Could this actually be Pike's best team?

Luvscarletknights

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2018
3,955
4,712
113
Getting back to original question -
Best teams don’t lose to Lafayette and Unass and DePaul.
having said that, there is no doubt they are PLAYING at least the best I have seen them, if not better.
Let’s continue to watch and hope.
Leadership is why this is the best team (Baker, Harper, Caleb, Paul). I also believe Pikiell feels this way because the players are Loving each other and rooting for each other.

I think teachability is another aspect. Reiber, Cliff, and Jalen have huge upside and are getting better and better. Hopefully Jaden starts earning his minutes. Hyatt is now turning the corner as well.

Myles and Jacob were good players but not much more improvement could be had.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CHR2022

RUfromSoCal?

Heisman
Nov 26, 2006
35,389
43,778
113
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Also, as I said a bit ago, I haven't been on the hoops board in days and never read the Carino thread and had no idea people had been arguing about this stuff for a few days. Thought I was just having a bit of fun with the thread title after a big win, but I absolutely believe that this team is capable of being as good as last year, as we're showing lately.

Okay.. I'll buy that. Coincidences happen. Really seemed like you were aware of it with that thread title. Suppose I shouldn't have assumed that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU848789

CHR2022

Senior
Nov 11, 2018
430
527
0
Leadership is why this is the best team (Baker, Harper, Caleb, Paul). I also believe Pikiell feels this way because the players are Loving each other and rooting for each other.

I think teachability is another aspect. Reiber, Cliff, and Jalen have huge upside and are getting better and better. Hopefully Jaden starts earning his minutes. Hyatt is now turning the corner as well.

Myles and Jacob were good players but not much more improvement could be had.
Agreed with the last point. Young and Myles were pretty much at their ceiling at Rutgers with our surrounding talent + coaching.
 

fbc1866

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2005
5,812
2,113
113
He calmed it through out our losing period, they appeared to be having fun.
 

Mr. Magoo1

Heisman
Nov 15, 2001
15,641
16,597
113
Hyatt for Montez is going to be a net positive by the end of this season.
Hyatt for Mathis was always a net positive…even when Hyatt wasn’t playing. People forget what a negative “me first” Mathis had become during the 2nd half of last season. He was selfish and If he didn’t “get his”, he forced shots and provided no value.
 

Scarlet Blind_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 5, 2001
4,742
4,819
62
How quickly forgotten, the X Factor change Pike/Jalen made was pulling the Redshirt off made a world of difference with the on floor chemistry of this year's team. Is he Jacob Young offensively no, not even close, this team doesn't need offense from him but he is an all out defender harassing the opposing PG on par with Young but different cause he doesn't take possessions off. Yes, this team looked great in preseason, practice, scrimmages with Miller leading to games 1-6, but who knew that missing piece on the floor was Jalen Miller's contributions, or to the players "Scoot". They were 3-3 and rudderless without him, barely beating Lehigh, Merrimack, NJIT, since (6-2) wins over Clemson, Purdue, Michigan and a 28 pt blowout win over Nebraska, not many of those in 8 years in the B1G. Do we even start as slow as we do if Miller played game 1-6, who knows? I like what I see the last 8 games, and 16 more to play to find out if Pike was right.
 

Eagleton95.99

All-American
Jul 25, 2001
7,562
6,490
113
Are we really going to have read these kind of threads after every win....or every loss

The constant calling out of posters or fanbase is negative and evil is insane......a very small number of posters posted really bad things...yet we keep hearing our media AMPLYFING nonsense about ALL OF THIS MESSAGE BOARD who turned on Pike blah blah blah. Look we ALL got analysis and stuff wrong, its a message board, it happens all the time.

guess what..we were AWFUL, early on, we almost lost to Lehigh and lost to some **** *** team Lafayette and then lost to to bad teams as well as being annihilated by Illinois

Yes we are a completely different team now but its revisionist history to say WE ALL KNEW WHAT WAS COMING and we are better than these other posters for being negative.. If RU loses the next couple of games, no one wants the negatoids coming in and saying SEE I TOLD YOU SO...that does not make for a fun board

GUESS WHAT, WE ARE ALL RUTGERS FANS HERE....LETS ENJOY THIS GREAT TURNAROUND NOW INSTEAD OF FIGHTING AND GIVING THE MEDIA ITS CLICKS

Notice that most of the really negative posters are not here posting,, why are you are worried so much about these people.


LET US MOVE ON FROM THIS
The moving on will happen naturally don’t worry (with a few ball busters still busting balls where they can). And the media was pretty clear in saying it’s a minority. But I do think it’s worth pointing out that many people here acted like noobs. Like this was the first full season of hoops they ever watched. Like they had never seen a team struggle and turn it around. And the lack of loyalty and gratitude for the coaches and players that brought us two NCAA tourney worthy seasons in a row. So effing entitled.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ancienthooper

RUBOB72

All-American
Aug 5, 2004
23,385
7,924
0
Way off base with this post, as you're mining posts from right after the worst loss of the Pike era and a loss as bad as any we've had in 10+ years. People are going to be pretty upset after a loss like that (it's almost like citing posts from game threads, which we know are full of rants even by level-headed posters) and I bet you could find dozens of pretty negative posts from posters who aren't usually that negative, right after that game. And even then, it was clear that my first post was half in jest - do you actually think one loss would make me give up tickets after being a season ticket holder for 30+ years and after seeing far worse teams and coaches?

Also, none of my posts was anywhere near as negative as the many calling for Pike's head or saying some really horrible things about the team and players - I think few posters would put my post-Lafeyette thread in that category. IMO, only the 2nd post you cited was really negative and even in that one I left an out, i.e., "Unless Pike can work some miracles really fast this season is toast." But congrats for being "that guy" who mines old posts in some odd attempt to derail a thread.
Numbers just take the criticism as constructive EVERYONE at times with Rutgers sports has been guilty of speaking out of frustration. Me of course but you also. You are an alum and fan and so we wear our hearts on our sleeves. We all want Rutgers to be great in academics and sports . Sometimes we often say things out of those heartfelt feelings. Don’t worry you are still loved .BTW: When is the next ice , snow, event ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: zappaa

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
Okay.. I'll buy that. Coincidences happen. Really seemed like you were aware of it with that thread title. Suppose I shouldn't have assumed that.
Thanks for acknowledging that, but I'll also add that in 30 seconds you could have seen I hadn't posted on the hoops board since Tuesday night, which is far less time than you invested in your first reply with my posts quoted from November. Yes, I was critical at the time, but no I wasn't unhinged or mean-spirited and never would have even thought of calling for Pike's head.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shields

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
Numbers just take the criticism as constructive EVERYONE at times with Rutgers sports has been guilty of speaking out of frustration. Me of course but you also. You are an alum and fan and so we wear our hearts on our sleeves. We all want Rutgers to be great in academics and sports . Sometimes we often say things out of those heartfelt feelings. Don’t worry you are still loved .BTW: When is the next ice , snow, event ?
No problem with criticism - just want it to be accurate. Next winter storm could be next Sunday, as we enter a colder and possibly snowier than normal pattern for the 2nd half of January...
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUBOB72

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Thanks for acknowledging that, but I'll also add that in 30 seconds you could have seen I hadn't posted on the hoops board since Tuesday night, which is far less time than you invested in your first reply with my posts quoted from November. Yes, I was critical at the time, but no I wasn't unhinged or mean-spirited and never would have even thought of calling for Pike's head.
And in 30 seconds you could have skimmed the basketball board before posting.

AND the points still remain true.. you created the thread title to taunt the critics based on Rutgers recent success.. admitted to that yourself.. then went on to explain your motivation was all the excessive negativity even though you participated in excessive negativity and only NOW.. after some good wins, did you not only find distaste for the critics but actually sought to tweak their noses with your posts.

My acknowledgment was of my motivation in responding to your post AFTER you admitted it was to stir things up. AND now you couldn't even let that alone.. you had to poke at it some more.

You do realize that one of your posts I quoted was where you went out of your way to agree with the OnTheBanks piece that said EVERYTHING WAS ON THE TABLE in terms of fixing things. And that could very well be considered "unhinged" and included something you pointed out as "unhinged" about the players who are NOT here this year...

"The absence of Jacob Young and Myles Johnson is the most obvious difference in this team." - your recommended OnTheBanks column

So much of that piece can look "unhinged" now that the players and coaches have seemed to have fixed things.... but it was not "unhinged" then. All of it was entirely supportable by the cold hard facts of what we all witnessed.

So, independent as to whether you were aware of the Carnio article and independent of my motivation in responding to your calling out of the negative posters.. your content in this thread proves the hypocrisy that you desire to erase by establishing a scale of negativity that places you on the right side and those you call on on the wrong side of the equations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

Scarlet83

Heisman
Feb 4, 2004
9,535
10,674
103
And in 30 seconds you could have skimmed the basketball board before posting.

AND the points still remain true.. you created the thread title to taunt the critics based on Rutgers recent success.. admitted to that yourself.. then went on to explain your motivation was all the excessive negativity even though you participated in excessive negativity and only NOW.. after some good wins, did you not only find distaste for the critics but actually sought to tweak their noses with your posts.

My acknowledgment was of my motivation in responding to your post AFTER you admitted it was to stir things up. AND now you couldn't even let that alone.. you had to poke at it some more.

You do realize that one of your posts I quoted was where you went out of your way to agree with the OnTheBanks piece that said EVERYTHING WAS ON THE TABLE in terms of fixing things. And that could very well be considered "unhinged" and included something you pointed out as "unhinged" about the players who are NOT here this year...

"The absence of Jacob Young and Myles Johnson is the most obvious difference in this team." - your recommended OnTheBanks column

So much of that piece can look "unhinged" now that the players and coaches have seemed to have fixed things.... but it was not "unhinged" then. All of it was entirely supportable by the cold hard facts of what we all witnessed.

So, independent as to whether you were aware of the Carnio article and independent of my motivation in responding to your calling out of the negative posters.. your content in this thread proves the hypocrisy that you desire to erase by establishing a scale of negativity that places you on the right side and those you call on on the wrong side of the equations.
Can you and numbers kiss and make up, so I can make my awesome vegetarian chili and not have to worry about you two knuckleheads? lol

;-)
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
And in 30 seconds you could have skimmed the basketball board before posting.

AND the points still remain true.. you created the thread title to taunt the critics based on Rutgers recent success.. admitted to that yourself.. then went on to explain your motivation was all the excessive negativity even though you participated in excessive negativity and only NOW.. after some good wins, did you not only find distaste for the critics but actually sought to tweak their noses with your posts.

My acknowledgment was of my motivation in responding to your post AFTER you admitted it was to stir things up. AND now you couldn't even let that alone.. you had to poke at it some more.

You do realize that one of your posts I quoted was where you went out of your way to agree with the OnTheBanks piece that said EVERYTHING WAS ON THE TABLE in terms of fixing things. And that could very well be considered "unhinged" and included something you pointed out as "unhinged" about the players who are NOT here this year...

"The absence of Jacob Young and Myles Johnson is the most obvious difference in this team." - your recommended OnTheBanks column

So much of that piece can look "unhinged" now that the players and coaches have seemed to have fixed things.... but it was not "unhinged" then. All of it was entirely supportable by the cold hard facts of what we all witnessed.

So, independent as to whether you were aware of the Carnio article and independent of my motivation in responding to your calling out of the negative posters.. your content in this thread proves the hypocrisy that you desire to erase by establishing a scale of negativity that places you on the right side and those you call on on the wrong side of the equations.
After a game, finding any older thread is very tough, plus I would've had to know to look for a thread like that, as opposed to you scanning for my posts would have been easy, so you're way off on that count.

And with regard to OnTheBanks, do you even realize that that is @dpwhite on this board, who completely agreed with my sentiments in this thread? Neither of us were "unhinged" post Lafeyette and never called for Pike's head - those are the folks we've been annoyed with, as have most posters. So off-base there too.

I also think the vast majority of posters on this board would have had no problems with my level of negativity post-Lafayette, especially since it's not like people called me out back then. You seem to be about the only one who has an issue with it (and only with me, but not dozens of other posters who said similar things back then) and won't let it go for reasons that are beyond me. This argument has gone way beyond tiresome, so feel free to continue it on your own if you like.
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
After a game, finding any older thread is very tough, plus I would've had to know to look for a thread like that, as opposed to you scanning for my posts would have been easy, so you're way off on that count.

And with regard to OnTheBanks, do you even realize that that is @dpwhite on this board, who completely agreed with my sentiments in this thread? Neither of us were "unhinged" post Lafeyette and never called for Pike's head - those are the folks we've been annoyed with, as have most posters. So off-base there too.

I also think the vast majority of posters on this board would have had no problems with my level of negativity post-Lafayette, especially since it's not like people called me out back then. You seem to be about the only one who has an issue with it (and only with me, but not dozens of other posters who said similar things back then) and won't let it go for reasons that are beyond me. This argument has gone way beyond tiresome, so feel free to continue it on your own if you like.
So dpwhite.. OnTheBanks.. agrees that his own column was not "unhinged".

Okay.

To be clear.. your use of "unhinged" as some imaginary designation that places yourself and dpwhite above those you wish to call out is arbitrary and self-serving.

My argument is that no one, especially Carino but also posters here, should not be calling out the critical posters from late November for any reason and should not be qualifying that by establishing some critics as "unhinged".

I do not know that dpwhite or OnTheBanks has called out anyone in that regard.

I should add.. when I saw this thread title I was fine with it.. even as I assigned it to be tweaking the "Fire Pike" thread people's noses. Because that is how absurdly better the team is playing now compared to late November. I found it as fine satire.

But then you went and tried to use it to make a serious point about the "negative" posters in a holier-than-thou moment. That is why I responded... because even though you did not know it, you were one of a few who had also tried to play that game about being better fans than those that were publicly negative in November.
 
Last edited:

dpwhite

All-American
Jan 21, 2003
3,017
7,350
103
So dpwhite.. OnTheBanks.. agrees that his own column was not "unhinged".

Okay.

To be clear.. your use of "unhinged" as some imaginary designation that places yourself and dpwhite above those you wish to call out is arbitrary and self-serving.

My argument is that no one, especially Carino but also posters here, should not be calling out the critical posters from late November for any reason and should be qualifying that by establishing some critics as "unhinged".

I do not know that dpwhite or OnTheBanks has called out anyone in that regard.

Now I’m confused. I think good ole is referring to OntheBanks the poster and Numbers is referring to the website.
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Now I’m confused. I think good ole is referring to OntheBanks the poster and Numbers is referring to the website.
He said it was one and the same.. not true? Did you write the article I quoted?

Please keep in mind.. I do not disagree with that article nor its tone. It was negative but justified imho. And even though there could be a game played as to what the proper degree of negativity was I don't think it is useful to do so.

Even the LIAR and Fire Pike threads.. ARGUABLE points that fans made. I disagreed with them both.. but. come on.. it is message board. If a few fans got to the point where they thought a change of head coach might be called for... why shouldn't they say so? In this case they were wrong... but similar fan-posters were right about Eddie Jordan, Flood and Ash (and may be right about CvS).

Why are people calling them out? Argue against their statements when they are made if you disagree.. but to do so months later.. because we are winning now.. why? Simply to stir up emotions? To have us all recall how bad things were in November? To feel better about being "good fans" as opposed to the "unhinged" fans?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

RUBOB72

All-American
Aug 5, 2004
23,385
7,924
0
Numbers for the love of all just let it go . It’s in the past as RH Jr. said . We all have times when people appear to be attacking us . Is it right …no but what hurts is when you , me , others want the last word as a symbol of victory. You won already nobody should do what some did.Steve Pikiell has once again shown himself to be pretty good as a coach. The team has looked much different than early on . I don’t think we will see a return to an offense where the left doesn’t know what the right is doing. Let’s just win the next game. Remember this site is no different than any other in the conference and most others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

dpwhite

All-American
Jan 21, 2003
3,017
7,350
103
He said it was one and the same.. not true? Did you write the article I quoted?

Please keep in mind.. I do not disagree with that article nor its tone. It was negative but justified imho. And even though there could be a game played as to what the proper degree of negativity was I don't think it is useful to do so.

Even the LIAR and Fire Pike threads.. ARGUABLE points that fans made. I disagreed with them both.. but. come on.. it is message board. If a few fans got to the point where they thought a change of head coach might be called for... why shouldn't they say so? In this case they were wrong... but similar fan-posters were right about Eddie Jordan, Flood and Ash (and may be right about CvS).

Why are people calling them out? Argue against their statements when they are made if you disagree.. but to do so months later.. because we are winning now.. why? Simply to stir up emotions? To have us all recall how bad things were in November? To feel better about being "good fans" as opposed to the "unhinged" fans?

Nope. I didn’t write that one.
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Who’s on first
Watching the UCONN - SHU game I was reminded of this... turns out UCONN has a player named.. "Akok Akok"

Lou: Who's that number 11 on UCONN?
Bud: That guy is Akok
Lou: I didn't ask if the guy was a cock, I asked you his name.
Bud: Akok Akok!
Lou: I heard you, that guy is a cock.
Bud: That's right. That guy is Akok.
Lou: Number eleven is a cock?
Bud: Akok Akok
Lou: Why is he a cock?
Bud: Well, that's what his parents called him.
Lou: His parent's call him a cock?
Bud: Yes.. everyone calls him Akok. Akok Akok.
.. etc
 

ancienthooper

All-Conference
Jan 16, 2019
1,212
2,848
113
The moving on will happen naturally don’t worry (with a few ball busters still busting balls where they can). And the media was pretty clear in saying it’s a minority. But I do think it’s worth pointing out that many people here acted like noobs. Like this was the first full season of hoops they ever watched. Like they had never seen a team struggle and turn it around. And the lack of loyalty and gratitude for the coaches and players that brought us two NCAA tourney worthy seasons in a row. So effing entitled.
Really think it's nothing more than the "unhinged" not liking being challenged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eagleton96
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano talks Penn State game week
  3. 03 The Knight Report Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half