Zion and Puke big trouble

Lumpy 2

All-Conference
Jan 16, 2011
1,944
1,106
0
Zion didn't know it was against the rules to take the money and Duke didn't think the rule about giving athletes improper benefits applied to them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kygrandpa

KentuckyCat420

Heisman
Sep 16, 2006
39,249
29,513
72
Zion’s argument is his contract with her was illegal because of a North Carolina law that protects athletes. She wants to show his family was already accepting benefits and their contract was in fact legally binding.
It protects student athletes, not just athletes. They’re going to prove he was no student athlete because of the impermissible benefits he received.
 

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
30,633
74,067
113
 

420grover

All-American
Mar 26, 2006
7,703
7,860
0
Duke is a private school and doesn't have to show anything or play by the same rules that everyone else does. Begs the question, how can you participate in the NCAA and not be obligated to show the same stuff as other Universities?
Those are requirements from the government, not the NCAA.
 

downw/ball-lineD

All-Conference
Jan 2, 2003
7,879
3,573
0
My understanding of the case (admittedly limited) is that Z's lawyers alleged his contract with the agent who is suing him was illegal under a state amateurism statute (can't remember if it was NC or SC). Regardless of the state, Z's own defense team essentially made Z's amateur status an issue by alleging the amateurism statute as a defense. As such, I can't imagine any court now saying those ?s (the questions Z and his team are trying not to answer)are not relevant. Z's defense team made them relevant by claiming it as a defense. Further, the rules on discovery are generally interpreted broadly by courts. Whether the information is allowed in a trial is another matter entirely---although off the top of my head I don't know why it wouldn't be admissible in Z's trial---as it is alleged to be his defense.

A distinction needs to be made here. Z would only be guilty of a crime if he was caught lying under oath or by proof of tax evasion/ money laundering---likely, but currently not being investigated. This case is about a contract dispute between the former agent and Z only. There is no law enforcement or NCAA involvement currently.By answering he received money under oath (if he did or it gets that far), Z would be admitting he was not an amateur at the time he signed the contract (as defined by the NCAA/ nor would he be availed of the protections of the state statute protecting amateurs---b/c he was not an amateur. He took money). Duke/NCAA would only be affected collaterally to those answers. This, of course, assumes the NCAA even cares about this matter. I have my doubts given who it would effect.

I do agree his attorneys will likely stall til the end of time, but given the defense Z raised I don't see how the answers to the questions are not "relevant". JMO
 

WGtripod69

Junior
Jan 5, 2020
218
298
0
It's not a criminal case. If he pleads the fifth, it's basically an admission of guilt and the judge will rule against him.
Then he can’t defend himself properly Over release of his contract. Even after appeal which zion will lose, he will have to admit to all the dirt in order to be released from his contract.

his defense currently is he was an amateur and couldn’t legally sign (in so many words). They are saying he wasn’t an amateur because he accepted money to play at duke which rules him ineligible and not an amateur meaning that contract he signed was legal. Now unless the brotherhood coughs up 100m for zion, I can’t see zion giving two buffets about throwing duke under the bus.

the agents won’t accept some bs middle ground to end the lawsuit cause zion is a cash cow and they have legal right to enforce that contract he signed. You think his agent will agree to some 10m payout when zion can bring them 10s of millions yearly. Zion pans out Hes the new Lebron aka atm machine.

I’m sorry puke is screwed. I imagine Zion settles but he will have to admit what he received. If he doesn’t he can always stay with his current agents
 

ConRay9

All-American
Nov 15, 2017
3,199
6,711
0
Everyone brace yourselves for the quick moving goalposts by Duke fans. Instead of denial, I’m sure most will decry the system and complain how every player gets paid nowadays—not just them. Duke fans everywhere will be the most vocal “pay players” crowd going forward.

Count on it.
 
Last edited:

LadyCaytIL

Heisman
Oct 28, 2012
33,077
34,745
113
Everyone brace yourselves for the quick moving goalposts by Duke fans. Instead of denial, I’m sure most will decry the system and complain how every player gets paid nowadays—not just them. Duke fans everywhere will be the most vocal “pay players” crowd.

Count on it.

of course... our fan base would do the same . just the way the human psyche works.

but damn it would be fun to watch the high and mighty untouchable Duke have to squirm
 

ConRay9

All-American
Nov 15, 2017
3,199
6,711
0
of course... our fan base would do the same . just the way the human psyche works.

but damn it would be fun to watch the high and mighty untouchable Duke have to squirm

I wouldn’t even wholly disagree with them—I think players should command whatever market value they deserve, but damn does it feel good seeing KU, Duke, UL etc all getting caught while for years they said our banners would be temporary.

