No one else was wasting time and losing viable candidates (Chesney) chasing him. You always had Terry. Sometimes you have to regroup and play the long game.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,469
6,206
113
In a scrimmage with opt outs. RB4 is perfect in that game
And, no, Clemson is awful especially with the opt out--Rutgers could have beat that make shift team
No, they couldn’t. And you say in one post that this game didn’t matter, then you downplay the bowl game because it didn’t matter. And then there’s parity, but the SEC and the Big are so much better than everyone else. You can’t even keep your arguments straight.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
Your right, it doesn’t matter, but we have sucked all year and RB threw away the Wisconsin and Michigan games and said it was ok because we were competitive against bad teams. This team sucked them when they had something to play for, and they suck now. And I’f PSU won 24-23, you’d still be saying this team knows how to win.
The competitive comment was regarding the future--it wasn't excusing the lost but you can't grasp that
No, if we won 24-23 I would have said we survived. I don't believe I've ever said this team knows how to win
I'm very critical of lot of what MC is doing--not sure why you're so confused--actually, you lack common sense and knowledge about the sport so I do know
 

psuno1

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
1,151
1,443
113
I got news for you The Terps will beat PSU next week as well. 6-6 going bowling what a feeling. Campbell is in way over his head. getting out coached really bad- going to be a long three year till he get's fired.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WestSideLion

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,765
5,579
113
Correct--the math never supported that--that was "feeling"--you get there's a difference?
You mocked me for saying:

Rutgers had all the momentum
They got the ball to start the second half
PSU had a history of poor play in the second half

Perhaps that was my "feeling" but it was based in fact. It seemed pretty obvious to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: m.knox

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
Then why even play? Just sit out the rest of the season after loss number 3.
Because there's an obligation to play--it's about developing and becoming better players and coaches
But winning and losing no longer has remotely the same relevance. If we were 9-1 coming into today I'd be livid. We were 6-4. It's a bad loss but in the grand scheme means nothing as you know.
 

KC-KS-Lion

Freshman
Oct 10, 2005
1,947
69
48
Hiring the Mormon from BYU probably would have been the best hire if it worked
Cheaney with a real bad loss today--they'll be free falling in the rankings tomorrow
It's a down year for the B1G conference, and college football in general...too much movement of coaches and players limits internal competition and depth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingLando

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
Because they recruit against us, and couldn’t say they beat us since 1988. How do you not get that
LOL--yes, now Rutgers is magically going to steal our recruits
No one has ever recruited a player to Penn State by saying Rutgers hasn't beat us in 1988
Losses like this don't hurt recruiting--kids see an oppportunity to play--all they care about is the bond with the coach and the cash
 

Bubbasubs

Redshirt
Nov 21, 2026
6
3
0
The lack of a pass rush was glaring. That kid was a statue who literally couldn't move with broken ribs and he had 6-8 seconds on nearly every pass
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,765
5,579
113
Empty stadium. Only going to get worse. Fire the staff. New AD. Bring in Chesney no matter the cost or you’re never going to pay off these renovations.
I thought the crowd looked pretty good considering there were no students and PSU was 3-4 in BiG play.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
Are you even a Penn State fan?
Are you?
You seem to care more about Rutgers?
How often are you commenting about Women's Volleyball or other Penn State sports?
Most people here aren't Penn State fans or football fans--they only care about Penn State football
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,469
6,206
113
Because there's an obligation to play--it's about developing and becoming better players and coaches
But winning and losing no longer has remotely the same relevance. If we were 9-1 coming into today I'd be livid. We were 6-4. It's a bad loss but in the grand scheme means nothing as you know.
That’s the dumbest rationale I’ve ever heard.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
It was never going to happen. No Mormon is leaving BYU to come here. Clown Kraft got played so the guy could get a better deal at BYU. No one else was wasting time and losing viable candidates (Chesney) chasing him. You always had Terry. Sometimes you have to regroup and play the long game.
That's a valid argument but ti would have been a great hire
I'm still not convinced Chesney wanted to come here or that he's this elite coach you all claim--time will tell. I do like him though and hope he's successful.
 

stater02

Senior
Dec 28, 2007
305
528
93
Once you're eliminated from the playoff losses don't matter
We played poorly and it's a bad loss but what difference does it make if we win or lose? Answer the question with something that isn't pride
Easy. If you were a talented player, why would you want to come here? Outplayed. Out coached. Consistently a terrible second-half team. Coach has no answer for it. And I’m a CMC fan. But he’s not it. Let’s just be honest at this point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: trufan

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
You mocked me for saying:

Rutgers had all the momentum
They got the ball to start the second half
PSU had a history of poor play in the second half

Perhaps that was my "feeling" but it was based in fact. It seemed pretty obvious to me.
I didn't "mock" you. I said 65% wasn't logical. Your emotion dictated that--it "worked out" because of the Wallace injury. We lost too many people--did your "feeling" tell you that was happening
Also, Rutgers getting the ball to start the second half was absolutely meaningless even after we fumbled. We scored first in the second half.
 
Dec 14, 2021
574
824
93
I got news for you The Terps will beat PSU next week as well. 6-6 going bowling what a feeling.
Need to prepare as if every opponent can. Not sure that was the case this past week. I have no inside sources, just seem under-prepared and with a lack of fire and emotion. I don't mind some swag, but I get tired of every incomplete pass being celebrated as if we just landed on the moon. We had defenders celebrating thinking the 4th & 11 was short event though the receiver's forward progress was 2-3 yards past the sticks.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,425
4,854
113
That’s the dumbest rationale I’ve ever heard.
How? What part of that is untrue?
You don't have to like it but it's factual
Have you ever played a sport? I've been on great teams and bad teams. Bad teams know they're bad and they understand winning doesn't matter though you always want to win--what matters is improving because hopefully that will lead to being truly relevant in the future.
I don't understand how you don't comprehend that losing this game has zero impact on anything other than it gives fans a reason to *****
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Watch: Matt Campbell recaps Penn State's 25-24 loss to Rutgers
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State-Rutgers takeaways: Lions slop and struggle their way to an inexplicable 25-24 loss they earned
  3. 03 BWI Football Highs & Lows: Penn State collapses late against Rutgers on Senior Day
  4. 04 BWI Football Recap: Penn State blows 16-point lead, loses to Rutgers on final play
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Brock Riker, James Peoples, Brett Eskildsen all exit in the first half against Rutgers