POLL: Should this season be Tom Brands last as HC at Iowa?

Should this season be Tom Brands last as HC at Iowa?


  • Total voters
    750
  • Poll closed .

lrtbahawk

All-Conference
Iowa Swarm member
Dec 31, 2022
471
1,768
93
Terry's sideline optics are just awful. I'll guarantee you his mad man act doesn't play well with parents of prospective recruits.
Not true. Would like to know whose parents told you this? I don't like what's going on with the program either, but I'm not going to sit back and let people try and tarnish a good man's reputation.
 
Last edited:

FanInBlack

All-Conference
Nov 9, 2001
1,933
4,078
113
I think there’s some truth to this and recruiting absolutely matters. But I also think development matters immensely. Nelson Brands was a takedown machine in high school. At Iowa, not so much. Was his style to blame or was there a major development component?

Ben Keuter? Ethen Lofthouse? Alex Marinelli? Nick Moore? Sammy Brooks? Grant Gambrall? Tony Cassioppi? Patrick Kennedy? Mike Evans? Ryan Morningstar? Alex Tsirtsis? Josh Dziewa? Charlie Falck? Mike Evans? Dan Leclere?

I think tons of those dudes had great offense in high school and abilities to extend it into college and reach great heights in the right coaching/training environment. Most of them did reach AA status, but how many reached the potential they had coming in? How many continued to be as offensive as they were in high school? I mostly see a bunch of dudes who primarily became “pressure” merchants rather than dynamic offensive scorers in college, but that’s not typically what they were in high school.

Even if they weren’t prolific or dynamic scorers in high school, that’s not a reason they shouldn’t reach their potential. Starocci wasn’t a dynamic scorer in college, but he certainly reached his potential and scored big team points. Prolific scorers or not, figure out how to get the best out of (and for) your guys. And when you consistently don’t, of course the recruiting suffers. It stems from the lack of development in the system.
TBF there have been a lot of take down machines in the 100+ years of Iowa HS wrestling. Not a lot of those guys ever wrestled at a high level in the B1G.

I never considered Nelson an elite recruit, TBH. I hoped he would develop into AA and he did.
 
Jul 2, 2025
74
377
53
TBF there have been a lot of take down machines in the 100+ years of Iowa HS wrestling. Not a lot of those guys ever wrestled at a high level in the B1G.

I never considered Nelson an elite recruit, TBH. I hoped he would develop into AA and he did.
I listed 14 others, not all from Iowa. Many/most of them were certainly elite recruits. And I could have listed more. My point wasn’t to do with Nelson so much as it was to do with countering the notion that (lack of) development under TNT isn’t a major part of the problem. To me, it’s undeniably obvious that it is.
 
Last edited:

Cali_Nittany1

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2019
718
3,089
93
Only the greats throw an occasional chair. Bobby Knight threw one farther than Cael.



The argument that Terry's matside behavior is scaring away recruits is hilarious.
 
May 21, 2023
101
335
63
Not true. Would like to know whose parents told you this? I don't like what's going on with the program either, but I'm not going to sit back and let people try and tarnish a good man's reputation.
I dont think its out to tarnish a good reputation by saying something that probably has some truth to it. Its like so many other facets of the staff that haven't really rolled with the times. Its the timeframe they wrestled in. Probably the same with some old timers on this board. Most of us probably had a borderline crazy coach that would lose their s**t on the sidelines. Seemed like it was almost a prerequisite of being a good coach to have a crazy side to them. Contrast that with the examples of successful coaches you see now. All are passionate, but most have a much more chilled approach. That reflects on their teams as well. They tend to be a little more freed up with their style. Im not saying it scares recruits away, but they see the difference in styles. Iowa as a whole generally looks tight, and as painful as it is to say, they wrestle timid. I think you would have to be a little crazy to not at least acknowledge the matside antics contribute to that.
 

HugoHugo

Senior
Jan 25, 2024
328
761
93
Not true. Would like to know whose parents told you this? I don't like what's going on with the program either, but I'm not going to sit back and let people try and tarnish a good man's reputation.

Unfortunately, he seems to be doing a pretty good job of doing that himself. Sheesh
 
  • Like
Reactions: kingstown

InTheCircle

All-Conference
Apr 3, 2018
429
1,671
93
Terry's sideline optics are just awful. I'll guarantee you his mad man act doesn't play well with parents of prospective recruits.
There is an exception. Before Spencer Lee made is commitment he said, “I just didn’t want Terry Brands coaching against me in the other corner.”
I wish this could have been parlayed into better recruiting.
 

maxpain

All-American
Jul 6, 2006
2,062
6,873
113
Watching ADS and Spencer wrestle makes me miss how fearless most of that group was. Those two, Eierman, Bull, Kemerer, Cass. Even Murin and Young but in a slightly different way.

It just feels like that fearlessness is gone. Caliendo is the only one I would say has it.
 

sdvike

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2016
945
2,113
93
If the U buys out their contracts, wonder where they go. Stay in BT maybe at Illinois or Rutgers? Maybe they go big 12 team.
 

Trapper85

Senior
Jun 22, 2020
192
680
93
Watching ADS and Spencer wrestle makes me miss how fearless most of that group was. Those two, Eierman, Bull, Kemerer, Cass. Even Murin and Young but in a slightly different way.

