Will Mitchell stay eligible?

MethodUK

All-Conference
Mar 29, 2009
4,683
1,872
113
See some trolls online saying Mitchell won't be eligible do to the Big10 ruling and that the SEC is following the train.

Saying his 10 day contract could make him ineligible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThorsbyTider

PastorofMuppets82

All-Conference
Mar 4, 2025
674
1,534
93
See some trolls online saying Mitchell won't be eligible do to the Big10 ruling and that the SEC is following the train.

Saying his 10 day contract could make him ineligible.
It was actually covered in the KY court case. He (and the others on the list) had to pay back any money they received from contracts signed over the summer. It was part of the TRO ruling that players believing they had exhausted their eligibility only entered into those contracts because they believed they could no longer play in college.

Now whether or not the Kentucky ruling stands on appeal is still a question. But legally the SEC will have a hard time enforcing it with most courts ruling in favor of the players at this point.
 
Last edited:

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,725
12,120
113
It was actually covered in the KY court case. He (and the others on the list) had to pay back any money they received from contracts signed over the summer. It was part of the TRO ruling that players believing they had exhausted their eligibility only entered into those contracts because they believed their could no longer play in college.

Now whether or not the Kentucky ruling stands on appeal is still a question. But legally the SEC will have a hard time enforcing it with most courts ruling in favor of the players at this point.
The next several weeks could get pretty interesting. Sure hope his Kentucky court ruling holds up.
 
Jul 23, 2026
48
115
33
I hate to agree with what Lane Kiffin said, but the NCAA basically told this class that they didn't have any eligibility, and then players were able to find a way through the courts to get eligible. The NCAA just needs to accept defeat and allow the class of 2022 to be grandfathered in with the 5 for 5 and move on. But that won't happen because the NCAA is the epitome of incompetence

Also, a lot of fans of the University 6 are hanging onto the SEC intraconference transfer rules. That rule falls apart when they decided to wait till the last second to apply the 5 for 5. Players will argue they were misled which forced them to have to wait to enter the transfer portal.

Nice to see fans of University 6 worried now that they no longer can claim the #1 Transfer portal.
 

Tprinceuk

Senior
Jun 13, 2024
297
905
88
Hard to say for sure, but I'm fairly confidant he will be eligible. The NCAA's argument seems arbitrary and doesn't make a whole lot of sense, Giving everyone BUT this class an extra year doesn't seem to have any logic behind it.
That's what doesn't make any sense, the COVID years got an extra year and the classes from 2023 and on will get it but they try and cut out 2022 from getting it. With the NCAA going for the 5 in 5 they should have just automatically granted it for the eligible kids from the 2022 class.
 

MethodUK

All-Conference
Mar 29, 2009
4,683
1,872
113
Appreciate everyone's feedback... fingers crossed he stays eligible... our track record is about as good as Popes Zoom calls...
 

Anon1766951099

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2025
5
20
3
Zero chance Mitchell plays for Kentucky.

We don’t get to have nice things, this should be accepted by now.

Mitchell played in the NBA Summer League, didn’t make a roster, and then filed to come back to college.

He is the definition of what all the power conferences are about to ban.

It was a nice try, would’ve been great, but it ain’t happening.
 
Jul 24, 2026
362
484
63
I think we need to think about this from a class of 2022 stand point. The NCAA unfairly is trying to bar the class of 2022 from doing 5&5 while every other class will get. So the class of 2022 under the assumption that there was no 5th year signed pro contracts as any smart individual would do with no other option. Now the NCAA is being petty even though they know the only reason 2022 guys signed pro deals is because they didn’t know they could go back

Possible likely outcome will be 2022 players will be eligible as they didn’t get a fair shake. But no one after will be able to do so again.
 
Oct 23, 2025
514
658
93
I wonder if I could get elected to office running on a platform of "The NCAA are morons, let's fix this mess:"

- 4 years of eligibility per student athlete
- your ineligible if you've played pro anywhere
- only 1 free transfer, all additional transfers require a mandatory season of ineligibility
- NIL salary cap of $15 million per sports program
- transfer fees where schools pay a percentage to the school they are taking the transfer from
- 64 team NCAA tournament, no more Final Fours in Football stadiums
- all conferences are reset to their membership circa the year 2000, with strict limits on all future realignment moves
- all conferences must be regional
 

CGBlue1.0

Junior
Jul 3, 2025
150
246
43
I wonder if I could get elected to office running on a platform of "The NCAA are morons, let's fix this mess:"

- 4 years of eligibility per student athlete
- your ineligible if you've played pro anywhere
- only 1 free transfer, all additional transfers require a mandatory season of ineligibility
- NIL salary cap of $15 million per sports program
- transfer fees where schools pay a percentage to the school they are taking the transfer from
- 64 team NCAA tournament, no more Final Fours in Football stadiums
- all conferences are reset to their membership circa the year 2000, with strict limits on all future realignment moves
- all conferences must be regional
You wouldn't get one thing done, and fit right in.
 
Oct 23, 2025
514
658
93
I think the most realistic way of looking at this is nobody is sure how many of these 5th year players will be eligible when their sports seasons kick off. Lot of court cases, lot of rules, lot of different judges' opinions, lot of tricks for lawyers to pull.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Corporal Upham

Bill_the_cat

Senior
Nov 17, 2025
359
491
57
I don't think it will matter. These players can sue the conferences just like the NCAA. Nobody seems to have any teeth for rules when it comes to NIL and the wildness that comes from it.
Where does it end?
Sue the NCAA- win. Then the conferences put up roadblocks.
Sue the conference- win. But if conferences hold the schools to their requirement, what does the player do?
Schools could easily fear repercussions.
Players are not going to sue the school??
 

FilsonCat

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2007
3,555
4,402
113
Where does it end?
Sue the NCAA- win. Then the conferences put up roadblocks.
Sue the conference- win. But if conferences hold the schools to their requirement, what does the player do?
Schools could easily fear repercussions.
Players are not going to sue the school??
If the NCAA and the Conferences lose in court and decide to enforce their rules anyway, we'll have to get the popcorn going. It will be quite a show.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
47,219
86,467
113
Mitchell and Afari ineligible if this is enforced.


They can try to enforce this but it’s a new rule that took effect after, he couldn’t not declare because he was supposedly out of eligibility, and he didn’t sign a deal. So I think he wins this. Plus doesn’t this make them violate multiple current TRO’s in court and it could be argued they are acting against the NCAA on their own which is another can of worms. I actually agree in broad terms of what they are trying to achieve, but banning one class from the same rules as everyone else is dumb and a stupid hill to die on.
 
Last edited:

Bluegrass79

Senior
May 4, 2006
552
781
61
Hell no.

The rule is withdrew from draft, not... went undrafted.

He went undrafted. He didn't pull out.
He fked.



Gonna need to look elsewhere immediately like right now. This one is cooked.


Anybody that doesn't realize the NBA part was put on there to stop Kentucky and Mitchell is....
Not paying attention.


Our University president voted for it. All16 teams voted for it.



Not even worth the trying to stop it. It was done on purpose by our own people.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Cayden Daughtry is down to 14 schools (yes, 14!) with Kentucky still in the mix
  2. 02 KSR Alabama and Auburn are playing an exhibition game and that's freaking awesome
  3. 03 KSR ESPN getting rid of BottomLine Ticker on college football games
  4. 04 KSR What does the SEC's new eligibility policy mean for Kentucky WBB's Ajša Sivka?
  5. 05 KSR SEC finalizes harsh penalties for rostering former pros