Wimsatt and redshirt rules.

RUmaz

Junior
May 31, 2007
1,047
222
48
I believe there is some confusion on these rules but if I’m wrong please explain why.
Once a player joins the team he has 5 years to play in 4. If a player like Wimsatt plays in up to 4 games then this IS his redshirt year but not a year of eligibility, he would still have 4 to play 4 but no longer have a RS year available. If he were to play in 5 games then he would have 4 years left to play in 3 and maintain a RS year as you don’t have to redshirt as a freshman you can to it in any year. This won’t happen. He can’t as some have said preserve his RS this year unless he uses a year of eligibility by playing in 5 games. Again this will be his RS year. He will not play in 5 games and lose a year of eligibility. He will have 4 years to play in 4 after this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: camdenlawprof

RUmaz

Junior
May 31, 2007
1,047
222
48
Great, now explain to me the difference between redshirt,blueshirt green shirt and grey shirt?
Not my point. Just trying to figure out the confusing there is between a RS year and a year of eligibility. This year has to be one or the other.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JDNB

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,331
113
I believe there is some confusion on these rules but if I’m wrong please explain why.
Once a player joins the team he has 5 years to play in 4. If a player like Wimsatt plays in up to 4 games then this IS his redshirt year but not a year of eligibility, he would still have 4 to play 4 but no longer have a RS year available. If he were to play in 5 games then he would have 4 years left to play in 3 and maintain a RS year as you don’t have to redshirt as a freshman you can to it in any year. This won’t happen. He can’t as some have said preserve his RS this year unless he uses a year of eligibility by playing in 5 games. Again this will be his RS year. He will not play in 5 games and lose a year of eligibility. He will have 4 years to play in 4 after this season.
You are correct.

 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
I believe there is some confusion on these rules but if I’m wrong please explain why.
Once a player joins the team he has 5 years to play in 4. If a player like Wimsatt plays in up to 4 games then this IS his redshirt year but not a year of eligibility, he would still have 4 to play 4 but no longer have a RS year available. If he were to play in 5 games then he would have 4 years left to play in 3 and maintain a RS year as you don’t have to redshirt as a freshman you can to it in any year. This won’t happen. He can’t as some have said preserve his RS this year unless he uses a year of eligibility by playing in 5 games. Again this will be his RS year. He will not play in 5 games and lose a year of eligibility. He will have 4 years to play in 4 after this season.
Thank you for explaining these rules. What you say makes perfect sense: a player cannot redshirt twice. But he can redshirt in any year, not just his first year.
 

MLBash93

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2012
1,507
2,175
113
If he doesn't appear in 3 more games he can redshirt this year.

That being said given his prospect ranking and the fact he came here early. The hope is probably he goes to NFL at some point so we likely won't see him for a 4th season (year 5)
 
  • Like
Reactions: rurichdog

Doctor Worm

Heisman
Feb 7, 2002
31,314
23,272
113
And then there’s the medical redshirt angle…
Not really. If you play in only four games or less, you can take a redshirt year, regardless of the reason why you didn't play in the other games - medical reasons or otherwise.

The only time the medical angle comes into play is that if you miss the bulk of TWO years for documented medical reasons, the school can apply for a sixth year for you. No guarantee you'll get it.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,502
61,085
113
If he appears in 3 more games he can redshirt this year.

That being said given his prospect ranking and the fact he came here early. The hope is probably he goes to NFL at some point so we likely won't see him for a 4th season (year 5)
Fixed it for ya. He's played in 1 so far. Can play in up to 4 and still preserve a year of eligibility.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,331
113
Fixed it for ya. He's played in 1 so far. Can play in up to 4 and still preserve a year of eligibility.
So, what you are saying is, he can play in 3 games, get us to a bowl game, but not play in the bowl game he gets us into. Got it. 😏 :CHOP:
 

camps116

Redshirt
Oct 3, 2017
14
16
0
After seeing Vedral get blown up on countless plays vs Wisconsin I don't think they play Wimsat with this O line. Snaps in the last 3 games yes, but no one should expect him to start against Penn state.
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
Wimstatt has been in for exactly one play. It's hard for me to believe that he is ready to do much more than that, or that GS would want to risk Winsatt losing confidence in himself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plum Street

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
Not really. If you play in only four games or less, you can take a redshirt year, regardless of the reason why you didn't play in the other games - medical reasons or otherwise.

The only time the medical angle comes into play is that if you miss the bulk of TWO years for documented medical reasons, the school can apply for a sixth year for you. No guarantee you'll get it.
Thank you for explaining the medical redshirt rules. I've never been clear on how one can get the sixth year.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,502
61,085
113
After seeing Vedral get blown up on countless plays vs Wisconsin I don't think they play Wimsat with this O line. Snaps in the last 3 games yes, but no one should expect him to start against Penn state.
You're talking the best defense in the B1G(Wisconsin) also arguably the best defense in the entire country. To Indiana who has the worst defense in the B1G. Huge difference in the defense we are about to face. Not saying we're going to win, just you're not going to see what we saw last week.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,502
61,085
113
Wimstatt has been in for exactly one play. It's hard for me to believe that he is ready to do much more than that, or that GS would want to risk Winsatt losing confidence in himself.
There's no harm, no foul in giving him some spot time. You figure out which 5 to 6 plays he's best at and you bring him in on a 3rd down or as a change of pace. You still let Vedral take the lions share but let him get his feet wet and slowly build from there. If he's going to be our starter next year he needs to start seeing the speed of the game while being in the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plum Street

camps116

Redshirt
Oct 3, 2017
14
16
0
You're talking the best defense in the B1G(Wisconsin) also arguably the best defense in the entire country. To Indiana who has the worst defense in the B1G. Huge difference in the defense we are about to face. Not saying we're going to win, just you're not going to see what we saw last week.
Completely agreed. Just frustrating hearing boos and people saying to put in Wimsatt in the stadium the other day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: koleszar

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,502
61,085
113
Completely agreed. Just frustrating hearing boos and people saying to put in Wimsatt in the stadium the other day.
I hear ya.

I couldn't make this game, but my seatmate was texting me, "they better put the freshman in". I replied, "you know football better than that, he'd get killed against this defense". He said, " I know I'm just completely frustrated with this offense". A lot of people know better, they've just come to the point of desperation with this team. People want to see hope, they didn't get that for the last 3 home games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: camps116

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
There's no harm, no foul in giving him some spot time. You figure out which 5 to 6 plays he's best at and you bring him in on a 3rd down or as a change of pace. You still let Vedral take the lions share but let him get his feet wet and slowly build from there. If he's going to be our starter next year he needs to start seeing the speed of the game while being in the game.
I think that's right.

As it stands, Wimsatt is the future AND a recruiting tool. But if we put him back there and he fails badly... due to ANY reason.. even if it is not his fault at all.. the recruiting tool doesn't work so well and the future doesn't look as good. Worst case is he is good, but we are bad.. players he is trying to help recruit tell him no while telling him that he should enter the transfer portal.

Now I have to admit, I had been in the "nothing to lose" camp.. but there just might be something to lose. Less is more with Wimsatt right now, IMHO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plum Street

Mr_Twister

All-American
Apr 1, 2004
15,684
5,819
0
With the current transfer portal situation, worrying about redshirts is a small concern. Get your best players on the field. Rosters are a revolving door. And the notion that you need to stick with one QB (or any position for that matter) getting all the playing time is outdated and self-defeating.
 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
51,277
63,377
113
As it stands, Wimsatt is the future AND a recruiting tool. But if we put him back there and he fails badly... due to ANY reason.. even if it is not his fault at all.. the recruiting tool doesn't work so well and the future doesn't look as good.
I'm more concerned that we put him in when he's not ready, and he gets creamed by some Big Ten 300+ pound defensive lineman.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thegock

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
With the current transfer portal situation, worrying about redshirts is a small concern. Get your best players on the field. Rosters are a revolving door. And the notion that you need to stick with one QB (or any position for that matter) getting all the playing time is outdated and self-defeating.
Yes , agreed for the most part . If he was actually a true freshman with a competent surrounding cast , he would be playing . But that’s not the case
 

ruman

All-American
Nov 30, 2001
12,862
9,925
98
He can play 4 games - he has played one

He's good to go (not sure about a bowl game, but I think it counts)

He can sit if we make one
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
There's no harm, no foul in giving him some spot time. You figure out which 5 to 6 plays he's best at and you bring him in on a 3rd down or as a change of pace. You still let Vedral take the lions share but let him get his feet wet and slowly build from there. If he's going to be our starter next year he needs to start seeing the speed of the game while being in the game.
I have no problem with having Winsatt do 5 or 6 plays that he's learned perfectly. You're right that seeing the speed of the game would help him. But that's it. I would not want to risk putting him in a situation that might hurt his confidence.
 

Mr_Twister

All-American
Apr 1, 2004
15,684
5,819
0
You do understand he is basically a high school senior, who arrived after the season started. Not understanding that is mind numbing.
Captain Obvious … Who around here doesn’t know that? So you’re saying just dress him for games and have him stand on the sideline like a potted plant. The coaches are incapable of putting together a package that he can run?
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Captain Obvious … Who around here doesn’t know that? So you’re saying just dress him for games and have him stand on the sideline like a potted plant. The coaches are incapable of putting together a package that he can run?
Apparently you don't know that or understand it. All hands on deck?? How many snaps do you think he gets in practice as the 4th QB? How many plays does he know and practiced with the first team? You want the coaches to dedicate time for a 4th string QB instead of working with the starters on the weeks gameplay? And you are fine burning the redshirt on a kid that actually started this season in High School??
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plum Street

Mr_Twister

All-American
Apr 1, 2004
15,684
5,819
0
Apparently you don't know that or understand it. All hands on deck?? How many snaps do you think he gets in practice as the 4th QB? How many plays does he know and practiced with the first team? You want the coaches to dedicate time for a 4th string QB instead of working with the starters on the weeks gameplay? And you are fine burning the redshirt on a kid that actually started this season in High School??
What will you say if he bails out after this year? He was only a 4th stringer … if he’s only the 4th string QB, the coaches need to find a new line of work.
 

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
973
904
93
Apparently you don't know that or understand it. All hands on deck?? How many snaps do you think he gets in practice as the 4th QB? How many plays does he know and practiced with the first team? You want the coaches to dedicate time for a 4th string QB instead of working with the starters on the weeks gameplay? And you are fine burning the redshirt on a kid that actually started this season in High School??
You're not making sense. If they put together a plan to get him some in game snaps I'm pretty sure he would see increased practice snaps to prepare. High school or not he is still better right now than anyone on the roster and it's not even close
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU#1fan

PSU_Nut_rivals17625

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
14,642
2,610
113
You're not making sense. If they put together a plan to get him some in game snaps I'm pretty sure he would see increased practice snaps to prepare. High school or not he is still better right now than anyone on the roster and it's not even close
How many practices have you attended to know that. He may have the most potential or physical ability but that doesn’t mean he is the best qb. If he not mentally ready physical ability and potential is worthless. It hard enough for a true freshman to be ready with a full summer and camp to prepare let alone joining the team mid season.

The reality is that the kid simply not ready for a big role. The coaches want to win and are not going to bench him for no reason. He simply not ready to handle more. That is ok and normal.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  5. 05 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics