Four cops were already at the school...

eerdoc

Redshirt
May 29, 2001
24,014
26
48
Training is one thing. When real bullets are flying it is another. I can sit here and tell you how I would run into that school and end the situation. I sure hope I would, but I've never been under fire before. I can't say with certainty that I wouldn't freeze up. I'd bet you are in the same category. And this gets to my concern about arming some teachers. This was a cop with hundreds of hours of training. We expect a teacher with tens of hours of training at best to do better?
So, if one is not sure how he might react when the going gets tough and bullets may be flying DON'T APPLY FOR A JOB WHERE YHIS IS A POSSIBILITY! It's ok to have fears and reservations. It's NOT ok to have these and then abandon those relying on you to perform under such situations. Having such a person in a time of critical need is far worse than having no one. Does anyone wish to schedule surgery with a MD who admits he cannot perform when he sees blood? Choose to be an auto mechanic or an electrical but avoid all those occupations where the sight of blood is expected.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
So, if one is not sure how he might react when the going gets tough and bullets may be flying DON'T APPLY FOR A JOB WHERE YHIS IS A POSSIBILITY! It's ok to have fears and reservations. It's NOT ok to have these and then abandon those relying on you to perform under such situations. Having such a person in a time of critical need is far worse than having no one. Does anyone wish to schedule surgery with a MD who admits he cannot perform when he sees blood? Choose to be an auto mechanic or an electrical but avoid all those occupations where the sight of blood is expected.
My point is that no one really knows how they will react under fire. Anyone can talk tough about what they would do, but no one truly knows.

The thing I can compare it to that I did is steel work. They asked everyone they interviewed how they were with heights. It's one thing to think you are good with heights and another to be on a 6" beam 40' in the air with nothing on either side of you for a dozen feet. I watched people who had done that stuff for years freeze up on occasion.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
You dont know if that cop had 100s of hours of training. I dont agree at al with you about not knowing how one will react. Ive been around cops all my life.
I'll still hold to my assertion that no one knows how any high stress situation will make them react.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
Even if you are correct it falls squarely on the sheriffs office.
Based on what we know right now, I think the sheriff is doing the right thing. He investigated what happened, reported it, and suspended the deputy. On the surface, it looks like he's dealing with this honestly. That's a good start. I'd be curious if there was radio trafgic withbthat deputy. If there was, that might be interesting to hear. That's part of what I don't know yet.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,636
927
113
Based on what we know right now, I think the sheriff is doing the right thing. He investigated what happened, reported it, and suspended the deputy. On the surface, it looks like he's dealing with this honestly. That's a good start. I'd be curious if there was radio trafgic withbthat deputy. If there was, that might be interesting to hear. That's part of what I don't know yet.
He owns this. His office failed the students.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
He owns this. His office failed the students.
What could he have done that would have stopped this before it started? Outside of having a deputy at the school, what could he have done to stop it more quickly once it did start?
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,636
927
113
What could he have done that would have stopped this before it started? Outside of having a deputy at the school, what could he have done to stop it more quickly once it did start?
Have a deputy at the school who could do the job.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,636
927
113
Can you tell me what the training requirements are for deputies in Broward County?
Can you tell me how many student death the Sheriff finds tolerable under his current training schedule?
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
Can you tell me how many student death the Sheriff finds tolerable under his current training schedule?
Zero, which is why the deputy was suspended pending further review. Can you answer the question I asked?
 

eerdoc

Redshirt
May 29, 2001
24,014
26
48
My point is that no one really knows how they will react under fire. Anyone can talk tough about what they would do, but no one truly knows.

The thing I can compare it to that I did is steel work. They asked everyone they interviewed how they were with heights. It's one thing to think you are good with heights and another to be on a 6" beam 40' in the air with nothing on either side of you for a dozen feet. I watched people who had done that stuff for years freeze up on occasion.
I'm not easily convinced that one takes a job, knowing the nature of it and is enthusiastic enough about the potential (all manners of such) and then panics when asked to do that for which he as hired. I content the reservations were there from the beginning, and the employee was just unwilling to admit to such. Such a hire is not worth the time required for training, etc. Definitely not the type you risk your life with.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
I get your point but there is an expectation that police will respond correctly in the situation. Trust me, I understand that you can’t simulate real life.
I absolutely agree with and have that same expectation, but I don't think you can fault the sheriff because this school resource officer, a deputy, appears to have frozen under fire, albeit fire he was directly under.

I'm really curious to see how the issue with the sheriff plays out given that the next 3 deputies on the scene took up positions outside the school also. The reason I wasn't quick to label this deputy is because I wondered what communications were going on with him. Was he in that position because he was ordered to be? With the next 3 doimg similar things, were they ordered to stay outside? Time will tell.

I have to go back to find some coverage of the Columbine event. I believe they had a lot of cops outside the school waiting for SWAT to arrive. I'm not saying that is factual. That's just my recollection. Verify that one before you repeat it.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,636
927
113
I absolutely agree with and have that same expectation, but I don't think you can fault the sheriff because this school resource officer, a deputy, appears to have frozen under fire, albeit fire he was directly under.

I'm really curious to see how the issue with the sheriff plays out given that the next 3 deputies on the scene took up positions outside the school also. The reason I wasn't quick to label this deputy is because I wondered what communications were going on with him. Was he in that position because he was ordered to be? With the next 3 doimg similar things, were they ordered to stay outside? Time will tell.

