Could this actually be Pike's best team?

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Way off base with this post, as you're mining posts from right after the worst loss of the Pike era and a loss as bad as any we've had in 10+ years.
THAT WAS THE POINT.

The same negative posts you are calling out were under the same conditions. You had many opportunities to profess your undying confidence and Pike and the players and the most serious post you made was to agree with the very negative OnTheBanks assessment of the situation.

I really cannot believe you are trying to wave this away by calling me "that guy" when "that guy" is exactly who you are being by calling out the negative posters while actually being one of them.
 
Last edited:

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
Could it be? I guess, there’s still a lot of time left. But it certainly hasn’t been so far. As always, people are waay overreacting to recent games instead of looking at all the data available. We are still well outside the bubble currently.
Agree, that we're still outside the bubble (implied in my first post), due to those 2 bad losses, but right now, we're playing at a very high level. Let's see if we can sustain it and win a few on the road.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FRA10Thunderbolt

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
THAT WAS THE POINT.

The same negative posts you are calling out were under the same conditions.
No, you've missed the point completely. Anyone who thinks my post-Lafeyette game thread or posts in that thread are anywhere near as negative as the crap we've seen on this board for weeks by some posters is delusional. They're not "the same negative posts" by a long shot and they continued well after that game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpwhite

needmorecowbell

Heisman
Oct 28, 2007
9,693
10,851
78
Who knows, but we've been playing at a really high level since the blowout at Illinois (I thought we played ok against SHU, but couldn't hit enough shots), winning our last 3 B1G games, including the huge win over #1 Purdue and a good win over UM and now a nice blowout win over Nebraska. If we just hadn't blown those two games to Lafayette and UMass, we'd be in the conversation for the bubble right now (would be 11-3/3-1 vs. 9-5/3-1). Yeah I know it doesn't work like that, but the point is we're certainly playing light years better than earlier in the year and now there's at least a path back to the tourney now, if we can finish out 0.500 to get to 18-13/11-9 (if we can get the Rider game back) - if we can do that, 1 win in the B1G tourney might be enough, but probably 2 would be needed. Quite a nice turnaround from where we were - very happy for the staff and the players.
They looked damn good today. I can see why Pike called this his best team.
 

nukem

All-Conference
Feb 3, 2003
2,169
4,780
113
No, you've missed the point completely. Anyone who thinks my post-Lafeyette game thread or posts in that thread are anywhere near as negative as the crap we've seen on this board for weeks by some posters is delusional. They're not "the same negative posts" by a long shot and they continued well after that game.
Didn't you retire from this board and swear you weren't coming back?
 

Scangg

Heisman
Mar 19, 2016
25,476
49,465
113
I've been all aboard the Pike train from the get go and a loud supporter. After the Illinois game I reached capitulation and posted some negative comments. They were well deserved though. We had multiple terrible losses and then embarrassed against Illinois. The team was looking disinterested playing with no defense or intensity.

I never called for Pike to be fired or anything though. Sometimes the team deserves criticism. It wasn't just one game it was a poor start game after game after game.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
If we get the next two wins by 8-12 points like I think we can...then truly, SEASON ON!!!
F that. Just win by 1! Win ugly! Get lucky!

In all seriousness….the hole we dug ourselves leaves us with little margin of error. Neither game is must win, but we can’t go 1-1.

Mark Phiilipousis or John Isner just put one down the T for a sick ace at 40-0 and we held serve impressively.

Cant get excited until I see how we do when we aren’t serving.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
THAT WAS THE POINT.

The same negative posts you are calling out were under the same conditions. You had many opportunities to profess your undying confidence and Pike and the players and the most serious post you made was to agree with the very negative OnTheBanks assessment of the situation.

I really cannot believe you are trying to wave this away by calling me "that guy" when "that guy" is exactly who you are being by calling out the negative posters while actually being one of them.
Call me out I have been pretty negative about this team. Quite frankly I gave up hope (still going to every game) #s has been a lot more positive than me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IL Lusciato

RUSeaGirtMA

Senior
Mar 8, 2011
515
586
0
Can’t really look back with this team and say ‘what if…’. They weren’t ready. It’s clearly a work in progress, growing as the season unfolds. Covid break helped immensely - silver lining. I do not see this team regressing - it will only get better as long as it avoids the injury bug.
 

