Is it possible UMASS is just good?

Anon503350

Redshirt
Sep 3, 2026
32
44
18
Disagree. Their players aren’t better but were well prepared with schemes to exploit everything RU did.

Schiano doesn’t have a playbook or ability to adjust. No passes to RB, TE, no QB runs. HS offenses are more complex.
I have to agree with you with the complexity. Unbelievably predictable. That's why I cringe when people want Kirk as the interim coach. Please no.
 
  • Like
Reactions: B6510

Anon503350

Redshirt
Sep 3, 2026
32
44
18
Yes. UMass was very good. Obviously we got their A game, but will be very interesting to see how they finish up. They are grossly underrated this year
This is two years in a row where RU's defense just sits back and reacts (way too late). They don't have the athletes to do that. UMass D looked like Ru's old D. I think we know why.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUgal

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
8,813
4,933
66
I have to agree with you with the complexity. Unbelievably predictable. That's why I cringe when people want Kirk as the interim coach. Please no.
Coordinators call plays but the playbook is what the HCs allow. The limited playbook isn’t Kirk’s doing.
 

RUnTeX

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2001
7,143
4,298
113
People have short memories. Rutgers lost to MAC team Buffalo in 2018 by score 42-13. It was 35-6 Buffalo at halftime. Buffalo outgained RU 220-40 yards in the first half. Much worse than this game. The difference is that one was hidden on a week 2 saturday and this one was in front of literally the national CFB audience.
2017 against Eastern Michigan as well. EMU 16 - RU 13.

That game had a trivia note about it at the time, maybe it was EMU's first ever win against a B1G opponent in its history or something.

Ash struggled against the MAC.
 
Last edited:

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,879
3,369
66
Umass actually made some plays, in addition to opportunities given. It was by no means all give aways and blown coverages, they made things happen. If the qb stays healthy it will be interesting to see what they can do.
 

RUfan1977

All-Conference
Mar 24, 2024
1,090
1,569
113
Rutgers losing is more on Rutgers than UMass. Rutgers came in unprepared, overconfident and with an idiotic game plan running a vanilla offense following their tendencies against a talented defensive coach with an entire off season to prepare. UMass played well in all aspects of the game while Rutgers players missed tackles. Rutgers quarterback also seemed like he had the jitters, but it was probably unnerving that UMass knew what they intended to do on virtually every play because Joe Harasymiak actually did know.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,593
61,926
113
No Pop Watson.
They gave up 34 points to Akron. Akron was 1–9 going into the game. Their defense giving up 34 points to Akron has nothing to do with Pop Watson. Please stop making excuses for the worst loss Greg has ever coached.

UMass is currently number 153 in Sagarin and will likely drop 10 spots come Sunday once the rankings are updated.

BTW - Akron came into the game 130th nationally in scoring at 18.6 points per game.
 
Last edited:

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113
They gave up 34 points to Akron. Akron was 1–9 going into the game. Their defense giving up 34 points to Akron has nothing to do with Pop Watson. Please stop making excuses for the worst loss Greg has ever coached.

UMass is currently number 153 in Sagarin and will likely drop 10 spots come Sunday once the rankings are updated.
Will that help or hurt our strength of schedule?