I have to go back to find some coverage of the Columbine event. I believe they had a lot of cops outside the school waiting for SWAT to arrive. I'm not saying that is factual. That's just my recollection. Verify that one before you repeat it.
Thats not protocol.
 
Aug 27, 2001
63,466
198
0
I'm not easily convinced that one takes a job, knowing the nature of it and is enthusiastic enough about the potential (all manners of such) and then panics when asked to do that for which he as hired. I content the reservations were there from the beginning, and the employee was just unwilling to admit to such. Such a hire is not worth the time required for training, etc. Definitely not the type you risk your life with.

He also was a 32-33 year veteran. Maybe he was a lot more risk adverse than he was 32 years ago. I am not defending him at all. My God I would hope a sworn officer would never react like that. But officers die every year when they freeze in life-threatening situations.

Reading this thread reminded me of a co-worker that is also an experienced climber. about 18 months ago he was with his buddies and froze on the rock. He said he was paralyzed by the thought of dying and leaving his wife and children behind. The dude had been climbing for years and froze. If happens.
 
Last edited:

TarHeelEer

Freshman
Dec 15, 2002
89,389
67
48
I absolutely agree with and have that same expectation, but I don't think you can fault the sheriff because this school resource officer, a deputy, appears to have frozen under fire, albeit fire he was directly under.

I'm really curious to see how the issue with the sheriff plays out given that the next 3 deputies on the scene took up positions outside the school also. The reason I wasn't quick to label this deputy is because I wondered what communications were going on with him. Was he in that position because he was ordered to be? With the next 3 doimg similar things, were they ordered to stay outside? Time will tell.

I have to go back to find some coverage of the Columbine event. I believe they had a lot of cops outside the school waiting for SWAT to arrive. I'm not saying that is factual. That's just my recollection. Verify that one before you repeat it.

Standard protocol changed after Columbine. Before then it was to handle hostage situations.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
He also is a 32-33 year veteran. Maybe he he is a lot more risk adverse than he was 32 years ago. I am not defending him at all. My God I would hope a sworn officer would never react like that. But officers die every year when they freeze in life-threatening situations.

Reading this thread reminded me of a co-worker that is also an experienced climber. about 18 months ago he was with his buddies and froze on the rock. He said he was paralyzed by the thought of dying and leaving his wife and children behind. The dude had been climbing for years and froze. If happens.
Your climbing buddy is similar to what I saw in steel work. I learned on that job that people will usually listen to direct commands when they freeze up. Don't try to talk them down easy, bark an order. That works. I've used that knowledge over the years. Maybe the cop who resigned would have gone in if someone on the radio ordered him to go in. Maybe they tried that with no luck. Maybe they told him to stand his ground. I think the radio traffic at that point is something they should share.
 

bornaneer

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2014
31,478
2,168
113
The cop probably just froze up. I think he had a duty to go in after he heard the first shots.....he had to know the shots were done by the bad guy.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,636
927
113
The cop probably just froze up. I think he had a duty to go in after he heard the first shots.....he had to know the shots were done by the bad guy.
Id guess they knew who the shooter was inmediately since half of Broward County had told the police he was going to do this.
 

TarHeelEer

Freshman
Dec 15, 2002
89,389
67
48
I'd be curious if there was radio traffic withbthat deputy. If there was, that might be interesting to hear. That's part of what I don't know yet.

You're onto something here.

 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,636
927
113
I can believe one guy not going in because fear is an unknown. No way 4 cops dont go in. Not sure why they didnt but it still points back to the sheriiff IMO. He has to go.
 

mneilmont

Sophomore
Jan 23, 2008
20,883
166
0
Stand down order given. Link
We were instructed to control perimeter in and empty building or no fear of human harm. First officers would take a corner where they could see two corners each. You can give chase and alert all when someone exits.

In this case, that is a hell of a lot different since you have a building full of students. At sound of first shot the armed officer goes to the sound of the shot. He is not required to go into the barrel of the gun, but he can hide in doorway of any other object that would give him some cover. Actually he should not return fire if there is an equal chance of hitting bystander. Clint Eastwood is probably the only capable of that shooting.

Anyone who would give stand down orders to initial officers on site of an active shooting scene should be fired(after tar and feather).

Self experience. Got a call one night of a n alarm at a liquor store - after hours. We were instructed to cover perimeter - each of us view two corners. We followed orders until it looked like every squad car in the area came to investigate an empty building. Didn't make sense why so many cars responded. Door was unlocked and all officers, except my car, exercised some self service. Commanding officer told us to get emergency telephone # on the door and switchboard would call to come and lock the door. Hell, that was just an invitation to every car within hearing distance - entire city - to come and help themselves. One of the guys from "old days" was carrying out cases. Probably one of the most difficult days I had on the job.
 
Last edited:
WV Sports

Latest

  1. 01 WV Sports Players 8 Tournament: West Virginia vs Kansas Preview
  2. 02 WV Sports Basketball How Ross Hodge is preparing WVU for a quick turnaround against Kansas
  3. 03 WV Sports West Virginia's Seydou Traore makes impact despite not scoring against Auburn
  4. 04 WV Sports Football Rich Rodriguez has a list of changes coming to WVU football
  5. 05 WV Sports Football DJ Epps' unlikely journey leads to one final home game at WVU