It just feels like that fearlessness is gone. Caliendo is the only one I would say has it.
I agree, but it's alot easier, or at least more productive, to be fearless when you have high talent. Marginal talent + fearless = counting or seeing stars in 30 seconds.
 

sdvike

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2016
945
2,113
93
Watching ADS and Spencer wrestle makes me miss how fearless most of that group was. Those two, Eierman, Bull, Kemerer, Cass. Even Murin and Young but in a slightly different way.

It just feels like that fearlessness is gone. Caliendo is the only one I would say has it.
I know he is taking more losses this year, but Drake wrestles fearless.
 

Stick Kitty

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
481
1,239
93
Iowa with no #1 seeds and PSU with six, and two #2 seeds.

It's time for a regime change.

There was a time a lot of us would have thought Iowa will wrestle way above that seed. Its gonna be ugly the next few eeks. There are no rabbits to pull out of hats.
 

blcoach80

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2018
334
1,722
93
There was a time a lot of us would have thought Iowa will wrestle way above that seed. Its gonna be ugly the next few eeks. There are no rabbits to pull out of hats.
This isn't fair or accurate. You don't think 125 finishes higher than 8th, 149 higher than 8th, 184 higher than 8th, 197 higher than 13th, or 285 higher than 10th?!? That is half the lineup.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nashville_Hawk

Stick Kitty

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
481
1,239
93
This isn't fair or accurate. You don't think 125 finishes higher than 8th, 149 higher than 8th, 184 higher than 8th, 197 higher than 13th, or 285 higher than 10th?!? That is half the lineup.

I was talking NCAA's and Big Picture. I refuse to acknowledge the BIG seedings as anything based in reality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blcoach80

InTheCircle

All-Conference
Apr 3, 2018
429
1,671
93
If the U buys out their contracts, wonder where they go. Stay in BT maybe at Illinois or Rutgers? Maybe they go big 12 team.
I don’t see TNT coaching collegiately anywhere except Iowa. While this season has been painful, no one bleeds black and gold more than TNT. It is possible Tom might do something administrative, while Terry is a freestyle coach for HWC and/or USA Wrestling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: maxpain and sdvike

Libertylover

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2020
1,001
1,699
93
My friend, I just don't see a path to 3-6 next year barring some serious portal grabs. Currently our over/under AA count for this year is what, 4.5 or 5? 3 of those are leaving this year and I don't see possible AAs replacing them. We got our men at 25 and 97 joining the party, but it's hard to picture them as AAs their first year. If something impressive doesn't happen I can easily see us with 2 or 3 AAs next year and finishing closer to 10th than 6th. Am I missing some recruits they're hiding in that windowless facility?
Harvey is a long shot to AA next year, but Deluca should have a decent shot if his injury isn’t too bad. Can’t believe nobody has heard a peep all season what this injury is that kept him out all year. Has he had surgery?
 

Random4598375

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2020
621
1,785
93
PSU and now OSU kept getting better and better as the number of top 10, then top 5 pfp recruits kept coming in each year. There is a reason next year will be Taylor’s best yet, and it’s not development, it’s recruiting.
Recruiting follows development. If the top 5 type guys thought they would get better in Iowa's room than Ok St's, they would be at Iowa. What they see is Iowa wrestlers injured and/or underachieving every year while PSU dominates nationals. There is certainly a bet by some that DT will be able to recreate the PSU formula at Ok St, which is not settled, but the one year returns look pretty good taking two career mid-AAs in Hamiti and Hendrickson and turning them into champions in one year in the room.
 

vhsalum

All-Conference
Nov 14, 2002
1,176
2,645
113
PSU and now OSU kept getting better and better as the number of top 10, then top 5 pfp recruits kept coming in each year. There is a reason next year will be Taylor’s best yet, and it’s not development, it’s recruiting.
This is a stupid thing to say and even in 1.8 seasons, the data shows you're wrong.

Recruiting is 1A, but developing is 1B. Feel free to look back at the top recruiting classes from the past 15 years. Iowa has had their fare share of glorious recruits. They don't develop. You have to do both.
 
Last edited:

Nashville_Hawk

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2015
726
1,894
93
Harvey is a long shot to AA next year, but Deluca should have a decent shot if his injury isn’t too bad. Can’t believe nobody has heard a peep all season what this injury is that kept him out all year. Has he had surgery?
My friend, living in Nashville the only news / updates I receive come from folks on this forum. I hope he’s a gamer; we need some new, aggressive blood and I hope he’s part of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Libertylover

Nashville_Hawk

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2015
726
1,894
93
This is a stupid thing to say and even in 1.8 seasons, the data shows you're wrong.

Recruiting is 1A, but developing is 1B. Feel free to look back at the top recruiting classes from the past 15 years. Iowa has had their fare share of glorious recruits. They don't develop. You have to do both.
Think you’re wrong VHS…not a stupid thing to say. Like you said, it’s 1a and 1b but you’re much better off if you start with Jax and Bo and don’t have to worry as much about the 1b. And we definitely don’t want to look back 15 years at Iowa; that’ll just make us even more frustrated than we already are.