Rate our recruiting class

thegock

All-Conference
Jul 30, 2012
2,099
1,630
113
In the context of the history of RUTGERS football, probably 8.5 or more. Look at the class compared to Flood's disaster, or the pre Schiano years.

For where we are right now, probably a 7 or so. We need DL (especially) and OL in this class and next year.
 

RU-Nation

All-American
Sep 8, 2011
1,938
9,254
83
At this very moment I would say a 7. But depending on how the DL recruiting plays out, this grade will change.
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Depends on perspective, as a lot of posters have already pointed out.

Based on our recent history? 8
Based on expectations of this class coming into this season? 8
Based on overall comparison to FBS? 6
Based on comparison to conference? 4
Based on comparison to division? 2
Based on the level of recruiting we need to get back to a bowl game? 5
 

RUschool

Heisman
Jan 23, 2004
49,960
14,044
78
I think the QBs are huge especially if one of the them is the”One”. A very good QB can win 2-3 games by himself.

Overall, I hope Ash is getting more quality recruits.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRZEER

Kbee3

Heisman
Aug 23, 2002
43,724
35,255
0
RU's 2018 class is currently rated #42 by Rivals.
These are the years when Rutgers had a more highly rated class: 2007 (#37), 2009 (#38), 2011 (#32), 2012 (#24)
The 2006 class was also rated #42.
These are the years when RU had a weaker class....as per Rivals rankings: 2017 (#43), 2016 (#78), 2015 (#53), 2014 (#57), 2013 (#45), 2010 (#64), 2008 (#46), 2005 (#68), 2004 (#52), 2003 (#45), 2002 (#46)
So, it looks like the 2018 class would rank in the top third of Rutgers recruiting classes since 2002....which is as far back as this site goes BTW.
Ash's two classes have been rated #42 and #43.....which isn't bad unless you thought he was gonna out-recruit the elite teams right away.
There's plenty of progress to be made in recruiting here, but his first two classes aren't too shabby.
 

RUwoz

All-Conference
Jul 20, 2014
3,266
1,982
0
RU's 2018 class is currently rated #42 by Rivals.
These are the years when Rutgers had a more highly rated class: 2007 (#37), 2009 (#38), 2011 (#32), 2012 (#24)
The 2006 class was also rated #42.
These are the years when RU had a weaker class....as per Rivals rankings: 2017 (#43), 2016 (#78), 2015 (#53), 2014 (#57), 2013 (#45), 2010 (#64), 2008 (#46), 2005 (#68), 2004 (#52), 2003 (#45), 2002 (#46)
So, it looks like the 2018 class would rank in the top third of Rutgers recruiting classes since 2002....which is as far back as this site goes BTW.
Ash's two classes have been rated #42 and #43.....which isn't bad unless you thought he was gonna out-recruit the elite teams right away.
There's plenty of progress to be made in recruiting here, but his first two classes aren't too shabby.
The problem is while we get (slightly) better, our yearly competitors got MUCH better. Yes Ohio State has always and will always be solid, and Michigan is Michigan, but MSU and Maryland have now done really well and PSU is top 5 in the country. We don’t have to be the best, but need to be closer
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,612
61,946
113
Pretty sure the OP asked us to RATE OUR CLASS...not to "rate it against other classes" or "rate it based on our division"...so, towards that I give it a 7 as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaRU102

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
Pretty sure the OP asked us to RATE OUR CLASS...not to "rate it against other classes" or "rate it based on our division"...so, towards that I give it a 7 as well.
My wife is a 10 to me. Refuse to rate her against anyone else. Think we all need to stop comparing us to the Jones. Will this class make us better? Absolutely.
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Pretty sure the OP asked us to RATE OUR CLASS...not to "rate it against other classes" or "rate it based on our division"...so, towards that I give it a 7 as well.

I just have trouble rating anything in a vacuum. If someone asked to "rate Eli Manning", you'd have to make some assumption as to the parameters.... among QBs all time? among active QBs? this season only? just his last game? Among overall #1 draft picks?

This was a good Rutgers class, but a poor Big Ten East class. This was a class that was ahead of my 2017 expectation, but behind our needs if we're going to compete for bowls.
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
My wife is a 10 to me. Refuse to rate her against anyone else. Think we all need to stop comparing us to the Jones. Will this class make us better? Absolutely.

The problem is, your wife doesn't have to go out and compete against the Joneses 12 times a year. Our football team does. If we keep bringing in "very good" Rutgers classes rated around 38-40, we'll be facing ~7 conference teams each year that have out recruited us.

This was a very good class in a year where a lot of the top NJ talent was already headed out of state no matter what we did, and coming off a 2-10 season in 2016. It will make us better, but 2019 needs to be better and 2020 better still, if we're going to start seeing regular bowl bids again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSU_Nut_rivals17625

kapyoche

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2010
5,151
1,509
0
The only one that matters is how we stack up against our competition: BIG East. On that basis this class rating is 1.
I don't see us getting better than our competition so how could rate this class any higher.
Nothing against the kids. They are going to work hard but we are not getting past Tier3 status with this recruiting class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUaMoose_rivals

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
My wife is a 10 to me. Refuse to rate her against anyone else. Think we all need to stop comparing us to the Jones. Will this class make us better? Absolutely.
Post pictures, and we can do it for you. :grimace:

The problem is, your wife doesn't have to go out and compete against the Joneses 12 times a year. Our football team does.
How do you know, maybe RUBird is "keeping up" with the Jones?
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,612
61,946
113
I just have trouble rating anything in a vacuum. If someone asked to "rate Eli Manning", you'd have to make some assumption as to the parameters.... among QBs all time? among active QBs? this season only? just his last game? Among overall #1 draft picks?

This was a good Rutgers class, but a poor Big Ten East class. This was a class that was ahead of my 2017 expectation, but behind our needs if we're going to compete for bowls.

I get it but it's not what the OP asked that's all I'm saying. We already know exactly where it stands in the Big Ten East (for better or worse), right?
 

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
To complete for Bowl games.

We need to be ranked higher than most of the Big Ten West

We play 3 OOC games every year

We play 3 B1G West teams every year

We will never have OSU, UM and PSU level classes, that has never happen at Rutgers before.

But I think we can have classes in the 30's every year and maybe crack the top 25 once and a while.

Who knows what the future holds, but so far it is a better than Flood so it moving in the right direction.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,612
61,946
113
We don’t play against ourselves, we play others

Still not the point. He asked to RATE OUR CLASS not to "rank our class in comparison with our peers." Verus our peers, the Big Ten East, we come in 7th per Rivals (literally tied with IU at 2.78 average stars, however) and currently 43rd nationally. This isn't up for argument, it is what it is, right? Scout has us at 42 slightly above IU but, let's be real, there's no difference between the 2 classes.

Anyway I'm not sure why people can't just do what the OP asks and "rate our class." Oh well.
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
The problem is, your wife doesn't have to go out and compete against the Joneses 12 times a year. Our football team does. If we keep bringing in "very good" Rutgers classes rated around 38-40, we'll be facing ~7 conference teams each year that have out recruited us.

This was a very good class in a year where a lot of the top NJ talent was already headed out of state no matter what we did, and coming off a 2-10 season in 2016. It will make us better, but 2019 needs to be better and 2020 better still, if we're going to start seeing regular bowl bids

My point is you never know what will happen to other teams. We also won’t have top 25 classes coming off losing seasons. It doesn’t happen that way. You hope someone like Artur can be a verbal leader and get some 4 star recruits to buy in.
I would much rather enjoy and support our new players rather than gripe that we are not in the upper tier( just yet)
 

snowboarder

All-Conference
Aug 3, 2004
1,001
1,094
113
5
Not enough power offers overall
Top player from NJ is at #15 in Rivals
Schiano's last year in 2012
8 of NJs top 15 and 2 of PAs top 10 with no league affiliation to help us then.
You have to look at who we play every year
Big Ten East has five teams in the top 25
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
[Roughly two weeks ago Artur was a 4 star which would have meant our class rating would be higher? Does if matter? Artur did not get to be a “worse” player in that period of time.? Enjoy the class
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
My point is you never know what will happen to other teams. We also won’t have top 25 classes coming off losing seasons. It doesn’t happen that way. You hope someone like Artur can be a verbal leader and get some 4 star recruits to buy in.
I would much rather enjoy and support our new players rather than gripe that we are not in the upper tier( just yet)

Maryland finished 6-7 last year and signed the #18 class. This year they finished 4-8 and have the (currently rated) #19 class coming in.

This year, looking at the Top 30 recruiting rankings for teams with losing records:
#15 Florida (4-7)
#19 Maryland (4-8)
#22 Baylor (1-11)
#26 Tennessee (4-8)
#30 Minnesota (5-7)

Last year, six of the Top 30 classes had finished with losing records, too.

2019 Needs to be a Top 30 class if we're going to start progressing in the win column. When 5 of our divisional opponents have four year average rankings better than 35th, the 6th is even with us, and 4/7 of the teams in the West are ahead of us.... that's 6+ conference games every year where we're in a talent hole at the coin toss, and 2 more where it's a toss up. The margin of error to get to 6 wins becomes razor thin.

If we can't start pulling in Top 30 classes with 4- or 5-win seasons, we may never do it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zazoo2002

NickyNewark51

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2015
2,729
1,000
0
Pretty vanilla and the shortage of LM and headliners I'd say a solid 6 and hope we stock up on DL/OL/LB next year and hope they develop quick !!
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
Maryland finished 6-7 last year and signed the #18 class. This year they finished 4-8 and have the (currently rated) #19 class coming in.

This year, looking at the Top 30 recruiting rankings for teams with losing records:
#15 Florida (4-7)
#19 Maryland (4-8)
#22 Baylor (1-11)
#26 Tennessee (4-8)
#30 Minnesota (5-7)

Last year, six of the Top 30 classes had finished with losing records, too.

2019 Needs to be a Top 30 class if we're going to start progressing in the win column. When 5 of our divisional opponents have four year average rankings better than 35th, the 6th is even with us, and 4/7 of the teams in the West are ahead of us.... that's 6+ conference games every year where we're in a talent hole at the coin toss, and 2 more where it's a toss up. The margin of error to get to 6 wins becomes razor thin.

If we can't start pulling in Top 30 classes with 4- or 5-win seasons, we may never do it.
Florida and Tenn. are doing it based off being a big name school. Baylor is doing it off if $
 

BeantownKnight

All-Conference
Feb 14, 2008
4,674
2,023
0
So, I guess no additional players have committed since Wednesday? Coach Ash said in his press conference then that there might be another one or two players this week.
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Florida and Tenn. are doing it based off being a big name school. Baylor is doing it off if $

And Maryland and Minnesota, our conference mates, who jumped into the Top 30 off of losing seasons, one from our own division who did it twice?

What I'm saying is it's possible, and has been shown to happen by a non-Big Name school in our own division. And if we don't start doing it soon, we'll be perennially duking it out with Indiana for last in the division... and hoping for luck in the cross-division lottery to get to 6 wins and a bowl.
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
And Maryland and Minnesota, our conference mates, who jumped into the Top 30 off of losing seasons, one from our own division who did it twice?

What I'm saying is it's possible, and has been shown to happen by a non-Big Name school in our own division. And if we don't start doing it soon, we'll be perennially duking it out with Indiana for last in the division... and hoping for luck in the cross-division lottery to get to 6 wins and a bowl.
I agree it is possible but much harder than most think. We are not a big named school and thank heavens we run a clean program and will never get caught up in $. We still have to look years from now to see not only if our class but Maryland, Minn. etc etc classes pan out
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,745
151,578
113
My wife is a 10 to me. Refuse to rate her against anyone else. Think we all need to stop comparing us to the Jones. Will this class make us better? Absolutely.

If we get better and still lose, does it really matter? You can’t rate a class without considering it against our peers. That’s who we compete with. Games are won in the trenches. We didn’t do nearly enough there. Hope we land some or Ash better turn into Lombardi.
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
If we get better and still lose, does it really matter? You can’t rate a class without considering it against our peers. That’s who we compete with. Games are won in the trenches. We didn’t do nearly enough there. Hope we land some or Ash better turn into Lombardi.
No team wins or loses based on the ranking of their recruits. Wins happen based on many things, type of recruits only being one thing. Coaching, staying healthy, breaks etc etc lead to wins
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod