the elephant in the room

Yeah Baby

All-American
Aug 14, 2001
19,261
6,466
0
It's been demonstrated that any ball Bolin throws more than 10 yards probably isn't going where we want it to go.

Kill's offensive strategy has to recognize that constraint.

Hopefully Gio can last the rest of the season.
Fans said that about Teel as well. Go figure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATIOH

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,770
151,629
113
That's basically how Schiano viewed it, too. He always saw the best defense as keeping the opposing offense off the field.

This is true. But the one area GS differs is from all of the conservative don't beat yourself on offense play we saw from him, on D he was very aggressive and his blitz schemes seemed to be very innovative. We were constantly getting unblocked shots on QB's. I see very little of that from Ash. Even when we blitz it seems to almost always get picked up easily. That isn't a talent thing. It's a scheme thing.

One of the not so great things getting a coach from the OSU's of the world is they had more talent than 95% of the teams they play. You teach the same guy,one more talented than the other, the same things, it won't be the same output on the field.

Ash is a newbie. Hopefully as he continues to coach, like we saw with GS, he matures and realizes he can't beat the OSU's of the world playing same way and using the same philosophy they do. Unless he gets those types of players, which isn't happening. That's the only way we are going to win.

But even then, I think running clock and playing a boring brand of football is just simply how he views the game of football.
 

needmorecowbell

Heisman
Oct 28, 2007
9,699
10,878
78
As an announcer said earlier in season, Kill is a fundamentals guy vs a schemer.

He beats you with solid coaching, not necessarily unique out of the box playcalling.

I prefer that.

Sure, it's a little vanilla right now, but where it's really exciting is just compare how upright our QB is this year. We're not taking many sacks. Watch how he actually uses RBs and TEs in protection, something DM brainlessly never did in favor of crazy plays. We have a developing running game, a TE passing game, and he does try to get the ball into different playmaker hands.

Most importantly, the line is showing improvement. This is where Kill is going to make us a better team a year from now, by coaching these guys up.

I think Kill is smart enough to know what we have, and if you can grind out the clock, you can stick in a game until the 4th. Which unlike last year, has been true in every game this season except for OSU, who's on another level and benefitted from our entire secondary going down with injuries in-game.

These next 6 games will hopefully confirm Kill's progression, not necessarily in W/L but improvement in fundamentals and ironing out a good team for 2018.
Well said. If anyone has watched Minnesota play while he was there, they never wowed anyone just moved the ball and never beat themselves.
 

nikoru09

All-Conference
May 2, 2016
1,987
1,729
113
As an announcer said earlier in season, Kill is a fundamentals guy vs a schemer.

He beats you with solid coaching, not necessarily unique out of the box playcalling.

I prefer that.

Sure, it's a little vanilla right now, but where it's really exciting is just compare how upright our QB is this year. We're not taking many sacks. Watch how he actually uses RBs and TEs in protection, something DM brainlessly never did in favor of crazy plays. We have a developing running game, a TE passing game, and he does try to get the ball into different playmaker hands.

Most importantly, the line is showing improvement. This is where Kill is going to make us a better team a year from now, by coaching these guys up.

I think Kill is smart enough to know what we have, and if you can grind out the clock, you can stick in a game until the 4th. Which unlike last year, has been true in every game this season except for OSU, who's on another level and benefitted from our entire secondary going down with injuries in-game.

These next 6 games will hopefully confirm Kill's progression, not necessarily in W/L but improvement in fundamentals and ironing out a good team for 2018.
ditto that
 

mychaljohn

Junior
May 16, 2003
2,582
347
0
This is true. But the one area GS differs is from all of the conservative don't beat yourself on offense play we saw from him, on D he was very aggressive and his blitz schemes seemed to be very innovative. We were constantly getting unblocked shots on QB's. I see very little of that from Ash. Even when we blitz it seems to almost always get picked up easily. That isn't a talent thing. It's a scheme thing.

One of the not so great things getting a coach from the OSU's of the world is they had more talent than 95% of the teams they play. You teach the same guy,one more talented than the other, the same things, it won't be the same output on the field.

Ash is a newbie. Hopefully as he continues to coach, like we saw with GS, he matures and realizes he can't beat the OSU's of the world playing same way and using the same philosophy they do. Unless he gets those types of players, which isn't happening. That's the only way we are going to win.

But even then, I think running clock and playing a boring brand of football is just simply how he views the game of football.
To be fair, we weren't really getting all those exciting cornerback and safety sacks in 2002.
 

PhilaPhans

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2005
11,665
4,334
0
Everybody knew what we were getting with Kill. Run, run, run the ball. That's his Minnesota style. And with the players we have, it makes sense. The problem is that running the ball isn't sexy. Scoring points is. (Don't get me wrong, 35 vs any B1G team is fine by me.) We look absolutely awful passing the ball, so I don't understand why the other team doesn't stack the box with like 9 guys.

But I think the question goes further back to whether a guy like Scott Frost would have been a better option than a guy like Chris Ash. Would you rather have that offensive minded HC or a defensive minded HC? And with either one, can you bring in that top guy on the other side of the ball. Like how PSU did with Joe Moorhead. Has Ash done enough with program building, recruiting, and the D to be happy with the hire so far (record aside for this argument). I'm OK with Kill, given our budget and everything. Former successful head coach to help out Ash. Etc. We tried to do it with Mehringer from JMU, but that didn't work because he was TOO green and timid and I think was only a co-OC there after being a WR coach at Houston. While we struck out there, it was a much different hire than a Kill. Down the line though, we've got to make a splash with our OC if Ash is still here.
 

knightfan7

Heisman
Jul 30, 2003
97,531
71,244
113
Exactly. Never heard anybody outside of this board call him an offensive guru.

