Zambrano to Cubs bullpen

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
more than anything is how Marmol will handle it because he didn't really handle the situation with Gregg all that well last year, if I remember right. However, on the flip side, since he has been through this before, he may handle it better.
 

DawgatAuburn

All-Conference
Apr 25, 2006
11,193
2,329
113
A $91.5 million dollar set up man. Not closer. Set up man.

Over/under on Cub wins this year. I'll set it at 73.5.
 

EmoryBellard

Redshirt
Nov 16, 2005
802
0
0
You really believe Z should continue to start just because that's what he is being paid to do?

I can see more than one argument that this is not a good idea; I'd wager there's better than a 50% chance it's not (but like I said, I do think it's the least bad option at this time). But "well the team is paying Z a bazillion dollars" is a weak reason not to do it.

And for the record, I will take the over - for now, at least.
 

DawgatAuburn

All-Conference
Apr 25, 2006
11,193
2,329
113
You paid the man to be a starter. You have to keep him in the rotation. Someone has to eat up the 170+ innings that he would take care of. Can you really say you feel confident that Tom Gorzellany can do that? Dempster, OK. Wells, getting my confidence more each day. Lilly, if healthy, is fine. Silva, three good starts but could fall off the cliff at any time. I'm not saying that if he is a 4 inning, 8 earned run guy every time out that you don't try something new, but the move to the pen after four starts and the day after his best start of the year is strange. The Cubs highest ceiling is with Zambrano pitching at a high level. Moving him to the pen lowers his ceiling, and therefore, the team's.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
bad contract can't dictate your rotation...I think the bullpen would be better for him because he likes to work fast and he is also a full-fledged idiot

If it works and makes them better, then it's the right thing to do, regardless of the insane amount they signed him for in the contract
 

EmoryBellard

Redshirt
Nov 16, 2005
802
0
0
I don't see this as a "punishment" for Z based on 4 games. This is in response to a major, major problem in the pen, and putting Z there is the least bad temporary solution.

The house is on fire, and something had to be done to put the flames out. Had the bullpen been even average, I don't suspect you'd see Lou making this move, even if Z continued having subpar outtings.
 

DawgatAuburn

All-Conference
Apr 25, 2006
11,193
2,329
113
Z alone is not going to fix the pen issues. All those other guys are still going to suck, and Z won't be able to pitch every day to get the 3-6 outs they need to get to Marmol. At some point the Cubs have to look in the mirror and say "Hey, you know what, our window passed with this group or players, so we need to retool for 2012." As soon as they do that and stop trying to fix it with stupid moves like signing Bradley and moving Z to the pen, then the sooner they can be relevant again. There is no long term upside to this move. None. Zero. The short term might be taking them from a 75 win team with a bad bullpen to a 77 win team with two great guys in the pen but a below average rotation.
 

EmoryBellard

Redshirt
Nov 16, 2005
802
0
0
If the season isn't going anywhere? Z isn't an ace, and hasn't been for 3 years, so why not shore up the pen and try something different.
 

RebelBruiser

Redshirt
Aug 21, 2007
7,349
0
0
but if he's a $90M set up man, then it's a huge indictment against Jim Hendry, along with Soriano, Bradley, and the other screw ups he's had. That guy has locked the Cubbies into building around a core of Z, Soriano, Ramirez, and Lee, and that's a shaky group to build around. You have to have some good luck with your minor leaguers to have that work.
 

Steakonastick

Redshirt
Jan 1, 2009
365
12
18
no way i move him to the pen, he is a head case, which i cant see anyway he can help any of the bullpen pitcher but do more to hurt their . Seems the cubs have a lot of problems this off season and alot of money in players who seems to be on the downhill quick.
 
Mar 3, 2008
217
0
0
<span style="font-style: italic;">Carlos Zambrano is simply a better pitcher than Carlos Silva. Carlos
Zambrano is simply a more durable pitcher than Carlos Silva. Instead of
getting 180-200 innings out of one of his top pitchers, Lou Piniella is
instead opting for about 40 to 50 innings from him and then 100 to 150
out of a pitcher who projected as average at best coming into the
season. The Cubs’ chances at the division were low coming into the
season. If Piniella’s rash and irrational decision stays in place, they
become virtually nil. </span><br style="font-style: italic;">
http://www.fangraphs.com/...ella-zambrano-to-bullpen
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
Tito Cheeseburger Jr said:
<span style="font-style: italic;">Carlos Zambrano is simply a better pitcher than Carlos Silva. Carlos
Zambrano is simply a more durable pitcher than Carlos Silva. Instead of
getting 180-200 innings out of one of his top pitchers, Lou Piniella is
instead opting for about 40 to 50 innings from him and then 100 to 150
out of a pitcher who projected as average at best coming into the
season. The Cubs’ chances at the division were low coming into the
season. If Piniella’s rash and irrational decision stays in place, they
become virtually nil. </span><br style="font-style: italic;">
http://www.fangraphs.com/...ella-zambrano-to-bullpen


The innings may be less for Zambrano, but he pitches in more games, and thus can help them in more games, uincluding the ones that Silva doesn't finish.

It worked with Kerry Wood a couple of years ago.
 
Mar 3, 2008
217
0
0
He throws 200 innings every year. Not many pitchers can do that. Wood got hurt all the time.

Plus Vegas wouldn't take odds on Silva regressing. The guy has been terrible and his ERA<1 after two starts. That's not going to last.

You can argue that it makes sense if it's more of a psychological move to get him going. Who knows, maybe it will work.
 

EmoryBellard

Redshirt
Nov 16, 2005
802
0
0
<span style="font-style: italic;">Carlos Zambrano is simply a better pitcher than Carlos Silva. </span>No one says otherwise. <span style="font-style: italic;">Carlos
Zambrano is simply a more durable pitcher than Carlos Silva. </span>That's actually debatable.<span style="font-style: italic;"> Instead of
getting 180-200 innings out of one of his top pitchers, Lou Piniella is
instead opting for about 40 to 50 innings from him and then 100 to 150
out of a pitcher who projected as average at best coming into the
season. </span>If Z stays in the pen, he'll get more like 70-80 innings, but point taken. Having said that, Z would be taking bullpen innings AWAY from someone shatty like Berg or Szmardjiajinemrfk, so this very well could be a step up<span style="font-style: italic;">. The Cubs’ chances at the division were low coming into the
season. </span>Maybe. The Cards and Brewers aren't anything special this year, and the rest of the division is atrocious.<span style="font-style: italic;"> If Piniella’s rash and irrational decision stays in place, they
become virtually nil. </span>Irrational would be to keep on doing the same thing, getting the same result, and hoping for better results.<br style="font-style: italic;">
 

EmoryBellard

Redshirt
Nov 16, 2005
802
0
0
And Silva has gone over 200 twice in his career.

I wouldn't bet on Silva having a great season. But I'd say there's a *chance* he does, in which case this move will pay huge dividends if Z is productive from the pen.
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
because relief pitching and starting are two totally different things. Durability may defined as 200 innings for a starter, but if a relief pitcher can pitch in 70 games or so, they would be considered very durable even though a relief pitcher would rack up half as many innings.

I think this works IF Ted Lilly comes back strong. If he doesn't, Lou will have to move Zambrano back to the rotation.

You have maybe 3-4 guys that htypothetically speaking are 5-6 inning guys, but you have this one guy who can pitch the other two and get the game to your closer every other day realistically speaking vs 1-2 inning eaters and a bad bullpen costing you games every 3-5th day, not to mention the "off days" that the inning eaters may have from time to time.

We'll see. I'm not entirely sold on it working simply because some guys are starters and that's all they are and they can't handle relief pitching. Some guys are relief pitchers and can't start on the other side of the coin. I will say that most aces can close and be relief pitchers, and that's why I think it will work, like I said IF Lilly is healthy.
 
Mar 3, 2008
217
0
0
Durability is different for starters v. relievers. Who knows how he'll react. To this point, Zambrano's value has come from pitching a high volume of innings at above average (but not ace) ability.

This is probably just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic. Soriano misplayed another ball in left last night and they lost again.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 88-46 Alabama State: Bulldogs beat the Hornets in annual Kids' Day game
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State at UCF: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball on the road
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times
  5. 05 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability