Why does Cals teams struggle from 3 so much?

Pete391

Junior
Feb 10, 2018
277
254
0
I've wondered a lot about this also. Other teams have players far less talented than ours, from a shooting perspective, but seem to light us up regularly. I've come to a theory, that it is Calipari's offense. Maybe it is not really designed for long range shooting. I mean look at PJ Washington... first NBA game and 7 three pointers. Maybe Calipari just does not make that a priority in the dribble drive. I don't really know, but seems to be a serious issue.
It is Cals offense...........Just look at the difference in UK players after they go to the NBA......Booker, PJ, even Davis was a much better shooter in his first NBA season....
 

willievic

All-American
Aug 28, 2005
6,167
7,114
0
The major reason is what Coach Cal said at his first press conference, when he was introduced as our coach.
He said, "I play the Dribble Drive." There is nothing wrong with the Dribble Drive, if you have players who can hit from the outside. In fact, every team plays the Dribble Drive, but they have shooters who force the defense to come out and guard them. Most teams know we can't shoot the three, so they pack it in, which makes it tough for us to drive. Remember WV in the NCAA Tournament.

OLD STOLL FIELD GUY!
 

TheOtherGreatOne

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2003
3,005
3,365
0
I've wondered a lot about this also. Other teams have players far less talented than ours, from a shooting perspective, but seem to light us up regularly. I've come to a theory, that it is Calipari's offense. Maybe it is not really designed for long range shooting. I mean look at PJ Washington... first NBA game and 7 three pointers. Maybe Calipari just does not make that a priority in the dribble drive. I don't really know, but seems to be a serious issue.
Cal recruits certain types of players. He recruits athletic talent with length, that he hopes he can mold into great defensive players. He recruits this instead of players that have actual basketball skills. There are very few players that are great athletes and have highly developed basketball skills. Shooting happens to be a developed skill rather than a natural talent. I would say that aau basketball has a lot to do with the lack of developed basketball skills This is not likely to change because Cal values atheletic talent over basketball skills, and that's just the way it is. I am not saying it is not right or wrong, that is just the way Cal does things.
 

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,183
21,142
103
Stated in another thread but will repeat here. We don’t shoot very well because we have no rhythm to our offense. Good shooting is a by product of a good rhythmic offense. Our young guys have this to adapt to in addition to just adjusting to the speed of the college game as well. They will slowly adjust to this and learn how to develop their own rhythm but it takes time but still will not shoot the % they would shoot in a more normal offense designed to free up open shots for shooters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wardlow

TomTraubertsBlues

All-American
Oct 13, 2014
5,004
8,433
113
Sample size is key. First two games, Duval was 0-7 from for Duke. Second two games he was 5-10. After first two games, a typical response from fans is Duval is the worst shooter ever, don't let him ever shoot a 3 again. next two games, a typical fan response would be "Duval is white hot. Run plays to get him looks from 3". He is the same person in all 4 games. Booker shot absymally to start the season, then got white hot.

That being said, I don't think this team is an above average 3pt shooting team, but I also don't think it's one of Cal's worst shooting teams either. The average will come up and probably end up being an average shooting team for Cal. Quickley is a good shooter. I think Juzang could get in a groove and be a good shooter if he got enough PT, but that's not a sure thing. Maxey's shot looks erratic as hell, but if they can figure out his mechanics, I think he could be a threat. And I think Sestina can be a good shooter too. Everybody else is probably below average to bad. I don't trust Whitney outside 10-12 feet. Same with Brooks. Hagans needs to take 3s out of his vocabulary.
 
Jan 24, 2005
20,352
11,690
0
Sestina gets a lot of open 3s but chooses to pump fake, which accomplishes absolutely nothing. Set him up as a pick and pop guy and let him shoot with no hesitation. Play to his strength and quit posting him up like he's Kevin McHale.

I think a lot of the guys are scared to shoot. They know Cal wants them to drive into the teeth of the defense or dump the ball down low. It's maddening.
All of our players pump-fake. It's clear our staff wants the player to pump fake as soon as they receive the ball. This has worked to fake out a defender exactly 0% of the time.

All it does is take our offensive player out of rhythm and allows the defender to recover. Pretty much its just a terrible technique to teach our players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: richbrookstomato

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
30,650
74,134
113
Part of it is too many athletes.

Guys like Booker, Lamb, Herro, Murray, Ulis.. those were basketball players first. Funny, none of them played defense particularly great.. some it was almost non existent.. but they could create shots and/or run the offense.

