Wimsatt and redshirt rules.

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
973
904
93
How many practices have you attended to know that. He may have the most potential or physical ability but that doesn’t mean he is the best qb. If he not mentally ready physical ability and potential is worthless. It hard enough for a true freshman to be ready with a full summer and camp to prepare let alone joining the team mid season.

The reality is that the kid simply not ready for a big role. The coaches want to win and are not going to bench him for no reason. He simply not ready to handle more. That is ok and normal.
I saw more in 1 play from him than the other QB's combined all season. That was more than just talent....he displayed poise, pocket awareness, decision making, accuracy in addition to physical ability. Like i wrote previously, give him more practice reps to prepare him for the game plan and let him play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GoodOl'Rutgers

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
I saw more in 1 play from him than the other QB's combined all season. That was more than just talent....he displayed poise, pocket awareness, decision making, accuracy in addition to physical ability. Like i wrote previously, give him more practice reps to prepare him for the game plan and let him play.
You know all that from one play? A play that he probably got to practice again and again? (It was clearly a designed play to have him roll to the right and throw all the way to the left.) That is what we academics call "hyperbole."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jimpeg and WhiteBus

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
973
904
93
You know all that from one play? A play that he probably got to practice again and again? (It was clearly a designed play to have him roll to the right and throw all the way to the left.) That is what we academics call "hyperbole."
Isn't it ironic that you question what I know from one play, yet in your very next sentence state what you "clearly" believe you know from the very same play??? For a so-called academic, you should know that us commonsense having individuals call that "hypocrisy"
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
Isn't it ironic that you question what I know from one play, yet in your very next sentence state what you "clearly" believe you know from the very same play??? For a so-called academic, you should know that us commonsense having individuals call that "hypocrisy"
C'mon . . . you really think GS sent him out there for his first play without a design? Numerous posts have outlined the play; it's a one-receiver play. It's very exceptional. Even if it had been a more normal play, it's only one play.
 
Last edited:

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
You know all that from one play? A play that he probably got to practice again and again? (It was clearly a designed play to have him roll to the right and throw all the way to the left.) That is what we academics call "hyperbole."
You saw the play, right? It was not a "clean" play.. Pacheco picked up an outside blitz that Wimsatt SAW and stepped inside of.. did not panic.. showed control.. was beginning to run and saw he was going to be cut off.. he did not abandon the option to pass in favor of just taking off... not without knowing where he had to get to and what defenders were on their way to stop him.... he then got his body and feet into a position to throw while watching Melton scramble across the field to give him a target.

It was quite a play for a 4th and 5 and, yes, he did very well. Maybe he can have practiced all the things that came up during that play.. but I doubt it.

Maybe this is a case of you not SEEING what was right in front of you?

I am not saying Wimsatt has to play now. I have explained while it might be best he did not elsewhere. And that was mostly we can recruit off his availability next year without risking putting him out there too early and his failing (which might not be his fault at this point). But I really liked that play and would love to see him in spot play.. a series here or there.. a play here or there.. nothing where he'd have to carry the team (or have the results on his shoulders).

You should also consider watching some of his HS game tapes and recognizing why he was so highly ranked as a recruit. You might then see he is perfect for what Gleeson wants to do here and no one else we have on the roster is. Think of it this way.. if we ran a wishbone as someone here suggests.. we'd recruit QBs who ran options in HS.. and wishbones if possible. That's what Wimsatt is to Gleeson's system. The right fit.
 
Last edited:

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
You saw the play, right? It was not a "clean" play.. Pacheco picked up an outside blitz that Wimsatt SAW and stepped inside of.. did not panic.. showed control.. was beginning to run and saw he was going to be cut off.. he did not abandon the option to pass in favor of just taking off... not without knowing where he had to get to and what defenders were on their way to stop him.... he then got his body and feet into a position to throw while watching Melton scramble across the field to give him a target.

It was quite a play for a 4th and 5 and, yes, he did very well. Maybe he can have practiced all the things that came up during that play.. but I doubt it.

Maybe this is a case of you not SEEING what was right in front of you?

I am not saying Wimsatt has to play now. I have explained while it might be best he did not elsewhere. And that was mostly we can recruit off his availability next year without risking putting him out there too early and his failing (which might not be his fault at this point). But I really liked that play and would love to see him in spot play.. a series here or there.. a play here or there.. nothing where he'd have to carry the team (or have the results on his shoulders).

