I'm not saying one is worse or better than any other. I'm just pointing out that disinformation is not new in politics. I have suggested that folks watch the NETFLIX documentary "Vietnam: the turning point". You'll see that leader of both parties decived the American people from beginning to end. And this deception has been ongoing ever since...
You're talking degrees of deception and that MAGA is worse ever. I haven't disagreed with that, my only point is that folks on here who constantly hammer trump about his "lies" seem to overlook the "lies that have come from leaders of both parties since at least the 60's. I'd ever wager (figuratively) that when democrats take control of Congress we'll see a large amount of deception concerning the reduction in fuel prices, grocery bills and all the other things they've complained about for the last two years. It's the system...
In fact I'll go out on a limb and say that when deficits increase during the next two years, in spite of all the posturing by democrats over the debt by democrats since January 2025, when the deficits contine over the next two years it will all be "Trump's fault".
I have been on the board for a year and a half, and you might not have seen it but if you think it's only MAGA folks that have set out propaganda, I'd tend to disagree with you. There are folks on here who are so far left (not extreme left, just left in their thinking) that no matter what trump or folks in his administration do, it's wrong...same goes for some MAga folks only they'll support trump even when he clearly in the wrong. People have their convictions, but most rational people can see that nobody is right, or for that matter, wrong all the time. That's why I point out now, for example, that all the clamoring about trump increasing the deficits and debt will go away when the democrats take control of at least one chamber of Congress. But debt education not going to happen in any significant way. When was the last time democrats wanted to reduce or cancel a social program? And they won't have the votes to raise taxes. So they can say what the want to say, but it's not real. Now if it were republicans saying it, lots on here will say "lies", just like they do now about trump. But, as I said, democrats will say then, "Trump's fault", and you know what, they'll be right. But my point is, they know now there's nothing substantive they're going to be able to do without trump but they certainly aren't going to tell the American people that before the election. deception?? I guess in the eyes of the beholder. The game is to get power and members of both parties will say whatever they think will get them that power.
I read every word of this, and considered going line by line to rebut or dialogue with each of your points. However, I'd rather not because it's almost like you didn't read my post. You agree with and repeat much of what I said, whilst painting what I wrote as diametrically opposed to what you're saying. I think the most egregious is when you said "but if you think it's only MAGA folks that have set out propaganda, I'd tend to disagree with you."
I wrote "Propaganda and misinformation have been bastions of politics for centuries in America, we all know this." I understand you missed the implication that I was saying the dems do it as much as pubs and always have. In fact, my entire premise was that politics and those seeking power will do anything to build their narrative and manipulate people to vote for them through propaganda to achieve power. I realize I didn't spell it out directly for you, but critical thinking was assumed. My apologies.
I do think our difference is here: From observing your beliefs over the past few years, it seems you take the idea "there is nothing new under the sun" as a core principal for how you see the world. And you're 100% right.
Where you miss, is that "nothing new under the sun" applies to things happening broadly, not the
degree to which those things that happen. Politicians always lie, people always murder, humans always seek power, etc. etc, but there are eras in history where politicians lie more, people murder more, and humans seek more power at all costs in vastly heightened degrees.
You talk about that Vietnam doc all the time; I understand this was another one of those pressure points where lies, misinformation, propaganda, etc. abounded and set the scene for where we are today. However, my entire point was that the way in which maga has utilized propaganda in the modern age is revolutionary, prolific, and unlike we've ever seen before
in the degree that they are able to rally their coalition, get their message out, and manipulate minds.
We are at a unique time (different but perhaps similarly unique pressure point-wise like the time before and after Vietnam) where people are hyper connected to one another and the internet; this has not led to uniformity of thought, but rather silos of thought that people flock to in solidarity to find people who think like them. It's resulted in a reduction of diversity and nuance in ideology, and instead reinforced preconceived notions and biases.
Maga has utilized this in a masterful way to get the (aforementioned, and caveat for you- both sides do this) lies and propaganda out to those silos in a way thats more destructive (in degree) and more effective (in degree) than ever before.
I understand you are not die hard maga, but as your wife is (and I'm not trying to get personal here or attack your wife, as I have many loved ones in the same boat), but you have to know the Facebook groups, the Signal chats, the twitter algorithms that have been leveraged and utilized by maga to enforce their base through propaganda. It's been incredibly effective to a degree that perhaps has never been seen before. Do I have to caveat again that dems do this too? I shouldn't- everyone knows they don't do it as well as maga does.
The dems have chosen to be the "quieter" side when it comes to propaganda and lies/deception when they are in power. It's worked, but it also hasn't either. The dems have a messaging (good, bad, and propaganda) and unity problem, and are leagues behind maga in that regard. I don't think thats even hyperbolic or biased to say.