Then you look at guys like Diallo, Wenyen, Whitney, Poythress.. athletes first, basketball players second.
Did you just say ulis wasn’t a great defender
 

The_Catfather

All-American
May 21, 2002
14,087
5,361
92
All of our players pump-fake. It's clear our staff wants the player to pump fake as soon as they receive the ball. This has worked to fake out a defender exactly 0% of the time.

All it does is take our offensive player out of rhythm and allows the defender to recover. Pretty much its just a terrible technique to teach our players.

It boggles the mind. It's just irritating me with Sestina in particular, who's no threat whatsoever to make something happen off the dribble. If by some miracle someone bit on one of his 3-point fakes nothing good is going to come out of it. Most likely a charge.

I think we have good shooters - for a Cal team anyway - they're just too spooked to let it fly confidently.

"DRIVE THE BALL!!!!" "GOOOOOOO!!!!!!!" :flush:
 

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,183
21,142
103
It is Cals offense...........Just look at the difference in UK players after they go to the NBA......Booker, PJ, even Davis was a much better shooter in his first NBA season....

Actually you don’t even have to look at the NBA. Look at Baker with Arizona. Made 13 out of 42 last year in 254 minutes of action over 28 games. This year in only 60 minutes of play over 4 games he is 8 of 15.
 

willyclyde

All-American
Feb 25, 2007
5,917
8,898
0
Because our players think they will get yanked if they either miss or do not drive into the lane and throw up a prayer of a layup in hopes that we either get the offensive rebound or get fouled.
 

Col. Angus

Hall of Famer
Apr 7, 2017
82,936
254,731
83
Cal’s offense isn’t designed to get shooters good looks. It’s designed to pound it inside and play inside out. When he doesn’t have dominant low post guys to open the perimeter, this is what you see.
 

Emarc

All-Conference
Nov 4, 2017
3,273
3,629
0
Its the dribble drive not the run and gun...
For God’s sake people we were 1 for 12 from 3 and still won by 8 and thats because we got to the line 35 times and hit 32 of them.

Thats who we are.

If you want to see the three shot and sometimes made go back and watch the probation years where we were getting beat 150-95 by Kansas.
Place was packed and rockin. One of the best years in Rupp
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
I think Cal has gotten more conservative with age, and that attitude filters down to the players. And his fallback position in big games is always grit and grind.

Take his last 4 Memphis teams. Those teams (that won 137 games) rated 17, 68, 76, and 145 in Pomeroy's tempo ratings, and
FWIW guys our accuracy from 3 isn't bad during Cal
This season we are 342nd but in a small sample

2019 = 35.4% (114)
2018 = 35.7% (124)
2017 = 35.3% (155)
2016 = 36.6% (74)
2015 = 34.9% (143)
2014 = 33.2% (214)
2013 = 34.6% (131)
2012 = 37.8% (37)
2011 = 39.7% (9)
2010 = 33.1% (218)

We hover around average. Which is perfectly fine when you are rebounding a boatload of misses on offensive and getting to the line.
Yeah, but there's also these numbers: UK +/- vs opponents on 3 point shots:

19-20= -60 so far
18-19= -204
17-18= -276
16-17= +96
15-16= +129
14-15= +84
13-14= -57
12-13= +15
11-12= +18
10-11= +213
09-10= -42

Cal is swimming against the stream, getting more conservative as the game gets less so. I think he's making things much harder on his teams than needs be, creating an environment where players are hesitant to take open shots. Some of that might be necessary, since the teams are so young, and there is a payoff in that you aren't going to see any more losses where UK heedlessly jacks up 30 threes, ala vs West Virginia in 2010. However, there is a downside, which I think we've seen in recent years.

I look at it like this: Cal's teams are playing a style where they can gut out a win over Houston in the Sweet 16. But that's also a style that loses to Auburn in the next round.

I personally think Cal is at the point of his career where he needs to gamble more. Never suffering a major upset and almost always advancing at least a few rounds in the tournament is great, but it's not the goal. Nearly every team he's had that's come close to a title but come up short has done so mostly because they could not hit any shots at all when it counted most. I think Cal needs to ask himself why that has happened so many times.
 

Bratkartoffeln

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2003
3,642
2,033
113
It seems as if it never fails. We think were going to have a great shooting team and then they come in and clank them left and right? It doesn't make sense. Johnny Juzang was known as an amazing shooter in high school and he can barely buy one. Seems as if this is every season. Is it practice emphasis? I know some people wanna blame the fact that they dont get to shoot around in Rupp except on gameday, but other UK teams from other UK coaches had the same issue and I recall us having some great shooting teams in the past. Yes the line is further out but how much of a difference should that really make? The 3pt shot is becoming more and more important in this new day and age of basketball and it's not good enough anymore to just be more athletically dominant. If you're scoring 17 pts off off of transition baskets and free throws and youre 0-4 from 3, but Joe Schmo is going 6 of 10 from three you're athletic edge got beat by a point by the shorter, slower shooter.
Part of it is the offensive patterns he runs...not really conducive to getting good three-point shots. Utah Valley ran some great half court offense geared to getting screens for open looks at the top of the key and on the wings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatguy87

catfando

All-Conference
Mar 31, 2009
1,550
1,729
113
Combination of Cal doesn’t really push the 3 on the offensive end. Dribble drive. He likes elite athletes that can defend, rebound, and impose their will. And keep in mind, they moved the line back this year. Will take a little adjusting. I believe we’ll be fine later in the year. Just gotta get used to each other, develop chemistry, and get healthy.
 
A

anon_q409idbs5m40a

Guest
The pressure at Kentucky is tremendous, most high school dead eye shooters don't shoot that well their freshman year here. I remember watching Tony Delk in the derby classic and went 3 for 16 or something like that and we all know how he turned out. You can't be just a shooter here, you have to be efficient in every phase of the game, it will come if he stays positive about it.
Lots of truth to this. I keep thinking about Todd Tackett back in the '90's. Couldn't miss at Paintsville but couldn't hit the broad side of a barn while at UK.
 

blockm2

Senior
Jul 9, 2001
4,354
584
0
I don’t know. Outside of a couple of years, our ranking is pretty bad IMO. UK shouldn’t be in the 100-200 range in most years.

to be fair the team FT shooting ranks are even worse over that time frame, being under 300 once and under 200 4 other times. Perhaps his teams tend to be populated mostly with players that simply are not good shooters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatguy87

arenk

Senior
Jan 3, 2003
2,108
927
0
Lots of truth to this. I keep thinking about Todd Tackett back in the '90's. Couldn't miss at Paintsville but couldn't hit the broad side of a barn while at UK.

Many players that were great shooters in high school such as Booker and Herro, for example, come to UK. Once they get that UK uniform on they seem to lose their shooting touch. As soon as they left and turned pro, what did Booker and Herro do?

I think it's a combination of all the things mentioned on this thread: recruiting long athletes who are not good shooters; an offensive scheme in which our best shooters don't get as many good looks as they should; not catching the ball in spots where they can shoot in rhythm; lack of a dominating big ever since 2015; and fear of being taken out of games if they miss two shots in a row. Cal also has an annoying habit of running too much clock when we're up by at least 8 or 9 with under 8 minutes to play. That nearly cost us a NC in 2012 against a Kansas team that was far less talented than we were. It took great plays from MKG, AD, Teague, and Jones in that final 4 minutes for us to pull that game out. That's ironic after Cal's comments yesterday about the difference between playing ''to win' as opposed to 'not lose' which is exactly what he does when he slows down the tempo and runs clock. We end up with shot clock violations or taking low percentage rushed shots by waiting until there are 6 or 7 seconds left on the shot clock to start the offense. Isn't that playing not to lose?
 

CatsIndy2010

Senior
Jan 27, 2010
1,948
742
0
Whens the last time we saw a guy come off a pick to score a 3? Or rotate the ball to weak side for an open 3? I think the guys are still learning Cals system.
 

bassworship

Heisman
Nov 7, 2018
12,005
38,435
98
People will hate this..

But because our team is super young. Polish isn't there.

Most freshmen don't shoot well. That's the reality. Look @ Duke. They are young like us and shoots terrible as well. Only fair comparison.

There is always exception to the rule.

However look at 2011. Cal had 3 players +40% and Brandon Knight. That's because liggins and Miller were able to polish their game out to 3 point line.

It doesn't stop there, Willis, PJ is another experienced players who became great shooter. If Herro had stayed, no one would be talking about bad shooting on this team because he probably would be shooting 40+.

(Also we were missing Quickley, who would slightly improve our shooting yesterday)

Exactly right and spot on post...It takes time for young players to learn the College game and become more comfortable in any offense no matter the talent level.
 

HerrosHeroes

Heisman
Aug 16, 2018
27,234
38,040
0
UK has played 4 games, could play 36 more.
Lets check back after about 10 gms played and see how we are doing.
Even then thats still a relatively small sample size but will tell a helluva lot more than a mere 4 gms.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bratkartoffeln
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
I think Cal has gotten more conservative with age, and that attitude filters down to the players. And his fallback position in big games is always grit and grind.

