Zion is good folks

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
He is a stronger version of Charles Barkley, with lesser perimeter skills.

I'm not sure how he has "lesser perimeter skills." I never saw Barkley hit four straight threes, and Zion's dribbling and passing skills are also well ahead of where Barkley's were at the same age.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GonzoCat90

GonzoCat90

Heisman
Mar 30, 2009
32,377
34,559
0
Also, Zion becoming one of the greatest players in the league isn't exactly a good thing if you're Kentucky going up against Duke/Coach K.

Yes, there are legit reason for Kentucky fans to want this guy to fail.

Coach K is almost 73 years old and it didn't make a damn bit of difference to Bagley or Zion or Ingram or Giles or anyone else when we were selling AD, Wall, etc compared to Plumlee and Austin Rivers because that isn't how they're landing those guys.
 
Sep 13, 2003
23,905
33,655
113
I'm not sure how he has "lesser perimeter skills." I never saw Barkley hit four straight threes, and Zion's dribbling and passing skills are also well ahead of where Barkley's were at the same age.

Barkley worked hard on his weight and perimeter skills from the time he stepped foot on an NBA court and could most definitely dribble and pass. He is a top 50 player EVER. He could score from everywhere on the court, so he didn't NEED to shoot many 3's. Heck, the ONLY reason Zion shot 4 last night was because the Spurs didn't even guard him out there and was begging him to shoot it. I DOUBT he makes 4 in a game again this year.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,941
63,129
113
Coach K is almost 73 years old and it didn't make a damn bit of difference to Bagley or Zion or Ingram or Giles or anyone else when we were selling AD, Wall, etc compared to Plumlee and Austin Rivers because that isn't how they're landing those guys.

One of the things K didn't have going for him, was NBA talent. He had/has NBA guys.. but aside from Irving, that was it. It was an area Cal had him beat and could use to his advantage. Coach K, can and has, utilized the following to recruit: money, NCAA impunity, Duke education, "brotherhood", not having to work as hard, Olympics and the US team, false promises for touches and playing time, and so on.

One guy, Zion, might not change that. But I'd rather not see him become a megastar for Coach K to utilize. I'd rather not have Coach K point to Zion when making pitches to Hardy, Banchero, Kuminga.

And we've been saying he was nearing the end in his late 60's. He is showing no signs of leaving in the next few years..
 
  • Like
Reactions: GonzoCat90

Bill Withers

All-American
Jun 23, 2019
2,756
5,924
0
Also it's a copout to just keep pushing the goalposts down the line.

If all you can do is predict that eventually his body breaks down, you never have to acknowledge how good he is in the meantime. It's basically the Siva>Wall argument Louisville fans made where you refuse to accept it and just wait until it's gone.
Come on Gonzo. You're better than that. You CAN both say he's a rare talent, and that his weight is an issue. See? I just did it. It's not a mutually exclusive proposition.
 
Jul 9, 2004
93,075
38,060
0
I've never thought otherwise. Also, he doesn't have to play 82 games a year. These guys aren't doing that anymore. They're now doing what they call "load management" where they take a game off for extra recovery. He's clearly been working on his game and if he can avoid injury he's going to be an all-star sooner rather than later.
 

GonzoCat90

Heisman
Mar 30, 2009
32,377
34,559
0
Come on Gonzo. You're better than that. You CAN both say he's a rare talent, and that his weight is an issue. See? I just did it. It's not a mutually exclusive proposition.

I didn't say it wasn't. I said trying to dismiss him by saying "yeah but he'll only be great for 7 years instead of 12" is weak.

You can't undercut everything he does in his entire career by predicting it'll end sooner than it should every time he does something great.

Injuries and longevity are something you weigh after the fact when debating greatness and careers, not a get out of jail free card to evade a guy you're hoping is a bust.
 

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
24,412
55,796
100
Coach K is almost 73 years old and it didn't make a damn bit of difference to Bagley or Zion or Ingram or Giles or anyone else when we were selling AD, Wall, etc compared to Plumlee and Austin Rivers because that isn't how they're landing those guys.
Good point, brother. BUT the Zion 24/7 hype machine doesn’t help.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GonzoCat90

TigerMoving

Heisman
Jul 13, 2014
8,079
22,438
113
I'm not sure how he has "lesser perimeter skills." I never saw Barkley hit four straight threes, and Zion's dribbling and passing skills are also well ahead of where Barkley's were at the same age.
Barkley actually hit SIX 3 pointers in a row on Feb 22nd 1989 against the Heat.
 

bluegrasshickory

Sophomore
Oct 28, 2017
303
167
0
its totally amazing to see people essentially root for one of the most electrifying 19 year olds ever to get injured so it hurts another teams recruiting. what ever happened to rooting for basketball? have you seen Zion pass in traffic at speed? he is unf'ing real. no one talks about his court vision but he feels like Magic Johnson at times.
 

justanotherguy505

All-Conference
Jul 16, 2003
13,225
2,217
0
Also, Zion becoming one of the greatest players in the league isn't exactly a good thing if you're Kentucky going up against Duke/Coach K.

Yes, there are legit reason for Kentucky fans to want this guy to fail.

Zion was going to be great no matter where he played; K had nothing to do with his talent level. He's going to be better than Davis.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,941
63,129
113
Zion was going to be great no matter where he played; K had nothing to do with his talent level. He's going to be better than Davis.

He has years of games he needs to stay healthy for, before he's better then Davis.

Jesus, the other team was daring him to shoot 3's last night giving him like 15 feet at times. It's great that he made them.. Let's see what happens a year from now when he's getting constantly double teamed and opposing coaches are trying to wear him out.

Also, it has nothing to do with his school, as it pertains to his past. It DOES have to do with that school using him a recruiting tool to get other players. Of course he was going to be great anywhere he went, that's not what people are arguing.
 

Catluv

All-Conference
Dec 18, 2018
3,546
4,692
0
Zion was going to be great no matter where he played; K had nothing to do with his talent level. He's going to be better than Davis.
Davis looks to be in WAY better shape than Z and he can't stay well. The way this is unfolding just don't see Z's body holding up. If he can stay healthy he will be phenomenal!
 

ChicagoCat90

All-American
Oct 12, 2014
2,125
6,373
97
People saying his ceiling is so and so are just hating. He has the ability, unnatural physical traits and the knack for getting to every loose ball/rebound to truly be special. Injuries will be the true wild card in his career. But if healthy there’s no telling how great he can be. Dude is a freak of nature and I mean that in the best of ways.
 

OHIO COLONEL

Heisman
Feb 11, 2009
14,803
59,401
0
Barkley worked hard on his weight and perimeter skills from the time he stepped foot on an NBA court and could most definitely dribble and pass. He is a top 50 player EVER. He could score from everywhere on the court, so he didn't NEED to shoot many 3's. Heck, the ONLY reason Zion shot 4 last night was because the Spurs didn't even guard him out there and was begging him to shoot it. I DOUBT he makes 4 in a game again this year.
Plus, two different generations. Barkley came up back when the 3 pt. shot was not emphasized as it is today. I imagine while in high school Barkley didn't shoot beyond 8-12 feet, while kids in Zion's generation want to become 3 pt shooters even if they can dominate inside.
 
  • Like
Reactions: richbrookstomato

Drcatfan

All-Conference
Apr 14, 2015
1,454
1,715
61
He is the heaviest or 2nd heaviest player in the NBA, and yes this includes the big centers that are over 7ft tall. He is as explosive of quickness and jumping as anyone in the NBA. That is the most weight plus the most acceleration. Force = mass x acceleration. Therefore, Zion is putting the most force on his joints and tendons of anyone in the NBA. I just don't see any way his body holds up.
 

Bill Withers

All-American
Jun 23, 2019
2,756
5,924
0
I didn't say it wasn't. I said trying to dismiss him by saying "yeah but he'll only be great for 7 years instead of 12" is weak.

You can't undercut everything he does in his entire career by predicting it'll end sooner than it should every time he does something great.

Injuries and longevity are something you weigh after the fact when debating greatness and careers, not a get out of jail free card to evade a guy you're hoping is a bust.
I think if folks can project Zion as the next Jordan, people can also say there's a good chance he's the next Greg Oden.
 

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
He is the heaviest or 2nd heaviest player in the NBA, and yes this includes the big centers that are over 7ft tall. He is as explosive of quickness and jumping as anyone in the NBA. That is the most weight plus the most acceleration. Force = mass x acceleration. Therefore, Zion is putting the most force on his joints and tendons of anyone in the NBA. I just don't see any way his body holds up.

This is how I see it too.

I'm a big Zion fan, and hope he's a huge success. But I think injuries will end up derailing him. There's a reason heavy players tend to have shorter careers, extra weight puts extra stress and wear and tear on the ligaments, bones and joints every time they land.

And with the extraordinary way he jumps, combined with his weight, I don't think any player has ever put more landing impact on his body than Zion. His body will probably break down at an earlier age than usual.
 
Last edited:

RipThru

All-American
Jan 11, 2010
4,739
5,969
0
It's awesome that he went 4/4 from 3 last night, but if you truly think that's who he is at this stage of his career...:flushed:
 

Trinity45

All-American
Oct 26, 2005
3,428
5,354
113
I know that ESPN has been the Zion hype channel, but he’s good. He might be a 50% three point shooter. I don’t know if he’ll be greater than LeBron as durability questions still linger, but if he plays like he did tonight, we’ll have a new king.

First he probably will be good, but if you are basing his 3pt % on that game, hell I could have made those, did you see the footage, they gave him over 5', it was like shooting in practice, which is most likely the one thing he could work on while in rehab.
 

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
I think he's more in the mold of zach randolph but with more athleticism.

He's three inches shorter and immeasurably more athletic than Randolph, and also a far better defender, ballhandler and passer.

But I guess there is the similarity in that they're both heavy lefty power forwards who really know how to to score in the post.
 

Grs51

Sophomore
Mar 31, 2016
212
189
43
I know that ESPN has been the Zion hype channel, but he’s good. He might be a 50% three point shooter. I don’t know if he’ll be greater than LeBron as durability questions still linger, but if he plays like he did tonight, we’ll have a new king.


Check back in 15 years in order to compare him to LaBron
 

Azbleedblu

Redshirt
Mar 17, 2019
24
8
0
I wish the kid nothing but the best but last night my wife and I were watching and just kept waiting for him to go down. That knee was wrapped like Bill Walton's - after he was in the league 20 years. He looked gimpy - then of course we turned it off and then I pull up ESPN this morning and he had 17 in a row, so yeah. I worry he may be another Greg Odom but I hope that's not the case
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Two Former Kentucky Wildcats Selected in UFL Draft
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Recruiting Kentucky signs 'perfect fit' in Ryan Hampton, 'unique build and skillset' in Cherif Millogo
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Women's Basketball The Memorial Memo (EP. 76): Previewing Marshall + Clara Strack's WNBA Draft stock
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Braydon Hawthorne's offensive game is only beginning to reveal itself