Who would you rather have back:

[Chesusdog]

Graveman or Renfroe?

 

[JacksonDevilDog]

Graveman. We need that inning eater on the weekends right now to save our bullpen.

 

[rabiddawg]

Ammorati

 

[57stratdawg]

Heck of a question. I'd go Renfroe. If you pick Graveman suddenly either him or Mitchell are going every Friday night which neutralizes their impact a bit IMO.

A power bat in the middle of this lineup would be great.

 

[FallAmericanDawg]

Graveman. We need that inning eater on the weekends right now to save our bullpen.

Mitchell's complete games aren't enough for you?

 

[msstate7]

Mitchell's complete games aren't enough for you?

When the other two rarely make it past 4, I'd say no. No it isn't enough

 

[JacksonDevilDog]

I wouldn't mind one other guy so we don't have to sweat Sundays.

 

[Uncle Ruckus]

Renfroe. His presence in the lineup helps detz and rea see better pitches, and it gives us potential for more than a single

 

[Wicked Pissah]

Easy. Gravemen

 

[Chesusdog]

To play my own game

I'd take Graveman. There is no denying we miss Renfroe's bat and he was a hell of a defensive player for us, but I think we'd be better served to have a pair of aces on the mound each weekend.

 

[johnson86-1]

Renfroe. His presence in the lineup helps detz and rea see better pitches, and it gives us potential for more than a single

I'm not sure that makes up for the rest of our lineup. I'd rather have another dependable arm. Plus I feel like a good pitcher is much more likely to produce in a super regional or omaha than a good hitter. It's pretty easy for a good hitter to make it through a super regional without having much impact, although a bad outing by a pitcher does the same.