Disappointed in Rupp/question for architects/ Engineers

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
If the architects were good managers they would have required the client to approve of all drawings.
Yes but they are the experts who knew or should have known the fact certain rows of seats would have a significant sight line issue. not sure you can expect someone in city government to know this .

But it just occurred to me that the architectural firm has the most to lose here if it is not fixed. The world is highly competitive. They tout themselves as experts on building and renovating sports arenas. All a competitor has to do is take some pictures from row C as it is and ask prospective clients if this is the type of expertise they want to buy. If you think about it Rupp/UK has leverage here regardless of who approved what. It is very much in the interest of the architectural firm to resolve this sooner rather than later.

I wish to repeat I am not really effected by this. I do use the tickets sometime because a friend owns them but I have others I can acquire as well. It's just that my wife and I love UK. We're up there all of the time. Serve on a number of committees to try and make OUR UNIVERSITY better. it just infuriates me that as hard as we all try to make UK academics and sports programs better that someone would shortchange us.

I know that some people on this board would argue about anything. But this is different . Our university and its fans didn't get what they paid for.
 
Last edited:

Dr. H Lecter

Heisman
Apr 5, 2007
15,307
30,233
66
I
I don't know why anybody on this board would take up for the architects . its clear the design was shoddy and should be corrected.

I am not taking up for them. I am just pointing out that there very well be a reason and cost may not be one. You've stated several times that there are 2 other possible ways to have done it without a top rail. You continue to ignore the inconvenient phrase, "provided they meet the load requirements."

You have no way of knowing if any non-railed installations would meet the load requirements for this specific installation because you have no idea what they are. Just because something has been tested to meet "X" does not mean it will pass a test for "Y".

Further, it may be for some other reason entirely. It may just be that the current code requires a hand rail. Its possible an exposed glass edge does not meet a "grasping" requirement of that nature. It is a walkway and ADA may require it or some other code could be in play.

It is certainly worthy of an explanation. A bunch of folks complaining will root out the reason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tinker Dan

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
as i said I'm sure they felt they could do it on the cheap and a bunch of dumb Kentuckians wouldn't know enough to object to it. Code says it can be done two other ways.

Ever been behind the glass at a hockey game? Glass will distort the view. You can’t see detail. Differing indices of refraction. Plus it gets dirty. The glass option is for esthetics, not optical clarity. There was a more expensive solution. There is not a better solution as regards optical clarity.
 

RickUK-Club74

Redshirt
Mar 26, 2015
53
43
0
Sitting in Madison Square Garden. First row on upper decks have heavy glass walls just above eye level with no brackets, no railings, no nothing other than glass. Completely transparent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Notelvis2

catfanlou

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2005
3,665
1,363
41
Sitting in Madison Square Garden. First row on upper decks have heavy glass walls just above eye level with no brackets, no railings, no nothing other than glass. Completely transparent.
Thank you . I was about to post same . Rupp arena and UK fans got cheated by cheap architecture .
No question whatsoever two inch rail is not necessary if built right . No more lies about building codes please . Fix the damn thing right .
 

catfanlou

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2005
3,665
1,363
41
Sitting in Madison Square Garden. First row on upper decks have heavy glass walls just above eye level with no brackets, no railings, no nothing other than glass. Completely transparent.
Can u tell if there are spaces between. The panels . That’s a big issue as well . im downstairs and I can tell no two inch cap but can’t see it well enough to see if there are spaces .
Might help if u could take pictures
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
does it meet current code in Lexington?
Some people are just negative. They have been building buildings in NYC a long time . Their codes are tough .
500 Very loyal U.K. fans have been screwed . The university shortchanged with a second rate product and all you can do is look at reasons it shouldn’t b changed .
I have spent my life both fighting City Hall and defending City Hall . This fight can b won if enough fans refuse to accept Rupp being a second rate arena.

The first thing that needs to b done us for the Mayor or Eli to invite the grad of the Architectual firm that screwed up to watch a ball game with them . They need to sit them in row C and after the game simply say we cannot recommend your firm until this is rectified .

Believe me it can and will b changed . UK should of have the worst upper arena in the nation .
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
Some people are just negative. They have been building buildings in NYC a long time . Their codes are tough .
500 Very loyal U.K. fans have been screwed . The university shortchanged with a second rate product and all you can do is look at reasons it shouldn’t b changed .
I have spent my life both fighting City Hall and defending City Hall . This fight can b won if enough fans refuse to accept Rupp being a second rate arena.

I asked a simple question. Does it meet code in Lexington? You gave me whining. This is really pretty damn simple.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
I asked a simple question. Does it meet code in Lexington? You gave me whining. This is really pretty damn simple.
And your ready to accept that if it doesn’t and just say U.K. basketball Is second rate. I’m not .

. I don’t know if it does or doesn’t . That’s why I asked architects help. but if it doesn’t it should change to whatever allowed Madison square garden and I suspect most other states have that allow a safe upper tier where the first five or six rows don’t have a visual impediment .