Take his last 4 Memphis teams. Those teams (that won 137 games) rated 17, 68, 76, and 145 in Pomeroy's tempo ratings, and

Yeah, but there's also these numbers: UK +/- vs opponents on 3 point shots:

19-20= -60 so far
18-19= -204
17-18= -276
16-17= +96
15-16= +129
14-15= +84
13-14= -57
12-13= +15
11-12= +18
10-11= +213
09-10= -42

Cal is swimming against the stream, getting more conservative as the game gets less so. I think he's making things much harder on his teams than needs be, creating an environment where players are hesitant to take open shots. Some of that might be necessary, since the teams are so young, and there is a payoff in that you aren't going to see any more losses where UK heedlessly jacks up 30 threes, ala vs West Virginia in 2010. However, there is a downside, which I think we've seen in recent years.

I look at it like this: Cal's teams are playing a style where they can gut out a win over Houston in the Sweet 16. But that's also a style that loses to Auburn in the next round.

I personally think Cal is at the point of his career where he needs to gamble more. Never suffering a major upset and almost always advancing at least a few rounds in the tournament is great, but it's not the goal. Nearly every team he's had that's come close to a title but come up short has done so mostly because they could not hit any shots at all when it counted most. I think Cal needs to ask himself why that has happened so many times.

Most years that plays into our hands tho. Go back and look at the accuracy of those three point shots. The only reason there's a wide margin there is because our opponents take a ton more three's than we do. 3 times in the last 5 years we have been in the top 15 in 3 point FG% defense. So if they are going to miss a large portion of them, let them take a boatload. And the reason they take a ton of three's is because that's the only way lots of teams that face us can actually beat us. Teams this year are shooting 27.5% from 3 against us. That's the same as shooting 42% from 2. You are going to win a ton of games if you force teams into those shooting figures.

But the 3 point shot is more random from game to game than 2 point FG%. So while it's a good strategy for an underdog to knock off a big team, I don't really think our strategy should be jacking up 20-25 threes a game. I mean unless you're Villanova where you had a bunch of 40% guys, but that's a rarity.

You want to take as much randomness out when u are the more talented team in a six game tournament.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G-PIP

WildMoon

Heisman
Apr 7, 2009
78,693
11,120
0
Many players that were great shooters in high school such as Booker and Herro, for example, come to UK. Once they get that UK uniform on they seem to lose their shooting touch. As soon as they left and turned pro, what did Booker and Herro do?

Well Booker shot better at UK than pro..
Herro shot similar here and first year in Pro.

There goes your argument.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G-PIP

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
Most years that plays into our hands tho. Go back and look at the accuracy of those three point shots. The only reason there's a wide margin there is because our opponents take a ton more three's than we do. 3 times in the last 5 years we have been in the top 15 in 3 point FG% defense. So if they are going to miss a large portion of them, let them take a boatload. And the reason they take a ton of three's is because that's the only way lots of teams that face us can actually beat us. Teams this year are shooting 27.5% from 3 against us. That's the same as shooting 42% from 2. You are going to win a ton of games if you force teams into those shooting figures.

But the 3 point shot is more random from game to game than 2 point FG%. So while it's a good strategy for an underdog to knock off a big team, I don't really think our strategy should be jacking up 20-25 threes a game. I mean unless you're Villanova where you had a bunch of 40% guys, but that's a rarity.

You want to take as much randomness out when u are the more talented team in a six game tournament.
That's a nice post. Higher basketball IQ stuff, in my opinion. Thanks.

I would add that when a team is forced to take a ton of 3s that creates a number of other negative effects not reflective from just looking at the shooting percentage - e.g., lack of FT opportunities, not generating fouls, etc. In short, That's why an offense overly dependent on 3-pt. shooting is generally a gambling style only suitable for teams that can't match up (i.e., inferior teams) - unless, as you said, the team has a number of great 3-pt. shooters who can get their shots off quick.
 

LadyCaytIL

Heisman
Oct 28, 2012
33,080
34,751
113
when you have Justus and Barbee instructing shooting for guards and wings........ you get what you deserve. Hire a great shooting coach for the love of god cal. someone that knows offense. anyone can recruit the guys we do with UK , Cal and Payne behind them... but not everyone can coach up offense.
 

Cal-4-Three

All-Conference
Apr 2, 2011
1,591
1,844
0
After last year and the changing of Herro's shot debacle, I wonder if they try to change these guys shots to make them quicker? That would definitely change their shot for the short time they are here. Maybe that was just a one time thing.
 

rabidcatfan

Senior
Jan 25, 2003
9,198
512
0
I just dont understand the misses on wide open 3 pointers (dont get me started on the unusual amount of point blank misses at the rim we've endured over the past several seasons). Any other team you watch someone shake their guy or find a teammate for a wide open 3, there's better than a 50-50 chance of it going in. Were lucky, historically, if we hit 2 out of 10 of them.
 

