Why doesn't the NCAA by pass the NBA rules

KentuckyFlyer

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2007
3,631
1,529
113
This may have been discussed before and I missed the thread. But why doesn't the NCAA just negate the NBA one year rule by making its own rules? Couldn't the NCAA make a rule that all scholarships must be honored for two years other than transfers to another school or some other hardships that may occur? If a player breaks the rule and leaves after one year, have it written into by-laws that he has to pay a percentage of his first contract to the NCAA as a penalty. 30% of a lotto pick is some serious cash. Seems they could do something like this rather than let the NBA dictate to them. Players could choose other options if they don't want to play in the NCAA for two years. Some think its unfair to tell these guys you HAVE to commit to a school for two years when they have the talents to go to the NBA right outta HS but the NBA is dictating to them already with the one and done rule.
 

ukgrad83

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2009
931
1,403
0
I've thought the same thing. You've got 18 year old's making a 4 year commitment to the military and they sure as heck don't back out of that. The net result would be less talent in college (as the OAD's would likely pursue Europe/Asia leagues), but you'd be back to having actual student athletes competing, not a training ground for the NBA.
 

Looksbetterinblue

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2018
1,085
1,412
98
What would the penalty be? The only real leverage if they left after one year would be repaymentf the scholarship and most wouldn’t have an issue if they went to the NBA.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Think every school would have to offer multi-year guaranteed scholarships for that. The big name players wouldn’t sign them and just go to the G- League or overseas.

Also there’s the image thing of the NCAA already making too much money off “amateur” athletes. Making the players sign contracts that could possibly take money out of their pockets... not a great look.

I’m not a lawyer but I feel there would be a lot of hurdles to drawing up a contract like that.
 

$Z71$

All-American
Nov 14, 2002
3,718
6,030
0
They already do though... that’s the NCAA for you.
My point was you don’t give an academic scholarship to a kid and if they leave to start a company say hey you need to pay us money now. Can’t do it for an athletic scholarship either. This isn’t even a feasible or morally correct idea. That’s why it’s never been discussed before.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
I've thought the same thing. You've got 18 year old's making a 4 year commitment to the military and they sure as heck don't back out of that. The net result would be less talent in college (as the OAD's would likely pursue Europe/Asia leagues), but you'd be back to having actual student athletes competing, not a training ground for the NBA.

But slippery slope if trying to mimick a military contract...
If that’s the case then should all college students sign/ be required to sign a 4 year contract? Law students ? Sociology majors? Those who play golf? Lacrosse ? Or just basketball...?
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf and brianpoe

mbc82584

All-Conference
Jun 11, 2006
3,321
2,204
0
This may have been discussed before and I missed the thread. But why doesn't the NCAA just negate the NBA one year rule by making its own rules? Couldn't the NCAA make a rule that all scholarships must be honored for two years other than transfers to another school or some other hardships that may occur? If a player breaks the rule and leaves after one year, have it written into by-laws that he has to pay a percentage of his first contract to the NCAA as a penalty. 30% of a lotto pick is some serious cash. Seems they could do something like this rather than let the NBA dictate to them. Players could choose other options if they don't want to play in the NCAA for two years. Some think its unfair to tell these guys you HAVE to commit to a school for two years when they have the talents to go to the NBA right outta HS but the NBA is dictating to them already with the one and done rule.

That would be a great way to make sure college basketball completely died.

The NBA holds all the power because they are the ones who actually negotiate with and pay players. It is a players league.

You can't stop someone from making a living, so any contract that tried to penalize the amateur athlete from turning pro would be unenforceable anyway.

Now, if the system changed to where kids could already be making a living while in school, you may be able to do something of this sort.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Make special rules just for athletes.


So you think they should make a contract/ rule that a player has to stay at whichever school they choose for all 4 years and if they leave then they owe the NCAA (who already make billions ) millions of $$ from their potential nba contract?

That seems like a huge slippery slope.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
There is absolutely no way they could enforce that. Not to mention it is simply unethical. A player by leaving after one year is not harming the school. At worst he is disappointing fans.