Confused Jeff Bridges GIF
 

B6510

Freshman
Jun 29, 2026
94
86
3
It drives me crazy when people use comparative games and previous year schedules to determine what a team should or shouldn’t be. Even the worst teams can have an outstanding performance in one game and even the best team can have a terrible performance. By all rights, Rutgers should have beaten UMass. The X factors were that being u mass was entirely brand new. There was absolutely no film to study, which made it a little bit harder to know what they were gonna do. And on the other side, UMass knew everything about Rutgers. He knew exactly what Rutgers was gonna do and how to exploit it because Schiano and Coarocca have no creativity. They have no ability to adjust and try to force a game plan no matter what. Schiano will stick to his analytics and his preplanned decisions instead of feeling out what the game is doing.
UMass is not a good team, but they are much improved team that we still should’ve beaten, but they were hyped up. It was their first game and they knew all of RU weaknesses. They punched RU in the mouth and stunned them and Schiano had no answers. Stop with the comparisons of what they did or didn’t do the rest of the season because it’s irrelevant. schaino made all the same mistakes against better teams as well, so it’s not as though you Umass being good makes a difference. They were on their A game against Rutgers and Rutgers was on their D game. At the end of the day it’s Schaino who screwed up. If he would’ve prepared properly, this would’ve been a non-issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,593
61,926
113
It drives me crazy when people use comparative games and previous year schedules to determine what a team should or shouldn’t be. Even the worst teams can have an outstanding performance in one game and even the best team can have a terrible performance. By all rights, Rutgers should have beaten UMass. The X factors were that being u mass was entirely brand new. There was absolutely no film to study, which made it a little bit harder to know what they were gonna do. And on the other side, UMass knew everything about Rutgers. He knew exactly what Rutgers was gonna do and how to exploit it because Schiano and Coarocca have no creativity. They have no ability to adjust and try to force a game plan no matter what. Schiano will stick to his analytics and his preplanned decisions instead of feeling out what the game is doing.
UMass is not a good team, but they are much improved team that we still should’ve beaten, but they were hyped up. It was their first game and they knew all of RU weaknesses. They punched RU in the mouth and stunned them and Schiano had no answers. Stop with the comparisons of what they did or didn’t do the rest of the season because it’s irrelevant. schaino made all the same mistakes against better teams as well, so it’s not as though you Umass being good makes a difference. They were on their A game against Rutgers and Rutgers was on their D game. At the end of the day it’s Schaino who screwed up. If he would’ve prepared properly, this would’ve been a non-issue.
Even worse is when people use a myriad of excuses for a loss that never should’ve happened.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113
It drives me crazy when people use comparative games and previous year schedules to determine what a team should or shouldn’t be. Even the worst teams can have an outstanding performance in one game and even the best team can have a terrible performance. By all rights, Rutgers should have beaten UMass. The X factors were that being u mass was entirely brand new. There was absolutely no film to study, which made it a little bit harder to know what they were gonna do. And on the other side, UMass knew everything about Rutgers. He knew exactly what Rutgers was gonna do and how to exploit it because Schiano and Coarocca have no creativity. They have no ability to adjust and try to force a game plan no matter what. Schiano will stick to his analytics and his preplanned decisions instead of feeling out what the game is doing.

I certainly hope that Keli Zinn and Pres Tate recognize what you wrote in your first paragraph, and unless Greg and Kirk change things up, we are doomed next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUChet

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,477
13,091
113
They gave up 34 points to Akron. Akron was 1–9 going into the game. Their defense giving up 34 points to Akron has nothing to do with Pop Watson. Please stop making excuses for the worst loss Greg has ever coached.

UMass is currently number 153 in Sagarin and will likely drop 10 spots come Sunday once the rankings are updated.

BTW - Akron came into the game 130th nationally in scoring at 18.6 points per game.
It’s hard to believe there are any SchIano defenders left. Totally clueless and mentally challenged on anything football.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Samson1975!!!

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113
1795197011163.png1795197053326.png

FFS, UMass put up the same amount of points against Rutgers when they played Sacred Heart, and one point less against Stonehill. This is an indictment of Greg's pathetic defense.

The last 7 teams they have played have put up as many (OK 20 for Miami OH) or more points than Rutgers did against UMAss.
 

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
38,984
52,183
112
It drives me crazy when people use comparative games and previous year schedules to determine what a team should or shouldn’t be. Even the worst teams can have an outstanding performance in one game and even the best team can have a terrible performance. By all rights, Rutgers should have beaten UMass. The X factors were that being u mass was entirely brand new. There was absolutely no film to study, which made it a little bit harder to know what they were gonna do. And on the other side, UMass knew everything about Rutgers. He knew exactly what Rutgers was gonna do and how to exploit it because Schiano and Coarocca have no creativity. They have no ability to adjust and try to force a game plan no matter what. Schiano will stick to his analytics and his preplanned decisions instead of feeling out what the game is doing.
UMass is not a good team, but they are much improved team that we still should’ve beaten, but they were hyped up. It was their first game and they knew all of RU weaknesses. They punched RU in the mouth and stunned them and Schiano had no answers. Stop with the comparisons of what they did or didn’t do the rest of the season because it’s irrelevant. schaino made all the same mistakes against better teams as well, so it’s not as though you Umass being good makes a difference. They were on their A game against Rutgers and Rutgers was on their D game. At the end of the day it’s Schaino who screwed up. If he would’ve prepared properly, this would’ve been a non-issue.

Its an embarrassing loss so people will discuss it. Of course its on Schiano but its also on the players who were manhandled like school girls.
 

Colbert17!

Heisman
Aug 30, 2014
17,568
19,098
113
Please stop making excuses for the worst loss Greg has ever coached.

Where did I do that? I think GS has to go.
IMHO UMass would have won that game if he played.
 
Aug 11, 2025
988
796
93
UConn grad here. Never thought I'd watch this game, but UMass played very well. I was impressed. They've finally gotten around to proper roster construction. They won in the trenches. They also played to win. Rutgers was playing to not lose and underestimated how much better the roster is now. UMass fans consider this game their biggest win ever in football.
So beating ******, poorly coached big ten punching bag is their biggest win ever. What a proud moment for them
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference