New redshirt rule incoming?

hawkandroll

Junior
Sep 7, 2011
175
343
63
Why stop there? Just give everyone 5 seasons. And make it retroactive. I mean overseas pros and nba g league players are eligible for college basketball, why not players from within the last 15 years who still haven't played a full 5 seasons?
what about players from the last 50 years?
rob gronkowski GIF
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
1,553
2,701
113
Why stop there? Just give everyone 5 seasons. And make it retroactive. I mean overseas pros and nba g league players are eligible for college basketball, why not players from within the last 15 years who still haven't played a full 5 seasons?
Why not as long as they haven’t already taken the class they can maintain their eligibility. You could stay in college forever. call it the Van Wilder rule.
 

Hawkeyes19

Junior
Feb 1, 2002
101
200
43
If that is true that Beck is not enrolled in any classes at Miami, he shouldn't be academically eligible, and should not be allowed to play and all wins vacated. It's been mentioned here on HR, when is the last time a major college athlete has been ineligible, but to not even be taking classes...
 

Hawk-A-Doodle-Doo

All-Conference
Oct 1, 2001
812
2,284
93
If that is true that Beck is not enrolled in any classes at Miami, he shouldn't be academically eligible, and should not be allowed to play and all wins vacated. It's been mentioned here on HR, when is the last time a major college athlete has been ineligible, but to not even be taking classes...
If that is true that Beck is not enrolled in any classes at Miami, he shouldn't be academically eligible, and should not be allowed to play and all wins vacated. It's been mentioned here on HR, when is the last time a major college athlete has been ineligible, but to not even be taking classes...
Why? He ain't come there to play school. Classes are pointless.
Sincerely,
Cardale
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Iron Doc

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,491
4,502
113
If that is true that Beck is not enrolled in any classes at Miami, he shouldn't be academically eligible, and should not be allowed to play and all wins vacated. It's been mentioned here on HR, when is the last time a major college athlete has been ineligible, but to not even be taking classes...
I have to believe thats up to the University at this point, since the NCAA has basically turned their backs at enforcement due to their court losses. Not surprising at Miami or some of the SEC schools. Pretty sure MG was taking classes at Iowa this year and he already had his engineering degree before he got there,
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pawkhawk1

MeetTheFerentzes

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2022
1,954
3,837
113
This guy already did it. :)


How the hell do you transfer from one school to another and not even be registered for any classes? I realize that athletes not actually going to class or doing any kind of real academic work is not a new thing, but to come out and admit that there’s essentially no need of being an actual student at the school? JFC

Edit to add that CB has the most punchable face I’ve seen in a while.
 
Last edited:

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,491
4,502
113
How the hell do you transfer from one school to another and not even be registered for any classes? I realize that athletes not actually going to class or doing any kind of real academic work is not a new thing, but to come out and admit that there’s essentially no need of being an actual student at the school? JFC
Agree. While theres been some small steps made to put some guardrails on this mess, its been too little too late. Alot more needs to be done to reign in this whole sale free agency.
 

Palmerhawk

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
1,830
3,608
113
Puff Johnson, OSU bb guard, just got a temporary restraining order from a local judge to allow immediate eligibility to play for buckeyes.
He played 3 seasons at UNC then played 2 seasons for PSU....112 games over 5 years.
Now, a 6th season for bucks because last season he only played 17 games due to a wrist injury in mid- January.
Tavion banks,stirtz,wetjen,grononski need to find a friendly Hawkeye judge in IC and keep playing.
No rules!
 

Bierhalter

All-Conference
Aug 15, 2023
734
1,304
93
We gonna get mad at all the Iowa players over the decades who redshirted, graduated in 4 years, then played while not enrolled/enrolled in some joke crap their redshirt senior year?
 

MeetTheFerentzes

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2022
1,954
3,837
113
We gonna get mad at all the Iowa players over the decades who redshirted, graduated in 4 years, then played while not enrolled/enrolled in some joke crap their redshirt senior year?
Different argument/situation. What you described has been going on forever everywhere. Someone “transferring” from one school to another then playing on the football team, but not actually being a student at the school is a new phenomenon in the new landscape we used to call college football.
 

oldxbbc

All-American
Sep 19, 2013
1,743
7,197
113
When I first started reading this I THOUGHT it was fake AI news-crazy!
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,491
4,502
113
We gonna get mad at all the Iowa players over the decades who redshirted, graduated in 4 years, then played while not enrolled/enrolled in some joke crap their redshirt senior year?
Thats not even close to the same thing as changing schools and not even enrolling in classes. You would think the Universities would have enough institutional pride not to have players who were not even enrolled as students on their teams. I do have to wonder about these G league "pros" going back to college as well
 

Mustang_hawk

Junior
Jun 27, 2001
115
307
63
I have to believe thats up to the University at this point, since the NCAA has basically turned their backs at enforcement due to their court losses. Not surprising at Miami or some of the SEC schools. Pretty sure MG was taking classes at Iowa this year and he already had his engineering degree before he got there,
So why the hell does the NCAA even exist?
 

airhawk

Senior
Jan 3, 2023
287
445
63
Puff Johnson, OSU bb guard, just got a temporary restraining order from a local judge to allow immediate eligibility to play for buckeyes.
He played 3 seasons at UNC then played 2 seasons for PSU....112 games over 5 years.
Now, a 6th season for bucks because last season he only played 17 games due to a wrist injury in mid- January.
Tavion banks,stirtz,wetjen,grononski need to find a friendly Hawkeye judge in IC and keep playing.
No rules!
Tavian Banks too. How about Brad Banks?
 

trfhawk

Junior
Jul 10, 2020
160
344
63
Why stop there? Just give everyone 5 seasons. And make it retroactive. I mean overseas pros and nba g league players are eligible for college basketball, why not players from within the last 15 years who still haven't played a full 5 seasons?
Why any rules? There are very few now. 12 playoff teams. 85 players per team. 1020 players. Can you name one player who was declared ineligible for their playoff game for academic reasons? This is not college football anymore. Why pretend? It used to be a concern every bowl season. (players being eligible for the bowl game) I guess the players are smarter now.