Ky_Bred_Cat

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2014
2,201
4,090
113
A couple of thoughts:

At the High School level superior athletes rule and thus rise to the top of the rankings. You don't have to shoot lights out to dominate the competition when you play way faster or way over everyone else.

When these guys come to UK the pressure and learning curve are tremendous, especially in the beginning. Even the good shooters are scared witless at first. Eventually the shooters come around and, sometimes, the athletes begin to shoot better.

Having said all that, something else must be in play here as our guys don't ever seem to hit open 3's consistently.
 

Rembrandt90

Heisman
Jun 25, 2018
6,758
13,246
0
It seems as if it never fails. We think were going to have a great shooting team and then they come in and clank them left and right? It doesn't make sense. Johnny Juzang was known as an amazing shooter in high school and he can barely buy one. Seems as if this is every season. Is it practice emphasis? I know some people wanna blame the fact that they dont get to shoot around in Rupp except on gameday, but other UK teams from other UK coaches had the same issue and I recall us having some great shooting teams in the past. Yes the line is further out but how much of a difference should that really make? The 3pt shot is becoming more and more important in this new day and age of basketball and it's not good enough anymore to just be more athletically dominant. If you're scoring 17 pts off off of transition baskets and free throws and youre 0-4 from 3, but Joe Schmo is going 6 of 10 from three you're athletic edge got beat by a point by the shorter, slower shooter.
Right off the top of my head, I can think of four reasons why UK tends to be a mediocre three-point shooting team.

Because Cal recruits players who come to UK with a goal of getting to the league as early as possible, UK basketball players tend to be younger, with less accumulated time spent on developing ideal shooting form and technique, than most college basketball players.

Given a choice between recruiting a shooter, or recruiting an elite athlete, Cal will recruit the athlete every time. This is because Cal is, first and foremost, a defensive coach. No matter how many shots a player makes, if he allows the player he is guarding to also make that many shots, then it is a wash. A player cannot play for Cal unless he can defend.

Early in the season, Cal teaches defense primarily. He has said in interviews that he doesn’t start focusing on teaching offense until the second half of December.

Cal’s offensive philosophy is based on driving the basketball into the lane. He wants to draw fouls and create offensive rebounding opportunities. For that reason, his teams take fewer three point shots than most other teams. Since the Cats don’t shoot as many threes as other teams, it takes our younger players longer to get comfortable from the perimeter. Which true freshmen were truly effective three-point shooters for Cal when guarded? Not that many. Bledsoe, Knight, Lamb, Booker, Murray, Monk, Herro.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScrooDook92

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
.... Which true freshmen were truly effective three-point shooters for Cal when guarded? Not that many. Bledsoe, Knight, Lamb, Booker, Murray, Monk, Herro.
You sure hit the mark with those players. Maybe the best freshmen shooters ever at UK. Even as freshmen it’s my recollection that they were all (except maybe, Lamb and Bledsoe) pretty good at being able to pull up quick and hit a relatively contested 3-point shot. But, at that early stage there were still many college upper classmen that did it much better. Nevertheless, you could see they were going to be very good at it in time – and they were/are now.

There just is no way around the effect of TIME & EXPERIENCE on shooting ability. The script is: A decent shooter as a freshman becomes a good shooter as a college upper classman and a great shooter as an NBA vet.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
FWIW guys our accuracy from 3 isn't bad during Cal
This season we are 342nd but in a small sample

2019 = 35.4% (114)
2018 = 35.7% (124)
2017 = 35.3% (155)
2016 = 36.6% (74)
2015 = 34.9% (143)
2014 = 33.2% (214)
2013 = 34.6% (131)
2012 = 37.8% (37)
2011 = 39.7% (9)
2010 = 33.1% (218)

We hover around average. Which is perfectly fine when you are rebounding a boatload of misses on offensive and getting to the line.
% is not the determining factor..its number of takes and makes... For me, a 3pt shooter is someone that makes 100+ and be near 40%...Meeks, Murray, Monk
 

rmattox

All-Conference
Nov 26, 2014
6,786
4,006
0
In high school. The great athletes that are good enough or quick enough to play defense that Cal demands don't "make their living" scoring from the perimeter
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  2. 02 KSR Football Playoff Viewing Guide: What games Kentucky fans need to follow in Week 11
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Kentucky vs. Indiana: Preview, Odds & How to Watch
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Kentucky vs. Indiana and the latest in recruiting
  5. 05 KSR Football SEC Availability Report: What to know about Thursday's update