Who's the better RB

[GBryne4Heisman]

Toby Gehart (Stanford) or Anthony Dixon?

 

[davatron]

.

 

[Buford T. Justice]

Gerhart had almost 10,000 yards rushing in high school. I think that is in the top 5 in history. He also plays on the baseball team. He has had to overcome the stigma (i.e. white running backs should be moved to fullback). He is as good as Dixon, if not better. AD has really stepped it up this year, however. When AD is in shape and running hard, he is special. When he is fat and lazy, he is ordinary.

 

[MSUCostanza]

They are very similar. I lean Dixon, but probably out of bias and from not seeing much of Gerhart until the last few weeks.

 

[GoState05]

I'm leaning Dixon, simply because Gerhart doesn't have to run on SEC defenses, much less every week. USC would have been the closest, but this season their defense just seems weak all around.