Of course, on ScarletNation, we wax poetic about every coach until they coach a single down. Then they’re all bums.

Why should coaches be treated any different than players lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUSK97
A

anon_xekqhstck0ygt

Guest
RU scored 35, and had a couple really costly TO's that might have kept point off the scoreboard.

Thought Gio's fumble his elbow hit the ground, not much mention of it that I've seen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AreYouNUTS

RUScrew85

Heisman
Nov 7, 2003
30,054
16,939
0
it always seems as if we are playing to keep the score close rather than to win. saying the play calling is predictable is an understatement. Is Jerry Kill's reputation as some kind of offensive guru deserved?

We are overmatched v. the B1G on talent and depth. The intention this season is to shorten the game - runs, short passes. Keep the clock moving so our guys don't get too worn out.
 

FanuSanu52

All-Conference
Nov 8, 2011
11,256
4,618
0
Everybody knew what we were getting with Kill. Run, run, run the ball. That's his Minnesota style. And with the players we have, it makes sense. The problem is that running the ball isn't sexy. Scoring points is. (Don't get me wrong, 35 vs any B1G team is fine by me.) We look absolutely awful passing the ball, so I don't understand why the other team doesn't stack the box with like 9 guys.

But I think the question goes further back to whether a guy like Scott Frost would have been a better option than a guy like Chris Ash. Would you rather have that offensive minded HC or a defensive minded HC? And with either one, can you bring in that top guy on the other side of the ball. Like how PSU did with Joe Moorhead. Has Ash done enough with program building, recruiting, and the D to be happy with the hire so far (record aside for this argument). I'm OK with Kill, given our budget and everything. Former successful head coach to help out Ash. Etc. We tried to do it with Mehringer from JMU, but that didn't work because he was TOO green and timid and I think was only a co-OC there after being a WR coach at Houston. While we struck out there, it was a much different hire than a Kill. Down the line though, we've got to make a splash with our OC if Ash is still here.

Why do we have to make a splash?

I liked what I saw on O Saturday - actually got a glimpse of what it is this staff wants to do. Winning is sexy, don't care of it's by 50 points or 3. In fact, the latter is probably preferable, and I don't find those 65 to 58 B12 games sexy at all. In fact, I find that whole conference borderline unwatchable. While we can't seem to pull in a game-changing QB to save our life, RB has long been a position of strength and has been the entire time Ash has been here. So why wouldn't we lean hard on the run?

Question will be can we recruit and develop the type of OL talent and depth we need to run this O against a B1G schedule. If not, don't know Ash will get the chance at hiring a splashy OC. I would go for an offensive-minded staff next go around, though.
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,452
13,341
113
We are overmatched v. the B1G on talent and depth. The intention this season is to shorten the game - runs, short passes. Keep the clock moving so our guys don't get too worn out.

When are we not going to be overmatched vs. OSU/UM/PSU? Does Ash just wait to try and win those games?

At some point you need to play to win the game. The reality is that we are a mid-major program playing in a major league. We need to gameplan around that on offense.

Our "run run run" offense has won us exactly nothing in 11 years.
 

RUScrew85

Heisman
Nov 7, 2003
30,054
16,939
0
When are we not going to be overmatched vs. OSU/UM/PSU? Does Ash just wait to try and win those games?

At some point you need to play to win the game. The reality is that we are a mid-major program playing in a major league. We need to gameplan around that on offense.

Our "run run run" offense has won us exactly nothing in 11 years.
It shorten's games so our overmatched guys have something left in the tank after B1G game 4. Just telling you what I've heard from sources.

I think the plan will changes as the player's talent and strength improve.
 

Yeah Baby

All-American
Aug 14, 2001
19,261
6,466
0
Teel was definitely more accurate than anything we've seen from Kyle Bolin this season.
The knock on Teel, especially here on this board was his lack of accuracy and touch on short passes. Bolin is more like Hart who many on this board loved. Teel had a big strong arm and made the most plays downfield with only Nova coming close in that category. All of our STARTINg QB's have received extreme criticism on this board even when we win, but especially when we lose. The backup is always the best QB we have ever had. Same **** different year.

Also every HC and OC get the same treatment here and probably in every fantasy. Mike Leach gets criticized for his Defenses LOL but not his offense. You know what's wrong with his defenses? They're on the field too much and are often in bad field position because he will go for it on 4th and anything from anywhere.

When you play our style every QB mistake is magnified. When you throw the ball all over the field each mistake is less scrutinized because you have 30 more chances to make a good play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knightmoves

Yeah Baby

All-American
Aug 14, 2001
19,261
6,466
0
Completely agree - that was almost a text book case of the ground causing a fumble. Horrible call in my book.
I like to argue every bad call, especially when we lose and not at all when we win. That one was a fumble IMO because it started to move just before he hit. You could see it on one angle and it was caused by the smack on the knee from the LBs helmet. My only criticism there is to keep his feet but he plays like that and his energy helped the team win.

Martin's fumble was a great play by the corner or safety who came from nowhere and threw his body into the ball. Martin could have secured that ball better but tough one for him because he was waiting all year to play a Defense we could ground and pound against.

I thought Edwards fumble was a case of him trying to get the extra yards but definitely left the ball hanging out there to get raked.

Glad they came back to Martin at the end there. Good to see Hicks get some touches as well. Crowded room for sure.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football PFF Grades + Snap Counts versus Penn State
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers vs Michigan State odds: Point spread released on Scarlet Knights, Spartans
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Football Every throw from Rutgers Football QB AJ Surace versus Penn State
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod