Some of those were before the playoff, and some others were "shared" titles, and he was also at Alabama for practically an extra decade. Look, Saban is a great coach, but if he doesn't exist, I think it's feasible another coach is getting a handful of those titles. Like, does Dabo Sweeny now have 4 titles in just a few short years? Where as if Cal doesn't exist, it's not like 2009 to 2015 just goes to the next best coach.. those Final4s are likely split up all over the place. Because pulling off 4 Final4's in 6 year is just not easy to do, and probably doesn't happen again.
College football is much more of a "Haves and the have-nots". Realistically there are 2-3 teams every year that just won't lose to anyone outside of that grouping, because of the sheer talent.
You totally lost me there, what titles did NS share? What titles somehow aren't the same because they were before the playoff?
There's a lot of ifs and buts there, but it simply boils down to this, no other coach has come close to equaling what Saban has done.
He won a title at LSU, he went to the NFL, came back to college and has been on a tear.
He also plays in, by far, the toughest conference, so the titles he won before the playoff started, are just as legit and the fact he has won most of the titles in the playoff era, proves even more that Alabama has been the best program because of him.
When Saban leaves, Alabama will fall off the mountain top and since nobody else has shown the ability to even come close to what Saban is doing, I think it's fair to say he's the greatest to ever coach college football.
Cal has had every opportunity, every advantage and he pissed it all away.
He's literally stated "they want me to win titles in this state, but my mission is bigger than that… ". That was a big F you to the fans.