RUnTeX

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2001
7,143
4,298
113
Digging deep for the Philippousis reference. He hasn’t been relevant in like 10-15 years. I like it though.
Tennis big server reference ftw. Greene Rice FIG has my attention...maybe a Greg Rusedski mention is in the works next? 😄
 
  • Like
Reactions: ClassOf02v.2

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
Can’t really look back with this team and say ‘what if…’. They weren’t ready. It’s clearly a work in progress, growing as the season unfolds. Covid break helped immensely - silver lining. I do not see this team regressing - it will only get better as long as it avoids the injury bug.
They will regress and then progress. Linear is not a thing.

past 2 years we had 2 stretches each where we were terrible and fans (as a whole) lost hope.
 

dpwhite

All-American
Jan 21, 2003
3,017
7,345
103
No, you've missed the point completely. Anyone who thinks my post-Lafeyette game thread or posts in that thread are anywhere near as negative as the crap we've seen on this board for weeks by some posters is delusional. They're not "the same negative posts" by a long shot and they continued well after that game.

Exactly. There’s a big difference between critical and unhinged and there was a lot of unhinged on here.
 

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
Call me out I have been pretty negative about this team. Quite frankly I gave up hope (still going to every game) #s has been a lot more positive than me.
But your negativism has generally been at least somewhat constructive and not mean-spirited, which is what I was referring to in talking about "negative posts/threads" but perhaps I wasn't clear enough. Also GOR likes to play "gotcha."
 

RU-ROCS

All-American
Feb 5, 2003
12,517
7,781
113
If they beat PSU and MD on the road, this may be Pike’s best team. But regardless this current team is nothing like the team that lost to Lafayette. We are 3-1 against pretty tough competition in the Big 10 and 1-1 in the Patriot league. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: IL Lusciato

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,100
182,110
113
Are we really going to have read these kind of threads after every win....or every loss

The constant calling out of posters or fanbase is negative and evil is insane......a very small number of posters posted really bad things...yet we keep hearing our media AMPLYFING nonsense about ALL OF THIS MESSAGE BOARD who turned on Pike blah blah blah. Look we ALL got analysis and stuff wrong, its a message board, it happens all the time.

guess what..we were AWFUL, early on, we almost lost to Lehigh and lost to some **** *** team Lafayette and then lost to to bad teams as well as being annihilated by Illinois

Yes we are a completely different team now but its revisionist history to say WE ALL KNEW WHAT WAS COMING and we are better than these other posters for being negative.. If RU loses the next couple of games, no one wants the negatoids coming in and saying SEE I TOLD YOU SO...that does not make for a fun board

GUESS WHAT, WE ARE ALL RUTGERS FANS HERE....LETS ENJOY THIS GREAT TURNAROUND NOW INSTEAD OF FIGHTING AND GIVING THE MEDIA ITS CLICKS

Notice that most of the really negative posters are not here posting,, why are you are worried so much about these people.


LET US MOVE ON FROM THIS
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
No, you've missed the point completely. Anyone who thinks my post-Lafeyette game thread or posts in that thread are anywhere near as negative as the crap we've seen on this board for weeks by some posters is delusional. They're not "the same negative posts" by a long shot and they continued well after that game.
Oh, I see. You get to determine the proper amount of negativity and retain the license to throw any other negative posters under the proverbial bus when you "get sick of the incessant negativism of some posters and the dozens of "sky is falling" threads we've had".

Got it.

You later admitted the thread title was meant to needle negative posters that were called out by Carino and others... while you never actually defended Pike explicitly at that time.

That means this whole thread, based on your OP, wasn't really about talking about Pike's best team.. but an effort to sarcastically call back a "fire Pike" thread.

Why?

Why do that?

Keep in mind... YOU are not a problem. Your negative posts were not a problem. But there is no need to call out the posts of people who were more negative than you were. It is childish... as is, I suppose, my pointing this out.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
Are we really going to have read these kind of threads after every win....or every loss

The constant calling out of posters or fanbase is negative and evil is insane......a very small number of posters posted really bad things...yet we keep hearing our media AMPLYFING nonsense about ALL OF THIS MESSAGE BOARD who turned on Pike blah blah blah. Look we ALL got analysis and stuff wrong, its a message board, it happens all the time.

guess what..we were AWFUL, early on, we almost lost to Lehigh and lost to some **** *** team Lafayette and then lost to to bad teams as well as being annihilated by Illinois

Yes we are a completely different team now but its revisionist history to say WE ALL KNEW WHAT WAS COMING and we are better than these other posters for being negative.. If RU loses the next couple of games, no one wants the negatoids coming in and saying SEE I TOLD YOU SO...that does not make for a fun board

GUESS WHAT, WE ARE ALL RUTGERS FANS HERE....LETS ENJOY THIS GREAT TURNAROUND NOW INSTEAD OF FIGHTING AND GIVING THE MEDIA ITS CLICKS

Notice that most of the really negative posters are not here posting,, why are you are worried so much about these people.


