Oh I don't know - I think Allar will keep his hair a lot longer than Bradshaw did.
What’s to be made of Drew Allar with the Steelers?
- Thread starter NittanyLionRoar
- Start date
I get that it was just preseason, but the post I read this morning that sums it up is this:
“James Franklin had the keys to a rocket ship and made it into a Radio Flyer”
“James Franklin had the keys to a rocket ship and made it into a Radio Flyer”
Couple of thoughts concerning Drew Allar's performance last night.
1. At that point in the contest, it was a JV game at the pro level. Drew is a potential Varsity quarterback and he looked the part with his performance.
2. His release was much quicker than I remember from the last couple of years.
3. He was "on target" with all throws except the one to his left where he thought the receiver would run an out pattern.
4. I thought (my opinion only) that the best ball he threw was a 6 yard gain on the right sideline. Hit the receiver low and away from any defender while running to his right.
5. And the last comment. It was nice to see him smiling late in the game. Haven't seen that since his game at WVU.
1. At that point in the contest, it was a JV game at the pro level. Drew is a potential Varsity quarterback and he looked the part with his performance.
2. His release was much quicker than I remember from the last couple of years.
3. He was "on target" with all throws except the one to his left where he thought the receiver would run an out pattern.
4. I thought (my opinion only) that the best ball he threw was a 6 yard gain on the right sideline. Hit the receiver low and away from any defender while running to his right.
5. And the last comment. It was nice to see him smiling late in the game. Haven't seen that since his game at WVU.
Tons of talent. Flashed some ability and it was somewhat typical for a Franklin player -- flashed but not great, fundamentally sound but not game changing, almost mechanical in individual play, not tremendously clutch, savvy or exciting. I think except for Barkley, Geskicki, Dotson, Warren and possibly Fatman, you could say the same for most big-time offensive recruits of BGJ. Always wondered why that was. Don't know. A real mystery -- coaching, system, or just the type of player recruited?
There are many places to find knowledgable and informed opinions.
"X" isn't one of them.
My only criticism of Drew was the pass to the back inside the five yd line on his1st series. It reminded me of the easy pass to Singleton that was behind Nick and this one was a little too far in front. Both were catchable, but not easy catches. Someone said last night as an NFL QB, you need to make that throw on the money 10 out of 10 times.
Why would anyone go anywhere other than here?
As a long suffering Jets fan my take is it means absolutely nothing.
HIs physical body may be gone but he still resides here and in a lot of peoples heads.
I am no fan of Aaron Rodgers but by all accounts he has been an excellent mentor to both Howard and Allar. Very generous with his time and advice. What I’m reading is that this is in direct response to the way Brett Favre treated him when he was a rookie. (Favre wouldn’t lift a finger to help him.)
Favre was too busy trying to figure out how to lift Rogers’ wallet.
I think Franklin is about to ride off into oblivion. He might be the most overpaid HC in the game. He would make a great administrator where BS counts without consequences. What he did to set up his own exit with player exoduses from PS was inexcusable.
He's a great actor, he had me snowed right up until the playoffs and the following spring.
I agree that I would like to have kept Grunk. CMC probably just wanted Becht, though I think a case could be made for trying to make the playoff this year with the friendly schedule and then hopefully have that be a springboard to big gains in recruiting. Grunk learning a new system would make that plan tougher to execute.
On your first point, someone correct me if I’m wrong, but I seem to remember Terry Smith saying we were going to push the ball downfield with our passing game, implying that was something we weren’t doing before under Franklin. Maybe that helped contribute to Grunk’s success?
I've always liked Drew and thought he was handcuffed by the coaching staff. I hope he has a great career but I'm going to reserve judgment until he's playing against 1st string pro's in meaningful games.
Becht is here to help establish the overall culture for the program, and culture is Campbell’s top priority in y1. Becht is probably a better qb than Grunk anyway, at least at this point of time. Grunk was offered a ton of money to stay at PSU (near P4 starter money) with the understanding that Becht was the clear starter and Grunk was a backup that could compete for the starter job in 2027. Grunk chose VT to start in 2026 and with the familiarity of Franklin’s staff. Grunk will win the starting job there, but the competition in their room is a lot closer than you would imagine.
I always liked him too, but I thought he didn't deal well with pressure. He would become visibly upset when a play went bad- something you don't want to see, especially not in a QB.
He has a ton of ability; my question is still about his mental toughness. Time will tell.
You don't see Josh Allen, Aaron Rodgers, etc being visibly upset when a play goes wrong?
Want some videos of Brady being upset?
CJF was playing 5-D Chess.....only James Franklin and Lion James (Lion Jim) can explain the extra complexity that the 5th dimension adds to the game. Doubt me if you want, but Drew Allar ended up in the perfect place in a perfect scenario as CJF knew that he would.......
Can confirm. Neshaminy voodoo.
You can't compare Allar to Pickett. Pickett was a self centered head case around the bum Tomlin. Allar was ruined by BGJ who cared about one thing, BGJ
It seemed to me his heart was at PSU and he really wanted to stay. But Matt Campbell was bringing his guys and there was only so much room. I think he felt he deserved to start after proving it for half a season—and he’s not necessarily wrong. But likely wrong about it being VT.
I don’t think the choice was Becht vs. Grunk. I think it was Manske vs Grunk. Both were Elite 11 QB’s rated as 4-star recruits. But at the end of the day, Manske is more mobile, which they want, and knows their system already. Plus, I’m just guessing, but they probably would’ve had to pay Grunk more than Manske.
And Terry Hanratty.He was right up there with Tommy Maddox.
I think Brady was POed in any clips you find.
Drew had fear.
I want Drew to do well. But he was his own enemy at times.
I keep reading stories about how assertive Rodgers is as a mentor. Dang, so impressive.
Latest
-
01
BWI
Following standout camp, LB Jess Officer plans Penn State return this fall
-
02
BWI
What the final SP+ preseason rankings tell us about Penn State in 2026, and what they do not
-
03
BWI
Penn State scrimmage coverage: Intel, top performers, film room and more
-
04
BWI
Penn State's five guys: Top performers at the Nittany Lions' Saturday scrimmage
-
05
BWI
Intel from Penn State's first Beaver Stadium scrimmage: Josiah Zayas shines again, offense has bounce-back performance