Our fans probably would too, but these other fanbases are now hypocrites. I’ll hold my breath on punishments—they can get off their high horse now though.
 

dukesuxone

Freshman
Jul 28, 2009
31
62
18
dUKe will skate Scott free. Zion will settle the case & pay & be reimbursed by dUKe Boosters & told to keep quiet, you don't know nothing got it big boy. Besides everybody knows dUKe would never cheat, they investigated themselves & found no wrong doings, imagine that. Had this been UK the media would have their pitch forks & torches ready to burn us to the ground. We did cheat "allegedly" & we did our time for the crime. UNcheat & Puke will never be compromised by the media or NCAA, just my opinion. I will believe it when it happens. UNCheat already walked free from 20+ yrs. of academic fraud.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kygrandpa

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
I'm just glad that dirtbag Coach K needs to spend some of his final days in the game, dealing with this mess. I hope it totally derails the upcoming season and messes up recruiting for a few years, before he calls it quits in his mid 70's.
Yep and everybody will know they are dirty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatfanMike47

podgejeff_

All-American
Dec 4, 2005
8,067
5,268
113
Man, if Duke boosters can cough up that much money quietly in order to protect their program, they deserve to skate.

I'm sure there are a ton of billionaires out there willing to take a significant hit to their wealth in order to protect the sanctity of Duke and the amazing Sweet 16 run they had.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,933
63,119
113
Man, if Duke boosters can cough up that much money quietly in order to protect their program, they deserve to skate.

I'm sure there are a ton of billionaires out there willing to take a significant hit to their wealth in order to protect the sanctity of Duke and the amazing Sweet 16 run they had.

IDK.. money is money. If someone asked you to give even just $20k or else Kentucky would lose a Sweet 16.. would you do it?

I have to believe even the biggest fans would bow out at that point.
 

arenk

Senior
Jan 3, 2003
2,108
927
0
Still - nothing will come of this for Duke, and I doubt anyone ever knows the answers that spew from Zions mouth. If he ever actually answers questions, which I doubt he will.

FYI - the only way he can refuse to answer is to take the 5th. While no adverse inference can be drawn from that in a CRIMINAL TRIAL with Zion as a defendant without violating Zion's 5th and 14th Amendment rights, the fact that he has to assert it would pretty well convict him, Duke and Coach K in the court of public opinion. It'll be a lot like what happened to Wooden, UCLA and its titles after the truth about Sam Gilbert was unearthed. This would cast a cloud over the Duke program going back decades and the stein will never be removed. UNC has the same problem.

We had a brief problem with the Chris Mills incident which Dwayne Casey insists to this day was a frame up job. There is also a cloud over what I believe was Rupp's 1954 undefeated team for point shaving, but I was too young then to recall whether the allegation was ever proved. Can anyone shed light on that? In any event, I believe Dwayne Casey, but have no opinion either way about the 1954 team shaving points. Either way, UK has never been proven to have systemically cheated in basketball recruiting or in any other way regarding its basketball program.

As far as Duke never being exposed, I'm sure Wooden thought that too. There is an old proverb that 'you can fool all of the people some of the time, some of the people all of the time, but you can't fool all the people all the time'. Not only is that true, but the cat is already out of the bag concerning Coach K's character. Ask Will Avery, Chris Burgess, Jason Tatum and a long list of other recruits that have said publicly that they were lied to by Coach K and we know that he lied about not having admonished that Oregon player for taking a shot against Duke in the last couple seconds when Oregon knocked Duke out of the NCAAT a few years ago. I could cite many other examples that reflect poorly on his character, but I think they are all well documented on this board.
 
Last edited:

Jmeeks54thebest

All-American
Apr 18, 2009
6,867
9,733
0
I want those cheaters caught, but how can they require him to answer questions? He has the fifth amendment right to not answer questions. And even if they violate that right and somehow force him to answer I would expect him to lie.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Duke fans want to get rid of Jon Scheyer after getting blasted by Illinois
  2. 02 KSR Basketball A 69-year-old record held by Kentucky legend Grady Wallace was broken last night
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Indiana takes down John Calipari, Arkansas ahead of showdown with Kentucky in Indy
  4. 04 KSR KSR Show, 11/18: Ask Anything Wednesday, live from 10-noon
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Heshimu Evans arrested on domestic violence charge in Lexington