LET US MOVE ON FROM THIS

Well said.

And ill know the season has truly turned around once I start seeing your bracketology posts lol. Not quite there yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
I couldn't figure out why people seemed charged up about this thread and then I noticed the Carino thread from Wednesday and now I get some of it I guess. Didn't read the Carino thread until just now, as I haven't been on the hoops board since at least Tuesday: Wednesday I drove home from Vero Beach, Thursday was all day snowstorm tracking, which continued through the night into Friday late morning, after which I slept a lot and today I had disc golf in the morning in the snow. Anyway, awesome win and let's hope the team keeps playing well and claws its way back onto the bubble and maybe even into the tourney.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

willisneverrana43

All-American
Jul 26, 2001
11,103
7,111
113
Who knows, but we've been playing at a really high level since the blowout at Illinois (I thought we played ok against SHU, but couldn't hit enough shots), winning our last 3 B1G games, including the huge win over #1 Purdue and a good win over UM and now a nice blowout win over Nebraska. If we just hadn't blown those two games to Lafayette and UMass, we'd be in the conversation for the bubble right now (would be 11-3/3-1 vs. 9-5/3-1). Yeah I know it doesn't work like that, but the point is we're certainly playing light years better than earlier in the year and now there's at least a path back to the tourney now, if we can finish out 0.500 to get to 18-13/11-9 (if we can get the Rider game back) - if we can do that, 1 win in the B1G tourney might be enough, but probably 2 would be needed. Quite a nice turnaround from where we were - very happy for the staff and the players.
5 of the next 7 games are on the road, brother. We’re 0 and the season on the road this year. Let’s discuss this important point after that.
 

Luvscarletknights

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2018
3,953
4,712
113
Way off base with this post, as you're mining posts from right after the worst loss of the Pike era and a loss as bad as any we've had in 10+ years. People are going to be pretty upset after a loss like that (it's almost like citing posts from game threads, which we know are full of rants even by level-headed posters) and I bet you could find dozens of pretty negative posts from posters who aren't usually that negative, right after that game. And even then, it was clear that my first post was half in jest - do you actually think one loss would make me give up tickets after being a season ticket holder for 30+ years and after seeing far worse teams and coaches?

Also, none of my posts was anywhere near as negative as the many calling for Pike's head or saying some really horrible things about the team and players - I think few posters would put my post-Lafeyette thread in that category. IMO, only the 2nd post you cited was really negative and even in that one I left an out, i.e., "Unless Pike can work some miracles really fast this season is toast." But congrats for being "that guy" who mines old posts in some odd attempt to derail a thread.
No he is not off base. You had similar content elsewhere.

We had a loss...big deal...yes it is disappointing but I never thought to jump off a bridge or throw everyone on the team under a bus....
 
Last edited:

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
Oh, I see. You get to determine the proper amount of negativity and retain the license to throw any other negative posters under the proverbial bus when you "get sick of the incessant negativism of some posters and the dozens of "sky is falling" threads we've had".

Got it.

You later admitted the thread title was meant to needle negative posters that were called out by Carino and others... while you never actually defended Pike explicitly at that time.

That means this whole thread, based on your OP, wasn't really about talking about Pike's best team.. but an effort to sarcastically call back a "fire Pike" thread.

Why?

Why do that?

Keep in mind... YOU are not a problem. Your negative posts were not a problem. But there is no need to call out the posts of people who were more negative than you were. It is childish... as is, I suppose, my pointing this out.
Yes, I get to determine what I think and it's my opinion that there was incessant negativism of some posters during our bad run and that many threads and posts were over-the-top. I like how @dpwhite put it, as the difference between critical and unhinged. You're free to disagree.

Also, as I said a bit ago, I haven't been on the hoops board in days and never read the Carino thread and had no idea people had been arguing about this stuff for a few days. Thought I was just having a bit of fun with the thread title after a big win, but I absolutely believe that this team is capable of being as good as last year, as we're showing lately.

Lastly I defended Pike a ton when the posts started coming about how he should be fired. You're obviously skilled at digging up old posts - maybe post a few of those.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football PFF Grades + Snap Counts versus Nebraska
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers vs Penn State odds: Point spread released on Scarlet Knights, Nittany Lions
  3. 03 The Knight Report Football Every throw from Rutgers Football Quarterbacks versus Nebraska
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Nebraska Cornhuskers Edition - TKR Pod
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Nebraska Postgame Press Conference