Why? Because some are too simplistic, and just think "everyone leaves". When in reality, many situations are different, unique. And they ignore facts/data that do not support their theories (for example WCS returning when he was a projected 1st round pick).
There are personal reasons why Reed would consider returning. Both playing for the team he's dreamed of playing for since a kid and the team both his parents played for, AND not rushing to become an adult moving to a big new city alone very different from anywhere he's lived before and being able to enjoy "the college experience". Not to mention getting closer to graduating (if that's important to him). And he is not in the situation many are in where they are being pressured to make $$$ asap to help remove their family from generational poverty.
There are also basketball reasons, as we saw in his final game where he not only disappeared, but just didn't play well. Happened a few other games to (i.e. USC), which makes you wonder if he can go out and get-his, create for himself, when he needs to. He most definitely did vs MSU. But consistently, IDK. AND more than that, is he physically ready (both strength and quickness), and I think the answer to that is definitely "No". IMO he will be manhandled by grown-*** Men in the NBA, at least next year. And so because of that, I think if he were to leave this summer, it may take him a bit longer than players who are already physically "ready" to develop into a good NBA player. And even that has questions, some think his skill set may be better for college ball than pro ball, the biggest pro limitation being his quickness. But the longer it takes him to develop, affects the next set of reasons...
Financial! Yes he can almost certainly be a 1st round pick, probably a lottery pick, possibly top half of lottery. But his goal shouldn't be to get there, to sign that first contract. It should be to maximize how long he can play there and maximize how much he can make there. But if he goes too soon, he could not be near his performance ceiling when it's time for that 2nd contract (which can be the really big one, much bigger than the draft contract). So by waiting 1 more year, and getting stronger and hopefully a little quicker, and becoming more of that "go-to scorer" when needed, and better defender, and better able to not fall to pressure or distractions, he could increase how much money he can make on that 2nd contract significantly.
So, he should be asking himself more than is he "ready" skill-wise. But is he also "ready" physically, mentally, maturity-wise, and emotionally.