Wrestling Thread

CrimeDawg18

All-Conference
Oct 17, 2006
8,643
2,584
113
If I'm not mistaken I believe that was due to an early IWA Mid-South show
If memory servers correctly when IWA Mid-South started they were drawing huge crowds. Jim Cornette and Danny Davis reported them to the Kentucky Athletic Commission and they got banned from the state. That's why they started running across the river in Indiana.
 

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
408
552
93
It's up to the guys like HHH and Michaels to be stewards for the business, to explain its ins and outs to the TKO guys that have no wrestling background. And they are failing miserably. But they don't care because they got theirs. Should've expected nothing different from the guys behind the Curtain Call.
That's not their job lol. Triple H oversees creative for two national shows, one on Netflix, the other on USA. HBK runs creative for a show on the CW and a couple times a year his roster gets raided and he and his team have to start over. Their job isn't to teach a billionaire the history of pro wrestling.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
I was listening to Busted Open radio this weekend, and one of the hosts said they thought her being in ROH had something to do with a wrestling school she runs. But they didn't elaborate on it, so I didn't really understand the reference.
She runs a school and an indie promotion or two tied to it. From what I gather, she loves doing it and is pretty hands on with all of it.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
Yeah it's just...boring. The idea that there are people that actually watch all of Raw and SmackDown each week is mind-blowing to me.

It's a wrestling company that is now ran by people that don't particularly like wrestling. Listen to their execs talk about it. It's just another revenue stream to them. There's little incentive for them to improve the product because most of their income is from huge media rights deals. WWE is exhibit A of enshittification.

They just don't get it. They took Saturday Night's Main Event, which was a pretty big deal, like a Clash of the Champions type, PPV-quality TV special. And they reduced it to just...another show. Everything feels skippable and nothing feels special.

It's up to the guys like HHH and Michaels to be stewards for the business, to explain its ins and outs to the TKO guys that have no wrestling background. And they are failing miserably. But they don't care because they got theirs. Should've expected nothing different from the guys behind the Curtain Call.
WWE is a very good example of late stage capitalism. Pay more and more and get less and less in terms of quality and quantity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheApostleSaulSmith

billCgmx_

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2009
769
4,953
93
The issue I have with Raw and Smackdown is the shows are basically the same most weeka. Let's start out with a couple of clips of what happened over the past weeks, then show some wrestlers walking into the arena. then have a 20 minute talk segment in the ring followed by a match that shows about 3 minutes worth of action followed by a slew of commercials. What's creative about that?

Back to AEW... RIP Generational Title Run
 
  • Like
Reactions: MegaBlue05

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
408
552
93
My contention is that they have trained their fans to not really like wrestling. They like WWE, not wrestling.

"AEW's PPV's are too long. AEW doesn't tell any stories, etc."

They literally complain about having too much wrestling on a show.

So the WWE fans are buying what management is selling, for some reason.
You're slowly turning into Dragon lol. This is an elitist attitude and one that turns away some who may give AEW a shot otherwise. Someone on the SquaredCircle sub recently asked what's stopped you from diving into AEW. The top answer was AEW fans. They're seen as elitists who look down at anyone who isn't submerged in indie wrestling or still enjoys WWE. I don't know where you got that WWE fans don't like wrestling since most of us grew up watching WWF, WCW, USWA, ECW, TNA, and various terrority tapes. I guess I don't like wrestling because I don't care about NJPW, ROH, or PWG in SOCAL? Do I need to care that Penta wrestled Chelsea Green in Lucha Underground before they won titles in WWE?

On the length of PPV's, that's more of an AEW fan complaint. I'm not the one leaving a venue at 12:40 am on a Sunday night after six hours and 14 matches so I have nothing to complain about. Some AEW fans however who do think that's a bit extreme while others embrace it.

I've said before I wouldn't go to a current WWE show for a variety of reasons but many still do. If I'm an AEW fan, I'd wonder why AEW can't get more than 2,000-4,000 to show up for Dynamite in the states. That's been my point in the past. AEW fans claim they're on fire and it's the best this and best that and this episode was great, that PPV was perfection - but where are the fans on Wed nights? Even a cooled down WWE just did over 9,000 in Rupp for SD. If AEW tried that they'd get less than 3,000. I'm glad they just sold out NYC but AEW fans tend to push a narrative when numbers say differently. Face it my guy, most wrestling fans may not be thrilled with WWE right now but most wrestling fans don't really care about AEW either.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
You're slowly turning into Dragon lol. This is an elitist attitude and one that turns away some who may give AEW a shot otherwise. Someone on the SquaredCircle sub recently asked what's stopped you from diving into AEW. The top answer was AEW fans. They're seen as elitists who look down at anyone who isn't submerged in indie wrestling or still enjoys WWE. I don't know where you got that WWE fans don't like wrestling since most of us grew up watching WWF, WCW, USWA, ECW, TNA, and various terrority tapes. I guess I don't like wrestling because I don't care about NJPW, ROH, or PWG in SOCAL? Do I need to care that Penta wrestled Chelsea Green in Lucha Underground before they won titles in WWE?

On the length of PPV's, that's more of an AEW fan complaint. I'm not the one leaving a venue at 12:40 am on a Sunday night after six hours and 14 matches so I have nothing to complain about. Some AEW fans however who do think that's a bit extreme while others embrace it.

I've said before I wouldn't go to a current WWE show for a variety of reasons but many still do. If I'm an AEW fan, I'd wonder why AEW can't get more than 2,000-4,000 to show up for Dynamite in the states. That's been my point in the past. AEW fans claim they're on fire and it's the best this and best that and this episode was great, that PPV was perfection - but where are the fans on Wed nights? Even a cooled down WWE just did over 9,000 in Rupp for SD. If AEW tried that they'd get less than 3,000. I'm glad they just sold out NYC but AEW fans tend to push a narrative when numbers say differently. Face it my guy, most wrestling fans may not be thrilled with WWE right now but most wrestling fans don't really care about AEW either.
AEW is averaging over 3K this year for Dynamite.

 

Im The Village Idiot

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2025
526
1,503
93
You're slowly turning into Dragon lol. This is an elitist attitude and one that turns away some who may give AEW a shot otherwise. Someone on the SquaredCircle sub recently asked what's stopped you from diving into AEW. The top answer was AEW fans. They're seen as elitists who look down at anyone who isn't submerged in indie wrestling or still enjoys WWE. I don't know where you got that WWE fans don't like wrestling since most of us grew up watching WWF, WCW, USWA, ECW, TNA, and various terrority tapes. I guess I don't like wrestling because I don't care about NJPW, ROH, or PWG in SOCAL? Do I need to care that Penta wrestled Chelsea Green in Lucha Underground before they won titles in WWE?

On the length of PPV's, that's more of an AEW fan complaint. I'm not the one leaving a venue at 12:40 am on a Sunday night after six hours and 14 matches so I have nothing to complain about. Some AEW fans however who do think that's a bit extreme while others embrace it.

I've said before I wouldn't go to a current WWE show for a variety of reasons but many still do. If I'm an AEW fan, I'd wonder why AEW can't get more than 2,000-4,000 to show up for Dynamite in the states. That's been my point in the past. AEW fans claim they're on fire and it's the best this and best that and this episode was great, that PPV was perfection - but where are the fans on Wed nights? Even a cooled down WWE just did over 9,000 in Rupp for SD. If AEW tried that they'd get less than 3,000. I'm glad they just sold out NYC but AEW fans tend to push a narrative when numbers say differently. Face it my guy, most wrestling fans may not be thrilled with WWE right now but most wrestling fans don't really care about AEW either.
Too much gatekeeping on both sides. Everyone should just think for themselves and enjoy what they enjoy. AEW is perfectly suitable for my tastes. Simple. Doesn’t mean it is for others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nightwish

Laparkafan

All-American
Sep 5, 2004
14,328
9,983
93
My contention is that they have trained their fans to not really like wrestling. They like WWE, not wrestling.

"AEW's PPV's are too long. AEW doesn't tell any stories, etc."

They literally complain about having too much wrestling on a show.

So the WWE fans are buying what management is selling, for some reason.
To be fair it was too long it ended at 1230 and the next train out of New York was 1236 and after that was 230am so if you missed the bum rush to get on one you were stuck for 2 hours.
 

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
408
552
93
AEW is averaging over 3K this year for Dynamite.


It's a bit better but a little over 3,000 isn't great. It's better than what TNA or any other promotion in the states is doing but I still don't understand why in year seven an A show can't have 5,000 or 6,000 on average. It's a large country. One would think one company (Raw) can do 9,500 and the other (Dynamite) do 5,000 or 6,000. I go back to them in Asheville with a small number and AEW fans online using "it's a small market!" as an excuse. Maybe the show just isn't as good as many claim. Doesn't mean their PPV's aren't great but something is amiss here.
 

Im The Village Idiot

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2025
526
1,503
93
3,000 or 30,000 fans at a show…..wtf cares? Do wrestling fans still care about the product? If I watch Raw, why does it matter whether 7,425 people did or did not enjoy the product? There’s an audience of one that matters and that’s you, the individual viewer. Now, certainly I can see having a hot crowd on the production can give the show a boost of energy, but it isn’t as though any wrestling show is going to place a camera on the empty seats for you to gaze at during the show. This stuff is nothing but reasons for people to sling mud at one another for picking the “wrong show” even though there is no such thing as a right or wrong wrestling show. And no one is smarter or better than the other for having a preference about a niche form of entertainment lol.
 

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
408
552
93
Too much gatekeeping on both sides. Everyone should just think for themselves and enjoy what they enjoy. AEW is perfectly suitable for my tastes. Simple. Doesn’t mean it is for others.
And that's cool. There was a point in the old thread where I said I felt Collision was the best show of the week and Dynamite second. It's just not really my thing anymore. I'm happy they exist and there's no doubt you get more bang for your buck with AEW than WWE right now. I've only really questioned how every PPV can be can't miss and with some, how every show can be great while AEW needed to move to small venues because the amount of fans they needed weren't showing up. It's a very "THIS IS GREAT EVERYONE WATCH HOW GREAT THIS IS" vibe as fans walk away or slowly stop watching.

I'm sorta with Brian Last at the moment. Some may disagree but he's said wrestling sucks right now. WWE is boring and riddled with ads and lazy storylines and AEW doesn't make sense with constant tourneys, constant titles, and random matches between dudes 90% of the wrestling world doesn't know exists.
 

Laparkafan

All-American
Sep 5, 2004
14,328
9,983
93
3,000 or 30,000 fans at a show…..wtf cares? Do wrestling fans still care about the product? If I watch Raw, why does it matter whether 7,425 people did or did not enjoy the product? There’s an audience of one that matters and that’s you, the individual viewer. Now, certainly I can see having a hot crowd on the production can give the show a boost of energy, but it isn’t as though any wrestling show is going to place a camera on the empty seats for you to gaze at during the show. This stuff is nothing but reasons for people to sling mud at one another for picking the “wrong show” even though there is no such thing as a right or wrong wrestling show. And no one is smarter or better than the other for having a preference about a niche form of entertainment lol.
Not slinging mud but there’s tons of articles like “Lexington did better in 2025 than this year with wwe ticket sales” it can give an inclination if the product is hot or cooling off. It can give a short term indication how the product is viewed. As opposed to Netflix being a 5-10 year deal that’s already money banked In wwe pocket.
 
  • Like
Reactions: American Dragon

Im The Village Idiot

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2025
526
1,503
93
And that's cool. There was a point in the old thread where I said I felt Collision was the best show of the week and Dynamite second. It's just not really my thing anymore. I'm happy they exist and there's no doubt you get more bang for your buck with AEW than WWE right now. I've only really questioned how every PPV can be can't miss and with some, how every show can be great while AEW needed to move to small venues because the amount of fans they needed weren't showing up. It's a very "THIS IS GREAT EVERYONE WATCH HOW GREAT THIS IS" vibe as they've lost viewers in recent years.

I'm sorta with Brian Last at the moment. Some may disagree but he's said wrestling sucks right now. WWE is boring and riddled with ads and lazy storylines and AEW doesn't make sense with constant tourneys, constant titles, and random matches between dudes 90% of the wrestling world doesn't know exists.
I dont agree with Brian Last or Cornette much on today’s product, think they love sensationalism and inconsistency. I actually think their type of content harms the business more than helps these days. A lot of gatekeeping. Huge old school wrestling fan and as a wrestler/manager myself a while back, I patterned a lot after Corny. Very smart man, not many more entertaining but he’s a highlight film of inconsistency and confirmation bias. Last and Corny are chief in an era of clickbait content that isn’t for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: American Dragon

Im The Village Idiot

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2025
526
1,503
93
Not slinging mud but there’s tons of articles like “Lexington did better in 2025 than this year with wwe ticket sales” it can give an inclination if the product is hot or cooling off. It can give a short term indication how the product is viewed. As opposed to Netflix being a 5-10 year deal that’s already money banked In wwe pocket.
As a fan, my goal shouldn’t be to care if the product is hot or cold. Is my product satisfying me? Simple as that. Sometimes a hot or cold product are so for a reason however. Not denying that. Other times it’s more complex than that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheApostleSaulSmith

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
And that's cool. There was a point in the old thread where I said I felt Collision was the best show of the week and Dynamite second. It's just not really my thing anymore. I'm happy they exist and there's no doubt you get more bang for your buck with AEW than WWE right now. I've only really questioned how every PPV can be can't miss and with some, how every show can be great while AEW needed to move to small venues because the amount of fans they needed weren't showing up. It's a very "THIS IS GREAT EVERYONE WATCH HOW GREAT THIS IS" vibe as fans walk away or slowly stop watching.

I'm sorta with Brian Last at the moment. Some may disagree but he's said wrestling sucks right now. WWE is boring and riddled with ads and lazy storylines and AEW doesn't make sense with constant tourneys, constant titles, and random matches between dudes 90% of the wrestling world doesn't know exists.
WWE runs more tournaments and has more titles than AEW
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
Big news in Japan

Good: Bushiroad no longer owns New Japan

Bad: Major Japanese wrestling has become a lot more monopolized. CyberAgent now owns DDT, Noah, and New Japan, three of the five "big" Japanese men's promotions which also happens to be the three biggest of the five (the other two are All Japan and Dragon Gate). They also own TJPW, which is 1 of 2 major Joshi promotions.

 

TheApostleSaulSmith

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2026
951
2,160
83
Big news in Japan

Good: Bushiroad no longer owns New Japan

Bad: Major Japanese wrestling has become a lot more monopolized. CyberAgent now owns DDT, Noah, and New Japan, three of the five "big" Japanese men's promotions which also happens to be the three biggest of the five (the other two are All Japan and Dragon Gate). They also own TJPW, which is 1 of 2 major Joshi promotions.


I miss All Japan being relevant.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
To be fair, they both are guilty of having way too many titles. I don’t see how anyone could dispute that.
I'm definitely not disputing that. It's just a lame excuse to use to justify one company is boring/not worth watching while giving the other company a pass for it.

That would be like me saying I don't like watching the Boston Celtics or think they are boring because they shoot too many threes (4th in the NBA at 42.1 attempts) while not including that as a reason I dislike watching the Warriors or find them boring (led the league at 44.1 attempts).
 

TheApostleSaulSmith

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2026
951
2,160
83
I dont agree with Brian Last or Cornette much on today’s product, think they love sensationalism and inconsistency. I actually think their type of content harms the business more than helps these days. A lot of gatekeeping. Huge old school wrestling fan and as a wrestler/manager myself a while back, I patterned a lot after Corny. Very smart man, not many more entertaining but he’s a highlight film of inconsistency and confirmation bias. Last and Corny are chief in an era of clickbait content that isn’t for me.
I think they actually hate WWE more than AEW at the moment which is really saying something.
I love Corny but his biases are clear. If you’re a big guy with a real athletic background and a “sports based presentation”, he likes you. He wanted guys like Dan Severn, Ken Shamrock and Steve Williams to hold the world title during the Attitude Era. That’s just goofy.
On the flip side if you’re a small man or Japanese woman, he will never bring himself to like you no matter what you do
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
I don't mind the National title in AEW now that it's firmly established as a midcarder title. Since the TNT, International, and Continental titles are always or much more frequently that not featured on someone that is good enough to be the AEW champion, it's good there is an actual midcard champ. TNT title used to be an actual midcard title, but the last five title holders have been Knight, Fletcher (2x), Ciampa, and Briscoe.

The trios titles are pointless even though I generally like the matches. They feel more like participation trophies and actually somewhat devalues the multi-man matches because of the pointlessness of the trios titles.

The women's tag title is a good idea in theory but that women's roster can never stay remotely healthy and they never get the TV time to properly book the world, TBS, and tag titles, especially not when Toni and Mercedes is out since they are seemingly the only two that can get consistent tv time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GeraldV

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,359
2,001
47
I think they actually hate WWE more than AEW at the moment which is really saying something.
I love Corny but his biases are clear. If you’re a big guy with a real athletic background and a “sports based presentation”, he likes you. He wanted guys like Dan Severn, Ken Shamrock and Steve Williams to hold the world title during the Attitude Era. That’s just goofy.
On the flip side if you’re a small man or Japanese woman, he will never bring himself to like you no matter what you do
Or god forbid you wrestle in a t-shirt. How many years did it take for Cornette to stop irrationally hating on Kevin Owens all because he wrestled in a t-shirt, like over a decade?
 

BookerNoe

Sophomore
Mar 9, 2021
73
103
33
WWE needs to merge the Men's tag titles and get rid of the Women's US title and have the Intercontinental title defended across both brands. The US Women's title is worthless.

Also if Roman wins this weekend then it is just more of the same. They need to make Fatu and not just have the same old ****.
 
  • Like
Reactions: American Dragon

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
408
552
93
On the whole SNME not feeling special point, you guys might wanna check the history of that show and the revitalized version in the 2000s. It's 4 or 5 matches and a lot of filler. Some of the cards I'm looking at are terrible minus a match here or there. Those shows felt special because we were young and it meant more wrestling.
 

Laparkafan

All-American
Sep 5, 2004
14,328
9,983
93
I think they actually hate WWE more than AEW at the moment which is really saying something.
I love Corny but his biases are clear. If you’re a big guy with a real athletic background and a “sports based presentation”, he likes you. He wanted guys like Dan Severn, Ken Shamrock and Steve Williams to hold the world title during the Attitude Era. That’s just goofy.
On the flip side if you’re a small man or Japanese woman, he will never bring himself to like you no matter what you do
Shamrock was awesome and fit in well and was a good ic champ. Plus the rock chair shot was unforgettable.

Severn was a joke but Steve Williams was good in the 80s with terry Gordy.