Also, you do realize I hope, that probably 80-90% of American NBA players grew up below the poverty line. Shame on anyone for wanting to put a mandatory delay in them getting themselves (and family) out of poverty by legal means. Not to mention the added (injury) risk (even if it is only 1-5%) by delaying their ability to earn an income.

What the NCAA should do, is allow undrafted players to return. If they accepted any cash, just pay it back and you can return. Pay for players travel expenses for NBA workouts. The NCAA-T is a Billion-$ cash cow for the NCAA. Say the top 100 players explore their options and workout for some teams, and on average spend $10K (which is a high estimate), that would be $1M, or just 1% of the NCAA-T revenue.

On top of that, I think the NCAA should also allow drafted players to return if they want to. Why protect the NBA's draft? You thought you would go in the 1st, but you went in the 2nd, come on back to school. You went #25 but you think you could be a lottery pick next year with a bigger contract, come on back to school. You don't want to move to OK City and play there, come on back to school. BUT, the NCAA could also use this threat as a tool for encouraging the NBA to change their draft rules and at least let the NCAA provide some input into the direction they change. The NBA teams do not want that added risk of losing their draft picks (even if it doesn't happen often). Think back to the 80's when John Elway said he would rather go play baseball than for the Colts. And I think 20 years later Eli Manning did something similar.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
So you think they should make a contract/ rule that a player has to stay at whichever school they choose for all 4 years and if they leave then they owe the NCAA (who already make billions ) millions of $$ from their potential nba contract?

That seems like a huge slippery slope.

No I don’t think that at all. The poster I quoted was saying they would have to make a special rule just for athletes. And I was pointing out they already have those so I wouldn’t put it past the NCAA.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
Oh, also, does this rule apply to computer geeks who leave college after 1 year to start up the next Snapchat or Facebook?
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
The reason for threads like this is fan selfishness. We don't want our best players to exit college and enter the NBA because we want our school to win more titles. So we PUNISH students who want to pursue their own version of happiness just to get what WE want? It's as absurd as passing gun control laws just to make ourselves feel better after a mass shooting. All that does is punish people who are trying to mind their own business. These threads are ridiculous.
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,642
36,339
113
That would be a great way to make sure college basketball completely died.

The NBA holds all the power because they are the ones who actually negotiate with and pay players. It is a players league.

You can't stop someone from making a living, so any contract that tried to penalize the amateur athlete from turning pro would be unenforceable anyway.

Now, if the system changed to where kids could already be making a living while in school, you may be able to do something of this sort.
Exactly. The last thing the ncaa needs is to look like even BIGGER a-holes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

Xception

Heisman
Apr 17, 2007
26,407
22,344
0
Athletes don’t have the rights regular students do and trying to hold them hostage just because fans want to build a super team is insane. Fans look out for their best interests concerning title chances, nobody outside that sphere would consider that rational thought.
 

Nubb16

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
128,718
10,043
67
What is the punishment going to be? Jail? Death?

Not sure how you can discipline someone who no longer wants to be there and will no longer be affiliated with your organization.
 

Trinity45

All-American
Oct 26, 2005
3,427
5,352
113
This may have been discussed before and I missed the thread. But why doesn't the NCAA just negate the NBA one year rule by making its own rules? Couldn't the NCAA make a rule that all scholarships must be honored for two years other than transfers to another school or some other hardships that may occur? If a player breaks the rule and leaves after one year, have it written into by-laws that he has to pay a percentage of his first contract to the NCAA as a penalty. 30% of a lotto pick is some serious cash. Seems they could do something like this rather than let the NBA dictate to them. Players could choose other options if they don't want to play in the NCAA for two years. Some think its unfair to tell these guys you HAVE to commit to a school for two years when they have the talents to go to the NBA right outta HS but the NBA is dictating to them already with the one and done rule.

How are you going to stop a kid from leaving college if they want to. There is no way this would stand up in court, are you going to do this for all students or just single out basketball players. Kids drop out of school all the time.
 

Wayward_Son

Redshirt
Mar 10, 2017
64
11
0
Expand the draft one more round. Let NBA ‘Draft and Stash’ college players. If they are not ready to play in the NBA, they stay and develop playing NCAA ball. Draft potential. Pay performance. Guarantee all draft contract. First round two years, like it is now. Second and third rounds one year. Allow a drafted player to take a ‘draw’ on his guaranteed contract which would count again the salary cap of the first season that the player was in the NBA. The only agreement with the NBA is the player couldn’t be called up mid-season of the NCAA season. Once a player is called up, he can’t go back; he is a pro. The NBA could keep their 19-year rule. That way the best players would still be able to play college ball at least for a year. NCAA basketball is still better when the best players play.
 

KentuckyFlyer

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2007
3,631
1,529
113
There is absolutely no way they could enforce that. Not to mention it is simply unethical. A player by leaving after one year is not harming the school. At worst he is disappointing fans.

Also, you do realize I hope, that probably 80-90% of American NBA players grew up below the poverty line. Shame on anyone for wanting to put a mandatory delay in them getting themselves (and family) out of poverty by legal means. Not to mention the added (injury) risk (even if it is only 1-5%) by delaying their ability to earn an income.

What the NCAA should do, is allow undrafted players to return. If they accepted any cash, just pay it back and you can return. Pay for players travel expenses for NBA workouts. The NCAA-T is a Billion-$ cash cow for the NCAA. Say the top 100 players explore their options and workout for some teams, and on average spend $10K (which is a high estimate), that would be $1M, or just 1% of the NCAA-T revenue.
The School would not be delaying them, they can go to Europe or other leagues for the one year that the NBA is already delaying their ability to earn an income.
And i like your idea of allowing them to go through the draft and if undrafted return.. There are several responses about the enforceable of the NCAA contract, im not a lawyer either, just assumed it would be if the player signed off on it.
 
Last edited:

ukgrad83

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2009
931
1,403
0
But slippery slope if trying to mimick a military contract...

I know, there are a lot of questions to answer and I'm not advocating for it yet, but it would return college athletics to what it was before the big money of professional sports came into play. Division 1 basketball/football athletics are no longer about student athletes, it's about chasing a pro dream. The NCAA doesn't give a dam-n about student athletes any more though, as evidenced by their lame a$$ response to UNC. For them it's all about the money and it has corrupted them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf

lsb34m3

Sophomore
Feb 19, 2012
114
130
43
I may be wrong but can’t high school baseball players be drafted and still go to college with the team holding their rights. Why isn’t this possible in basketball?
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,601
7,289
113
Yes, let's bring back indentured servitude so that Joe Schmo can watch pro-caliber basketball players for more than 1 season in college.

Greaaaaaaaaaaaaat idea.
 

awf

Heisman
May 31, 2006
10,411
20,774
0
I've thought the same thing. You've got 18 year old's making a 4 year commitment to the military and they sure as heck don't back out of that. The net result would be less talent in college (as the OAD's would likely pursue Europe/Asia leagues), but you'd be back to having actual student athletes competing, not a training ground for the NBA.
Can't you actually join the military and then quit if it doesn't suit you......I don't think it is like before where no matter if they found out that you was a peg leg you had to stay in ....
 

awf

Heisman
May 31, 2006
10,411
20,774
0
I've thought the same thing. You've got 18 year old's making a 4 year commitment to the military and they sure as heck don't back out of that. The net result would be less talent in college (as the OAD's would likely pursue Europe/Asia leagues), but you'd be back to having actual student athletes competing, not a training ground for the NBA.

But aren't all students training for a future profession?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 420grover

KentuckyFlyer

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2007
3,631
1,529
113
What is the punishment going to be? Jail? Death?

Not sure how you can discipline someone who no longer wants to be there and will no longer be affiliated with your organization.
lol, im not sure i was advocating prison or death.. The penalty would be a percentage of the first year NBA contract. I just assume that if the NCAA made the rule and the player signs off on it, its enforceable in any court, Could be wrong though.
 

KentuckyFlyer

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2007
3,631
1,529
113
What would the penalty be? The only real leverage if they left after one year would be repaymentf the scholarship and most wouldn’t have an issue if they went to the NBA.
There would be exceptions to the rule in hardship cases. Most likely dropping out for any reason other than the NBA
Yes, let's bring back indentured servitude so that Joe Schmo can watch pro-caliber basketball players for more than 1 season in college.

Greaaaaaaaaaaaaat idea.
If you have a choice in a matter and if you are being paid LOTS of cash for your services i fail to see how you are in "indentured servitude" Do Explain !!
 

ukgrad83

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2009
931
1,403
0
Can't you actually join the military and then quit if it doesn't suit you......I don't think it is like before where no matter if they found out that you was a peg leg you had to stay in ....

No idea but who knows in this day? Heck, I signed two different 4 year letters of commitment to employers during my career. If I reneged, I had to pay back a percentage to them (100% the first 2 years). But then I wasn't being woo'ed by Microsoft/Google either where I could casually pay off something like that, which is kind of what the kids are looking at by going pro.
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf

Ineverplayedthegame

All-Conference
Aug 12, 2005
5,139
4,960
0
The NCAA doesn’t need to make more rules.
It needs to make less rules.

Let the marketplace sort this out. Let the players sign with agents and make money off their own name and image. College basketball wins against minor league all day every day.

This is the easiest way to get money to the actual small number of players with pro potential in all sports without the colleges going broke having to pay non-revenue athletes. This would also bypass Title 9.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 420grover

awf

Heisman
May 31, 2006
10,411
20,774
0
Make special rules just for athletes.
The NCAA does have rules but they are all over the place....baseball, football and basketball all have different eligibility rules. Why can't they do like baseball and let drafted players stay. Why can't it be like football? The NCAA is unfair, contrary and obstinate!
 

awf

Heisman
May 31, 2006
10,411
20,774
0
Think every school would have to offer multi-year guaranteed scholarships for that. The big name players wouldn’t sign them and just go to the G- League or overseas.

Also there’s the image thing of the NCAA already making too much money off “amateur” athletes. Making the players sign contracts that could possibly take money out of their pockets... not a great look.

I’m not a lawyer but I feel there would be a lot of hurdles to drawing up a contract like that.


IF the happenings of the last couple of years are any indication........the NCAA doesn't really care if they look like a bunch of big buffoons!
 
Mar 13, 2004
14,745
12,925
0
If a player breaks the rule and leaves after one year, have it written into by-laws that he has to pay a percentage of his first contract to the NCAA as a penalty.

And you've given the NBA the best gift ever - the top 30 players every year now skip college entirely and go to the G league.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
The NCAA does have rules but they are all over the place....baseball, football and basketball all have different eligibility rules. Why can't they do like baseball and let drafted players stay. Why can't it be like football? The NCAA is unfair, contrary and obstinate!

I believe the rules for both baseball and football are based around rules from the MLB and NFL. It can’t be like football because the NFL won’t draft players until they are three years removed from high school.
 

seccats04

Heisman
Dec 6, 2004
14,848
24,568
113
They don't want to make it look like they are alienating black athletes by making them pick school or basketball. And, let's not kid ourselves, the NCAA would lose a lot of tv money if these OAD's weren't on tv and in the Tourney. You think Oklahoma and/or Texas deserved to be in the Tourney? No. But the committee knew that Trae Young and Bamba would drum up ratings.
 

awf

Heisman
May 31, 2006
10,411
20,774
0
I believe the rules for both baseball and football are based around rules from the MLB and NFL. It can’t be like football because the NFL won’t draft players until they are three years removed from high school.

It could be like the NFL/MLB if the NBA would change it's rules..........Maybe when this FBI thing comes to a head the NCAA will be forced to clean up it's act?
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Women's Basketball KSR's top takeaways from another blowout Kentucky WBB win
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Ticket prices for Kentucky's game against Grambling State are a bad sign
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Kentucky opens as an overwhelming favorite (again) in bounce-back opportunity
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky opens as underdog at Missouri in SEC finale
  5. 05 KSR Volleyball Kentucky VB closes regular season strong, locks up No. 2 seed in SEC Tournament