Why are u not for other U.K. fans?why are u so negative ? Why don’t you want U.K. to have the best of everything ? You should b outraged but apparently are willing to accept shoddy work that hurts our school.
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
What I saw was that the option to a rail was also going to have vision issues due to differing index of refraction. This is an engineering and safety question. Go play Robin Hood somewhere else.

Further, the rail is thin. Not that objectionable to long over or under. Some people just gonna *****. They don’t like it, sell the tickets.

Careful on that high horse. Gonna hurt if you fall on that torch.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
And your ready to accept that if it doesn’t and just say U.K. basketball Is second rate. I’m not .

. I don’t know if it does or doesn’t . That’s why I asked architects help. but if it doesn’t it should change to whatever allowed Madison square garden and I suspect most other states have that allow a safe upper tier where the first five or six rows don’t have a visual impediment .

Why are u not for other U.K. fans?why are u so negative ? Why don’t you want U.K. to have the best of everything ? You should b outraged but apparently are willing to accept shoddy work that hurts our school.
Furthermore if the Lexington building codes require the mess they have created the architects owed it to Rupp and UK to advise then that four prime rows in the upper tier would b unusable . I very seriously doubt it was a building code issue . I suspect somebody cut corners and it was up the the architects to tell them that corner should not b cut .
At least we can agree it was a great game tonight . Great seeing so many happy UK fans up here in NYC.
 

RickUK-Club74

Redshirt
Mar 26, 2015
53
43
0
Can u tell if there are spaces between. The panels . That’s a big issue as well . im downstairs and I can tell no two inch cap but can’t see it well enough to see if there are spaces .
Might help if u could take pictures
Yes there were periodic 1/4th inch gaps but they were not a problem. Seemed like those vertical gaps lined up nicely between every few seats.

If I knew how to post pics I would. The view was crystal clear with no distortion.
 

RickUK-Club74

Redshirt
Mar 26, 2015
53
43
0
My last comment on Building Codes. Codes require interpretation and advances in materials and design often create conflicts that require resolution.

My biggest point is I have been on the design forward side as an owner's development consultant on very large mixed use projects with heavy public use and major international sports events for many years. We always face code hurdles and they usually get resolved in a manner that never compromises the guest experience.

But here is the deal. There are often adversarial positions taken where one party raps the discussion in highly technical engineering and power grabbing code interpretations and it is nothing more than a "rope a dope" move.

Finally sight lines and seat comfort is everything in public space design. I cannot imagine that views from every major seating section down to each row were not studied through various forms of virtual and augmented I reality. Typically conflicts like the ones between fully unobstructed views and the two inch rtop railing are fully understood and discussed with all parties with a cost and benefit analysis of options and resolutions.
 
Last edited:

The_Godfather_rivals

All-Conference
May 22, 2002
25,432
3,795
113
What I saw was that the option to a rail was also going to have vision issues due to differing index of refraction. This is an engineering and safety question. Go play Robin Hood somewhere else.

Further, the rail is thin. Not that objectionable to long over or under. Some people just gonna *****. They don’t like it, sell the tickets.

Careful on that high horse. Gonna hurt if you fall on that torch.
You really are a moron.

Good luck to UK selling those tickets for $1,800 per seat when you have that mess between you and the court.
 

Notelvis2

Junior
Jul 9, 2005
5,855
355
83
Maybe sell the seats in those rows only to fans of the visiting team.......

Seriously though -

The view in those sections used to be fantastic and now, as a first-time season ticket holder in those endzone bleacher seats (but I knew exactly what I was getting going in......), I'll linger a little after an upcoming game and go see what you're talking about for myself. IF I had just bought season tickets for a row with an obstructed view, I'd be asking for some kind of relief too.
 

Catapult_rivals218351

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2002
3,472
1,705
0
What I saw was that the option to a rail was also going to have vision issues due to differing index of refraction. This is an engineering and safety question. Go play Robin Hood somewhere else.

Further, the rail is thin. Not that objectionable to long over or under. Some people just gonna *****. They don’t like it, sell the tickets.

Careful on that high horse. Gonna hurt if you fall on that torch.
Are you sitting there??? Try putting a 1 inch strip of tape across your big screen TV and see how you like it. Suspect if it came from store that way you would object and return. Try it and tell us how easy it is to get used to!
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
Are you sitting there??? Try putting a 1 inch strip of tape across your big screen TV and see how you like it. Suspect if it came from store that way you would object and return. Try it and tell us how easy it is to get used to!

Yes I’ve dealt with handrails, drunk fans, dirty glass, flashing lights and leaking roofs. It’s part of being there. If I wanted the very best view, I’d stay home.

By the way, the tape over the TV screen is infinitely worse. Parallax. Interesting phenomenon. Read about it.
 

gright

Senior
Aug 24, 2010
936
626
0
I have seats in section 231 row D which is only one row up from the OP. I did not notice obstruction of my view but have only been to one game so far.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
positive things u can do to help win this argument
BE COURTEOUS .
Calls :mayors office, your councilperson, mitch Barnhart, Herald leader sports desk, all three TV stations,, Rupp arena authority .

write letters to editor . I’ll come up with a plan but wife says we gotta go shop in NYC . Oh my God.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
No, actually, its about engineering and safety. Well, and about whiners. Clearly.
Are you the city official that approved this plan? Don’t understand otherwise why u would take that position .
Please please just sit in row C next game for a minute before the game . You will change your tune .
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
I have seats in section 231 row D which is only one row up from the OP. I did not notice obstruction of my view but have only been to one game so far.
Please let us know after next game if that is true , how tall are u. On row B I have a problem but my wife who is five inches shorter does not .
I briefly sat in row C D and E to see how far up I would have to go to not notice the bar . Maybe I am wrong as to D . If so that would b great . However , C and B definitely have an issue and I suspect D depending upon your height .
Do let me know if I am wrong on to D . Thanks .
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
Are you the city official that approved this plan? Don’t understand otherwise why u would take that position .
Please please just sit in row C next game for a minute before the game . You will change your tune .

I don't have to sit in row C. I've sat in worse. I understand about codes, technical requirements, safety issues. I understand that they are intractable. You don't. You understand whining till you get your way.

Bottom line, that rail will persist until such time as a viable, compliant, safe and economically feasible solution can be found. Now, lay in the floor, hold your breath and turn blue. Some kicking adds a good effect too.
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
positive things u can do to help win this argument
BE COURTEOUS .
Calls :mayors office, your councilperson, mitch Barnhart, Herald leader sports desk, all three TV stations,, Rupp arena authority .

write letters to editor . I’ll come up with a plan but wife says we gotta go shop in NYC . Oh my God.

You forget sobbing uncontrollably and bleating about how the need for safety has blotted out an entire 2 foot strip of floor for you, but only if your head is held absolutely rigid. Don’t forget the fate of the known universe stands in the balance.

I forget any other bleeding heart exaggerating?
 

catmankev

Redshirt
Jan 22, 2014
48
35
0
  1. First those who are familiar with my posts know I am not a complainer . I think MB has done a fantastic job with all the conflicting priorities of our various programs . He gets an A plus in my book ..
However my observation is that in the name of safety the improvements to the upper tier of Rupp were perhaps performed by architects not familiar with sporting events. Basically , rows B tru F have gone from some of the best seats in the house to some of the worst .

Question. With all of the technology available is it really necessary to have a two inch metal strip obstructing the view to hold the plastic panels in place . Before u had simply a wire which worked fine and after a while your eyes got use to it. No way to see though two inches of metal . Has to b a better solution.

Second question . Is it really necessary to have a half inch gap between plastic panels ? The gap creates a further visual barrier which when combined with the Two inch metal strip Is really annoying .
Also ,
When the person below u leans forward u either have to also lean forward or see the back of their head for half of the court area. I don’t remember this ever being a problem in any other coliseum or stadium where I have watched games . Something the matter with the pitch?

I also note that for some reason they raised the second tier by about seven or eight feet .
which makes you that much further from the court .

Any architects or engineers have any solution to the two inch bar at the top of the plastic panels obstructing the view or of the half inch gap between the panels. Are both really necessary?
why not go back to the metal cord which worked fine previously ?any other modern solution.

I find myself watching the game on the big screen most of the time . Kind of crazy to go to the fame to see it on TV.

Again not trying to b a complainer. I’m not a season ticket holder . But many if those around me in row C tonight were and to say the least were disappointed . Any constructive solutions any if you have seen elsewhere or is that simply the limit of today’s technology that it delivers worst sight lines than the architects of forty and fifty years ago.
Thanks
I have had this kind of seat. It’s a terrible seat and and should be sold at a steep discount.
 

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
You forget sobbing uncontrollably and bleating about how the need for safety has blotted out an entire 2 foot strip of floor for you, but only if your head is held absolutely rigid. Don’t forget the fate of the known universe stands in the balance.

I forget any other bleeding heart exaggerating?
Whatever . Had a great night watching to kill a mockingbird and drinks at Sardi ‘ s . Got to see my Cats become the number one team in the nation last night from the eleventh row. I’m a very lucky guy.
Not in a mood to argue.
Good luck and may peace with you.

Please just go sit In row C Friday night if u really are are a UK fan.

Lou
 
Last edited:

Catfanlou_rivals54997

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2014
1,516
2,351
0
I am 6foot 1
Thanks for the info . My wife who is 5’4” tried row D and said the bar was in the center of the court for her. Guess it depends on the person.
As I said in earlier post U.K. could sell Row B to Short people under 5’ 4 ” and row D to people over 6’1” and I guess use row C to store coats .
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Cats in the NBA BBNBA: Tyler Herro's 50-piece bucket almost came with a side of buzzer-beater
  2. 02 KSR Football Where Kentucky sits in updated AP, Coaches Polls following loss at Mizzou
  3. 03 KSR Football SEC Officials Made an Egregious Error in Kentucky vs. Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Dethroned: Kentucky VB’s SEC title streak snapped, but chance for redemption is alive
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky will host Louisville as an underdog at Kroger Field