Example of why 24 team playoff is too many

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
Cignetti is the best coach and Indiana could win it the way they are playing now. It's hilarious that you advocate for a 24 team playoff with part of your rationale being that these teams seeded 20 or 19 or 21 or 17 have a shot to win it all yet you make a definitive declaration that Indiana the way they are playing now "will get trounced". So that is saying Indiana has no shot as a top 10 team yet you think #20 does have a shot?

You really think Utah or Miami or ND or Georgia would trounce Indiana the way Indiana's offense is playing now (no improvement and no change)? So indiana versus Georgia in a neutral site will be Georgia favored by 21? That would be a trouncing. You really think that would happen? Again Utah could beat them but they are not getting trounced. Their D is elite and will not let them get trounced. Plus who do you think will outcoach who? Cignetti out coaching the Utah coach or vice versa? I'll hang up and listen to your answer.
He's not the best coach. That's an absurd claim as long as Kirby Smart is alive
You still are ignoring what was said to try to create an argument
Yes...if Indiana can't put up points they'll lose by 2 scores or more against those teams. You're pretending Cignetti is Saban. He's not...
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
Didn't answer anything You just want to watch more college football but the reality is no team seeded lower than 10 is ever winning but money rules everything. At least cut it off at 16. No way #17 through #24 have any shot. Louisville, Houston Florida have legitimate shots to beat Georgia or ND? A waste.
There's less football. The bowls will be dead
17 played for the title and lost in OT in FCS last year.
Auburn beat Georgia...anyone can beat anyone.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
But you said TV was disappearing:

"Viewership for everything is done--younger generations stream thing (hence games on Peacock)--and attendance is down for obvious reasons--same reason the Bills built a smaller stadium"

Were those not your words?

Still waiting on how more = better.
Viewership will decline...the money won't. The networks still are fighting for what exists. Peacock and others will be paying well.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
848
927
93
Viewership will decline...the money won't. The networks still are fighting for what exists. Peacock and others will be paying well.
So viewership and attendance will drop, but money will go up. Sounds like the expectation is everyone is paying more for what they get?!

that’s a sustainable equation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

AvgUser

All-Conference
Jul 12, 2016
1,585
2,170
113
Who cares that they lost 4 times? In what other sport is 4 losses unacceptable?
You all have this insane belief that the goal is to be 12-0 because it used to be--back when teams played 2 or 3 teams that had any talent a year.
Many care that four loss teams deserve to sit it out.

You don’t have to have a zero in the loss column. Having a 1 or at most 2 is good acceptable. After that you have flawed and undeserving teams being given a lifeline they should not be offered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,368
1,354
113
Many care that four loss teams deserve to sit it out.

You don’t have to have a zero in the loss column. Having a 1 or at most 2 is good acceptable. After that you have flawed and undeserving teams being given a lifeline they should not be offered.

Just absurd to base seeding on absolute # of loses when the teams are playing completely disparate schedules. The current 10th, 11th and 12th ranked teams in the latest AP Rankimg are perfect examples. They are all ranked where they are ranked because of their absolute W/L record. #10 Wake Forest is 9-1 (#2 in ACC), #11 TxTech is 9-1 (#2 B12) and #12 BYU is 8-2 (#3 B12). All of these bubble teams in the current 12-team format are only there because of this absurd obsession with seeding/ranking based on number of losses while ignoring why they only have 2 losses. Are you really trying to claim that any of these teams would only have 1 or 2 losses if they played in the B1G or SEC rather than the B12 or ACC??? Seriously??? You really believe that LSU couldn't beat any of the three in a 24-Team Format First Round Game (even in their home stadium) where LSU was the 21, 22 or 23-Seed and one of these teams was the 10 , 11 or 12-Seed???? You are seriously diluded if you really believe these things.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
Many care that four loss teams deserve to sit it out.

You don’t have to have a zero in the loss column. Having a 1 or at most 2 is good acceptable. After that you have flawed and undeserving teams being given a lifeline they should not be offered.
That's the most absurd thing I've ever heard. Teams improve as the year goes on--you're just not embracing change. Which is fine.
At the end of the day--you can hate it all you want but it's thankfully happening and anyone that watches college football (not just their team) is going to be thrilled.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,368
1,354
113
Do you understand basic economics?

You're wildly exaggerating the financial impact of an expanded playoff. Recent analysis predicts the financial impact to be $2mm per team per year on the high-side for B1G/SEC teams and half that for ACC/B12 teams (even less for remaining conferences). That's doodley-squat when you're paying your QB alone anywhere from 2x to 5x that amount (and player salaries are continuing to rise at astronomical rates).
 
May 11, 2016
473
280
63
There's no spin
You're simply ignoring what is for what you want to believe. I'm used to that here.
You do nothing but spin. You made conflicting statements then claim we don't understand the obvious.

Still waiting for you to prove more is better. You have yet to even make an effort. If it is sooo much better it should be easy for you to address.

You like to deflect and project. Claiming people are wanting only 12-0 when they obviously aren't, that they are in favor of the old bowl system when they are not.

But that is your m.o.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AvgUser

AvgUser

All-Conference
Jul 12, 2016
1,585
2,170
113
That's the most absurd thing I've ever heard. Teams improve as the year goes on--you're just not embracing change. Which is fine.
At the end of the day--you can hate it all you want but it's thankfully happening and anyone that watches college football (not just their team) is going to be thrilled.
Facts matter. Whether you improved or not is immaterial. You lost four games. Abe you should have played better earlier. Take a seat. You don’t deserve a chance.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,368
1,354
113
You do nothing but spin. You made conflicting statements then claim we don't understand the obvious.

Still waiting for you to prove more is better. You have yet to even make an effort. If it is sooo much better it should be easy for you to address.

You like to deflect and project. Claiming people are wanting only 12-0 when they obviously aren't, that they are in favor of the old bowl system when they are not.

But that is your m.o.

More is definitely "fairer", so if you consider a format that is fairer for all teams involved "better", than more is better. But better is a subjective, not an objective, word at the end of the day.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
He's not the best coach. That's an absurd claim as long as Kirby Smart is alive
You still are ignoring what was said to try to create an argument
Yes...if Indiana can't put up points they'll lose by 2 scores or more against those teams. You're pretending Cignetti is Saban. He's not...
Cignetti>Smart. Never going to convince me otherwise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NoBareFeet

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
You do nothing but spin. You made conflicting statements then claim we don't understand the obvious.

Still waiting for you to prove more is better. You have yet to even make an effort. If it is sooo much better it should be easy for you to address.

You like to deflect and project. Claiming people are wanting only 12-0 when they obviously aren't, that they are in favor of the old bowl system when they are not.

But that is your m.o.
Remember he’s the only one on here that watches college football, so he knows more than anyone else.
 
May 11, 2016
473
280
63
Remember he’s the only one on here that watches college football, so he knows more than anyone else.
He did say:

"At the end of the day--you can hate it all you want but it's thankfully happening and anyone that watches college football (not just their team) is going to be thrilled."

That is one hell of a mind reading future predicting feat. He is wasting his time on a message board.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,368
1,354
113
He did say:

"At the end of the day--you can hate it all you want but it's thankfully happening and anyone that watches college football (not just their team) is going to be thrilled."

That is one hell of a mind reading future predicting feat. He is wasting his time on a message board.

He is the king of the "Argumentum ad populum" debating logic fallacy.
 

NoBareFeet

Senior
Oct 25, 2021
426
691
93
At the end of the day--you can hate it all you want but it's thankfully happening and anyone that watches college football (not just their team) is going to be thrilled.
I watch college football, and not just Penn State. Especially the bowls, which are the best games of the year!

I think the 24 team playoff blows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knickslions69

Connorpozlee

All-American
Aug 29, 2013
3,500
6,910
113
I really have no interest in a 24 team playoff f Penn State isn’t involved. Honestly, I won’t have much interest in this year’s playoffs without Penn State involved.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fac

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
543
929
93
I enjoy watching the bowls/playoffs even if PSU isn't playing. I can root against teams/coaches I can't stand and for underdogs in games I don't care about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
848
927
93
I enjoy watching the bowls/playoffs even if PSU isn't playing. I can root against teams/coaches I can't stand and for underdogs in games I don't care about.
Maybe it’s just me, but with all the player movement, and less players being identified with their school, I get less enjoyment rooting against schools.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
Facts matter. Whether you improved or not is immaterial. You lost four games. Abe you should have played better earlier. Take a seat. You don’t deserve a chance.
It's not immaterial--your opinion is that you don't deserve a change and those that matter disagree with you--thankfully since it's an absurd opinion
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
please explain how less people watching generates more money without the price going up. Not to mention paying players more.
Is this real life? The less people that watch TV in general the more important the segment is that is watching--see the TV contract which proves that.
 

Catch1lion

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,535
7,624
113
Gotta get all those sec teams in .Latest CFP- 1. UGA, 2. Utes, 3. Bama 4. ucla , 5. Tx , ahead of one loss ND and UM and 8. Indy
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
848
927
93
6-4 LSU would still be in the conversation, and probably in if they beat Tennessee.
May be beating a dead horse, but just saw the discussion on the CFP show about Florida at 6-4 being in next year. I know some disagree, but I don’t see how a team that loses 4 of 5 to #3, #25 and two unranked teams making the playoff, doing anything but killing interest in college football until November. Yes , Florida fans would probably be excited for their last two games, but I don’t see nearly the interest in early season matchups. Hell, even the whiteout would have mattered less, as it makes less of a difference. Heck, and we might see teams resting starters. If Indiana loses to Washington, does ucla rest their starters against usc? We’ve seen pros do it in rivalry games. May work but not what I’ve enjoyed.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'
  2. 02 BWI Football Matt Campbell on Penn State's turnaround, Senior Day and two key return announcements
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Three 2028 Rivals300 prospects confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  4. 04 BWI Football Ben Brahmer and Kooper Ebel returning to Penn State will help 'start to accelerate a little bit of that planning' for the 2027 season
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Did Carson Hansen practice on Wednesday? Latest on Caleb Bacon, Jahmir Joseph