the elephant in the room

RU677381

Senior
Apr 21, 2010
397
640
45
it always seems as if we are playing to keep the score close rather than to win. saying the play calling is predictable is an understatement. Is Jerry Kill's reputation as some kind of offensive guru deserved?
 

FanuSanu52

All-Conference
Nov 8, 2011
11,256
4,618
0
I feel like nothing in your post is really right. We beat Illinois handily yesterday and were clearly not playing to keep close.

As Vk mentioned, literally not a single person, at least not anyone who knew what he was talking about, was crowing about J Kill being an offensive guru. Some said the exact opposite.

An experienced, successful HC, program turnaround tyoe, and sage elder voice on staff, yes. Offensive mastermind, no. Think people just swap him with Fridge at will because they were both HCs.
 

RUSK97

All-American
Dec 28, 2007
10,460
6,551
0
Did anyone here claim that Kill gives us a decided schematic advantage over our opponents ?
What is was is that DM gave us a decided disadvantage over 11-12 of our opponents last year, so Kill - or any warm body for that matter would possibly give us one more victory over the ‘16 campaign.
 

RUBOB72

All-American
Aug 5, 2004
23,385
7,924
0
Those that really are in tune with our current staff realize coach Kill was not a Guru of offensive game planning...but he certainly followed the Minnesota plan from his days as head coach yesterday...Granted it was against a week Illinois team but even so it was evident that we can run the ball very well if the O line plays well... One thing I noticed was a much more active Oline especially our guards and Cole is very good...even Miller and Applefield , Seymour were get out in front... blocking and moving bodies...was this a once time thing? I hope not... Also saw Krimins and Heeman out there... they are B1G... like Wisconsin heffer size... it proves the adage you win games up front.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FanuSanu52

bigbirdru

Senior
Mar 6, 2010
2,304
411
83
Winning by several scores in the 4th, I would opt to play it safe rather than sling the ball around to totally ice the game. I don't think I trust the qb play enough to keep the foot on the gas. Yes, playing aggressive can score you more points and really ice the game, but I'd rather not risk a pick/incomplete pass to stop the clock that could let Illinois back in the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LC-88

hiwater

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2001
9,595
3,167
113
Did anyone here claim that Kill gives us a decided schematic advantage over our opponents ?
I think it's pretty apparent that kill is an upgrade over DM with regard to play calling from last year. He isn't trying to force the side line to side line passing game despite 11 defenders within 7 yards of the LOS as DM did. You can also see a back getting repositioned on a lot of plays to the weak side when it is clear that the D is bringing extra pressure from the short side. DM would not allow that last year. Either the play was run as he called it or the QB was benched. You can see the adjustments to protect the QB this year.

The running game is 100% better play calling. If DM was the OC, we would have a big back running parallel to LOS on many plays and he would be getting stuffed as much as they did last year. The outside rushing plays are mostly bounces after the Inside is clogged up. is

Kill still does not seem to be aggressive in trying to get defenders out of the box with the exception of EMU and Morgan State. That's understandable see how bad Bolin was with going down the field in the EMU game. It's a wasted play throwing down the field with Bolin because he so badly overthrows everything that the receiver has no chance. I would have like to see him give Gio the chance to make a couple of down field throws yesterday. Gio was pretty good at it last year, but we really didn't need to yesterday because the few short passes that he completed and the running game were more than enough to beet Illinois.
 
Last edited:

rutgers4life11

All-Conference
Jan 22, 2014
2,951
2,450
66
As an announcer said earlier in season, Kill is a fundamentals guy vs a schemer.

He beats you with solid coaching, not necessarily unique out of the box playcalling.

I prefer that.

Sure, it's a little vanilla right now, but where it's really exciting is just compare how upright our QB is this year. We're not taking many sacks. Watch how he actually uses RBs and TEs in protection, something DM brainlessly never did in favor of crazy plays. We have a developing running game, a TE passing game, and he does try to get the ball into different playmaker hands.

Most importantly, the line is showing improvement. This is where Kill is going to make us a better team a year from now, by coaching these guys up.

I think Kill is smart enough to know what we have, and if you can grind out the clock, you can stick in a game until the 4th. Which unlike last year, has been true in every game this season except for OSU, who's on another level and benefitted from our entire secondary going down with injuries in-game.

These next 6 games will hopefully confirm Kill's progression, not necessarily in W/L but improvement in fundamentals and ironing out a good team for 2018.
 

chuckin'charlie

Redshirt
Jan 31, 2003
56
13
0
As an announcer said earlier in season, Kill is a fundamentals guy vs a schemer.

He beats you with solid coaching, not necessarily unique out of the box playcalling.

I prefer that.

Sure, it's a little vanilla right now, but where it's really exciting is just compare how upright our QB is this year. We're not taking many sacks. Watch how he actually uses RBs and TEs in protection, something DM brainlessly never did in favor of crazy plays. We have a developing running game, a TE passing game, and he does try to get the ball into different playmaker hands.

Most importantly, the line is showing improvement. This is where Kill is going to make us a better team a year from now, by coaching these guys up.

I think Kill is smart enough to know what we have, and if you can grind out the clock, you can stick in a game until the 4th. Which unlike last year, has been true in every game this season except for OSU, who's on another level and benefitted from our entire secondary going down with injuries in-game.

These next 6 games will hopefully confirm Kill's progression, not necessarily in W/L but improvement in fundamentals and ironing out a good team for 2018.
 

chuckin'charlie

Redshirt
Jan 31, 2003
56
13
0
Rutgers is playing with QB's with limited ability. None of the three are going to fill the skies with passes. Therefore, a running game is a must. I thought Kill did an admirable job rotating backs to best advantage. Also clock management is a factor that helps the defense. Perhaps if Lewis matures and learns the game Rutgers can open the offense.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,770
151,629
113
People, including me, are just going to have to get used to pounding the ball and working clock. Win or lose that's how Ash and Co. view football.
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,509
25,555
113
it always seems as if we are playing to keep the score close rather than to win. saying the play calling is predictable is an understatement. Is Jerry Kill's reputation as some kind of offensive guru deserved?
Stop it. Watch the game again. 35 points is not predictable, we threw it when we had to. Playing with an 18 point lead you run it down their throats in the fourth quarter. Nothing to see here
 

hiwater

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2001
9,595
3,167
113
As an announcer said earlier in season, Kill is a fundamentals guy vs a schemer.

He beats you with solid coaching, not necessarily unique out of the box playcalling.

I prefer that.

Sure, it's a little vanilla right now, but where it's really exciting is just compare how upright our QB is this year. We're not taking many sacks. Watch how he actually uses RBs and TEs in protection, something DM brainlessly never did in favor of crazy plays. We have a developing running game, a TE passing game, and he does try to get the ball into different playmaker hands.

Most importantly, the line is showing improvement. This is where Kill is going to make us a better team a year from now, by coaching these guys up.

I think Kill is smart enough to know what we have, and if you can grind out the clock, you can stick in a game until the 4th. Which unlike last year, has been true in every game this season except for OSU, who's on another level and benefitted from our entire secondary going down with injuries in-game.

These next 6 games will hopefully confirm Kill's progression, not necessarily in W/L but improvement in fundamentals and ironing out a good team for 2018.
When you outclass your opponents with skill, fundamental/no mistake play calling works, but it falls flat on it's face when you are undermanned. RU needs to be innovative to give them an edge or even a chance against better teams.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: rutgersguy1_rivals

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,988
8,968
113
Out of the box play calling and offensive philosophies cannot consistently compensate for not having adequate personnel. Ultimately, effective offense comes down to executing consistently. There's only so much success that you can have based on confusion. As great and innovative a coach as Chip Kelly was, when he faced teams that figured out how to line up properly, his offense wasn't nearly as effective.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rutgers4life11

graystork

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2008
8,515
3,367
0
Kill used our advantage in the run game to get a win. Seriously I don't get the bitching about the passing attack in this game. All the press comments "Rutgers needs a better passing game." If you can dominate on the ground, why the hell would you throw the ball. I think Kill is gonna like Gio's running ability and is going to use it.
 

RU4Real

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
50,955
30,734
0
Kill used our advantage in the run game to get a win. Seriously I don't get the bitching about the passing attack in this game. All the press comments "Rutgers needs a better passing game." If you can dominate on the ground, why the hell would you throw the ball. I think Kill is gonna like Gio's running ability and is going to use it.

That's assuming Gio can survive the season. It wasn't looking very promising yesterday.
 

madchuck

Heisman
Oct 22, 2016
21,856
46,631
62
it always seems as if we are playing to keep the score close rather than to win. saying the play calling is predictable is an understatement. Is Jerry Kill's reputation as some kind of offensive guru deserved?
\

Never was an offensive Guru. He's a good head coach, he's better than Mehringer and he knows football. He also won B1G coach of the year and won in the B1G without crazy recruiting classes. I haven't been impressed by his play calling but we can't hire a new offensive coordinator again. I give Kill the benefit of the doubt a lot because of his resume. We scored 35 points. He also kept Washington close by holding the ball. Although I'm not thrilled with all of his play calls, he's done some good things this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoeRU0304

MorrisAsh

All-Conference
Dec 5, 2015
2,637
4,429
113
The games that we have little chance to win, there seems to be an effort to get to the 60th minute without getting blown out. Sometimes it works (Washington) and sometimes it doesn't (OSU).

There are two games that RU has a chance to win: Purdue and Maryland. Judge Kill on those games (no we won't win at Indiana so stop).
 

HeyHuey

All-Conference
Jun 16, 2008
8,042
4,663
0
Didn't Kill once state that he didn't learn how to really run an offense until he got to Kansas State?
 

DHajekRC84

Heisman
Aug 9, 2001
30,708
19,816
0
wow..thank God. For a minute I thought we announced an upgrade to our SOS by adding Alabama for a 2 fer one.:flushed:

I would say Kill deserves being called a offensive GORU after yesterday :smiley:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Abro1975

NBKnight

Heisman
Jul 8, 2008
24,757
15,666
61
When you outclass your opponents with skill, fundamental/no mistake play calling works, but it falls flat on it's face when you are undermanned. RU needs to be innovative to give the an edge.

But you still need the personnel to execute your plan.

Last year everyone complained about DM running an offense that did not match the personnel.
 

hiwater

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2001
9,595
3,167
113
But you still need the personnel to execute your plan.
Agreed. We know we have a good TE and RB's. After 6 games we still do not know much about our WR's except for Grant because they have not had more than a couple of real chances to make plays. At this point, most of us think that we have more speed and depth at the position now, but the jury is still out on that one. When teams started pressing the LOS the short passing game was taken away, and Bolin has not been accurate enough past 10 yards or on longer throws to the sidelines to get them the ball.

We know that Gio was able to hit windows down the field last year, but we did not try a pass over 10 yards yesterday. We didn't need the to pass the ball down the field yesterday though.
Last year everyone complained about DM running an offense that did not match the personnel.
That's true too, but don't see how it's related to the subject of this thread. Are saying that Kill is better because he is running an offense that did DOES match the personnel? I think his play calling is better even if the WR's are under utilized.
 
Last edited:

NBKnight

Heisman
Jul 8, 2008
24,757
15,666
61
Agreed. We know we have a good TE and RB's. After 6 games we still do not know much about our WR's except for Grant because they have not had more than a couple of real chances to make plays. At this point, most of us think that we have more speed and depth at the position now, but the jury is still out on that one. When teams started pressing the LOS the short passing game was taken away, and Bolin has not been accurate enough past 10 yards or on longer throws to the sidelines to get them the ball.

We know that Gio was able to hit windows down the field last year, but we did not try a pass over 10 yards yesterday. We didn't need the to pass the ball down the field yesterday though.

That's true too, but don't see how it's related to the subject of this thread. Are saying that Kill is better because he is running an offense that did DOES match the personnel? I think his play calling is better even if the WR's are under utilized.

Maybe the the WR's are not being used because they are not ready.

Gio was not good throwing downfield last year.

People are questioning that we are too conservative and not being creative enough, I am just saying that you have to run an offense that fits your personnel.
 
Last edited:

hiwater

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2001
9,595
3,167
113
Maybe the the WR's are not being used because they are not ready.
It's not like we didn't try to use them in the early games. Outside of the OSU game the receivers were getting open and not dropping balls.

Bolin just was not able to connect with anyone past 10 yards except for 2 passes. He hit Melton for a 48 yarder against Morgan state. Melton took the ball away from 2 defenders on an underthrow. Grant had a big down field catch against EMU we he outfought 2 guys for the ball there too.

The EMU game had 6 bad overthrows of guys going down the field that were open each time. Most of them by at least 5 yards. You can't put that on the receivers not being ready. We had 2 receivers that were breaking open on the sideline in that game also that were taken down. We did not get the calls because Bolin threw the ball out of bounds.

Our receivers made plays in the first half of the Washington game. It wasn't like Kill was hiding them. Kill admitted after the game that he was surprised that the OL protected the QB so well. His game plan only called for short passes, but he would have called for some shots down the field or deeper passes had he know the OL would play that well ahead of time.

That is not hiding receivers that are not ready. All that says is that Kill can't make adjustments on the fly. He is not innovative.
 

mychaljohn

Junior
May 16, 2003
2,582
347
0
it always seems as if we are playing to keep the score close rather than to win. saying the play calling is predictable is an understatement. Is Jerry Kill's reputation as some kind of offensive guru deserved?
I do not think that word what you think it means.
 
Feb 5, 2003
11,011
9,450
113
OP has a highly suspect post-to-like ratio.

Our OL was blowing their front seven up yesterday on a regular basis. I liked that we ran things repeatedly until Illinois showed they could stop us (or couldn't). Example - our first TD run. I think we ran that one quite a few times. As long as it's working, no need to go deep in the passing playbook. If we are struggling to run it against Purdue and we still only throw 10 passes, then there is a problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hiwater

RU4Real

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
50,955
30,734
0
It's been demonstrated that any ball Bolin throws more than 10 yards probably isn't going where we want it to go.

Kill's offensive strategy has to recognize that constraint.

Hopefully Gio can last the rest of the season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: soundcrib
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football PFF Grades + Snap Counts versus Penn State
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers vs Michigan State odds: Point spread released on Scarlet Knights, Spartans
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Football Every throw from Rutgers Football QB AJ Surace versus Penn State
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod