FC/OT: What will the 'Save College Sports Act' actually do?

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
12,454
20,663
113
Seems like after some threats from POTUS, the B1G and SEC are on board. I assume there will be some pushback from various legislators, and a lot of this seems very difficult to enforce, but the highlights are:

- Limits conference expansion (for the Power 4) to 19 teams and does not allow teams who have been in a conference for five years to move to another without first operating as an independent for five years. It also prevents the creation of a 'Super League'.

- Transfer restrictions would return in the form of a one time no penalty transfer per player, as well as unlimited graduate transfers. Subsequent transfers would require sitting out a year. Also, players would be allowed to transfer in the event of a new head coach hiring or misconduct related circumstance.

- Increased revenue sharing and 'hard' spending cap:

The money opened up for athletes by the House v. NCAA settlement (around $21 million this year) would increase by way of a new $22.5 million “retention fund” limit to be used on a school’s current players, plus another $5 million capped pool exclusively for women’s sports and nonrevenue sports, totaling nearly $50 million per year.

In an attempt to close spending loopholes and to create a harder cap, the bill also adopts the House settlement’s definition of an “associated entity” and requires school multimedia rights holders and third parties to provide signed certification that a school is not the source of NIL compensation to the athlete. This was the final change that got the SEC and Big Ten on board.

The bill also preempts the various state laws on NIL, eligibility and transfers that had complicated the NCAA’s pursuit of a national standard for a level playing field.


- 'Lane Kiffin' rule - prevents coaches from performing head coaching duties at a new school until their current school's season concludes. This isn't just for HC's taking a new job; it's any college coach who accepts a HC position at a new school - so, OC's and DC's are in the same boat.

- Caps agent fees to 5% of NIL deals and requires agents to register with a state before representing an athlete. Also maintains a database of agents and allows the NCAA to certify/decertify them.

Some good stuff here (mostly with transfer rules and agent limitations); no idea how this isn't challenged in court the first time a HC takes another job and wants to leave. Thoughts?
 
Last edited:

DaytonRickster

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
3,073
3,611
113
Seems like after some threats from POTUS, the B1G and SEC are on board. I assume there will be some pushback from various legislators, and a lot of this seems very difficult to enforce, but the highlights are:

- Limits conference expansion (for the Power 4) to 19 teams and does not allow teams who have been in a conference for five years to move to another without first operating as an independent for five years. It also prevents the creation of a 'Super League'.

- Transfer restrictions would return in the form of a one time no penalty transfer per player, as well as unlimited graduate transfers. Subsequent transfers would require sitting out a year. Also, players would be allowed to transfer in the event of a new head coach hiring or misconduct related circumstance.

- Increased revenue sharing and 'hard' spending cap:

The money opened up for athletes by the House v. NCAA settlement (around $21 million this year) would increase by way of a new $22.5 million “retention fund” limit to be used on a school’s current players, plus another $5 million capped pool exclusively for women’s sports and nonrevenue sports, totaling nearly $50 million per year.

In an attempt to close spending loopholes and to create a harder cap, the bill also adopts the House settlement’s definition of an “associated entity” and requires school multimedia rights holders and third parties to provide signed certification that a school is not the source of NIL compensation to the athlete. This was the final change that got the SEC and Big Ten on board.

The bill also preempts the various state laws on NIL, eligibility and transfers that had complicated the NCAA’s pursuit of a national standard for a level playing field.


- 'Lane Kiffin' rule - prevents coaches from performing head coaching duties at a new school until their current school's season concludes. This isn't just for HC's taking a new job; it's any college coach who accepts a HC position at a new school - so, OC's and DC's are in the same boat.

- Caps agent fees to 5% of NIL deals and requires agents to register with a state before representing an athlete. Also maintains a database of agents and allows the NCAA to certify/decertify them.

Some good stuff here (mostly with transfer rules and agent limitations); no idea how this isn't challenged in court the first time a HC takes another job and wants to leave. Thoughts?
I don't like the 2nd paragraph. They are taking the control of movement away from the universities.
It could lead to the Power 4 conferences leaving the NCAA and starting their own organization.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
12,454
20,663
113
I don't like the 2nd paragraph. They are taking the control of movement away from the universities.
It could lead to the Power 4 conferences leaving the NCAA and starting their own organization.

Wouldn't that be a 'Super League' that this bill would supposedly prevent? Genuinely asking....
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
34,638
10,076
113
- 'Lane Kiffin' rule - prevents coaches from performing head coaching duties at a new school until their current school's season concludes. This isn't just for HC's taking a new job; it's any college coach who accepts a HC position at a new school - so, OC's and DC's are in the same boat.
Regarding that Lane Kiffin rule, I'm not sure why it was given that nickname. The recent trend for prominent schools desiring to make a head coaching change is to hire the new head coach in late November at the latest, so that he can get busy recruiting players in advance of the early National Signing Day, which is in early to mid December. I'm no fan of Lane Kiffin, but this trend is certainly not limited to him.

I have to assume that the definition of "coaching duties" at the new school would include recruiting, because that is the primary thing these schools are looking at when making an early hire.
 

Thorndike2021

All-Conference
Mar 1, 2012
865
1,916
93
I'm glad to hear that our "leaders" have nothing more important to do
I beg to differ; in my opinion, this is EXACTLY what we want Congress, etc. spending their time on. All other Congressional activities consist of graft, corruption, or further eroding the liberties of we the people.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
12,454
20,663
113
There’s a fairly significant barrier to entry for the Super League initiative (or so I seem to recall from this show).

Great podcast; really nailed it wrt the value of college football compared to the NFL minor leagues. As in there simply isn’t a market for a minor league system. Good points too with regard to capitulating to the SEC and B1G; why bother? They can F off and see what the alternative looks like - and my guess is not good.
 

psuro

Heisman
Aug 24, 2001
9,556
20,955
113
Seems like after some threats from POTUS, the B1G and SEC are on board. I assume there will be some pushback from various legislators, and a lot of this seems very difficult to enforce, but the highlights are:

- Limits conference expansion (for the Power 4) to 19 teams and does not allow teams who have been in a conference for five years to move to another without first operating as an independent for five years. It also prevents the creation of a 'Super League'.

- Transfer restrictions would return in the form of a one time no penalty transfer per player, as well as unlimited graduate transfers. Subsequent transfers would require sitting out a year. Also, players would be allowed to transfer in the event of a new head coach hiring or misconduct related circumstance.

- Increased revenue sharing and 'hard' spending cap:

The money opened up for athletes by the House v. NCAA settlement (around $21 million this year) would increase by way of a new $22.5 million “retention fund” limit to be used on a school’s current players, plus another $5 million capped pool exclusively for women’s sports and nonrevenue sports, totaling nearly $50 million per year.

In an attempt to close spending loopholes and to create a harder cap, the bill also adopts the House settlement’s definition of an “associated entity” and requires school multimedia rights holders and third parties to provide signed certification that a school is not the source of NIL compensation to the athlete. This was the final change that got the SEC and Big Ten on board.

The bill also preempts the various state laws on NIL, eligibility and transfers that had complicated the NCAA’s pursuit of a national standard for a level playing field.


- 'Lane Kiffin' rule - prevents coaches from performing head coaching duties at a new school until their current school's season concludes. This isn't just for HC's taking a new job; it's any college coach who accepts a HC position at a new school - so, OC's and DC's are in the same boat.

- Caps agent fees to 5% of NIL deals and requires agents to register with a state before representing an athlete. Also maintains a database of agents and allows the NCAA to certify/decertify them.

Some good stuff here (mostly with transfer rules and agent limitations); no idea how this isn't challenged in court the first time a HC takes another job and wants to leave. Thoughts?
I come to a sports board to "get away" from politics!!!!!!! Stop this!

(Hope my good buddy Obliviax is reading this!)
 

Zenophile

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2001
1,440
4,486
113
I come to a sports board to "get away" from politics!!!!!!! Stop this!

(Hope my good buddy Obliviax is reading this!)
Hey Obli!
Tom Hanks Hello GIF
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI The weekly rundown: Feldman's Freaks list, how to watch Penn State practice on BTN today, and more
  2. 02 BWI Inside Lasch: Breaking down Penn State's early 2028 offensive line targets
  3. 03 BWI Three Things to Watch as Penn State Puts on the Pads for the First Time for the media
  4. 04 BWI Former, current Penn State coaches among list of coordinators who could be head coaches in 2027
  5. 05 BWI LOOK: More photos from Penn State Football's first week of practice