You should also consider watching some of his HS game tapes and recognizing why he was so highly ranked as a recruit. You might then see he is perfect for what Gleeson wants to do here and no one else we have on the roster is. Think of it this way.. if we ran a wishbone as someone here suggests.. we'd recruit QBs who ran options in HS.. and wishbones if possible. That's what Wimsatt is to Gleeson's system. The right fit.
I don't think anyone disagrees with you that spot play would be a great idea. Nor do I disagree that there were good reasons he was highly ranked as a recruit. He has a great deal of potential. That doesn't mean he is our best quarterback right now. BTW, I have looked at the video over and over again, and I disagree that he was beginning to run. He rolls to his right and keeps rolling until he is ready to throw the ball.
 
Last edited:

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
973
904
93
C'mon . . . you really think GS sent him out there for his first play without a design? Numerous posts have outlined the play; it's a one-receiver play. It's very exceptional. Even if it had been a more normal play, it's only one play.
You do know this is football right? In football EVERY play is designed and practiced. Sitkowski had designed plays, Snyder has designed plays, Simon has designed plays, and Vedral has designed plays. The player still has to execute the play even when things don't go exactly as designed. Wimsatt did exactly that.
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,980
10,159
58
You do know this is football right? In football EVERY play is designed and practiced. Sitkowski had designed plays, Snyder has designed plays, Simon has designed plays, and Vedral has designed plays. The player still has to execute the play even when things don't go exactly as designed. Wimsatt did exactly that.
It is a play with one possible receiver. So it doesn't tell you much about how well Wimsatt would do in more usual pass plays. So as well as Wimsatt did, the play is not an adequate basis for concluding that he is currrently our best quarterback, although we all certainly hope he turns out that way. BTW, what is your basis for thinking that the play didn't go "exactly as designed?"

BTW, I find it amusing that you first attack me for saying it was clearly a designed play, and then you say that it was a designed play. You're just desperate to make the point you want to.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: PSU_Nut_rivals17625

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
973
904
93
It is a play with one possible receiver. So it doesn't tell you much about how well Wimsatt would do in more usual pass plays. So as well as Wimsatt did, the play is not an adequate basis for concluding that he is currrently our best quarterback, although we all certainly hope he turns out that way. BTW, what is your basis for thinking that the play didn't go "exactly as designed?"

BTW, I find it amusing that you first attack me for saying it was clearly a designed play, and then you say that it was a designed play. You're just desperate to make the point you want to.

I attacked you and I'm desperate to make a point lol. Anyway my thoughts and opinion on this "one play" is just as valid as yours. I'm sure when they designed the play they anticipated a blitzing cornerback on a free run to the QB
 

RutgersDom

All-American
Nov 18, 2003
6,164
7,550
113
You're not making sense. If they put together a plan to get him some in game snaps I'm pretty sure he would see increased practice snaps to prepare. High school or not he is still better right now than anyone on the roster and it's not even close
everyone needs to pump the brakes on Gavin...We think he is better, we don't know. He threw one pass! What if his next two throws were picks and we lose the game. Everyone would say we blew a chance at a bowl! Let's get him what we can in 2 out of the next 3 (Hopefully) games and he doesn't blow his red shirt as that would be silly.
 

rob kight

All-American
Oct 22, 2020
5,067
6,477
113
The bowl game does count towards redshirt eligibility. So with Vedral’s health an issue, I think it was a mistake to put Gavin in the Indiana game when we were sure to win. Should have used Evan or Cole. Now Gavin can only play in 2 of 3 if we become bowl eligible to preserve redshirt. If Noah gets hurt early in Penn State game, who do you play?
 

Doctor Worm

Heisman
Feb 7, 2002
31,314
23,272
113
The bowl game does count towards redshirt eligibility. So with Vedral’s health an issue, I think it was a mistake to put Gavin in the Indiana game when we were sure to win. Should have used Evan or Cole. Now Gavin can only play in 2 of 3 if we become bowl eligible to preserve redshirt. If Noah gets hurt early in Penn State game, who do you play?
Snyder or Simon. Regardless of Wimsatt's RS status. Do not assume that because Wimsatt got garbage time mop-up duty, he is now the #2 QB.
 

kapyoche

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2010
5,151
1,509
0
He is gone in two years. He will either go Pro or Portal. I do not see him playing here for more than two years (not counting this year).
 

Doctor Worm

Heisman
Feb 7, 2002
31,314
23,272
113
He is gone in two years. He will either go Pro or Portal. I do not see him playing here for more than two years (not counting this year).
I'll sign up right now for a Wimsatt three-and-out to the NFL. But why do you see him headed for the portal?
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  5. 05 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics