+1. It really is shocking reading some of these posts and trying to comprehend how some of these perceptions are created. So many willing to discard Ash after 2 years. Lots of instant gratification folks out there.
Unfortunately, that is much of our society. Everyone wants McDonald's like turn around, but this process is not that quick. The program was a mess. Ash has it going in the right direction.
I don't follow you guys enough now and especially then to speak to what Ash inherited v Greg. What I can say though is this is Ash's 1st head coaching gig. I think too often we think of coaches as binary. Meaning either they can coach or they can't. However, I think coaching is like any other profession where you get better at your job with experience. I remember reading an article that said basically year 3 of any job is when you "figure it out". That included moving to a new company in the same profession. It just takes time to learn the in and outs.
There are two reasons when I think a coach needs to be fired early. 1. He has an off-field incident. 2. He loses the team. If the team is tuning him and not taking any coaching then it's hard to improve. But if you look at a coach and everything he's doing around the program is all pointing up I think you got to give the guy 5 years. He'll probably figure the game day stuff out.
According to your reasons to be fired, it looks like Flood was given a little leeway through the years.